12 Sci-Fi Movies That NOBODY Understands

Some films have plots, some have characters, and some have Julian Sands as a centipede-man...

Dwayne Johnson in Southland Tales
Darko Entertainment

Science fiction can be a tricky beast. For every simple enough Star Wars-style story, there’s a trippy headf*** full of deep questions and moral complexity like Ridley Scott’s seminal cyberpunk flick Blade Runner, adapted from the labyrinthine works of Philip K Dick, or an almost impossible to decipher riddle of a flick like Shane Carruth’s Primer, a movie you’d need a degree in theoretical physics to unpack on your first viewing.

That’s not an exaggeration, either—the film’s director literally had a background in advanced mathematics informing his twisty time travel thriller.

Sometimes, though, it can be surprisingly freeing to simply shrug, throw your hands up, and say “Hell, I have no idea what it all means.” There are some flicks which reward close watching and reveal their meaning through repeat viewings, but some are so complex and intentionally obtuse that you’re better off simply enjoying the ride for what it is—a mental rollercoaster with no clear answers.

With that in mind, we’ve compiled this list of flicks which no one actually gets—and yes, you can feel free to prove us wrong by providing a one-line explanation of these films in the comments. But you only get one line.

12. Upstream Color

Upstream Color
ERBP

Directed by the aforementioned Primer helmer Shane Carruth, 2013’s Upstream Color manages to outdo the director’s earlier effort in terms of sheer strangeness. This is mostly due to the fact that (we’ve been reliably informed that) a sufficiently advanced understanding of physics and maths can, conceivably, make sense of Primer’s complex internal machinations, whereas the stream-of-consciousness seen in Upstream Color has no such skeleton key hidden somewhere.

Impossible to decipher, this hypnotic flick follows a man, a woman, and a whole bunch of pigs as it tracks the journey of a possibly alien parasite—but that limited description barely scratches the surface of this strange and strangely beautiful flick’s layers, a complex maze of potential meanings designed to be pondered by film students for eons to come.


11. Eraserhead

Eraserhead Head
American Film Institute

The first feature from king of weird David Lynch, Eraserhead stills blows the director’s later strange offerings out of the water in terms of sheer visual and aural oddity. Admittedly the story of this one is actually a lot more straightforward than most of the helmer’s later efforts such as Lost Highway, Twin Peaks, and Mulholland Drive—a young man has a very odd baby, his wife leaves him, and a lady emerges from his radiator to save him.

That’s it.

No trippy intersecting realities or out-of-order timelines. But trust us when we say that the uniquely disturbing design of this flick, from details as small as the mannered performances and strange hair and make-up all the way through the grotesque puppet design used for the baby, ensure that it is a nightmare impossible to make sense of—mainly because it’s hard to actually watch the screen long enough to start deciphering.


10. Southland Tales

Justin Timberlake Southland Tales
Universal Pictures

Ah, the ambitious second feature. Donnie Darko director Richard Kelly was the toast of Hollywood after his moody, ambitious teen sci-fi dramedy hit cinemas in 2002, and the world was watching to see his next move when his sophomore effort Southland Tales debuted in Cannes 2005.

Then came the feedback. Cluttered, impossible to understand, and over-stuffed, Kelly’s second film earned itself a place in bad film history as it brought together the Rock’s amnesiac movie star, Sarah Michelle Gellar’s porn star love interest, and Seann William Scott as two versions of the same future cop in a story depicting a post-WWIII LA as a bizarre wasteland.

Surreal, silly, and often surprisingly satirically sharp, this flick was nonetheless summarily dismissed by critics who—admittedly, accurately—complained it was quite literally impossible to make any sense of.


9. Naked Lunch

Naked Lunch
20th Century Fox

If ever there was a book which couldn’t be filmed, it would be Beat scribe William S Burrough’s hallucinatory sort-of-biography sort-of-confessional sort-of-satirical-detective novel Naked Lunch. And if ever there were a director able to film the unfilmable, it would be the auteur behind sci-fi horror masterpieces like The Brood and The Fly.

So it came to pass that, in 1996, Cronenberg endeavoured to translate Burrough’s drug-addled trip into his own shattered psyche onto film, and the resulting flick became a cult classic. Filled with unforgettable imagery and a surreal atmosphere, this film defies genre classification let alone any explanation, but it’s nonetheless a funny, scary, and even occasionally (somewhat) poignant tribute to the singular voice of a deranged, inimitable genius.


8. Zardoz

Zardoz film
20th Century Fox

Come on now—they can’t all be good films, can they?

Directed—somehow—by Deliverance and Point Blank helmer John Boorman, 1974’s Zardoz is positive proof that the director should have stuck to simpler stories. And it’s just as well the film proves this, because there’s pretty much no way to work out whatever else it’s supposed to say.

The surreal tales of “Eternals” and “Brutals”, this flick follows a perpetually and understandably confused Sean Connery as he tries to uncovers the meaning behind the generations-long battle between the two groups, who act as obvious metaphors for the ruling and working class in a story whose dystopia is otherwise impossible to make sense of. There’s the eponymous flying rock, an AI, some Beethoven, and eventually even a Wizard of Oz reference, but don’t try to decipher it all—you’ll be far too busy staring at Connery’s distracting g-string.


7. Stalker

Stalker (1979)
Goskino

Adapted from the novel Roadside Picnic, Stalker follows its three protagonists, the titular stalker, a depressed author, and a naïve scientist, as they endeavour to explore a restricted Zone thought to grant the wishes of its rare visitors. What follows is an existential trip like no other, with the director borrowing from Beckett and Camus as well as the source material as the trio encounter all manner of strangeness in what appears to be a post-nuclear, post-industrial, possibly post-reality wasteland.

It’s nigh-on impossible to interpret in literal terms, but critics and scholars are still debating the film’s metaphysical, political, and cultural themes decades later, mining deep allegorical meaning from this strange trip and its many odd, at times discomfiting, encounters.


6. Total Recall

Total Recall Movie Spoilers
TriStar Pictures

Yes, this flick may initially appear far more mainstream than most of the bonkers movies appearing on this list, but remember the criteria—we’re talking about movies that NOBODY understands, and it’s our firm belief that virtually no viewers of this gory high-octane action thriller actually deciphered its meaning.

Much like Robocop director Paul Verhoeven’s other sci-fi satire Starship Troopers, many critics and audiences alike missed the layer of irony pervading this thrill ride, and the subtle clues throughout the flick that all is not as it appears. Some critics argue that the film—the intense, violent plot, the exciting chases and fights, the whole revolution—is the mental vacation Arnie’s beleaguered protagonist was sent on, and that none of it is really happening.

Canny viewers will recognize that this’s the twist in Rick and Morty’s season 3 offering The Ricklantis Mixup, but we’re certain Blade Runner scribe Philip K Dick came up with it first.


5. Xtro

Xtro sam the alien
New Line Cinema

Finally, some justice for the much-hated video nasty list. Overzealous moral guardians throughout the easily offended UK may have banned half of the horror genre during the VHS boom of the eighties, but they couldn’t keep this sci-fi horror mindf*** out of our hands for too long—not that the delayed release made Xtro any easier to decipher.

Initially a gruesome Alien clone, the film follows an amnesiac alien-man hybrid who returns from being abducted to find his wife and young son have moved on and moved in with a new man—awkward. What else is there to do in this gory remix of Castaway but for him to move in there too, begin to exert some sort of alien influence over his son, and gradually—possess the kid? Turn him into an alien too? Make his toys come to life and kill the neighbours?

The flick may not make much sense but, like all good nightmares, it can certainly leave an audience shook and scared by the time it reaches its violent, enigmatic conclusion.


4. Holy Motors

Holy Motors
Les Films du Losange

How do we begin describing French auteur Leo Carax’s surreal sci-fi dramedy Holy Motors? A nightmarish trip through the mind of a deranged man? A day in the life of a versatile actor living in some strange dystopia? A vicious satire of the expectations thrown at us by society and culture’s demands that we fulfil preordained roles?

Following an odd man as he acts out a day of surreal sequences which appear to be directed by various external forces and include motion capture sex, a bank robbery, some sing-alongs and a chimpanzee family, this flick defies any attempts at explanation but hits like a hammer to the gut.

Alternately nightmarish and hilarious, Carax’s film is certainly saying something about the state of our world—good luck making any sense of the message, mind.


3. Rubber

rubber movie
Canal+

Directed by alternative music legend Quentin Duplieux, this strange desert-set sort-of-horror definite-comedy follows a telekinetic sentient tire which decides to start killing the denizens of a small outpost town—oh, and the whole thing is aware it’s a film in the weird meta sense, beginning with the actors acknowledging the audience and somehow managing to only grow more self-referential from there.

Rubber finds the thin, vaguely defined line between sci-fi, horror, comedy, and cartoons before gleefully skidding back and forth between genres, giddily grab-bagging elements of each category in order to produce a singularly surreal satire which must be seen to be believed.

Should you choose to sit through it, though, good luck making any sense of the film’s logic-free plot and bizarre characters.


2. Waking Life

Waking Life
Fox Searchlight

This entry is so obscure and experimental that we actually paused before referring to School of Rock helmer Richard Linklater’s 2001 effort as a “sci-fi.” It’s not that the film doesn’t tread genre territory frequently and fairly well—the various unexplained moments where our unnamed protagonist (played by the director’s muse Wiley Wiggins) floats off into the sky ensure that this flick takes place well outside our reality.

But the film is so offbeat and strange that the phrase “sci-fi”, like “fantasy” or even the much-maligned “arthouse”, doesn’t begin to encapsulate the rotoscoped flick’s bizarre winding sort-of-story, wherein the nominal hero wanders through life slipping between reality and dreams without warning whilst discussing life, the universe, and everything, man.

Far out.


1. God Told Me To

God Told Me To
New World Pictures

Directed by cult horror icon Larry Cohen of Q the Winged Serpent fame, this 1976 oddity is a far stranger offering than his usual sci-fi satire hybrids, and defies any attempts to follows its bizarre, winding story.

The titular phrase is uttered first by a sniper offing random civilians in New York and eventually by our hero, an NYC cop whose investigations into this shooting and a subsequent series of unprecedented mass attacks uncovers a hermaphroditic alien Jesus substitute who is actually the protagonist’s sibling, with both of them being born of the same mysterious light orb, and who wants use a cult to take over earth, only for their fellow alien-man-hybrid (our hero, you remember) to instead stab him, thus saving the world from—anyone still following?

Perfect. If you’ve got any idea what’s going on in this demented film, please inform us ASAP.


Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.