12 Underrated Actors & Actresses Who Deserve More Recognition

winners by now. As a matter of fact, I believe all of these factors and more contribute to an actor being underrated. On this list you will find twelve of the most hard-working, dedicated actors working today, delivering some of the most powerful performances and showing some of the most impressive acting range... and failing to receive the widespread recognition, respect, and awards they deserve. You may not recognize their names immediately, but hopefully, you will someday soon. These are the unsung heroes of the acting world today. These are... the top 12 underrated actors and actresses.


12. Rufus Sewell

This Twickenham, England-born thesp has been gracing the screen both big and small from the early 90's - his first major role was Fortinbras in Kenneth Branagh's epic film adaptation of Hamlet. Since then, Sewell has tackled an impressive array of roles both big and small, in a multitude of genres. His biggest role to date no doubt remains his stellar starring turn in Alex Proyas' iconic film Dark City; one would hope that a film of that scope, and particularly one that has amassed quite a cult following since its release, would make Sewell a better known actor. Instead, he continues to toil away as a character actor in supporting roles, from the fiercely intense (Crown Prince Leopold in The Illusionist, quite possibly his finest performance to date) to the charmingly comedic (Reverend Doucheman on the BBC's Parade's End). Sewell has even dabbled in romantic comedy, as Kate Winslet's unsatisfying husband in Nancy Meyers' The Holiday, and as any character actor, occasionally finds himself indulging in the occasional paycheck role (as in the recent Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter). However, despite his consistency and prolific career in both film and television, Sewell's sole acting nomination in any awards ceremony is a single BAFTA TV nod for his performance in The Taming of the Shrew segment of the BBC's ShakespeaRe-Told, from 2005. It is unbelievable to me that an actor as prolific and talented as Sewell has received no further career recognition other than this single nomination. KEY WORKS: Dark City (1998), A Knight's Tale (2001), The Illusionist (2006). NEXT SEEN IN: Hotel Noir (available on V.O.D. in the States, UK release date pending).

11. TIE: Jane Lynch and Catherine O'Hara

Back in 2004 when The 40-Year-Old Virgin came out, I had no idea who Jane Lynch was. But I knew she was acting circles around the cast of otherwise recognizable faces in that film, and ended up completely stealing the show. Impressed with her unbelievable comedic chops, I decided to look back at her previous roles. It was then that I discovered God's gift to modern comedy: Christopher Guest's series of mockumentaries, featuring his regular troupe of the most talented improv performers ever to grace the screen, of which both Lynch and Catherine O'Hara are members. O'Hara had been a staple of Tim Burton's own group of regulars, turing in hilariously demented performances like Lydia's crazed mother Delia Deetz in Beetlejuice, to surprisingly tender ones like her voice work as Sally in The Nightmare Before Christmas. Subsequently, O'Hara took on a series of comedic supporting roles in various Hollywood productions (from Home Alone to the more recent Away We Go), but it wasn't until her work with Christopher Guest that her comedic genius was fully unleashed. It's hard to single out one, but my favorite might be as under-appreciated character actress Marilyn Hack in For Your Consideration (a role that oddly parallels O'Hara's own career). Both women got their start in The Second City improv comedy troupe (from which Guest pulled a lot of his acting ensemble in his mockumentaries), and have recently enjoyed success on the small screen as well as the big (Lynch on the quickly deteriorating Glee, though she is in it far less now than she was in its first, hilarious and dare I say brilliant, season; and O'Hara in a recent hilariously memorable guest role on 30 Rock). Though appreciated by critics and die-hard fans of comedy, though, neither actress has yet managed to truly become the sensation they are both firmly capable of becoming. Sure, they are both on the older side, but their talents lie beyond simply playing wacky supporting roles in Judd Apatow films, as evidenced by Lynch's wonderful performance as Julia Child's sister opposite Meryl Streep in the recent Julie & Julia. Let's hope for more roles like that to come! KEY WORKS: O'Hara: Beetlejuice (1988), Home Alone (1990), Best In Show/A Mighty Wind/For Your Consideration (2000-2006). Lynch: The 40-Year-Old Virgin (2005), Role Models (2008), Best In Show/A Mighty Wind/For Your Consideration (2000-2006). NEXT SEEN IN: O'Hara: Frankenweenie (voice only, currently in theaters). Lynch: Wreck-it Ralph (voice only, UK release date: February 2013).

10. Clifton Collins, Jr.

Gary Oldman is often called the "chameleon of his generation", a title alluring to his uncanny ability to disappear physically into a role and render himself almost recognizable for the sake of the performance. No one Gary Oldman character looks like another, and throughout his illustrious (and recently, finally, Oscar-nominated) career, he has demonstrated one of the finest and most versatile ranges of any actor working today, and has garnered an immense amount of respect from fans as well as from the acting community. However, there is another actor out there who shares Oldman's chameleon-like ability to truly lose himself in the physicality of his characters; so much so, that his name is barely recognizable even to die-hard cinephiles, despite the fact that he has appeared in some of the biggest and best films of the past decade. Throughout his career, Collins has played everything from an eager soldier (Tigerland) to a hardened cartel leader (Traffic); from a pleasant, one-armed hardware store owner (Sunshine Cleaning) to a psychotic gangster (Crank: High Voltage); from a sympathetic death row inmate (Capote) to a Romulan officer (Star Trek). The range of work is staggering, and Collins truly, fully commits himself to each performance. As he continues to toil away in brilliant supporting roles in movies and on various TV shows (most notably his Emmy-nominated performance in the FX mini-series Thief), Collins has yet to receive the widespread recognition and respect that he deserves. KEY WORKS: Traffic (2000), Capote (2005), Star Trek (2009). NEXT SEEN IN: Parker (UK release date: January 2013).

9. Olivia Williams

Since winning the hearts of every tweed-wearing, horn-rimmed glasses-toting cinephile back in 1998 as the romantic lead (a loving kindergarten teacher) in Wes Anderson's Rushmore, London-born Olivia Williams has quietly been toiling away at one of the most impressive cinematic careers of her generation - and yet, nobody seemed to notice. While her contemporaries such as Cate Blanchett and Helena Bonham-Carter reached stratospheric career heights, Williams remained on the sidelines, though her range and quality of roles rivals any of her compatriots. Like any good actress, it is her incredible range that remains Williams' signature strength. She is able to shift with graceful ease between tender motherly roles (An Education, Hanna) to cold ruthlessness (The Ghost Writer, Joss Whedon's short-lived but excellent TV series Dollhouse), and sometimes portrays both at the same time (as in the upcoming Hyde Park on Hudson, as first lady Elanor Roosevelt). Williams has the looks of a movie star, but she refuses to cease taking risks with her project choices, and seems perfectly comfortable in supporting roles or as part of an ensemble. On the one hand, this is a shame - I firmly believe that Williams has the talent (and the cheekbones) to attain a Cate Blanchett-level of success, and I wish more people were familiar with her. But her selflessness and dedication to the craft over the limelight is something to be admired. KEY ROLES: Rushmore (1998), An Education (2009), The Ghost Writer (2010). NEXT SEEN IN: Hyde Park on Hudson (UK release date: February 2013).

8. Garret Dillahunt

Looking back at his filmography, you would think that Garret Dillahunt would be one of the most recognizable actors out there, or at the very least more well known than he is now. Primarily a television actor (most well known for his dual roles as Francis Wolcott and Jack McCall in separate seasons of Deadwood), Dillahunt made one of the most impressive transitions into a feature film career to date, although you wouldn't know it from his name alone, which still goes mostly unrecognized, even by hardcore cinephiles. Dillahunt is often typecast in similar supporting roles as a grizzled country type, and is often either a lawman or a lawbreaker. But the sheer pedigree of projects alone deserves respect - Dillahunt has played supporting characters in No Country for Old Men, The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, Winter's Bone, The Road, and most recently, Looper and Killing Them Softly (almost all of which feature additional actors that make appearances later in this list). He is a regular cast member of the fairly pedestrian Fox sitcom Raising Hope but also still finds time to deliver stellar performances on the big screen. Hopefully, his upcoming lead performance as part of a 1970's gay couple (played by Dillahunt and Alan Cumming) in the based-on-a-true-story drama Any Day Now, as well as a supporting role in the upcoming Steve McQueen film Twelve Years a Slave, will further increase his profile and hopefully lead to more widespread recognition. For now, at least, he will always have his showdown scene with John Hawkes in Winter's Bone, one of the most tense and memorable film sequences of that year. KEY ROLES: Deadwood (TV series, 2004-2005), No Country for Old Men (2007), Winter's Bone (2010). NEXT SEEN IN: Any Day Now (UK release date pending).

7. Joan Allen

With three Oscar nominations, four SAG nods, and countless other nominations and wins, Joan Allen might be the least underrated actress on this list, at least as far as critics and awards shows go. Without much bravura or limelight attention, Allen has crafted one of the most consistently solid bodies of work of any actress of her generation, deftly balancing roles in big-budget mainstream films (Face/Off, the Bourne series) with smaller dramatic roles in the likes of The Ice Storm, Pleasantville, and The Contender. So why is she on this list? Despite her critical acclaim and awards success (though no major wins to speak of, yet), Allen is not nearly as well-known nor as widely recognized as some of her contemporaries such as Michelle Pfeiffer or Susan Sarandon, despite the fact that she has shown time and time again that she has the dramatic chops and ability to choose meaty roles rivaling those of her contemporaries. And yet, Joan Allen remains the unsung star of her generation, quietly delivering a string of subtle performances and refusing to take the spotlight. Her career highlight is probably her Oscar-nominated performance as a powerful vice presidential nominee with some dark, sexy secrets opposite Jeff Bridges and Gary Oldman in The Contender, though Allen's output throughout the 90's was incredibly solid overall, including her other two Oscar-nominated roles in The Crucible and Nixon. KEY ROLES: The Crucible (1996), The Contender (2000), The Bourne Supremacy/Ultimatum/Legacy (2004-2012) NEXT SEEN IN: A Good Marriage (2013)

6. Chiwetel Ejiofor

Like many actors before him and since, London-born Chiwetel Ejiofor got his start in a Steven Spielberg film, playing the key supporting role of James Covey, a Navy translator. However, unlike many other actors whose careers were kick-started by Spielberg (just to name a few: Christian Bale, Vin Diesel and Amy Adams, and even the twice Oscar-nominated Djimon Hounsou, also from Amistad), Ejiofor never quite reached A-list status, and remained regulated to small but very pivotal and memorable supporting roles in a wide variety of films and genres. Ejiofor found a particularly interesting niche for himself, playing supporting characters - often villains - in a multitude of genre films. No matter what the character or how antagonistic, Ejiofor always finds a way to inject some humanity and soul into his characters, as evident in his performances as The Operative in Serenity, Luke in Children of Men, Huey Lucas in American Gangster, and others. However, it's not all grim sci-fi: Ejiofor has also turned in more charming and light-hearted supporting performances in the likes of Love Actually, She Hate Me, and others. Ejiofor has also played his fair share of lead roles, but unfortunately, none of the films he has starred in were particularly successful or widely seen, although his performances are always stellar. Particular standouts are his conflicted immigrant hotel employee in Dirty Pretty Things, and his excellent turn as a mixed martial arts instructor in David Mamet's Redbelt. However, his upcoming lead role in the extremely high-profile Steve McQueen film Twelve Years a Slave will hopefully finally but Ejiofor on the map and seal his leading man status. KEY ROLES: Dirty Pretty Things (2002), Kinky Boots (2005), Children of Men (2006). NEXT SEEN IN: Savannah (2013).

5. Patricia Clarkson

Although her name is not very well known, Patricia Clarkson just may have the most familiar face of anyone on this list, if only for the sheer volume of work she has put out over the past twenty-odd years. With supporting roles in both comedies (Easy A, Woody Allen's recent films) and high-profile dramas (Good Night and Good Luck, Shutter Island), Clarkson has established herself as one of the hardest working character actresses today. Her first big break was as as Catherine Ness, the thankless wife to Kevin Costner's Elliott, in Brian De Palma's The Untouchables. Throughout the 90's, Clarkson was regulated mostly to made-for-TV movies, save for the occasional supporting turn in films such as Jumanji and The Green Mile. Clarkson's eccentricity, gravely voice and charm make her perfect in memorable supporting character roles. And yet, despite her success in that field, Clarkson is underrated for her true talents lie in her little-seen lead roles in small, wonderful independent films such as The Station Agent and Cairo Time. It is in these roles that Clarkson strips away her character actress charm and fully embodies powerful, leading characters. However, like her contemporary Joan Allen, Clarkson has never managed to attain the heights and success as other similar actresses, despite garnering a well-deserved Oscar nomination for her powerful turn as Katie Holmes' suffering mother in Pieces of April. KEY ROLES: Far From Heaven (2002), Pieces of April/The Station Agent (both 2003), Easy A (2008). NEXT SEEN IN: The East (2013).

4. John Hawkes

Based on his recent high-quality and relatively successful output (including an Oscar nomination for his very memorable turn as Jennifer Lawrence's grizzled uncle Teardrop in Winter's Bone), it is easy to forget that John Hawkes has been around for over 20 years, appearing in a vast multitude of TV series and supporting roles in films of various size and scope. For the longest time, Hawkes was actually a very successful character actor in large-budget mainstream films; looking back on his filmography, though, I had actually forgotten that he was in many of the films under his belt, including supporting roles in Congo, Rush Hour, The Perfect Storm, Identity, and more. Hawkes has also achieved a modicum of success on the small screen, with a major role in the seminal HBO series Deadwood (alongside an earlier entry in this list, Garret Dillahunt), as well as Danny McBride's thankless brother Dustin Powers on Eastbound & Down. While he was toiling away in forgettable mainstream fare, Hawkes had also begun to establish himself as a very memorable and effective leading man in a variety of small, little-seen independent films, including Miranda July's Me and You and Everyone We Know, as well as the aforementioned Winter's Bone and his equally chilling performance in Martha Marcy May Marlene. Hopefully, the increased exposure and success of his buzzed-about (and truly excellent) performance in The Sessions, not to mention a supporting role in Steven Spielberg's Lincoln, will further cement Hawkes' leading man status, and increase his profile so that many more can see and enjoy his unique characters and talents. KEY ROLES: Deadwood (TV series, 2004-2006), Winter's Bone (2008), The Sessions (2012). NEXT SEEN IN: The Sessions (UK release date: January 2013).

3. Laura Dern

With a series of iconic film performances under her belt, two very famous parents (actors Bruce Dern and Diane Ladd), an Oscar nomination an Golden Globe win, I am constantly shocked that Laura Dern isn't more famous than she is. Belonging to the same generation of actresses as Cate Blanchett, Nicole Kidman, Gwyneth Paltrow and others, Dern has attained nowhere near the same amount of success and recognition as her peers, despite demonstrating an acting range and dedication to risk-taking performances rivaling those of her fellow actresses. Dern's early roles include now iconic performances in a handful of David Lynch movies, including Blue Velvet and Wild at Heart (and culminating in Inland Empire, quite possibly her most fearless performance to date). Dern earned an Oscar nomination for her visceral performance opposite her real-life mother Diane Ladd in Rambling Rose, and around the same time also starred in quite possibly her most high-profile role to date, as Dr. Ellie Sattler in Jurassic Park. The peak came in 1996 when Dern played the lead role in Alexander Payne's feature film debut, Citizen Ruth, about an irresponsible, drug-addicted woman caught in the middle of the pro-life/pro-choice debate. Unfortunately, Dern never attained the success nor the leading roles that her peers enjoyed, and was regulated to small but very memorable supporting roles in a variety of high-quality films over the past fifteen years (save for the occasional Inland Empire). Still, her iconic early performances, coupled with her more recent supporting roles, including her uncanny, Golden Globe-winning portrayal of Katherine Harris in the HBO made-for-TV movie Recount as well as a brief but memorable turn in Paul Thomas Anderson's latest film The Master, cement Dern's status as one of the best unsung actresses of her generation. KEY ROLES: Blue Velvet (1986), Jurassic Park (1993), Inland Empire (2006). NEXT SEEN IN: The Master (Currently in theaters)

2. Sam Rockwell

There are only a handful of actors who have successfully managed to carry an entire, large-scale genre movie on their shoulders as the sole character for most if not the entire runtime of their respective films. One of them is a multiple Oscar nominee, Grammy award-winning rapper, and one of the most famous, recognizable, and successful people in the world (Will Smith, I Am Legend). The other is a two-time Oscar winner and five-time nominee, and one of the most respected and revered actors of his generation (Tom Hanks, Cast Away). The third is Sam Rockwell. It continues to astound me that, after a career of over 70 film appearances in both lead and supporting roles, mainstream and independent films, comedies and dramas, Rockwell only has about a dozen acting nominations and wins, mostly as part of an ensemble cast and not as an individual performer, and none from any of the major awards organizations. Rockwell has appeared in some of the most iconic and memorable films of the last decade and has consistently delivered performances of immense quality and dedication, ranging from outrageously goofy (Matchstick Men, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy) to tortured soul (Snow Angels, The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford, Moon) to completely psychotic (The Green Mile, Confessions of a Dangerous Mind, Seven Psychopaths - in fact, most of his other roles). At this point and after iconic roles in many of the aforementioned films (not to mention a key villain role in Iron Man 2, and a handful of other mainstream roles he has portrayed over the years), Rockwell has already gained a substantial amount of traction amont cinephiles and film buffs. Which makes his lack of mainstream success or critical and award recognition all the more staggering. Rockwell consistently brings a unique and memorable sense of energy and dedication to every performance, and yet, none of his upcoming roles looks poised to catapult him into the spotlight. Perhaps it's better that way, though. Rockwell will always be our actor, success or no success. All I know is, anyone who can dohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gvj8ZEnNrQY) deserves my undying and eternal admiration. KEY ROLES: Confessions of a Dangerous Mind (2002), Snow Angels (2007), Moon (2009). NEXT SEEN IN: Seven Psychopaths (UK release date: December 2012).

1. Hope Davis

As far as I know, Hope Davis doesn't have a single leading role credit to her name. Her entire career of just about 40 film and television appearances is comprised of supporting roles. It is rare for an actress in this day an age to be truly humble and seemingly actively resist the spotlight cast on leading roles, but that is exactly what Hope Davis is. Instead of succumbing to the pressures and temptations of stardom, over the past twenty years Davis has crafted an impressive resume of roles comprised almost entirely of independent films and quality TV shows, usually in supporting roles or as part of large ensemble casts. But oh, the actors she has supported! Over the years, Davis has played wives, daughters and co-workers to the likes of Jeff Bridges, Anthony Hopkins, Jack Nicholson, Paul Giamatti, Nicolas Cage, Richard Gere, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Dennis Quaid, and many more. She has played Hilary Clinton, earned Tony, Emmy and Golden Globe nominations, and all the while has never compromised on her integrity as part of the acting troupe, never upstaged or stolen the spotlight from her co-stars, and never taken a lead role. She is not one to shy away from high-quality television either, having made appearances on In Treatment, Mildred Pierce, and most recently, The Newsroom. All in all, Davis is the most thankless and yet consistently reliable actresses in the business, never ceasing to bring her A-game to any character she has to portray but also never over-acting or drawing attention to herself. Hope is the ultimate supporting actress: she is so selfless in her performances, most casual viewers would never even notice that they've seen her appear in so many movies and TV shows. And so, for all of these reasons and more, I firmly believe that Davis is the most underrated actress working today. KEY ROLES: About Schmidt (2002), American Splendor (2003), The Special Relationship (2008) NEXT SEEN IN: Disconnect (2013).

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Oren Soffer is currently a Junior majoring in Film/Television production at NYU Tisch School of the Arts. He has been harboring and fostering a love and passion for cinema since early childhood. Though he mainly focuses on making movies these days, he still enjoys writing about them as well.