12 Most Insulting Changes To Movie Remakes

Really Disney, did you have to do King Stefan dirty like that?

Maleficent Rapist
Disney

Movie remakes are more common in our increasingly nostalgia driven society than ever before, with companies like Disney having all their releases now being driven by the rebirth of cherished relics of the past.

It gives them the chance to not only tell a tale with modern technology, but fix any glaring issues the original had to, theoretically, make the perfect film. It can also allow someone with a bold new vision to re-imagine a narrative or concept and portray it differently, allowing audiences to fall in love with two versions of their favorite flick.

There are of course the utterly pointless shot-for-shot remakes, like the terrible Psycho remake starring Vince Vaughn and the recent Lion King disaster, but this is a list of remakes that dared to do something different and ended up making the worst choices they could have.

They aren't just a weaker direction or minor change, these are changes seemingly designed to cause at much hate towards the remake as possible. An insulting breach of trust with directors mishandling a beloved retelling in order to be different when they should have left well enough alone.

The following 12 movies decided that they just couldn't hold back, and said yes to some incredibly misguided choices to try and spice up their respective imaginings.

Warning: Full spoilers ahead.

12. The Karate Kid (2010) - The Kid Doesn't Learn Karate

The Karate Kid
Sony

The Karate Kid is a prime slice of 80's nostalgia that has held up well enough with great performances, classic soundtrack and a sincere warm tone. The legendary performance of Mr. Miyagi even earned Pat Morita an Academy Award nomination, and it is held dear to fans hearts even today.

The idea of remaking it seemed blasphemous at the time, and there was a swarm of negative reception to the film pre-release. Even an icon like Jackie Chan as the new teacher Mr. Han couldn't help quell fans distaste for this kids new training.

When it was released, however, it turned out to be an above average offering that took viewers to Asia for a change of scenery, and a more balanced focus on Dre and Mr. Han's lives over the original narrative's focus on Daniel fighting his bullies for a love interest.

Except for one simple thing - the title is a big fat lie and karate is nowhere to be found in this film literally titled The KARATE Kid.

In an extremely puzzling move, instead of karate being taught to our young protagonist, he is taught Kung Fu. He also learns it in China, the birthplace of Kung Fu, and not Japan that invented the titular martial art.

It was clearly labelled The Karate Kid to rope in fans of the original while doing its own thing. It was titled the Kung Fu Wonder in Asia, so the refusal to change it here for the sake of the almighty dollar was just insulting.


11. Halloween (2007) - Explaining Michael Myers' Motives

Halloween 2007 Danny Trejo
TWC

Michael Myers is a horror icon for inadvertently jump-starting the slasher craze and for being a downright terrifying, seemingly unstoppable villain. Part of what makes Michael so great is the original Halloween's lack of explanation it gives for the reason he kills.

All audiences get is a glimpse of a stoic child after stabbing his sister to death, and a host of chilling lines from Dr Loomis describing how Michael 'has the Devil's eyes' and other horrifying descriptions of the enigma that is his mind. Along with Michael's seeming invincibility, it gave him a mythical quality with your mind racing to wonder how he worked and could be stopped.

After many sequels, the plot-lines grew insane to the point audiences discovered Michael was controlled by a cult, and a reboot was desperately needed.

Enter the Rob Zombie directed remake almost 30 years later that decided to give the serial killer a believable backstory and clue viewers into what makes Michael tick. However, instead of being a frightening force of the unknown, Michael is given the most boring, generic backstory for a murderer you can think of.

All the cliched tropes, such as coming from an abusive home and starting off by killing small animals, are present, and turns one of horrors biggest icons into a bullied mamma's boy.

It may be what many killers admittedly do start out as, but your imagination running wild trying to understand Myers urge to kill is far more terrifying than anything that could be put to screen.


10. The Thing (2011) - Swapping Practical Effects For CGI

The Thing 2011 Mary Elizabeth Winstead
Universal

This movie was so close to being the coolest film of 2011.

John Carpenter's original The Thing is a testament to the craft of practical effects, with showstopping set-pieces of alien transformations and grotesque death scenes that horrify now just as much as they did back in 1982.

The remake's story-line following the first team that discovered the Alien also allowed the film to follow the same basic structure of the original, while lending itself to fresh scenarios and answer some lingering fan theories.

When it was announced it thrilled horror fans whose imaginations ran wild with how stunning modern day effects could bring the titular Alien, and it's disgusting habits, to life. The film was then released with horrendously bad CGI effects and the entire world let out a unified cry of anguish.

It felt like a betrayal for what the original film stood for, and the fact the movie had a huge amount of it's run-time done with outstanding practical effects only to be erased and replaced with the garbage we got instead is just salt in the wound.

The film itself is decent for what it is, but the ugly computer effects kill almost all enjoyment you could have stone dead, and make it borderline unwatchable for fans of the original.

This wasn't just a bad choice, it was a straight up insult to audiences faces.


9. Godzilla (1998) - Changing Godzilla's Appearance

godzilla 1998
Sony Pictures

Godzilla is a massive, unstoppable force of nature. At the last count he was 355-foot tall, nuclear bombs did nothing but make him temporarily stronger and he specialized in whipping similarly sized beasts using his immeasurable strength and atomic breath.

So why the hell Roland Emmerich thought making him a tiny, raptor-looking wimp would make anyone happy is one of cinema's biggest mysteries. Well that's a bit of a stretch, the reason was Jurassic Park just dropped, was massive, and the creators wanted to ride off the success of big CGI dinosaurs while ripping it off any way they could.

Godzilla is a brain-dead popcorn flick, though an admittedly fun monster movie if you take it at it's own merits, but as a Godzilla remake it's utterly atrocious. Godzilla doesn't even tower over most the buildings in New York city and spends most of his time running away while being hurt by military helicopters.

The Toho series story-lines were never Oscar caliber, so if the remake kept the same plot but at least had Godzilla actually look like he should (and not been killed by a few measly missiles) it might not have simply been labelled a weaker Godzilla film. As it stands though, it's a big middle finger to fans who loved the original incarnation.

The backlash was so harsh, the monster was officially named 'Zilla', and is treated as a joke in future installments of the franchise that shows up just to get the snot beaten out of it.


8. I Am Legend (2007) - No Longer A Legend

I Am Legend
Warner Bros.

Despite some incredibly ropy CGI, I Am Legend is a great adaption of the 1954 novel with a fantastic tone kept throughout, and some of the changes it makes really helping to elevate the emotional weight of the story.

It follows Dr. Robert Neville as seemingly the last man on Earth who lives in a world where humans have either died out or turned into cannibalistic vampire creatures named Darkseekers. Robert spends his days killing time, hunting vampires and capturing some to experiment on.

The previous adaptations – 1964's The Last Man on Earth and 1971's The Omega Man - this film remakes both understood what the original book was going for, and contain the terrifying realization that the Vampire creatures were actually intelligent and held emotional attachments to one another.

Coming in the night to kill them, and experimenting on innocent creatures for his own gains, the sudden revelation shocks both the character and the audience to the core at all the damage and cruel things he has done. To the Darkseekers, he is a legend.

In this version, he has a big action movie showdown with the vampires, and sacrifices himself to save 2 characters immune to the virus. Robert ends up as your basic movie hero without any shock twist or realization to give him any depth.

It's an insultingly weak way to shake things up, and a superior directors cut ending is better, but still nothing on the other versions bombshell reveal.


7. Total Recall (2012) - No Journey To Mars

Total Recall Farrell
Columbia Pictures

The original Total Recall stands the test of time as a highly entertaining action film with impressive special effects, a riveting story and a highly intelligent narrative that left audiences debating its true intentions for decades after.

A remake seemed completely pointless as there wasn't much the original didn't get right the first time, but a Colin Farrell lead one was produced and the results were exactly what fans feared.

Aside from some admittedly great actions scenes, this version of Total Recall was completely devoid of all the character and humor the original. The biggest kick in the teeth, however, was the fact the film never leaves the planet Earth.

As such, the remake doesn't go fantastical enough to give any reason for it's weirdness, and prevented fans from revisiting the mutant colony and multi-layered alien plot-line from before.

In this version the infamous three-breasted mutant lady is just a random lady with three boobs. No complaints, but it sticks out like crazy when there is literally no reason she has the extra one. This adaption instead opts for a by-the-numbers story about rebels uprising against the government .

Gone are the crazy cast of memorable martian characters from before, instead we get saddled with flat businessmen, cops and rebels you could peel from any other sci-fi thriller from the past 30 years. The visuals, narrative and characters are so instantly forgettable that you'll be craving the original all the more.


6. The Haunting (1999) - Showing That The Ghosts Are Real

The Haunting 1999
Dreamworks

The original haunting is a classic masterclass in how to do slow-paced psychological horror with a creeping sense of dread, and allowing viewers to make up their own minds on whether our character's descent into madness is the result of the supernatural or just her unhinge mind. It's subtle use of sound, the character reacting to things the audience can't sense and scaring the audience through implication rather than straight up scares.

The remake is about as subtle and scary as a puppy ripping up a roll of toilet paper.

Gone is any sense of mystery and instead viewers are treated to some incredibly dated, cartoon-like CGI ghosts running around and spoiling any sense of intrigue you might have. There's no question that this haunting contains real specters, and the narrative goes down the most rote, boring route possible.

Every single horror cliché you could think of is in this 114 minute car crash, with the plot a predictable mess having the main character realize she has a forgotten connection to the spirits and ending in a horrendous climax where you pretty much watch ghosts fly around and try to look scary while you stare at the screen with a blank expression of disinterest.

The 1999 version was nominated for a host of Razzies and has rightfully gone down as one of the worst remakes of all time. If it had embraced the originals suspenseful less-is-more approach, it would have came out much better.


5. Evil Dead (2013) - The Deadites Become Generic Infected Humans

Evil Dead 2013 Movie
TriStar Pictures

The original Evil Dead series is a cherished horror classic, with it's unique visual style and over-the-top gore giving it mythical status in the days of VHS as a video nasty.

A remake was always sought after as the original is backed up with Sam Raimi's now trademark camerawork and editing, plus some fantastic special effects, but was as low-budget as you can get. It's charm was undeniable, however, and the highlight was the villainous deadites that made sure you never knew what was coming next.

Due to the special effects being applied different almost every scene it made them grotesque, ever-changing disfigured creatures. Everyone's performances are dialed up to 11 and each has a distinct character designed to torture our hero Ash in different ways. They could also withstand insane amounts of punishment while gushing a wild variety of colored bodily fluids from their wounds.

The deadites in the remake were generic wimps who passed away after too much blood loss. Their skin turned grey, their blood turned black and they screeched like the infected from 28 days later. They don't torment their prey, and despite the films best efforts are never memorable.

They still dished out carnage to an insane degree and are extremely intimidating, but without their childlike taunting and a lack of surprises, the remake suffered heavily in giving itself any personality. If it had given the demonic villains more character, it would have made for a much more fun ride than the joyless gore-show we got.


4. Planet Of The Apes (2001) - Trying To Top The Ending

Planet Of The Apes Ending.jpg
20th Century Fox

The original Planet of the Apes ends on a genuinely great twist as it's revealed our dear hero wasn't on an alien planet after all, but earth far into the future after humans had doomed it. Tim Burton, Mark Wahlberg and a band of actors in ape suits took a stab at remaking this titan of cinema, and the results were very mixed.

It made plenty of changes, and some you could argue for such as the world having a jungle theme rather than desert (how many monkeys do you see in the desert?) but others like the humans being able to speak, and focusing on their uprising rather than Monkey society, kind of defeated the ideas of the original.

After all is said and done, it's the infamous ending that really went down like a cup of cold sick with audiences.

In the climax, our heroes lock the villain, General Thade, in a spaceship huddling under a desk in fear. Marky Mark then takes his trip back to his own planet for the big reveal.

Instead of the iconic Statue of Liberty, we get a monkey-fied version of the Lincoln Memorial, and it made absolutely no sense. Many have claimed Thade simply got there first, but there's no explanation as to how that was even possible and instead of being a horrifying revelation, it just confused everyone.

They wanted to be smart and one-up the original , but instead ended up just annoying everyone with how pretentious it felt.


3. The Day The Earth Stood Still (2008) - Removing The Message

day the earth stood still
20th Century Fox

In 1951, the nuclear age was on the horizon and the horrors that swept the world were the threat of atomic power and violence through War.

The message of the original is a genuinely prophetic one about the dangers of nuclear war and how we as a race must all get along. The remake is a pale imitation that desperately needed an issue to hammer home and make a point.

The remake instead doesn't really have any message to say at all. Klattu is just there to tell Earth he's there to kill them in order to save the planet and you are left wondering why he is delaying his mission that he seems dead set on doing. Keanu Reeves performance is also so emotionless and bored compared to Michael Rennie's more sympathetic take that Klattu being convinced of humankind's worth saving doesn't seem genuine.

Instead of a deep puncturing look at the cruelty and malice of humankind, we get treated to pretty CGI visuals of a digitized cloud eating everything in sight for vague reasons.

You can argue that it is open to interpretation just what destruction Keanu-Klattu is hinting at, but with the film's plot already so incoherent it just makes an already slow film drop dead with no real emotonal goal for the audience to latch onto.

If this was remade today, the message about humankind working together instead of shelling each other into oblivion would actually be scarily timely.


2. Ben-Hur (2016) - Cutting Down The Runtime

Ben Hur Toby Kebbell
Paramount Pictures

The original Ben-hur's legacy is set in stone as a bonafide cinematic monument with its sheer scope being unrivaled for decades. In terms of spectacle, some modern films have been able to match it, but aside from the famous chariot race, people forget this is a 3-and-a-half hour long drama.

In basic terms, the story follows a prince that is falsely accused of treason, regains his freedom and plots revenge on those who wronged him.

A remake was inevitable, but a huge feat to take on. In 2016 Timur Bekhmambetov took on the challenge and completely missed the mark to the point every marketing opportunity attempted to label the film a re-imagining rather than a remake despite it following pretty much the exact same plot.

The film was only 2 hours long and went the way of many 2010's blockbusters with a focus on CGI driven action scenes, and worrying if it didn't move along briskly enough that it would lose the audiences attention. The film misunderstood what powered the story, never allowing the movie room to breathe as characters are buried under a sea of bad CGI.

Chopping off 80 minutes of plot-line and character development, then filling up what remained with lengthened action scenes just made the remake a glorified B-movie you'd find in the bargain bin soon after release.


1. Maleficent (2014) - Turning Stefan Into A Rapist

Maleficent Rapist
Disney

Yeah, this happened.

Aside from the obvious focus on Maleficent over Aurora, this was actually a pretty hyped movie with many looking forward to a new take on the classic story of the original film.

In the end, the film looked beautiful and had some great moments, but overall fell completely flat with some curious choices that might possibly be the reason Disney doesn't take any bold chances with the all their other remakes nowadays. Far and away the boldest choice this film made though was turning King Stefan into a fantasy rapist.

The original King Stefan is a kind, just ruler who by all accounts seems like a decent bloke despite his limited screen-time. He came across as our typical Disney King only being distinguished by the fact he's first one to not have grey hair.

In this edgy Sleeping Beauty remake where Maleficent is simply a misunderstood anti-hero, he's an evil, tyrannical ruler with all the charm of a foot verruca who deceives Maleficent to become the true villain of the film. In a painfully awkward scene, Stefan meets up with his childhood friend Maleficent to hang out, then drugs her so she falls asleep and cuts off her wings.

Essentially, it's a dark, metaphorical rape scene in a Disney movie.

Stefan was already a pretty weak villain, especially with an over the top Sharlto Copley rocking an awful accent portraying him, and this unneeded scene made him an irredeemable villain and rightly got a large amount of criticism upon release.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Maleficent
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Crazy fan of MMA who also loves his films.