12 Easy Solutions To Save The X-Men Franchise

It’s not over yet: “in mutant heaven there are no pearly gates, but instead revolving doors.”

XMen Marvel

It’s no exaggeration to say that, if you’re purely a fan of the X-Men through their movies, then you haven’t really seen the X-Men at all. You’ve seen cardboard cutout versions of some of the characters associated with the X-Men, but not the X-Men themselves.

It’s what comes of the films being propelled by movie producers with an eye on the bottom line rather than enthusiasm for the source material; studio executives with no real love for the premise and the characters, and so no interest in recreating that feeling in a new, global audience.

Deadpool - made with passion and unswerving commitment by a writer, director and star who refused to take no for an answer, is the most successful film in the X-Men franchise to date. X-Men: Apocalypse, on the other hand, touted as bigger and better after the breakout critical and commercial success of X-Men: Days Of Future Past, only did two-thirds the numbers of its predecessor.

Why? Because word of mouth told everyone that it was another made-by-committee crapfest - what one reviewer called “gliding, passionless mediocrity” - and featured a director and cast that appeared burned out and bored by the whole thing.

I’m no Marvel fanatic that claims that sticking slavishly to the source material is the answer: but understanding why the source material resonated so strongly with people should be the first step in considering any adaptation… and especially how to save a franchise that’s nosediving, and make it soar again.

12. Stop Making Prequels To Films That Don’t Exist

Xavier and Magneto
Fox

The third prequel in the franchise (yes, the first Wolverine movie counts), X-Men: Days Of Future Past’s time travel shenanigans ultimately altered the X-Men franchise’s timeline, course-correcting after the disastrous public reaction to the events of X-Men: The Last Stand.

Despite this, the next film in the series, X-Men: Apocalypse, was yet another prequel… which begs the question, prequel to what? It’s not been made clear whether the changes to the timeline still result in the events of X-Men and X-2: what we do know is that people killed in X-Men:The Last Stand are still alive as a consequence of X-Men: Days Of Future Past.

Are we now in uncharted territory, making X-Men movies set in the increasingly recent past, as Xavier and Magneto meet up every ten years to bicker over the same old rubbish like exes at a family barbecue?

It’s already beginning to come off as stupid. Neither Magneto nor Xavier look any older in the eighties than they did in the sixties, and in X-Men: Apocalypse Quicksilver is, ten years after his debut in X-Men: Days Of Future Past, still exactly the same age and living in his mother’s basement. And ten years is a sod of a long time. What else have they been up to?

Continuity is also falling by the wayside through sheer laziness. Technology is light years ahead of where it should be in decades past, and lip service is paid to past fashions and a few historical events, rather than whole cultural paradigms.

Moreover, people are still narked that central characters introduced in X-Men: First Class are murdered between films, and there’s never been a satisfactory explanation as to how Xavier is restored to life between the events of X-Men: The Last Stand and The Wolverine, or how Wolverine ends up in the Weapon X facility in X-Men: Apocalypse when at the end of X-Men: Days Of Future Past he was being rescued by Mystique.

The simplest way to fix all of this narrative damage - without going the scorched earth route of the complete reboot - is to begin telling contemporary X-Men stories again.


11. Enough Of This Temporal Malarkey

X-Men: Days Of Future Past Cyclops Wolverine Jean Grey
20th Century Fox

And, following on from that - no more godd*mn time travel.

There isn’t a franchise in cinema that hasn’t been tangled into a thick web of bullsh*t by the inherent paradoxes incumbent in time travel. The Back To The Future films became a mathematical nightmare, while the Terminator movies have officially begun tunnelling up their own backsides.

These are not rigorously plotted novels or marathon seasons of television. These are two hour popcorn flicks, intended to be watched in a single sitting, and they need to be coherent, or at the very least comprehensible.

And no, it’s not enough to script a massive expositional splurge of timey-wimey nonsense and have the Xander of your group of protagonists comically exclaim that he can’t follow it, or for everyone to agree not to think about it because ‘time travel gives them headaches’. That’s just a giant lampshade to your audience that you don’t really understand it either, and can’t be bothered to fix it or make it more intelligible.

X-Men: Days Of Future Past was an unusually strong X-Men movie, but it’s properly thrown the cat amongst the pigeons. Figure out what the timeline of 2018 looks like now, set the next X-Men movie in it and come up with a story. It’s not rocket surgery.


10. Dressing To The Left

1159960

The X-uniforms. Dear god, the leather, the armour… the flight suits, the zippers, everything. It’s all so homogenised, so dull. In X-Men: Apocalypse, they all looked like Star Wars villains who’d lost their helmets.

The Fantastic Four are a literal family - a husband and wife, her kid brother and the grumpy ‘uncle’ - and so can get away with wearing identical uniforms. The X-Men, on the other hand, tend to wear a whole panoply of different colours and styles to reflect the fact that they’re all individuals who’ve come together by choice to form a team.

Obviously you have to be a little careful, or you run the risk of having your cast looking like randy cosplayers at San Diego, two Jager shots away from some inappropriate sticky groping behind a Pixar display. But is there really any justification for these people not to have their own clothes that they dress in to fight and save lives? Why are they picking them all off the stormtrooper rack at the X-Mansion?

And isn’t looking like a fascist paramilitary squad the last thing that this team need if they want to make people feel more secure about mutants in society?


9. Infamy, Infamy, They’ve All Got It In For Me

783684

Now, I’m not sure if I’ve correctly parsed the clever cultural subtext in the X-Men films, so apologies if I’ve misinterpreted something… but my understanding is that, in these radical political texts masquerading as summer superhero fluff, the X-Men fight to protect a world that hates and fears them for no other reason than that they are mutants, in a thinly veiled allegory of every real life civil rights issue that’s ever plagued mankind.

You know how I know this? Because the default plot of every freaking X-Men movie ever made is twofold. Either Magneto is going off on one because humans hate and fear mutants, or humanity’s hatred and fear of mutants has caused them to experiment on them/enact legislation to control them/invent giant robots to kill them.

Or, in a dramatic and unforeseen turn of events, Magneto has gone off on one again. Because humans, you see, hate and fear mutants. We’ve seen so many different versions of these two incredibly depressing plotlines that I’m starting to hate and fear mutants.

Even X-Men: Apocalypse had to give us yet another appearance from mutant-hating military man William Stryker, the villain from X2 and X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: Days Of Future Past, and yet another visit to the mutant experimentation facility at Alkali Lake that birthed the Weapon X project.

The X-Men movies need new antagonists to antagonise them. Apocalypse would have been an excellent start, had Simon Kinberg and Bryan Singer not completely failed to bring the character’s awesome power and repellent magnificence to the screen.

The last film’s post-credits sequence teasing the arrival of Mister Sinister is very welcome… but how about a villain who’s not obsessed with genetics, mutation, stealing mutant powers or orchestrating some form of Nietzschean bloodbath?

Arcade, Mojo, the Shi’ar, the Brood, the Technarchy/Phalanx… even the modern day return of the Hellfire Club. Not every X-Men villain is a mutant supremacist/terrorist, and some of them are even...


8. Depression Is Not A Mutant Power

X-Men Apocalypse Quicksilver
Fox

…fun.

The odd one-liner aside, fun is something singularly lacking from the X-Men franchise. The closest we’ve come to a genuinely pervasive sense of fun was X-Men: First Class, and Matthew Vaughn’s winsome take on the swinging sixties.

That lasted for around the first half of the film… and then went into the toilet as soon as we were introduced to the mutant Nazi who experimented on other mutants in Auschwitz. Sebastian Shaw had made a blood enemy of Magneto, which depressingly gave us both default X-Men movie plots at one and the same time. Thank god one of them was Kevin Bacon.

Quicksilver gave us a moment of spectacular fun in X-Men: Days Of Future Past, a film that was otherwise bleaker than bleak. We could do with some more of that, because not every mutant hates being a mutant, you know?

Nightcrawler is a case in point: a wisecracking, devil-may-care swashbuckler with a heart of gold. Blessed with a prehensile tail, the man Errol Flynns around fencing with three swords at once. That’s wonderful. Why isn’t that all over our cinema screens?

Instead, X2 proffered a tattooed case of Catholic guilt, and X-Men: Apocalypse gave us Kid Nightcrawler with his Flock Of Seagulls haircut. Both versions of Kurt Wagner were good as far as they went (and frustratingly, nearly great), but we need more.

We need a real Fastball Special, not an ersatz Colossus swinging around and chucking a man nearly the same size as him. We need tongue-in-cheek superpowered games of baseball, volleyball, dodgeball; we need X-Men: Apocalypse’s trip to the mall, only with an actual trip to the mall, complete with image inducers going on the fritz and panicked soccer moms and security guards.


7. I Got All My Mutants With Me

X Men
Marvel Comics

More than anything, we need to be reminded that the X-Men are a family. Not the kind of tight family unit that the Fantastic Four represent, but the kind you select for yourself later on in life when you’re left to choose who you want to be and what you want to stand for.

There’s a tribalistic element to it, sure. But throughout decades of comic books, the core X-Men have always been a group of people who stay together, not just because they’re the same, or to survive, or out of some kind of superheroic sense of obligation to society... but because they’re a team. The whole is greater than the sum of its parts. They live together, train together, learn how each others’ powers work and what makes each other tick.

These are people who’ve taken on codenames, not to protect their true identities, but to adopt new ones that express who they are as mutants. It’s literally an empowerment issue… but they’ll still call each other by their given names half the time, bicker like siblings, pair off like excited kids at summer camp, and occasionally vow never to speak to one another again - and even mean it for a few years.

Other superheroes can have their Civil War, come to blows and even bloodshed over misunderstandings and politics. The X-Men will fight, sure - but the same way you fought with your brother when you were kids, with an anger that’s soon forgotten.

The X-Men in these movies have never been a family, and that - aside from the inconsistent and questionable characterisation that’s often haunted these films - is one of the main reasons they’re just not as compelling as they should be. These are gaps that a new X-Men script needs to fill.


6. The Hobgoblin Of Little Minds

X Men Animated
Marvel

It’s becoming more and more difficult to find consistency with the X-Men in these films. For all their faults, the first three movies gave us the same group of people played by the same actors; as much as the scripts weren’t the greatest, there was continuity.

If you liked Halle Berry’s Storm, then good news! She was playing her in the same way across all three films. If you were a Professor X fan and appreciated Patrick Stewart’s compassionate, gentle take on the character, then you were in for a treat right up until the end of act two of X-Men: The Last Stand (at which point you wanted to throw rocks at Brett Ratner’s head).

In 2016, the only layer of continuity in the X-Men teams we’ve experienced has been Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine, who’s been a presence (to varying degrees) in all but one of the X-Men movies to date. But these are the X-Men, not Logan And His Super Friends, and an X-Men movie should be a genuine ensemble piece… and one that keeps the same ensemble together, for the most part.

All of the best and most iconic X-Men stories of the comic books came at a time when the core X-Men team was something that could be relied upon. The characters and relationships were set in stone: we knew that Scott and Jean were soulmates; that Wolverine was drawn to Jean in ways he didn’t know how to articulate, a wild beast worshipping an angel; that Kitty was everyone’s scrappy kid sister and that Kurt had the romantic soul of D’Artagnan in the body of a demon.

Give us a set team that doesn’t change, and then establish that team as people via the way that they speak to one another and relate to one another - beyond what strange abilities they have, and whatever cool look they’ve got going on.

Audiences follow things they can engage with, things they can relate to, and nine times out of ten that’s going to be people, not powers. There’s a reason that Robert Downey Jr made Tony Stark a household name, not just Iron Man.


5. Just Get It Over With

hugh jackman explosion wolverine
20th Century Fox

If there are going to be Fox X-Men movies for a while to come (and it seems that this is Fox’s plan for the property at this stage), then the elephant in the room needs to be addressed, and it needs to be addressed sooner rather than later: Wolverine needs to be recast.

Even if they amp up the personas of the other members of the team to create that true ensemble feeling that I’ve been talking about, Hugh Jackman’s portrayal of Wolverine has been central to the franchise for sixteen years now, and over eight out of the nine movies in that franchise. But he’s not going to be playing Logan for much longer… the third Wolverine movie is up next, and that’s going to be his last go at the guy.

But Wolverine’s a core member of the team, and the one that casual fans link most to the whole concept of ‘X-Men’. You can’t have an X-Men team without Wolverine on it - and no, not the X-23 Wolverine that Marvel’s trying to foist on us, the real one. But how do you go about recasting someone considered so married to the role?

Marvel Studios are going to have similar issues at some point, having been so successful with the Marvel Cinematic Universe that they’ve created multiple film versions of their characters that are intrinsically tied up with the actor who plays them. After all, while anyone could wear the Iron Man armour, no one except for Robert Downey can play Tony Stark.

There are any number of ways to make a new Wolverine: cloning and a sneaky mind-transfer can create a similar but not identical copy, or a displaced alternate universe Logan could arrive to, I don’t know, restock on cigars or something. The Logan we know and love could mutate further, changing appearance - or be radically altered for some reason. They could be incredibly cheeky and simply recast the role with no storyline explanation: it works for James Bond.

Fundamentally, the ‘how’ isn’t as important as the ‘who’, and whoever’s cast as Wolverine 2.0 will have his work cut out for him. But if it’s got to happen - and it probably does - then it’s got to be prepared for, and the steps taken to begin the process, soon.


4. Cancel The Chuck & Erik Show

X-Men Apocalypse Charles Xavier Magneto
20th Century Fox

It may surprise fans of the X-Men movies who don’t read the comics to realise this… but Professor Charles Xavier isn’t the hero of the X-Men comics. He’s not the leader, he’s not the protagonist. He never has been - and there’s a reason for that.

Charles Xavier is the X-Men’s avuncular mentor/stern grandfather/adored father figure, depending on the generation of X-Men you're talking about. There’s a reason some supporting players don’t step into the limelight, and there’s a reason some protagonists aren’t the most charismatic or the most complex: the protagonist carries the narrative, and often it’s easier if they’re less idiosyncratic, and more relatable.

Most of the X-Men movies that aren’t Wolverine solo flicks (I know, I know - it’s sometimes difficult to tell) feature Xavier in a prominent role as the protagonist… and his greatest nemesis and best friend Magneto in a prominent role as either co-protagonist or antagonist, seemingly switching between the two as and when he feels like it.

It’s already been touched upon… but it’s time for a new paradigm in the X-Men movies. This whole ‘frenemies’ thing has been done to death. Patrick Stewart and James McAvoy, Sir Ian McKellen and Michael Fassbender - they’ve all been great in the role(s), often with very little to work with. But both Charles Xavier and Erik Lehnsherr need to take a back seat now.


3. Will The Real [Insert Name Here] Please Stand Up?

Cyclops x-men
Marvel Comics

For various reasons, important figures in the X-Men mythology have been badly misrepresented by the movies to date. Former Interpol agent and tough Irish b*stard Banshee was reduced to a teenage stereotype and killed between movies; Wolverine’s nemesis Sabretooth went from being a feral mass-murderer, the thing that Logan is most terrified of becoming, to a sarcastic a-hole with big sideburns that pounces on people like an excited kitten.

Mystique is not a hero. Not even in the movies. She’s a founder member of the Brotherhood Of (Evil) Mutants. The Raven Darkholme in the comics tends to be a ruthless pragmatist with almost no scruples or ideals whatsoever: the Mystique in X-Men, X2 and X-Men: The Last Stand was a ruthless idealist and martyr to the mutant cause.

Between X-Men: First Class and X-Men: Days Of Future Past, Jennifer Lawrence (playing the younger Mystique) became the highest grossing action heroine in cinema history with The Hunger Games. Since then - and especially in X-Men: Apocalypse - Lawrence has made it crystal clear that she doesn’t want to be in the X-Men films anymore.

Unfortunately, she’s contractually obligated to do them: and to capitalise on her fame, they’ve skewed the character to keep her at the forefront of the narrative, even to the extent that Lawrence is delivering the big motivational speeches and spending most of the film out of makeup.This heroic icon to the mutant people isn’t any version of Mystique. It’s a version of Jennifer Lawrence’s character from the Hunger Games, a cynical cash-in, nothing more.

Cyclops, on the other hand, is the real deal: the team’s leader and the definitive X-Man. This is a kid who had the worst childhood you can imagine, a boy who was pretty much saved by Xavier. Driven to the point of obsession, he's transformed himself into the perfect leader, but he's also a mass of scar tissue in the shape of a man, and can be pretty f*cking scary to boot.

Now, James Marsden is a wonderful actor in many ways, but he’s not Cyclops. Those lasers in his noggin aren’t Cyclops’ optic blasts either, by the way. They’re beams of concussive force, and they don’t set fire to trees.

You can have an X-Men movie without Mystique… but you shouldn’t be able to make an X-Men movie without Cyclops. Professor X might have had the dream about co-existence, but Cyclops is the man who’s charged with keeping it alive: he should be front and centre in any new X-Men movies.


2. Kill God

Bryan Singer
20th Century Fox

Simon Kinberg and returning director Bryan Singer have been the central creative force behind the X-Men movies for a number of years now… and Singer’s made it perfectly clear that he’s got no investment in the X-Men franchise, banning the comic books from the set and going on record in 2004 and again this year as saying he wanted to get away from it and do something else.

As far as Kinberg goes, it beggars belief that people are still allowing him anywhere near this franchise now.

Let’s not forget, he was at least partially responsible for X-Men: The Last Stand. By now it’s fairly common knowledge that director Brett Ratner, with no prior knowledge of or interest in the X-Men, left huge chunks of story development up to Kinberg and fellow screenwriter Zak Penn.

They, in turn, bowed to Fox executives who demanded various changes occur - including Cyclops’ murder, forcibly inserted into the script because James Marsden had taken a job on the latest Superman movie. It was suggested that Cyclops wasn’t relatable to audiences ‘because they couldn’t see his eyes’.

Kinberg seems genuinely not to understand why it is that his movies aren’t working - let’s not forget the massive creative hand he had in last year’s Fantastic Four abortion, which was supposedly intended to bring the FF and X-Men universes together. After every failure, he chalks it up to experience and, inexplicably, is given the task of screwing up the next one.

X-Men: The Last Stand. Fantastic Four. X-Men: Apocalypse. These are all films written and mostly produced by Kinberg, all movies that have received some of the worst notices - from fans and critics - of any superhero movies in the last twenty years. Only Catwoman has done worse.

It’s time to admit that the Singer-Kinberg team isn’t working. Neither man has any investment in or passion for the X-Men as a group of characters, as source material or as a concept: it’s why so many things have failed in the journey from page to screen. Neither Singer nor Kinberg understand why ‘the X-Men’ works, and that’s the reason they broke it.

It can easily be argued that, together and separately, Singer and Kinberg are the creators of the X-Men franchise to date. Well, in that case it’s time to kill God, bury Him at a crossroads and salt the g*ddamn earth to make sure He doesn’t rise again.

Whatever the next X-Men movie ends up being, it needs to be brought to the screen by different people.


1. Make Mine Marvel

Doctor Strange Ms Marvel.jpg
Marvel Studios

This isn’t some slavish demand for the X-Men to be sandwiched into the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and I’m not some shameless apologist for the MCU that believes they’ve done everything right.

However, the things that Marvel Studios have done right are precisely the things that the X-Men franchise has failed to do.

Things like, having the same creative circle, people who knew the properties back to front, micromanaging the individual teams on each film.

Things like, ruthlessly maintaining continuity between films to make each one must-see viewing, casting the same actors, plotting crossovers years in advance, planting seeds for the future.

Things like, finding the heart of the character and staying true to that, even if it means rewriting the established back story of that character.

Things like, sticking to their guns and creating the movies that work in the context of the universe they’re creating , and not allowing anyone outside that creative bubble to make demands about what would and wouldn’t be in those movies.

These are all mistakes make - often through the corporate culture of Fox, and its complete disinterest in the property being adapted - by the people behind the X-Men franchise, mistakes Marvel hasn’t made.

The X-Men films can still be fixed… if someone steps on board that’s willing to take ownership of the property and steer it away from the institutionalised creative bankruptcy that’s plagued it before. Let’s see whether anyone at Fox has the guts and the foresight to give that a try.

How would you fix the X-Men film universe? Share your suggestions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.