12 Dire Plot Twists From Recent Hollywood Films
Shyamalan isn't the only master of terrible plot twists in Hollywood...
As enjoyable as Hollywood movies often are, there are many flaws which keep recurring across multiple different projects. These include bad casting, hit-or-miss writing and studios being too eager to set up franchises, but there is another huge issue which arguably doesn't get enough attention: the way So Many Hollywood films insist on shoehorning in a plot twist.
Yes, we all love a good plot twist and there are many great ones out there. For example, the plot twists of films like The Usual Suspects, Arrival, Memento, Oldboy, Psycho and Planet of the Apes (1968) to name a few are completely genius, but not all films need twists.
Seriously awful plot twists are frequently forced into Hollywood genre films, with many of these twists are either incredibly predictable or entirely illogical. In fact, they're often a combo of both.
These following twelve studio films contain some of the worst recent examples of awful plot twists. Obviously, spoilers lie ahead, but then again, you'll probably guess most of these twists long before the big reveal...
12. Creedence Barebone Is Aurelius Dumbledore - Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald was a disastrous misfire that was full of awful plot elements and dreadful twists, but it saved the worst for last.
Throughout the film, antagonist Gellert Grindelwald (Johnny Depp) is pursuing the troubled young wizard Creedence Barebone (Ezra Miller), who is trying to discover his true parentage. At the end of the film, Grindelwald tells him who he really is: he's Aurelius Dumbledore, an unknown sibling of Albus Dumbledore.
Huh?
There are two colossal issues with this twist. Firstly, it's an uninteresting and cliched twist that doesn't add anything whatsoever to the film and secondly, it completely breaks Harry Potter lore, as well as Albus Dumbledore's family backstory.
Additionally, once you examine the timeline more closely, it's unclear as to how he was actually born since both the Dumbledore parents died before the early 20th century, which is apparently when Creedence/Aurelius was born. This is a twist where as soon you think about it with any sort of logic (for example, how did Dumbledore himself not know about this?) it falls apart like a house of cards in the wind.
The film was written by JK Rowling, who is brilliant at plot twists and subversive storytelling (as proved by the Harry Potter books), so this was uncharacteristically sloppy plotting from her.
11. Pedro Pascal Did It - The Equalizer 2
The most common type of plot twist in Hollywood right now is the surprise villain twist and 2018's The Equalizer 2, an OK but extremely messy action sequel, delivered one of the worst examples of this. It was one of those twists which was so ridiculously obvious it was kind-of funny, but mostly just annoying.
The Equalizer 2 concerns Robert McCall's (Denzel Washington) quest for vengeance after his best friend Susan (Melissa Leo) is killed while investigating a murder alongside Dave York (Pedro Pascal), who was McCall's partner in their Marine days.
Ultimately, McCall discovers (through a contact list on an assassin's phone) that York and his mercenaries killed Susan... which we all saw coming.
The giveaway was the casting. Pedro Pascal is a very talented and well-known actor and before this twist his character had been doing very little. It seemed unlikely Pascal would've been brought in for a nothing law enforcement role and therefore it was logical to assume the character would have a more substantial part to play later.
Additionally, the leader of the mercenaries being kept a mystery set up a plot twist involving a known character and York (who was a very badly-written villain overall) was easily the most likely candidate.
10. Aaron Paul Did It - Central Intelligence
Here, we go from one terrible surprise villain twist to another and much like the aforementioned Equalizer 2, this wasted another great actor.
In this solid buddy-cop comedy, CIA agent Bob (Dwayne Johnson) and accountant Calvin (Kevin Hart) , who went to school together, have teamed up to investigate The Black Badger, a mysterious criminal who murdered Bob's previous partner, Phil (Aaron Paul), in a lift and then framed Bob. The duo work to stop the Black Badger from selling satellite codes to the highest bidder.
Eventually, Bob goes to an auction posing as the Black Badger, but as bad luck would have it the real Black Badger shows up... it's Phil. Well, he might've fooled Bob but he certainly didn't fool any of us.
This is another example of how not to do a plot twist. Three key things spelt this one out in flashing neon lights long before the big reveal.
Firstly, the Black Badger being unknown immediately set up a twist involving a known character, meaning viewers were on the lookout. Secondly, in the flashback to Phil's 'death', we never saw a body and that's always a giveaway sign of a fake-out death. Thirdly, and most importantly, why would a film bring in a talented, well-known actor like Aaron Paul for a single flashback death scene?
9. Patrick Wilson Did It - The Commuter
The Commuter focuses on Michael (Liam Neeson), an ex-cop and insurance agent, who is offered $100,000 by Joanna (Vera Farmiga) in exchange for carrying out a task: he has to locate a passenger on his commuter train who doesn't belong. Should he fail to locate this passenger, who faces death upon being identified, his family dies.
This is a great premise and The Commuter is a solid, tense mystery thriller that'll keep you guessing, but although it gets most of its twists right, one of the big twists is very obvious indeed.
The reveal that Alex Murphy (Patrick Wilson), Michael's former police partner, is a corrupt cop and the guy who suggested Michael to Joanna was predictable from very early-on in the film.
At the start of the film Michael is laid off from his job and the only person he tells about this, and therefore the only person who knows Michael needs money, is Alex. Additionally, Alex voices discontent about his police career and immediately sounds like a corrupt cop.
The person who Michael is supposed to locate is a murder witness and as soon as this passenger reveals that the men who carried out the killing were police, it put what most had probably already worked out beyond any doubt.
8. Samuel L. Jackson's Idiotic Plan - Glass
No list like this would be complete without something from M. Night Shyamalan.
It's frustrating that Shyamalan is best known for his plot twists since they're usually the worst part of his movies and there's so much more to this gifted (although Incredibly inconsistent) director. Unfortunately, Shyamalan delivered another terrible ending twist in Glass, his OK but overall disappointing follow-up to Unbreakable and Split.
Glass sees superhero David Dunn/The Overseer (Bruce Willis) and super-villains Kevin Wendell Crumb/The Horde (James McAvoy) and Elijah Price/Mr Glass (Samuel L. Jackson) being locked in an asylum, where Elijah and Kevin soon team up to carry out a terrorist attack in the city.
David intercepts and battles them and in the following confrontation all three of them die. After that, the bombshell is dropped: Elijah had never planned to carry out the attack. He'd wanted to cause a battle between the three of them so he could live-stream it and then release the asylum's CCTV footage, exposing the existence of super-humans.
Wait, that's it?
This is a thoroughly dull twist and it was made even worse by the fact that Elijah's scheme was completely pointless; thanks to the events of Unbreakable and Split everyone already knew about super-humans, so this footage won't have changed anything. Those death scenes were pretty awful too, especially for David who gets... drowned in a puddle. Ridiculous.
7. Franz Oberhauser Is Blofeld - Spectre
As soon as the title 'Spectre' was revealed, it was obvious that Blofeld would finally be returning to the James Bond franchise and Christoph Waltz was, in spite of how badly he was wasted in the final film, a perfect fit for the character and the right sort of age too, so although everyone involved in the film insisted that the character named 'Franz Oberhauser' wasn't Blofeld, everyone knew that he was.
Sure enough, Oberhauser revealed his real name to Bond during a torture scene and while this was actually a good scene for the most part, this reveal was so predictable it was groan-inducing.
Oh, and then there was the backstory that Bond and Blofeld were stepbrothers and Blofeld hates Bond because he felt his father showed favouritism towards Bond. Brotherly jealousy is Blofeld's motivation? Seriously?!
So, Oberhauser killed his dad, faked his death, changed his name and has not only been leading Spectre, but was responsible for the events of Casino Royale, Quantum of Solace and Skyfall, as well as the man in charge of the villains of those films.
That doesn't make any sense whatsoever!
There was a simple solution here: don't make this a twist. Blofeld using a fake name didn't add anything anyway. After the failure of a similar plot twist in Star Trek: Into Darkness two years earlier, you'd think studios would've learnt something from that. Unfortunately, they hadn't.
6. Dr Lawrence Gordon Is A Secret Jigsaw Apprentice - Saw 3D
This terrible 'final' chapter in the interesting but wildly inconsistent Saw franchise delivered another example of a plot twist so obvious it was actually painful.
As soon as Cary Elwes was announced to finally be returning to the franchise as Dr Lawrence Gordon for the first time since the original, it seemed very likely he would be a surprise villain, since the Saw franchise does love surprise villain twists.
Sure, he could've been trying to get revenge on the Jigsaw Killer and his apprentices (and that would've been far better) but the investigator role was taken by an obnoxious, atrociously-played detective in the movie. Additionally, before this reveal he'd only appeared briefly at a survivor's meeting and it seemed unlikely he'd be brought back for just a one-scene cameo.
What makes this twist even worse is that it makes zero sense. Gordon was not supposed to be the most likeable character in the original but he definitely wasn't a psychopath, so why would he happily join forces with the madman who put him through hell and tried to murder his family?
The Saw films usually end with a big twist and while these have varied in quality this is definitely the worst Saw plot twist to date.
5. Sterling K. Brown Did It - The Rhythm Section
In this spy thriller, Stephanie Patrick (Blake Lively) trains with a former MI6 operative Iain Boyd (Jude Law) in order to get revenge on the people behind the plane bombing that killed her family. Former CIA agent turned information broker Marc Serra (Sterling K. Brown) also helps them out.
After a hit goes wrong, Patrick ditches Boyd and stays with Serra as she continues to hunt for the terrorist known only as U-17, who masterminded the plane bombing. Serra eventually tells her that he believes Reza, a young bombmaker, is actually U-17.
As soon as he said this (Reza obviously isn't U-17) it's likely that most immediately guessed that Serra was U-17 and then spent the film's final act with their fingers crossed that the film wouldn't drop this Awful twist-ending on us. Alas, it proceeded with this twist.
Not only was this reveal blindingly obvious but it also added nothing whatsoever to the film and led to an anticlimactic showdown between Stephanie and Serra. Additionally, Serra never seemed like a villain at all and this was impossible to buy.
If Boyd had been U-17, with Serra as a red herring instead, that could've worked. Sadly, this mostly enjoyable movie fatally undermined itself with its generally terrible final act and the twist was the thing which finally broke it.
4. Felicity Jones Did It - Inferno
Inferno's predecessor in this dire trilogy, 2009's Angels & Demons, had one of the worst plot twists of the 2000s and this terrible sequel followed suit by having one of the worst plot twists of the 2010s.
Robert Langdon (Tom Hanks) discovers that the unstable, now-deceased billionaire Bertrand Zobrist (Ben Foster), who committed suicide to escape authorities, has created a devastating viral weapon that could kill half the world's population, which is his twisted solution to over-population. Langdon works with Dr Sienna Brooks (Felicity Jones) as he tries to find and contain the virus before, out of nowhere, it's revealed that Brooks was actually Zobrist's girlfriend and is planning to release the virus.
Brooks is a poorly-written character who never seemed like a villain and rather than being shocking, this reveal is likely to make audiences roll their eyes en masse.
It's also, like everything else in this trilogy, totally ridiculous. Instead of leaving clear instructions on how to release the virus, Zobrist had his girlfriend going on a convoluted, barely doable treasure hunt which she requires assistance to work out.
Zobrist had left the task to Brooks in case he couldn't release the virus himself, but it seems illogical that he wasn't able to do that since all he needed to do was slit open a plastic bag containing the weapon. Clearly he didn't quite think this through.
3. Mark Ruffalo Did It - Now You See Me
Now You See Me, a terrible thriller about a group of magicians (Jesse Eisenberg, Woody Harrelson, Isla Fisher and Dave Franco) who are carrying out bank robberies and are being pursued by FBI agent Dylan Rhodes (Mark Ruffalo), is a film built around hit-or-miss plot twists. It saved the very worst one for last though: Dylan Rhodes is the mastermind behind the heist.
The good news? Unlike almost every other twist on this list so far, it's very likely that no-one saw it coming. The bad news? The reason no-one saw it coming was that it's a completely bulls**t twist. There was no way Rhodes could've been the mastermind behind the heists.
How did Rhodes mastermind such a complicated series of heists while also pursuing the people doing them? How did this magician/criminal rise through the FBI? In fact, how did he oversee this whole scheme without his own agency knowing?
It also negates the entire film since the guy who we all assumed was chasing the magicians was never actually trying to catch them.
As for his motivation, Rhodes was using the heists to get revenge on various people he feels were responsible for his father's death. Wasn't there a less convoluted way to get revenge?
2. It's All A Video Game - Serenity
Serenity concerns Baker Dill (Matthew McConaughey), an island fisherman who's approached by his ex-wife Karen (Anne Hathaway), who asks him to kill her abusive new husband Frank (Jason Clarke). Eventually, it turns out that this is actually a video game programmed by Baker's son Patrick (Rafael Sayegh); Baker is an avatar for Patrick's late father, who died in Iraq.
This was a very interesting idea, but Serenity pulled it off disastrously and is basically a bewilderingly awful, misjudged film to rival 2017's The Book of Henry.
For starters, the twist is very blatantly hinted at numerous times before the actual reveal, while Serenity never realises how silly it really is and plays things like Baker talking to a character called The Rules (Jeremy Strong) as if they're the most natural things in the world.
It gets worse the deeper you go. Patrick has programmed a game in which his dead father does sex-work and shags an avatar of Patrick's mother, which is weird enough, but the game mainly seems to be a way to live out his fantasies of murdering his real stepfather. Once Baker kills Frank in the game, Patrick murders his stepfather in real life.
Yes, a young boy killing his stepfather is Serenity's idea of a triumphant ending. Everything surrounding this twist is misjudged, disturbing, atrociously written, messy and just awful.
1. David Lives - Alien Covenant
In the watchable but mostly irritating Alien: Covenant, a group of colonists and their android, Walter (Michael Fassbender), are lured to a mysterious planet by a transmission from the sinister android David (who's identical to Walter and is also played by Michael Fassbender), who is marooned on the planet and trying to escape.
In the following ordeal, most of the crew die but the survivors eventually defeat the early version of the Xenomorph that David has created, while Walter (who's benevolent, unlike David) apparently kills David.
Unfortunately, right before protagonist Daniels (Katherine Waterston) goes into cryo-sleep, she realises that Walter is actually David, who's disguised himself as Walter. But of course it was!
This one was predictable to the point of parody. Earlier on, David cut his hair to look like Walter and the end of the fight between the androids wasn't even shown; there is no way that the death of the film's most important character would be off-screen.
Worse still, it's surrounded by plot holes. Why didn't Daniels and her crew-mates check it really was Walter? How did David have time to change into Walter's clothes and cut off his hand (Walter had lost his hand earlier) before getting to the ship?
Make no mistake, this is one of the worst plot twists of all time.