12 Films That Wasted Incredible Potential

All of these films had the chance to be so much more, but sadly, they all blew it...

Resident Evil The Final Chapter
Sony

Every so often the latest lineup of films poised to hit theatres can give us very little to get excited about.

Another unnecessary sequel to a once beloved franchise. A family film with an unbearable cast of child actors. An older actor known for starring in serious dramas now appearing in a cringe worthy comedy. And of course, the generic action film you’ll probably want to watch just to see how stupid things can get.

Sometimes you will feel like you have seen all of these films before and once again begin to question if originality is well and truly dead in the film industry.

But once every blue moon, a new film will come along and capture everyone's attention. Trailers show the potential in the film's premise and the hype begins to build as audiences hope the film can deliver an experience worthy of said hype.

But where some of these films stick the landing, others miss the mark completely, and despite their enjoyability, end up leaving audiences to wonder what could have been.

Here are some films that had such great potential, only to waste it on a mediocre and underwhelming experience.

12. Lucy

Lucy Scarlett Johansson
EuropaCorp

Based on the myth that humans only use 10% of their brain’s capabilities, Lucy explores what would happen if we were able to use 100%. With Scarlett Johansson starring as the titular character and Luc Besson as writer and director, people took notice of the film very quickly and were excited to see what would happen.

The film would start out strong, as Johansson’s character unintentionally ingests large quantities of a new drug. As a result, she acquires superior mental and physical abilities which later develop into superpowers like telepathy and telekinesis.

Unfortunately, while the drugs give Lucy the ability to become superhuman, the film did little to stimulate the brains of its audience.

Besson would admit that the idea was to have the first half of the film follow a similar style to one of his previous films, Leon: The Professional, while the second half was to be a combo of Inception and 2001: A Space Odyssey. This would explain why the film had such a nonsensical plot

Although the film was a commercial success, it left many film goers and critics unsatisfied with its ludacris ending.


11. Warcraft

Warcraft Durotan
Universal

Warcraft is a franchise of numerous video games, novels and other media created by Blizzard Entertainment. It is set in the high fantasy world of Azeroth and focuses on the many different races within it, such as humans, orcs, trolls, dwarves and elves. Multiple expansions have led to the Warcraft series standing tall as one of the most popular real-time strategy and MMORPG games of all time.

With such a devoted fan base and a wealth of material to work with, many believed that Warcraft would stand a better chance of succeeding at the box office than most. But despite it becoming the highest grossing video game adaptation of all time, Warcraft would not enjoy the same critical success of its games.

The film had a convoluted plot that was trying to tell the story about how war between humans and orcs began while also trying to weave in elements of Warcraft mythology. This resulted in a lot of exposition that only fans of the series would be able to understand. Casual film audiences would not be able to follow its complex plot and remember it as another promising high fantasy film series that failed to impress.


10. The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen

The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen
20th Century Fox

Alan Moore is one of the most renowned comic book writers of his generation for such works as V For Vendetta, Watchmen and Batman: The Killing Joke, which would all get adapted into their own films. The same would happen to The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen, although it would not receive the same levels of success as the later mentioned comics.

The comic focused on a Victorian era ensemble of heroes with steampunk technology. Like most of Moore’s work, the comics embrace and focus on the darker side of its characters, such as Mr Hyde, The Invisible Man and its lead, Allan Quartermain. Fans of the comics were certain that if the film stayed faithful to the source material, then it would be a major success.

Unfortunately, it would diverge from the original comics so heavily, that Moore would do everything to distance himself from the film.

Major production issues and questionable casting choices resulted in a critical and box office flop that would kill plans for a sequel and convince Sean Connery to retire from filmmaking altogether.

A reboot has been talked about in the past, but it would not be hard to do better than this disappointment.


9. Chappie

Chappie movie
Columbia Pictures

After making multiple shorts films, writer and director Neill Blomkamp rose to fame with his first feature length film District 9, which was based on one of his original shorts. His next film, Elysium, would not be as successful, but further demonstrated his ability to make interesting and compelling stories in a gritty and realistic science-fiction setting.

Chappie, at least on paper, seemed like it was going to be more of the same from Blomkamp. Based on another one of his short films, Chappie was about a law enforcement robot in Johannesburg, South Africa, that is uploaded with a new artificial intelligence. The robot is captured by gangsters, who name it Chappie and try to teach it how to fight and stand up for itself.

But what was looking like a new and interesting science-fiction film turned out to be another attempt by a director to try and say something meaningful, without the means to say it in a compelling way.

In the end, Chappie was nothing more than a confusing mix between Short Circuit and Alita Battle Angel, with a story that threw logic out the window on more than one occasion.


8. The Monument Men

The Monuments Men
Columbia Pictures

There have been many films depicting true events from the Second World War, but none of them are quite like the story of The Monuments Men, which is why it interested so many people.

The Monuments Men is based on an Allied Forces group called the Monuments, Fine Arts and Archives program, or the MFAA. Their mission is to find and save the many pieces of art and other culturally important items before the Nazis can steal or destroy them.

Combine the story with a hefty cast of incredible actors, such as George Clooney, Matt Damon, John Goodman and Bill Murray, and many people believed it was obvious that the film was going to be a big success with critics and fans.

But considering the title of this list, it should be apparent that was not the case.

Clooney admitted he was heartbroken to hear of the film's underperformance at the box office and its mixed critical reception. Even though the film was praised for its noble intentions and relevant theme, it was not enough to draw attention away from its unsatisfying plot or one dimensional characters.


7. The Last Airbender

The Last Airbender movie
Paramount Pictures

Avatar: The Last Airbender was a hugely successful tv show on Nickelodeon. Set in an Asiatic world where people can control the elements, water, earth fire or air, the series centred around the journey of the Avatar. As the only person capable of bending all four elements and to enter the spirit world, The Avatar must travel the world with his friends to master all four elements and defeat the evil Fire Nation.

Its popularity and success as an animated kids show led to many wondering if it could be just as successful in a live action version, and it would not be long before they would get their answer. Two years after the show's final episode, a live-action film adaptation was released with M. Night Shyamalan as director.

Casting controversies, promotional blunders, awful special effects and horrible acting caused the film to receive abysmal ratings and killed any chance for more films in the franchise.

Fans of the original series hated it so much that they preferred to block it out of their memory and did all they could to distance the film from the tv show.


6. Jupiter Ascending

jupiter ascending
Warner Bros.

The Wachowski’s have had an interesting career. They were flying high after writing and directing The Matrix Trilogy and the film adaptation of V for Vendetta, both of which earned them massive critical acclaim. But things started to go down hill for them after both the live-action adaptation of Speed Racer and the film adaptation of Cloud Atlas performed terribly at the box office.

Jupiter Ascending was a chance for the Wachowski’s to prove to their doubters wrong, and to be fair, the premise for the film was able to turn some heads. Described as a mix between The Matrix and Star Wars, a young woman discovers that she is a royal descendant of a transhuman race and is at the centre of a major political dispute over ownership of the Earth.

It was a highly ambitious science-fiction epic that sadly failed on multiple levels.

The films over reliance on special effects, horrendous performances from the likes of Mila Kunis and Eddie Redmayne and confusing story made for a dull and boring experience that turned out to be nothing more than another incoherent science fiction film with goofy action sequences and garbage dialogue.


5. Resident Evil

Resident Evil Milla Jovovich Michelle Rodriguez
Screen Gems

The Resident Evil franchise is based on a number of survival horror games where an outbreak of zombies and other grotesque monsters is started by the Umbrella Corporation. It has earned a devoted following over the years and is one of the most iconic franchises in all of gaming.

A film adaptation was talked about for years, but the German production company Constantin Film could not decide on who was going to write and direct it. Eventually, they decided to go with Paul W. S. Anderson, which was seen as an excellent choice by fans at the time as he had just finished making the Mortal Kombat movie, which was one of the first commercially successful video game adapted films.

Although the film did well at the box office, it failed to resonate with existing fans of the franchise because of its boring story and the way it treated some of the series most beloved characters.

What would be most disappointing for fans is that the film would spawn multiple sequels that would continue to divert further away from the original material, leaving them to wonder what could have been.


4. Alien Vs Predator

AVP Alien Vs Predator
20th Century Fox

On paper at least, this looked like it was set to be an easy win for everybody involved.

In one corner, you had the extraterrestrial terror that would burst out of people's chests, had acid for blood and another mouth on the end of its tongue. In the other, was the space traveling prize hunter, who could turn invisible and had an arsenal of deadly weapons that made a squad of badass commandos look like a bunch of amateurs.

Fans of both the Alien and Predator series knew just how tough it was to kill these things, and were instantly drawn in to see who would come out on top.

Unfortunately, the film would not be the mother of all alien showdowns that fans were hoping for, courtesy of the same writer and director of the Resident Evil film, Paul W. S. Anderson

Instead, fans got a lot of painful B movie acting, terrible directing and a lack of compelling fight scenes. Throw in a bunch of terrible dialogue for good measure and you have a swarm of hopeful fans yawning their way out of the theatres.


3. The Golden Compass

golden compass
New Line Cinema

The Golden Compass film from 2007 is one of many examples of how a studio's attempts to make a film franchise out of a successful book series ends in miserable failure.

Based on the first book in Philip Pullman’s best selling series, His Dark Materials, The Golden Compass focuses on an orphaned girls journey to save her kidnapped friend. Along the way, she encounters armoured polar bears, witches and the despicable Oblation Board, who are secretly experimenting on children in their attempt to better understand the properties of a magical substance referred to in the world as Dust.

The books offered everything a fan of fantasy adventure novels could ask for. Sadly though, the film would not live up to the same success as the books.

The decision to dilute or omit key elements of the original book's story did not sit well with fans. Things got worse when the studio stepped in to make multiple changes in post-production in order to make the film more appealing to wider audiences. The film would fail to make any lasting impressions and lead to the studio cancelling plans to adapt the other books in the series.


2. X-Men: The Last Stand

X-Men The Last Stand Poster
Fox

Two years prior to the incredible success of Iron Man, Marvel released the disappointing third instalment in the X-Men series.

The film's script was loosely based on a few X-men comics and focused on a potential war breaking out between humans and mutants. At the same time, Jean Gray returns as The Phoenix, a powerful alter personality of Jean with incredibly destructive capabilities.

Fans of the series were positive that The Last Stand would be just as successful as its two predecessors and were excited to see the Dark Phoenix arc as an integral part of the story. Unfortunately, it looked like the film was doomed to disappoint from the start.

The director and writers from the first two films left to work on other projects and the studio was struggling to find replacements, as all of their top picks were committed to other films. In the end, they picked a director with limited knowledge on the X-Men myths who heavily relied on the new writing team to adapt the comic faithfully.

The result was a film that was panned by fans and critics for its mediocre screenplay and was labelled the weakest of the three films.


1. Solo: A Star Wars Story

Solo A Star Wars Story Poster
Lucasfilm

Solo: A Star Wars Story focuses on Han’s early adventures ten years prior to the original Star Wars trilogy. As he reluctantly becomes part of a heist within the criminal underworld, Han would come to meet Chewbacca and acquire the Millennium Falcon from Lando Calrissian.

The premise was more than enough to excite long time fans, who were keen to see an origin story to one of the most popular characters in all of film. However, the final product did more to undermine its main character than to make them stand out as the likeable rogue everyone had all come to know him as.

Instead of highlighting any of Han’s skill or natural abilities, he just comes across as being insanely lucky or having things given to him with little effort. The film also went out of its way to focus more on new characters, like L3-37 and Han’s love interest Qi’ra, instead of focusing on the character the film is named after.

Ultimately, Solo was a story that was screaming with potential, but was screwed up so badly that it became the first Star Wars film to lose money at the box office.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Resident Evil
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

I am an open minded guy who is always up for trying new things. I love playing video games, watching and critiquing the latest films and tv shows and a big fan of football. P.S, I hope you are all doing well during these challenging times and that you have a great day.