12 Dumbest Movie Plot Twists Of 2017

The bad, the obvious, and the really, really stupid.

Alien Covenant Michael Fassbender David
Fox

A great plot twist can cement a movie in the annals of cinema history forever more, as is the case with The Sixth Sense, The Usual Suspects, Fight Club, Psycho, The Empire Strikes Back, Saw and literally hundreds of other popular films.

If a movie gets it wrong, though, it's destined to live on in infamy until the end of time, because a bad plot twist can ruin the entirety of a film, fundamentally changing everything audiences thought they knew and leaving an extremely sour taste as the end credits roll.

2017 certainly had its share of great twists, but arguably just as memorable are those big reveals that fell way short of the mark, either inviting unintentional laughter, aggressively raised eyebrows or even straight-up anger that a movie pulled something so mind-bogglingly asinine.

These twists, from lazy killer reveals to ridiculous sequel bait, jaw-dropping tonal shifts and tasteless attempts to surprise the audience at all costs, are the most absurdly braindead "gotcha!" moments from the last year of movies...

12. Tom Cruise Becomes A Mummy At The End - The Mummy

The Mummy Tom Cruise Ending
Universal

The Twist: The movie ends with protagonist Nick Morton (Tom Cruise) stabbing himself with the Dagger of Set, transferring the God's essence into his body, allowing him to fight and defeat the mummy, Princess Ahmanet (Sofia Boutella).

However, Nick pays the ultimate price, in that he's now permanently fused with Set's spirit as a human-mummy hybrid, cursed to roam the desert forever more.

Why It's Dumb: It's an hilariously transparent piece of sequel bait, promising a bigger, crazier sequel where Tom Cruise is effectively transformed into a superhero mummy, who will presumably battle against other evil mummies.

It's amusing, for sure (especially Cruise's hands being wrapped in actual mummy bandages), but also a cliffhanger ultimately more head-smackingly silly than enticing.


11. The Major Really Is Japanese After All - Ghost In The Shell

Ghost In The Shell Scarlett Johansson Ending
Paramount

The Twist: In the film's third act, it's revealed that Major Mira Killian (Scarlett Johansson) is actually a Japanese woman named Motoko Kusanagi, whose memory was wiped and her brain placed inside this very Caucasian-looking shell.

Mira/Motoko actually meets her mother late in the movie, and in the film's closing moments, has a very, very weird reunion with her at Motoko's grave.

Why It's Dumb: This was basically an attempt by the movie to "own" its controversial white-washing, whereby Paramount refused to simply cast a Japanese actress as Motoko and hired a popular white actress instead.

In a way it's almost admirable that the movie was this self-aware, but some fans have also felt that it was a smug way to try and defend against criticism, with the ending basically screaming, "See! She was Japanese all along! But we still 'need' a white face for our big-budget movie, so screw you!"

It wants to have its cake and eat it too, but fans were naturally infuriated by the unintentionally comical if not downright insulting nature of the big reveal.


10. Barbossa Is Carina's Dad - Pirates Of The Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales

Pirates Of The Caribbean Dead Men Tell No Tales Barbossa
Disney

The Twist: Captain Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) turns out to be the father of the series' new female lead, plucky astronomer Carina Smyth (Kaya Scodelario)...for some reason.

Why It's Dumb: Because big-budget Hollywood franchises (especially Disney-owned ones) just can't resist making everyone related to everyone else, Carina can't just be a cool new character, and has to be needlessly related to Barbossa even though it makes little sense and comes totally out of nowhere.

More to the point, it's clearly intended to make Barbossa's sacrificial death at the end of the film more emotional, but when he refers to Carina as "treasure" moments before dying, it rings totally hollow and feels completely unearned.

If Barbossa does actually stay dead this time (unlikely), hopefully fans can just forget about this one.


9. The Ring Video Goes Viral - Rings

Rings Ending
Paramount

The Twist: Just when protagonist Julia (Matilda Lutz) and her boyfriend Holt (Alex Roe) think they've set Samara's spirit free, the Ring video magically decides to e-mail itself to everyone in Julia's address book, even after Holt unplugs the computer, effectively making the video go viral as the end credits roll.

Why It's Dumb: Taking The Ring viral is pretty much the laziest and most predictable route this series could've gone in the Internet age, but it might've actually worked with a less-goofy execution.

For one, who the hell even e-mails videos anymore? Wouldn't it have made more sense to have her post it to Facebook, YouTube or Twitter, where everyone can see it?


8. Harry Is Saved By...Nanobots - Kingsman: The Golden Circle

Kingsman The Golden Circle Harry Alive
Fox

The Twist: Harry Hart (Colin Firth) managed to survive being shot through the head in the first film because Statesman agents Ginger Ale (Halle Berry) and Tequila (Channing Tatum) quickly arrived on the scene and managed to administer a special "Alpha Gel" wrap to Harry's head, which prevented further trauma to his brain and repaired the damaged tissue, but also left him with retrograde amnesia.

Why It's Dumb: Bringing Firth's character back was always going to be tricky after he died so decisively in the original film, but like a lot of The Golden Circle's writing, this just felt lazy and overly daft.

It wasn't even knowingly dumb in a self-aware way, and left some fans wishing they'd just gone the whole stupid hog by giving Harry a twin brother instead. Lame.


7. Logan Is The New Apprentice - Jigsaw

Jigsaw Logan
Lionsgate

The Twist: Forensic pathologist Logan (Matt Passmore), thought to have been killed in Jigsaw's final trap moments earlier, stands up, revealing himself to be the original Jigsaw apprentice from a decade ago, who is only now stepping up to continue his work (for some reason).

Why It's Dumb: Though the timeline twist (that most of the movie was secretly set 10 years earlier) was incredibly unimaginative, the final big reveal of the new apprentice trumped it in the lazy, old-hat, recycled cliched plot twist stakes.

For starters, the "one more apprentice!" reveal just reeks of desperation to keep the franchise going, basically rehashing Saw IV's twist to diminished returns.

It's hard to believe Logan would just sit around doing nothing for ten years, and above all else, Logan's possibly an even less interesting apprentice than Detective Hoffman was. Terrible.


6. Naomi Watts Almost Murders A Child Molester - The Book Of Henry

The Book Of Henry Naomi Watts
Focus Features

The Twist: Early on in the movie, single mother Susan's (Naomi Watts) genius son Henry (Jaeden Lieberher) develops a brain tumour and dies, but leaves behind a book for his mother, announcing that their next door neighbour Glenn (Dean Norris) is molesting and abusing his own daughter.

Henry orders Susan to kill Glenn, detailing how she can carry it out without getting caught. Susan even goes to the lengths of setting up a sniper rifle to shoot Glenn, before realising that taking advice from your dead 11-year-old son isn't the best idea, and leaves it to the cops.

Why It's Dumb: For starters, the marketing suggested that The Book of Henry was going to be a sweet coming-of-age story, not a weird, tonally jarring, creepy and unintentionally comical flaming trainwreck about a woman dealing with her son's death in the worst way possible.

This movie did not need Naomi Watts peering down the scope of a sniper rifle, but in the so-bad-it's-awesome stakes, it's actually a good thing it happened. On any serious filmmaking level, though, Colin Trevorrow's major narrative left-turn was an hilarious, baffling failure.


5. Ed Harris Is The "Secret" Villain - Geostorm

Geostorm Ed Harris
Warner Bros.

The Twist: Secretary of State Leonard Dekkom (Ed Harris) is revealed to be the saboteur behind the impending Geostorm, hoping to use it to wipe out the line of Presidential succession and install himself as the Leader of the Free World.

Why It's Dumb: From pretty much the second he shows up on-screen, Ed Harris has a neon sign stapled to his shoulder reading "THIS GUY IS BAD. LIKE, REALLY BAD, GUYS!"

Anyone with a remote bead on how human beings act should've seen his subterfuge coming a mile off, and incredibly stupid though his scheme is, this is a movie called Geostorm after all, so it's not inconsistent with the rest of the movie (compared to, say, The Book of Henry).

Plus, the twist does mean that audiences get to see Harris grabbing a rocket launcher from the trunk of a car and firing it at a car he thinks contains the President, so you can't hate it too much.


4. Ellen Page Randomly Dies Before The Third Act - Flatliners

Flatliners Ellen Page Dead
Sony Pictures Releasing

The Twist: After flatlining, medical student Courtney (Ellen Page) is harassed by ghostly visions of her sister Tessa, who died in a car accident that was Courtney's fault.

Courtney flees to her fire escape to get away from the visions, but Tessa reappears, causing Courtney to fall over the fire escape to her death.

Why It's Dumb: For starters, Ellen Page was by far the best thing in this film, and killing her 40 minutes before the end of the movie wasn't such a smart idea.

Then there's the comical nature of her demise, and how shockingly little it seems to inform the rest of the movie. Though it was at least unexpected, it traded general storytelling logic for shock value and was totally laughable as a result.


3. David Steals Walter's Identity - Alien: Covenant

Alien Covenant Michael Fassbender David
Fox

The Twist: After the Covenant's surviving crew members, Daniels (Katherine Waterston) and Tennessee (Danny McBride), kill the final Xenomorph, they prepare to re-enter stasis on the way to Origae-6.

As Walter (Michael Fassbender) puts Daniels into stasis, she realises that the android is actually his evil "twin" David, who has somehow subdued Walter and taken his place on the Covenant.

The film then ends with the implication that David is going to use two facehugger embryos to continue his experiments.

Why It's Dumb: Though the film ending in such bleak fashion is pretty neat, the David twist is unfortunately so comically obvious that Ridley Scott deciding to make a big reveal out of it made it fall incredibly flat.

The twist is laboured to the point that the audience is just begging everyone to get on with it already, and overall it might've worked better if we actually just saw David defeat Walter.

That way, the suspense would relate to whether or not Daniels would discover David's deception before being put under. Sadly, poor execution ruined what otherwise could've been a chillingly horrifying finale.


2. Gary Oldman Is Asa Butterfield's Dad - The Space Between Us

The Space Between Us Gary Oldman Asa Butterfield
STX Entertainment

The Twist: Mars-born teenager Gardner (Asa Butterfield) heads to Earth to meet the man he believes to be his father, but when the man insists he isn't Gardner's dad, Gardner runs into the sea and tries to drown himself.

At that moment, the man who took care of Gardner on Mars, Nathaniel (Gary Oldman), appears and helps resuscitate Gardner, revealing himself to be the boy's father, having had a love affair with his mother on Mars, who died while giving birth to him.

The film then ends with the newly-reconciled father and son back on Mars together. How touching.

Why It's Dumb: Much like the Pirates of the Caribbean twist, this just didn't feel at all earned, but more like the sort of desperate, chintzy twist you'd expect to see in a Nicholas Sparks movie.

It was a lousy attempt to enhance the film's already flaccid level of viewer involvement, but was more likely to prompt howling chuckles than flowing tears.


1. Hitler Was Killed By A Transformer-Watch - Transformers: The Last Knight

Transformers The Last Knight Watch
Paramount

The Twist: When Cade Yeager (Mark Wahlberg) ends up visiting Sir Edmund Burton (Anthony Hopkins) to receive a colossal exposition dump, his love interest Viviane Wembly (Laura Haddock) takes a nose around and grabs hold of a clock housed within a glass case that's sporting a few suspicious bullet marks.

Burton promptly warns her to put the clock down as it begins to sprout robotic arms and legs. Burton then tells her, "That's the watch that killer Hitler. Don't screw with it."

Why It's Dumb: This is a Transformers movie, so of course it's dumb, and though previous Transformers movies have engaged with real-world history by inserting the Autobots and Decepticons into the space race, the fifth film made the wildly tone-deaf decision to suggest a Transformer actually killed Hitler.

On one hand it's outrageously tacky and tasteless, and on the other it's totally hilarious. Either way, it's so over-the-top and silly it verges on self-parody for the franchise. It's idiotic, but there's a good chance you smirked when Anthony Hopkins of all people revealed the historical revision.

What were the 2017 movie plot twists that left you stunned by their idiocy? Shout them out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.