12 Sci-Fis With Bafflingly Low Rotten Tomatoes Scores
Shane Black made the best Predator movie. End of story.
In a perfect world, critic scores and evaluations wouldn't matter. If you watch a film and truly enjoy it, it wouldn't harm your movie-watching experience if cinema snobs and professional critics had a different opinion.
But sometimes a score really gets to you; you're amazed by the consensus that a film you loved is bad or not as well received as you'd thought. Are you seeing something they're not? Or is your standard of a good film considerably lower than others?
The answer is neither, and some films just resonate in different ways to other people. In the world of science-fiction, the element of creativity is extended and what we see on screens scratches an itch you wouldn't normally get from a period piece or a contemporary thriller.
There are some films that haven't been watched in a long time, that are remembered fondly (or at least not as poorly) that were really disliked by critics. Scoring low definitely doesn't mean a film is bad. So much now are movies looked back and enjoyed ironically, but then there are some that carried a certain charm to them that they just had to be universally liked?
Yet they weren't, and it's weird to see.
With that in mind, let's take a look at twelve science-fiction films that carry surprisingly low scores on Rotten Tomatoes.
12. The Matrix Revolutions - 35% Score
Right out the gate, this one!
The Matrix Trilogy didn't exactly conclude the way fans hoped, and it could be argued the back to back sequels weren't necessary to begin with, but for what it's worth the Wachowski's did put thought into the movies; it's just a shame they cared about aspects that fans of the films didn't.
Between Reloaded and Revolutions, the latter is the better film and while it can be a bit cringing to watch at times, knowing it has a 35% scoring on Rotten Tomatoes feels a little vindictive from the critics. Perhaps they were still soured from the messy second film, and Revolutions came out far too soon?
Admittedly, there are legitimate complaints to be had about the movie; the Neo vs Smith fight amounts to a live-action rip of Dragonball Z (except we can't see half of what's going on in this film) and 75% of the machine invasion of Zion is presented with characters the audience genuinely doesn't care about.
But behind that is the symbolism and metaphors the Wachowskis set up from the very first film. They don't pay off on a first watch and need to be revisited to fully appreciate what was foreshadowed.
11. Men In Black II - 39% Score
The sequel to the tongue-in-cheek Men In Black came with such high anticipation that at a first glance it is strange to imagine it as a failure.
Admittedly the second film is unnecessary (much like all the other MIB films), but when you look at the ingredients of this sequel, it's actually hitting on all the right notes. The two leads still share screen time, but the main story arc comes from Agent Kay (Tommy Lee Jones) and the audience gets a pretty interesting origin and the reason for his return.
The sequel does lack some of the first film's charm, and the villains of Serleena and Scrad (played by Johnny Knoxville because Jackass was relevant in 2002) don't stand out as much as a cockroach-man, but the return of Frank the Pug, Jack Leebs and even the Worm Guys makes up for the dismal stuff.
Perhaps the films lack of originality is why it didn't sit so well with critics? But you can't deny that the MIB sequel hits some notes and if nothing else, a double-feature back-to-back of this film and it's predecessor wouldn't be received as poorly as future films.
10. Transformers: Dark Of The Moon - 35% Score
Michael Bay's Transformers franchise never had a chance of reaching critical acclaim; and the last two installments (featuring Mark Wahlberg) received such low scoring the franchise should be dead and buried by now.
But they make money so get ready for more.
While the first film is the only one to surpass 50% on Rotten Tomatoes, it's a weird surprise that the third film didn't do the same. Don't get me wrong! It's still a terrible movie, but being scored so low seems quite harsh.
DOTM has some legitimately good moments (Optimus Prime's beating Shockwave, the Decepticons assassinating humans to name a very short few), and while it is easier to just write off all the Transformer movies, after six live-action installments it would be fair to say DOTM could be looked back on fondly.
After Revenge of the Fallen deservedly scored poorly with critics, DOTM seemed to take some course correction with a much more coherent plot and character development. The Michael Bay problems of leering close-ups of women, nonsensical camera shots and explosions, and obscene humor still existed and maybe that's why it's so low? But on the whole, the third film was a step in the right direction.
9. The Predator - 32% Score
If you're a fan of the Predator mythology, then it's understandable why Shane Black's anti-Predator movie The Predator didn't appeal to you. You expected one thing, but got something entirely different.
The previous films had always been presented with such an earnest take, that a movie that actively makes fun of the mythology seems almost derogatory, but that's what you get with a Shane Black film. A man who wrote Iron Man 3 and The Nice Guys isn't going to sit down and make a serious Predator movie.
You have to ask why does The Predator have 32% on Rotten Tomatoes?
For starters, this is a legitimately fun film. The main heroes are action movie cliches, and if you know sci-fi and action movie tropes like Shane Black does you can identify them too throughout the flick.
Early test audiences disliked The Predator and re-shoots took place; taking out a number of jokes from the film and honestly, that's where the movie fell apart. Critics and audience members judged this film against the Arnold Schwarzenegger piece, and that inevitably trapped the film; comparing The Predator to the original.
This movie deserves a much higher score. Probably not too high though.
8. Space Jam - 43%
Michael Jordan teaming up with cartoon characters to play basketball against enhanced aliens is such a wild concept, and yet it works so well throughout the course of the film.
Perhaps the goofy set pieces and below average acting of the live-action characters are why Space Jam isn't favored as much by critics, but honestly, who didn't like this movie?
But if you were to read reviews taken when the film came out, it was generally favored by critics (especially well-regarded ones) and I personally remember it being a big hit with kids in the 90's.
The film inhabited two things that were hot for kids; Michael Jordan and Looney Tunes, which combined together created (at least back then) a compelling story that made you cheer for the heroes, and imagine what it it would be like playing five-a-side with Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck.
And were it not for Space Jam, the world wouldn't have got Lola Bunny; admittedly a confusing sex symbol for young boys (sod it, adult men too!), but also a character who has been hailed as a strong female influence for young girls.
7. What Happened To Monday - 57% Score
Netflix movies are a real hit or miss, and thankfully over the last couple of years they've finally been recognized by Hollywood as the underdogs of creativity in a sea of remakes, reboots, unnecessary sequels and spin-offs.
It's one of the reasons why many actors and directors seek out Netflix as the distributor for the firms; zero studio interference.
With that last point comes really interesting and unique ideas, and for the sci-fi thriller What Happened To Monday, a film overlooked by many should really hold a better score on Rotten Tomatoes. At just below 60%, it would be a fair score if there was nothing original about this film, but that's the point- it's shockingly original and leans into a splendid premise that Netflix should provide more of.
Noomi Rapace is seems to be constantly getting a rough deal; mainstream movies misuse her acting abilities, and when she's given free reign to do what she wants no one sees the films she's in. What Happened To Monday gives Noomi the chance to play seven different characters (though four genuinely unique ones) and display superb action heroine chops.
If nothing else, the movie is compelling and exciting and definitely worth a watch.
6. G.I. Joe: The Rise Of Cobra - 34% Score
Technically more action than science-fiction, but there is a universe where a grounded "Jarhead-version" of G.I. Joe exists and I for one prefer the version we got in 2009 that leans very heavily into the toys and silliness of faux-camp spies and gadgets.
In retrospect, had Rise of Cobra came out five years later in a cultural landscape where over-the-top films like the Fast & Furious franchise reigned supreme, this maniacal G.I. Joe film would have been celebrated by critics as playing into the craziness of ironic cinema.
If you've seen Rise of Cobra, ask yourself honestly if you thought it was a bad film. The set pieces are explosive and exciting enough, the use of absurd technology is fanciful and fun, and (especially looking back) a glance at the cast of this film really cheers on some rising talent.
What's funny is Rise of Cobra is an anti-critic film; made exclusively for fans of the toys and cartoon series, every review acknowledges the nostalgia for a simpler time, but sneers at the lack of a dense plot.
It just goes to show that with an audience score higher than a critics', maybe movies should be judged by genre fans, and not cinema snobs?
5. The One - 14% Score
Fair enough, looking back this film is a bad one by Jet Li standards, but so bad it warrants fourteen percent?
The film's nu-metal soundtrack was a fist pump in 2001, but there is something charming to the multi-universe premise, and one Jet Li fighting an exact double has to be up there as a seminal moment of crazy early millennium entertainment?
If you scroll through enough reviews for The One, you might find some legitimate criticism; but on the whole the low scoring seems to amount to critics being offended by the lack of "substance" and story. The irony being that most audience members who tuned in to watch The One didn't to see dramatic acting from Jet Li's side. They did it to see Jet Li one-inch punch his exact double.
The One is another film in this list that you might have watched once, a long time ago, and have no desire to watch again. And maybe that's why it scores so low. But to share a similar percentage rating as the latest Transformers movies or lower than Species III proves that something was gravely overlooked.
Any film that shows Jet Li deflect bullets with another gun deserves some critical praise.
4. I, Robot - 56%
I, Robot admittedly is a film you don't think too much about. The sci-fi trope of A.I gaining sentience has been done to death and by better writers and directors, but there is something fundamentally exciting in I, Robot.
It's a futuristic murder-mystery with a few twists and turns; and the film comes at a time when Will Smith stopped screaming into the camera and put on his "I'm an actual actor" hat.
All the performances (even Shia LaBeouf) are great, and while most of the visual effects wouldn't hold up today, the motion captured character of Sonny is what stood out the most in the film. And while this 2004 summer blockbuster probably lost a few merit badges with an overblown action sequence at the end, what was really driving the film was Will Smith's performance.
So many more films have made a better story out of this concept, and while in comparison to films like Blade Runner, Ex Machina or even Westworld, this film doesn't reach their heights of intelligence.
I, Robot doesn't deserve such a low scoring when it is a film that at least tried to reach heights with splicing science-fiction with philosophical ideas.
3. The Lost World: Jurassic Park - 51%
There's something disheartening about knowing a Spielberg film doesn't score high on Rotten Tomatoes, and, compared to other entries in the Jurassic Park franchise, The Lost World is still a decent movie.
While the argument could be made that The Lost World didn't carry the same wonder, charm or charisma of the first film, Steven Spielberg does still take his time with a number of shots and set pieces, and the decisions of a majority of his characters still make sense.
Most reviews of The Lost World comment on how much the sequel lacks charming characters, and that is fair to say since Ian Malcolm is promoted/reduced to the straight-man of the film with no one zany or chaotic to bounce off.
But the sequences involving the capturing of the herbivores by InGen, the mother and father T-Rex getting their baby back from Malcolm & Co. and of course the Velociraptors in the tall grass are still some of the most tense and exciting entries in the franchise.
Any and every ranking of the Jurassic Park films will always put The Lost World in second place, it's weird that the Tomatometer score doesn't say otherwise.
2. Mars Attacks! - 54% Score
Tim Burton's gothic-fantasy aesthetic in cinema is so identifiable it can be spotted on sight; so when he makes a film that has more than four grey colours it can be a rare treat to see him play with variety.
Burton's 1996 alien invasion film Mars Attacks!, weirdly enough doesn't sit with a high percentage on the Tomatometer and I for one want to know why.
Was it because that very year, a more serious alien invasion movie was released? Independence Day felt wholesomely patriotic, and displayed the competent success of the US and world military united, while Mars Attacks! made anyone in any position of authority a useless liability, and it was zany music and video-game obsessed kids who actually saved the day.
Perhaps because movie watches haven't given this film a second viewing in over twenty years? And the new generation of cinema goers were gifted a second Independence Day movie that (literally) no-one asked for. But Mars Attacks! isn't as fundamentally bad as critics suggested.
Understanding a movie maker's comedic style suddenly shines a new light on their previous work, and while Mars Attacks may not have been top-shelf Tim Burton, it certainly warrants more than barely passing 50%.
1. Equilibrium - 40% Score
Sometimes films reach up too high and crash down with the heights they aspire to. One concept is good enough, but filmmakers sometimes go overboard and throw in other cinematic ingredients and the once dense and interesting plot can feel both light, and bloated.
It's understandable that expressionless actors in dark trench coats wielding akimbo shotguns wouldn't appeal to many. Especially since The Matrix did it so much better.
Having said that, what kind of monster gives a film like Equilibrium a low scoring?
The movie boils down action and dystopian tropes to their most basic essence, and rolls it all up into an appealing story that caters to the highest common denominator of teenagers in the early 2000's.
With a very interesting concept behind it, Equilibrium might have been ahead of its time as it proposed a dystopian society governed not just by thought and emotion police. Christian Bale acts the hell out of playing an unstoppable gun ninja, and the action set pieces are fun and exciting enough to keep audiences of even today entertained.
How can this film score so low? Sure, it debuted and then was forgotten almost immediately, but the target audience for a film like this definitely didn't complain.