12 Times DCEU Movies Completely Changed The Comics
Why mess with such great source material?!
The DC Extended Universe is arguably the most divisive franchise in cinematic history this side of the Star Wars and X-Men franchises. It owes its divisive nature to the complete overhaul of the characterization of its heroes and villains, changes to their histories and backgrounds, and very loose adaptations of some of DC's most seminal stories.
Creative liberties are not inherently a bad thing, of course, but they require a deft touch and informed ideas of what should remain from the original story and what can be done away with.
Unfortunately, the filmmakers behind the DCEU are a little hit and miss with this, with a fair number of the changes made on the journey to the silver screen disappointing fans and completely missing the point of the characters and stories' enduring appeal.
12. Steppenwolf's Motivation - Justice League
Steppenwolf is the poster boy for all unconvincing and bland CG villains in film and his poor rendering and generic motivations were some of the reasons why the long-awaited Justice League film was a complete critical and commercial bust. This failure is a shame because the changes made to his background could have provided a unique spin on the Apokoliptan general's motivation and characterization.
In both the comics, Steppenwolf is the general of Darkseid's military forces as well as his uncle. What separates the two iterations of the character are their motivations; comics Steppenwolf lives to serve Darkseid and is his right-hand man alongside the vile Desaad. He is not fleshed out beyond that and that undeniably made his adaptation rather difficult.
According to actor Ciaran Hinds, the DCEU version was further motivated to win back Darkseid's favour and was described as tired. This had the potential to show a character who was slightly more interesting and complex but behind-the-scenes wrangles got in the way of this.
11. Dr. Sivana - Shazam!
Shazam! was a small scale delight that further cemented the DCEU's course correction following its earlier failures. It was light on its feet and full of humor and heart. It was a mostly faithful adaptation, capturing the earlier comics' wholesome feel with the newer comics' modern sensibilities.
However, its biggest deviation from the source material was the characterization of the chief antagonist, Dr. Sivana, specifically his background and abilities. The comics version of the character is a traditional mad scientist with no abilities beyond his intellect and technology. However, he has dabbled in magic and even obtained the ability to see magical forces after being blinded by mystical lightning.
The DCEU takes Sivana's magical indulgence to the next level as this version of the character was once chosen by the Wizard (who imbued Billy Batson with his power) to be his mystical champion. However, Sivana was shown to be highly susceptible to the Seven Deadly Sins and they became the source of his power. This brought him into conflict with the newly christened Shazam and his adopted siblings.
10. Cassandra Cain's Characterization - Harley Quinn: Birds Of Prey
The DCEU's vision for the titular heroes in the Birds of Prey film was less ''dark and mysterious'' and more ''quirky R-Rated Looney Tunes'' and this change to the tone and style of the franchise was a welcome one, with its irreverent style and colorful characters and visuals making it one of the stronger DCEU efforts from a critical standpoint.
This stylistic deviation was felt in the film's walking Macguffin, Cassandra Cain. Her characterization and demeanor in the comics and film are worlds apart, with comics Cassandra being the child of DC's premier martial artists, David Cain and Lady Shiva. She was trained from an early age to be a martial arts maestro but at the expense of her ability to speak as well as her social skills (her cognitive skills have been directed towards reading her opponent's movements).
The film version of the character has none of her assassin skillsets nor is she is the child of Cain and Lady Shiva. Instead, she is a pre-teen pickpocket who lives with neglectful foster parents. She runs amok of the film villain', Black Mask after stealing his prized diamond from his right-hand man, Victor Zsasz.
9. Rick Flag And June Moone's Relationship -Suicide Squad
2016' Suicide Squad was a commercial success but a critical misfire due to its haphazard editing, confused tone, and uninspired antagonists leading to a movie that reeked of executive interference that was a result of a misguided response to Batman v. Superman's failure and the tone set by its admittedly excellent first trailer.
Some of the movie's problems are captured in the handling of Rick Flag and June Moone/Enchantress. Their romance was designed to be the heart of the film's storyline and show the personal implications the Enchantress' plans had on the couple. However, that was possibly lost in the editing room as neither character is fleshed out and their relationship gets the bare minimum treatment.
In the comics, the characters were nothing more than unwilling teammates on the titular group and as a result, their arcs were given more attention without the crutch of an arbitrary romance. As a matter of fact, Enchantress is in a relationship with Killer Croc, an unlikely pairing that is more interesting than the film romance.
8. The Kryptonian Growth Codex - Man Of Steel
Man of Steel introduced the concept of the Kryptonian Citizen Registry Codex (or simply the Codex) to the Superman mythos. The Codex is the skull of an ancient Kryptonian that contained the potential genetic information of the Kryptonian race (think of the skull as belonging to the genetic precursor to modern Kryptonians).
Kryptonians used this information to develop a system that saw the artificial creation of children that were then bred for specific tasks such as artists, warriors, and leaders. During the planet's final days, Jor-El bonded the Codex with his son Kal-El's genetic makeup with the intent of preserving the Kryptonian race after the planet's destruction.
The idea of the Codex and the artificial birth of Kryptonians is reminiscent of the bottled city of Kandor, a city captured by Superman villain Brainiac and the idea that Kryptonians experienced artificial births respectively. The bottled city of Kandor, in particular, is touted as a means for Krypton to be repopulated elsewhere in a manner similar to DCEU Jor-El's and Zod's plans to save their homeworld.
7. Steve Trevor's Fate - Wonder Woman
Undoubtedly the best film in the franchise, 2017's Wonder Woman was an entertaining film that acted as a brilliant character piece for the film's two leads, Diana of Themyscira (Gal Gadot) and Steve Trevor (Chris Pine); two of the most well-developed characters in the franchise. Their chemistry and short-lived relationship was a joy to watch and played a significant role in humanizing the movie.
Unfortunately, Trevor's life was cut short after he sacrificed his life to save London from a poison gas bombardment, driving Diana to a brief episode filled with rage and grief during her clash with Ares, the God of War. This contrasts with the comic incarnation of the character, who lives beyond his first adventure with Diana and even becomes a United States liaison to the Justice League in some storylines.
However, the upcoming Wonder Woman 1984 shows that Steve is very much alive and well despite the events of the first film. It remains to be seen how his resurrection played out and whether it will stick beyond the sequel's own event
6. Batman's Ethos - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice
The Dark Knight is well-known for his staunch 'no-killing rule' when fighting crimes in the streets of Gotham City. However, this rule has been bent in recent comics and outright ignored or non-existent in various alternate realities or adaptations (especially films). This is most notably seen in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, where an older, more jaded Caped Crusader dishes out justice in an extremely violent manner that disregards human life.
This iteration of the hero is inspired by Frank Miller's seminal rendition of the character in terms of design, age, loss of a Robin and a cynical approach towards heroism. However, there are a few key differences; DCEU Batman never retired and as mentioned earlier, he goes beyond simply incapacitating evildoers.
This is seen in the film's car chase and warehouse sequences where the Bat runs over Lex Luthor's mercenaries with his Batmobile and literally bashes their heads in the latter sequence. Cinema had never seen such a brutal and murderous Batman up until this point.
5. The Timeline Of Wonder Woman's Debut - Wonder Woman
In the comics, Diana of Themysicra dons her armour and uses her divine power to champion for peace and justice in Man's World under the moniker Wonder Woman at different points in history. This timeline is dependent on the comic era but it's commonly accepted that she begins her heroic career not too long after Superman and Batman publicly debuted.
However, this timeline is vastly different in the DCEU as Wonder Woman made her debut in World War 1, decades before her Justice League teammates were even born. This is due to her being born hundreds, if not thousands of years ago (depending on the filmmaker). This makes her the first hero in the DCEU by a significant margin.
The change in the timeline allowed for the exploration of a period in human history that is rarely touched in films (especially superhero cinema) and is more morally murky than World War 2's ''Allies are good and Nazis are bad'' narrative. It also gives Diana a deeper understanding of human morality that goes beyond her belief of human beings' seeming infallibility.
4. Superman And Zod's Clash - Man Of Steel
The climactic bout between the Last Sons of Krypton in 2013's Man of Steel displayed how powerful Kryptonians can be under the Earth's yellow sun but was also reviled for its disregard of human life and excessive property damage. This version of Superman, in particular, was criticized for his failure to take the fight elsewhere and save lives instead of bashing Zod through skyscrapers.
The fight reached its fever pitch when in a desperate (mostly forced in nature) attempt to save bystanders from Zod's heat vision, the Man of Steel snapped the Kryptonian's despot's neck, killing him instantly. This was regarded as an extremely controversial attempt to make Superman ''dark and gritty'', a move that completely ignored the spirit of the character.
Previous incarnations of Superman have also murdered Zod, but they were last-ditch efforts that were justifiable than the cinematic version. In addition to this, Zod is alive in the continuities that inspired much of the DCEU, specifically the New 52 and Post-Crisis timelines.
3. Doomsday's Creation - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice
The Kryptonian monster was introduced in Dawn of Justice and despite a lackluster visual design, it proved to be an extremely potent threat to our heroes, completely overwhelming Superman and Wonder Woman in close quarters combat. It even accomplished its comics counterpart's feat of killing Superman (though the Man of Steel was merely beaten to the point of a death-like coma in both cases).
What separates the two behemoths is their means of creation. The comics version of Doomsday was created on prehistoric Krypton by a scientist named Bertron. His goal was to create the ''Ultimate'', an unstoppable killing machine that would represent the pinnacle of evolution. Every experiment was even crueler than the last and this led to Doomsday developing an intense hatred for Kryptonians.
DCEU Doomsday was created by Lex Luthor to kill Superman in the event that Batman fails. Luthor took Zod's corpse and infused it with genetic material from the Kryptonian Scout Ship that was considered to be a genetic deformity on the doomed planet.
2. Nearly Everything About Lex Luthor - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice
Superman's arch-nemesis was reimagined in the DCEU to the point of being near unrecognizable. Both incarnations of Lex share a strong loathing for Superman due to his use of his overwhelming power for altruistic means and they both believe that the Man of Steel is the vanguard for an alien invasion that would lead to humanity's extinction. They see themselves as humanity's last hope against this perceived threat. But that's where the similarities end as a number of liberties were taken with the DCEU iteration.
The film version of Lex was about the same age as Superman, despite there being a notable age gap between the two and he has East German ancestry courtesy of his father. In addition to this, DCEU Lex was the son of Lex Luthor Sr, as opposed to the more well known Lionel Luthor.
The biggest change was to Luthor's personality. His cartoonish demeanour was more Riddler meets Joker-esque than the comic book Luthor's cold and calculating persona, a change that warranted ridicule and backlash from fans who wanted a more traditional Luthor that could go toe-to-toe with the Man of Steel.
1. Superman's Resurrection - Justice League
The DCEU Superman's death may have been a narratively rushed affair that was bereft of the emotion and proper build-up found in the comic book iteration, but it was an impactful event that led to the formation of the Suicide Squad, the invasion of Earth by the Apokoliptan army and the subsequent formation of the Justice League.
Both versions of the character died at the hands of Doomsday after a long and destructive battle and they were revealed to be in near-death states that required an external boost to further hasten the regenerative process. The comics Superman was brought back to life by the Eradicator, one of four copycat Supermen that emerged in the wake of his death to fight another Superman copycat, Hank Henshaw/the Cyborg Superman.
The DCEU version involved fewer copycats and more Justice League members, with the fledgling team desperate to have more firepower in the battle against Steppenwolf and the Parademon army.
The Man of Steel was brought back to life using a mix of supercharged Kryptonian tech and the Apokoliptan Mother Box but the process was overwhelming for the hero's mind and in his delirious state attacked the Justice League before coming to his senses and later joining the team.