12 Movie Sequels That Luckily Didn't Happen
A surfing Michael Keaton, an odd Superman and lots of bullets dodged...
Some films are such great successes that a follow up is instantly considered. Some of these sequels work wonders; others even surpass their originals (The Dark Knight, for example, or Friday the 13th Part 2) whilst many fail hard (Terminator: Rise of the Machines and Batman and Robin). Looking at the more unfortunate follow ups to our favourite movies, it's a sigh of relief that some proposed sequels never got the go ahead.
Family favourites, comedy icons, classics and action flicks - no one genre is safe from the possibility of a bad or completely redundant sequel. Though none of the following films were ever released or even filmed, the fact that they were even humoured at one time is quite baffling. Some even venture into the realm of insulting their predecessors.
Many films on this list simply didn't warrant a follow up, but producers thought their popularity demanded one. Others were planned but fell through because the original ended up being a failure. Whatever the reasons, here are 12 movie sequels that thankfully never happened.
Some spoilers for the original films follow.
12. Con Airport
The '90s really was a wonderful time for insane but deeply entertaining action flicks, wasn't it? If you're ever wondering how brilliantly over the top that decade could get with its cinema, look no further than Simon West's 1997 flick Con Air, a film complete with an awful Nic Cage accent, a typically nuts John Malkovich, and Steve Buscemi as the world's most insane and terrifying serial killer.
Oh, and an airplane filled with violent convicts.
Con Air is brilliant, simply put. It's fun, crazy, violent, extravagant and awesomely silly. Because of the success of the film (making a hefty $225 million at the box office) director Simon West wrote a 15 page treatment for what he wanted from the sequel.
The film would have followed John Cusack's US Marshal Vince Larkin as he is put in charge of an entire airport for convict transport planes. And, yes, it would be overrun by some angry and wildly confident villains intent on tasting freedom.
Luckily, the treatment was ditched and nothing came of it. In recent years, West has said that he wants to do a sequel in space, and like the aptly named Con Airport, we're glad this hasn't come to anything yet either. When a film is as ridiculous as Con Air, one is enough.
11. Batman Triumphant
Batman Triumphant was set to be the sequel to Batman and Robin. Originally titled Batman Unchained, it would star George Clooney, Chris O'Donnell and Alicia Silverstone from B&R, with Jack Nicholson returning as the Joker and Jeff Goldblum turning up as the Scarecrow.
Now, everyone remembers Batman and Robin. Partly because it remains one of worst superhero films ever made, and very nearly ruined Batman as a movie commodity. Director Joel Schumacher, who was also set to return for the sequel, and Clooney have on many occasions apologised for the film, but of course it's too late; the deed is done, and Arnold Schwarzenegger's Mr Freeze is now a part of cinema history. Forever.
Batman Triumphant would have seen Scarecrow infect Batman with his infamous fear toxin and make the Joker come back as a hallucination in the hero's mind. Harley Quinn would also turn up, but she was set to be portrayed as Joker's daughter. Needles to say, the whole thing was scrapped after B&R was released. B&R was a critical and commercial failure, and George Clooney vowed never to return to the role.
The sequel was then scrapped and hasn't been revisited since, somewhat unsurprisingly. And because of Christopher Nolan's Batman Trilogy, audiences can rest assured they'll never have to endure it.
10. Superman Lives
Another superhero what-if, Superman Lives (previously Superman Reborn) was a '90s vehicle set to be directed by Tim Burton, written by Kevin Smith, and star Nicolas Cage as the title hero. It was to be a sequel to Batman Returns and the start of a DC film series, as Michael Keaton was also said to be given a cameo for the film.
The film's script was completed and Cage was even confirmed for the role and since around 2009, pictures have surfaced online of the actor in full costume during early screen tests. The film was to follow Superman as he battled Brainiac (played by Christopher Walken), Doomsday and Lex Luther.
Loosely based on the comic "The Death of Superman", the original script also called for the merging of Brainiac and Luther into one super-organism called "Luthiac." Which would have most likely looked as bad as it sounds. Lois Lane would have been portrayed by either Sandra Bullock or Courtney Cox, and at one point Superman was set to fight a giant spider.
All in all, it's probably for the best it was scrapped. Warner Bros couldn't afford to produce it, thanks to the financial losses of Batman and Robin, and a rewrite of the script was met with unfavourable reviews from the company, who decided instead to make Wild Wild West. It makes you wonder, though: How bad did the script have to be for it to be replaced with Wild Wild West?
9. E.T 2: Nocturnal Fears
This proposed sequel to the 1982 classic is nothing short of horrifying. In fact, it's a wonder it was even considered for production. In hindsight, E.T never needed a sequel - any attempt to bring the little alien back to Elliot for a new adventure would likely have seemed forced, cheap, and sloppy. At the time, though, Steven Spielberg thought a follow-up was a good move, and he started working on some new ideas.
Spielberg wanted to direct a sequel in which Elliot is kidnapped by evil aliens (portrayed as "cousins" to E.T's mysterious race) and experimented on until E.T comes and saves the day. Bringing a whole new definition to the idea of taking a film in a "new direction", Spielberg pondered on the story and came to the conclusion that it was far too dark to be a successful family film.
It was a good decision, needless to say. Since then, Spielberg has gone onto bigger and better things and E.T has been left alone in all its glory, untainted by traumatising sequels.
8. Searching For Keyser Soze
Yet another classic which really doesn't need a follow-up, The Usual Suspects is a cult favourite with one hell of a twist. It may be common knowledge now who the infamous Keyser Soze actually is, but it remains a brilliantly executed reveal and a fantastic climax.
The film came out in 1995 and in 2004 director Bryan Singer proposed a follow-up which would see the infamous criminal mastermind pursued by Chazz Palminteri's Detective Dave Kujan. Thankfully, nothing came of the idea and a sequel hasn't been considered since.
Which is a good move, most movie fans will agree; a follow-up would have cheapened the effect of the original's ending, and Keyser Soze would have likely gone from mysterious villain to unnecessarily fleshed-out cliche. Simply put, The Usual Suspects works because of the questions it doesn’t answer.
And given the state of Kevin Spacey and Bryan Singer's now extinct careers, it's safe to say we're fully safe from this ill-advised sequel.
7. Forrest Gump 2: Gump And Co
Forrest Gump is another family favourite almost sullied by a weak and uninspired sequel. Whilst the first film was original, clever, fun and deeply affecting, the proposed follow-up Gump and Co reads like a cheap re-hash set in a different decade.
Set in the '80s, the film would have seen the Bubba Gump Shrimp company massively expand, with Forrest at the helm and unable to keep with the demands of his business. As he struggles with a new chapter, Forrest would come face to face with both Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton, fight in the First Gulf War, witness the Iran-Contra Affair, see the New Coke marketing disaster, and play a vital role in Rudy Giuliani eventually becoming Mayor of New York.
Though it sounds relatively entertaining, it would never have captured the essence of the first outing and would have appeared forced and cliched. Tom Hanks and director Robert Zemeckis sensed this, and refused to return for another film. Meanwhile, Winston Groom, who wrote the novel on which the original was based, got himself into a heated feud with Paramount Pictures about the direction of the proposed project.
Ultimately, then, with no one behind it, Gump and Co was shelved and so far Forrest Gump has been wisely left alone.
6. Ferris Bueller: Another Day Off
The unimaginatively titled Ferris Bueller sequel was proposed to follow Ferris, now in his 40s, as he struggles through a mid-life crisis. Seeking help from Cameron, who is now (you know, obviously) his boss, the two skip out of work and go on a journey of self discovery and evaluation. And that's it: Ferris Bueller, exactly as you remember it, only everyone's older.
Director John Hughes said openly that such a follow up would be a bad idea and refused to return. He also said he didn't like doing sequels, despite penning both Home Alone 2 and (sigh) 3. Matthew Broderick also wasn't interested, saying that he didn't think the film needed a follow up and was fine as it was.
Since Hughes sadly passed away in 2009, speculation about a sequel has died down, and it seems as though the film will never happen. Of course, this is for the best; some films don't need a shock Part Two. Some, like Ferris Bueller, work better alone.
5. It's A Wonderful Life: The Rest Of The Story
It's A Wonderful Life is one the greatest films ever made, a family favourite and a modern Christmas staple. In 2013, nearly seventy years after the original was released, a sequel was pitched and quickly scrapped as a bad idea. What could possibly live up to George Bailey (Jimmy Stewart) running down the street wishing everyone a merry Christmas?
The film would have followed the grandson of Zuzu (Jimmy Stewart's philosophical daughter in the original) as he is visited by his grandmother. Zuzu would be played once more than Karolyn Grimes, and her return would see her guide her grandson on the path to becoming a better person. Basically, A Christmas Carol masquerading as another classic in a bid to gain views and make money.
The idea was quickly scrapped, but should never have been considered in the first place. Apparently, one factor in its scrapping the issue of ownership, as Paramount (who owned the rights to the original) threatened Star Partner Productions (who wanted to make the sequel) with legal action. It was binned before it came to this, however, and audiences have dodged a bullet because of it.
4. Casablanca 2
There have been many attempts to follow up on 1942's Casablanca, and it's good to see that they've all fallen through. Whilst there was a '50s TV show (mercifully cancelled after one terrible season), an '80s show starring Ray Liotta (why?) and an all-female Japanese musical (yes, this is a real thing), a film following up on the exploits of Rick Blaine and Ilsa Lund has never happened.
That doesn't mean it hasn't been attempted, however. A year after the first film, Warner Bros pitched a sequel titled "Brazzaville", which would have seen Rick and Captain Renault revealed to be Allied operatives. The studio hated this twist and the project was scrapped. Even Madonna has piped up with an idea, suggesting the original story could be remade in modern day Iraq. This was back in 2008, and nothing has been heard of this idea since, for obvious reasons.
The biggest proposed sequel idea was revealed in 2012 by producer Cass Warner, who wanted the film titled "Return to Casablanca" or "As Time Goes By." Warner had apparently been given the idea by Howard Koch, a screenwriter on the original film, and she said that making Koch's vision come true was something she aimed to achieve.
However, the idea - which would see Rick and Isla's illegitimate son, Richard, search for his father - was met with severe opposition from fans of the original, and since then nothing has been mentioned about a follow-up.
3. Ei8ht
David Fincher's 1995 psychological crime drama is one of cinema's most popular and widely imitated films. Starring Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman as detectives attempting to track down a killer who is using the seven deadly sins as his M.O, Seven is as dark, bleak and affecting as it was 25 years ago.
Soon after the movie's release, a treatment was given on a possible sequel. The film, titled "Eight", would have seen Morgan Freeman's Detective William Somerset develop psychic abilities, which he uses to track down a new foe. Fincher was one of the first to reject the idea. When asked about the possibility of a follow up, the director bluntly said he'd rather have cigarettes put out on his eyes than make a sequel. He certainly didn't leave anything to the imagination there, and since then nothing has been said about a new project.
The 2015 film Solace is said to be an indirect successor to the original, but Seven doesn't deserve that kind of disrespect. "Eight" would have been panned - it's the kind of sequel that sullies the good name of what came before - and it's a blessing it never came to anything. Bringing in the supernatural to a film explicitly about the true extent of human evil would have cheapened everything that Seven achieved, and it's good to see no one's clambering to make it happen.
2. Beetlejuice Goes Hawaiian
Beetlejuice is Tim Burton at his most peculiar and ingenious. Released in 1988, the original film revolves around a deceased couple - now ghosts - who seek help from Beetlejuice the "bio-exorcist" (Michael Keaton) to get rid of the new family who have moved into their house. It's silly, incredibly funny and wonderfully dark.
Two years later, Tim Burton attempted to ruin it all by hiring screenwriter Jonathan Gems to write a follow up called Beetlejuice Goes Hawaiian. The proposed film would have seen the Deetz Family moving to Hawaii and finding out that Mr Deetz new work project is being conducted on an ancient burial ground.
Oh, and Beetlejuice wins a surfing contest by using magic.
Worryingly, both Winona Ryder and Keaton agreed to star in the film (so long as Burton was directing), but the whole project fell through when Burton and Keaton began making Batman Returns. After his Batman adventure was done, Burton still wanted to make it, but couldn't get a script to stick (he called in Kevin Smith at one point, who turned down the gig to write the aforementioned Superman Lives. Ouch).
According to Gems, the script is still owned by The Geffen Production Company, and he has conceded that the film will never be made because too much time has passed. On a positive note, we got the Broadway musical, and that was great. The sequel wouldn't have been.
1. Battlefield Earth 2
A proposed sequel to a film that shouldn't have been made in the first place. Battlefield Earth is without question one of the worst films ever made. It's long, boring, full of incredibly poor dialogue and some extraordinarily bad performances from some generally extraordinary actors (Forest Whitaker, Barry Pepper and Kim Coates included).
The worst part of the film is that a sequel was planned from the very beginning, as Battlefield Earth only covers around the first half of L. Ron Hubbard's book. Despite producer Elie Samaha claiming it is in fact a good film, and that critics panned it because of their "prejudice" to Scientology, and despite John Travolta's adamant claims that Quentin Tarantino liked it, Battlefield Earth was so disliked by movie goers and critics that the sequel was quickly scrapped.
The film world is infinitely better for this. Another film like the original would have been an enormous mistake. Some films are so good they don't need a sequel; others are so bad they don't deserve one. And this one sits firmly in the latter category.