12 Movie Openings That Totally Trolled Audiences

Killing off stars! Comedies starting sad! Car crashes! Movies starting out as other, fake movies!

Scream Drew Barrymore
Dimension Films

Some films are determined to mess with the heads of their audience and make no qualms about this from the opening images onward.

Many of the flicks on this list are horrors which became infamous in the jolt-inducing genre for leaving viewers shell shocked before the end of their opening reel, whilst some are comedies, dramas, and even children's films which used their first scene to ensure viewers started off wrong-footed.

This way, the audience knows that the filmmakers are willing to mess with expectations, whether it's to make a meaningful point about the ideas that predictable stories reinforce or just to surprise you the sake of it.

Many flicks which attempt this delicate balance simply end up annoying viewers before the opening credits have even begun (check out the many "it was all a dream" openings of the Bring It On franchise for evidence of this phenomenon), but a precious few pull it off and those are the films celebrated here.

12. The Descent

The Descent
Lionsgate

Hellboy director Neil Marshall’s 2005 horror masterpiece The Descent is easily the Dog Soldiers director's best loved film, a claustrophobic nightmare which sees a set of women besieged by cannibalistic monsters when they venture far too deep into a remote cave system and become stuck.

Which makes it surprising that this bleak, unrelentingly grim and gruesome movie opens with a happy family picking their beloved mom up from a fun white-river rafting girls trip.

Then there's a little awkwardness on the ride home... and then out of nowhere dad and daughter alike are skewered by a passing truck’s cargo.

Right, there it is, so the unremittingly dark two hour nightmare begins. Start on a gory shock and work your way right back up to them, as the experts always say. Good luck ever sleeping again, viewers!


11. South Park: Bigger Longer and Uncut

South Park Bigger Longer Uncut.
Comedy Central

Okay, so this one makes the list because directors/ BASEketball stars Trey Parker and Matt Stone put in work to ensure this flick opened with a clever troll of a sequence.

But anyone familiar with South Park wasn't likely to be fooled.

Nonetheless, the Oscar-nominated animated feature South Park: Bigger Longer and Uncut opens like any other critically acclaimed cartoon. Its first musical number is a cheery tune about small town life which wouldn't sound out of place in a then-recent Disney Renaissance-era effort.

The film that follows, however… is not one.

Maybe it was the explicit sexual relationship between the Devil and Saddam Hussein that gave it away, or one young boy's search for the mythical clitoris, or the record-breaking amount of swearing, or all the gory onscreen deaths, or just everything about South Park as a franchise...


10. Scream 4

scream 4
Miramax

It should come as no surprise (ironically) to see master of horror Wes Craven’s name appearing on this list.

The late Last House on the Left filmmaker marked himself out as one of the genre's greats by constantly surprising audiences in flicks as diverse as The People Under the Stairs, A Nightmare on Elm Street and of course, the meta slasher series Scream.

Reunited with the scribe of the first two flicks Kevin Williamson, the fourth film in Craven’s quadrilogy saw the pair commit as always to outdoing themselves.

The film includes not one, but two starry fake openings, both revealed to be meta-openings to fictional films. First, teen TV stars Lucy Hale and Shenae Grimes are gruesomely offed after some witty back and forth, then True Blood's Anna Paquin bemoans this sort of smug, predictable self referential horror so much that Kirsten Bell skewers her with a knife...

Which is another movie-within-a-movie, and then the film actually begins.


9. Feast

The Feast
Dimension Films

Created by contestants on Bourne star Matt Damon's Hollywood reality series Porject Greenlight, the gory action comedy horror hybrid Feast from 2005 is an agreeably cheesy slice of creature feature horror which endeavours to do for monster movies what Scream did for slashers.

Does it succeed in this admirable goal? Not quite, but like its contemporary Hatchet, there's a lot of guilty fun to be had in the process. This quality is never more obvious than in the audacious troll of an opening.

The film opens on a remote desert diner besieged by monstrous fanged man-eaters, prompting the arrival of Grey's Anatomy star Eric Dane.

The rugged actor appears as a character named only “Hero” and says he's the guy who can save our cast from the bloodthirsty beasts...

Then he’s promptly torn out the window (and into pieces) a half second later, with the film offing its leading man and most recognisable face after barely a second of screen time.


8. Guardians Of The Galaxy

Guardians of the galaxy Star Lord Crying
Marvel

Not all non-horror trolling openings are comedic in nature, despite what the clever twist of South Park's G-rated opening number might have you believe.

Just look at 2014's Guardians of the Galaxy, a slice of space-set sci-fi action comedy which won both critical and commercial acclaim upon its 2014 release.

The MCU adventure came from former Troma helmer James Gunn after a string of more mature, subversive flicks like 2006's Slither and 2010's Super.

So the once-controversial director really needed to make it clear that this one was a kid friendly family blockbuster, and what better way than opening on... a small child’s mum losing her battle with cancer.

Yes, okay, so said kid is then almost immediately whisked off for an interstellar adventure and this crazy bleak opening isn’t referenced again until the otherwise cheery film’s climax. But still, a daring way to open a fun family film.


7. Tragedy Girls

Tragedy Girls
Gunpowder & Sky

Still wildly underrated, the 2017 indie horror comedy Tragedy Girls is the latest in a long line of genre hybrids which use the conventions of the lasher sub genre to comment on horror's wider socio political implications.

However, where the likes of 2015's Final Girl or TV's Scream Queens recast the horror heroine as a more self aware protagonist with added agency (thanks to Sidney Prescott's enduring influence on the horror genre). Tragedy Girls takes, er, a different route.

The film opens on a serial killer pursuing a teen victim, until he's outsmarted and kidnapped by a pair of young girls who reveal themselves to be far worse (but better organized) murderers. The rest of the film follows their gleeful murder spree, all of which they pin on said killer.

A pitch black twist on the genre's conventions, this one flips expectations from the very first reel.


6. Poetic Justice

Poetic Justice
Columbia Pictures

Sitting down to 1993's Poetic Justice, a minute into the movie most viewers are likely to be lost already.

Want to know who this woman seducing Billy Zane is, and how they know each other?

So do the characters of Poetic Justice, because this opening scene is actually a scene from a fake movie they’re watching within the movie. The next shot cuts to the drive in theatre where our heroine sits with her current beau. So begins a dark and thoughtful romantic drama which couldn't be less like the cheesy potboiler it appears to open as, with Janet Jackson trying to get over the untimely death of her ex as she's romanced by hip hop legend Tupac Shakur.

And the answer unfortunately is no, as good as this John Singleton film is, the viewer never does find out what was going on with Billy Zane and his mysterious paramour.


5. The Exorcist

Linda Blair in The Exorcist
Warner Bros. Pictures

This one feels less like an intentional troll, but it's nonetheless deservedly infamous as an inexplicable opening amongst film fans.

Yes, 1973's still-shocking possession horror The Exorcist remains one of the scariest films ever made.

The French Connection director William Friedkin's simple story of a young girl's demonic possession and her attempted exorcism by a pair of priests is a deeply unsettling exercise in tension building, gradually growing scarier until its deeply disturbing conclusion.

So it's all the more bizarre that this supernatural shocker opens on... an archaeological dig in Iraq which has almost no bearing on the actual plot, beside setting up two of its many terrible sequels.

Yes, there's thematic elements being laid down, but in terms of actual impact on the plot, the film's brief sojourn into Indiana Jones territory does little other than informing the viewer that... There's a demon named Pazuzu?


4. Funny Games

Funny Games
Concorde-Castle Rock/Turner

Austrian filmmaker/ occasional purveyor of pretension Michael Haneke (yes, Cache is great, no, Benny's Video is not) set out to deeply unsettle audiences with his 1997 home invasion film Funny Games.

Of course, with the director being an auteur, making an intense home invasion horror was not sufficient. No, to truly dissect screen violence in an intellectually daring fashion never before attempted by a director, Haneke... allowed his villains to talk to the audience and pause and rewind the film at will.

That's it, that's the bit. Think Wayne's World meets Texas Chainsaw Massacre.

As self indulgent and self important as the rest of this austere exercise is, the opening effectively shocks the audience with a burst of metal music that interrupts an anodyne family outing mid-sentence. It's a jolting blast which leaves the audience reeling thanks to the sudden dissonant screaming, and was one inevitably reprised by the filmmakers of Cabin in the Woods over a decade later.

If only this punk rock attitude was actually echoed in the remainder of this flick's interminable runtime.


3. Scream

Scream Drew Barrymore
Dimension Films

Another entry from the A Nightmare on Elm Street helmer, 1996's Scream may be the most infamous trolling opening in cinema history, as well as one of the best.

Wes Craven’s iconic slasher opens with a painfully slow and tense game of cat and mouse between teenager Casey Becker and a killer taunting her via phone, slowly building tension until its harrowing and horrific reveal.

The sequence is tense and terrifying as a standalone short shorn of context, and the film rarely needs to get as violent again after this early shock. But for viewers attending the film upon release, the shock of the movie killing off its most famous star Drew Barrymore in bloody, brutal fashion so early on in proceedings left audiences reeling.

The twist may be famous by now, but this opening remains one of horror cinema's most intense and iconic moments thanks to its ingenious trolling.


2. The Cars That Ate Paris

The Cars That Ate Paris
British Empire Films

Directed by The Truman Show helmer Peter Weir, 1974’s indie horror comedy The Cars That Ate Paris is a nightmarish slice of Lynchian creepiness from the director's pre-fame period which concerns a small town who make a living off the many vehicular manslaughters which occur within its borders.

The filmmaker's unsettling debut opens as it means to go on, wrong-footing an unsuspecting audience and ensuring they have no idea what's coming next.

The film's first scene is shot on an idyllic country road, following an attractive young couple on a quiet afternoon drive. The sequence is shot in the style of a glitzy television advertisement so that cinema patrons would mistake it for another cigarette ad before the movie began.

Then the opening sequence soon takes a dark turn, shocking cinema patrons as the duo's smiles falter and the sequence ends with a grisly car crash.

Smoking kills, kids.


1. A Series Of Unfortunate Events

Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events Jim Carrey
Paramount Pictures

Adapted from Daniel Handler's highly successful, unusually dark children's series of the same name, 2004's A Series of Unfortunate Events is not a movie without its flaws. That said, whilst the flick may soften the mean-spirited apathy and aporia which made the original novels so beloved, it does benefit from a classic villainous performance from Jim Carrey.

Shpick and shpan indeed.

Amongst the uneven adaptation's other highlights is the opening sequence, a scene which pulls a truly audacious troll for a family film.

This sardonic kid’s flick opens as a cutesy kids animated movie, committing to this joke long enough to feature a full set of beautiful stop motion credits… Before abruptly pulling a record scratch bait-and-switch trick and introducing its real, and real dark, story.

It's a neat trick designed to warn young viewers and their parents that this is far from a typical family film, and as imperfect as the finished product is it's hard not to admire this sort of daring.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Scream
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.