13 Most Disappointing Movie Threequels
Third time unlucky.
Making one good movie sequel is hard enough, but a quality third film in a franchise, where countless possibilities have already been exhausted? It's a huge challenge.
While there are a few outliers, such as Indiana Jones & The Last Crusade, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King and Toy Story 3, all of which lived up to if not exceeded the original, they are very much exceptions that prove the rule.
Movie studios love trilogies, and will put pressure on filmmakers behind two successful movies to quickly churn out a third sneaky milk of the cash cow, so it's not a shock that so many of them ending up disappointing audiences.
That doesn't make it sting much less, though, especially in the case of these hyped-up and promising threequels, which sadly fell rather short of the standard set by their predecessors. They're not all strictly bad films by any means, but it's hard not to look at them and see nothing but a blown opportunity...
13. X-Men: The Last Stand
The Originals: Bryan Singer is largely credited with bringing the comic book movie into the mainstream with 2000's flawed-but-thrilling X-Men, before following up with 2003's X2, which remains a high-point for the genre.
The Threequel: Singer unfortunately sat out The Last Stand, opting to shoot Superman Returns while Brett Ratner was brought in to helm this extremely underwhelming third effort.
The Dark Phoenix storyline gets a highly dissatisfying payoff, there are way too many subplots, Cyclops dies off-screen, Xavier is killed only to be weirdly sorta-resurrected in a post-credits scene, and it was simply an overall misguided attempt to one-up X2.
Thankfully Singer's recent Days of Future Past jettisoned it from the continuity in the most brilliantly passive-aggressive way possible. Good riddance.
12. The Matrix Revolutions
The Originals: The Wachowskis melted minds the world over with their stunning 1999 game-changing action masterpiece, which led to the slightly disappointing but still thoroughly entertaining The Matrix Reloaded in 2003. You can't fault that brilliant car chase, even if the pretentious Colonel Sanders speech at the end was a bit much.
The Threequel: The Matrix Revolutions arrived mere months after Reloaded, the two having been filmed concurrently, and though marketing promised it would bring Neo's saga to a satisfying close...it really did the exact opposite of that.
Morpheus feels like he's barely in it, Trinity pointlessly dies after being resurrected in the previous film, the finale is too overblown for its own good, and Neo's fate is left ambiguous as the credits roll.
Yes, the Zion battle against the Sentinels is terrific and there are inspired moments throughout, but a fitting end to The Matrix franchise this is not.
11. Alien 3
The Originals: Ridley Scott's 1979 original Alien and James Cameron's 1986 follow-up speak for themselves, the former introducing audiences to the Xenomorph with a suspenseful slow-burn, while the latter opted for a nerve-wracking, and no-less excellent, action thriller.
Quite rightly, they're popularly regarded as two of the greatest films ever made.
The Threequel: David Fincher made an ambitious but ultimately sloppy directorial debut thanks to Fox's constant creative meddling, resulting in an end product that squandered an impeccable cast and was ultimately too miserable for its own good.
Plus, there are bad digital aliens and Newt and Hicks were unceremoniously killed off before it even got going, the latter of which is enough to make a lot of hardcore Alien fans hate it.
It's an interesting experiment up to a point, but a pretty stamina-draining sit all the same.
10. Shrek The Third
The Originals: Shrek arrived in 2001 and, with its gleefully subversive take on fairy tales, became an instant classic for DreamWorks. Then 2004's sequel arrived and arguably one-upped the original with its hilarious litany of clever pop-culture references, indicating a bright, considered future for the franchise.
The Threequel: Shrek the Third is where the series began to become a self-parody, leaning back on the tired fairy tale tropes it so brilliantly sent up prior. The gags don't hit as hard, it's not as affecting, and it basically feels like a typical, less effortful third film that knows it can coast on the success of what came before.
The series did manage to rebound somewhat with the improved Shrek Forever After, even if it still felt totally unnecessary.
9. Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines
The Originals: James Cameron delivered two all-time classic sci-fi films with 1984's The Terminator and the indelible 1991 follow-up Terminator 2: Judgement Day, helping catapult Arnold Schwarzenegger to global fame while the series became a pervasive staple of pop-culture.
The Threequel: Arriving on a tidal wave of hype but without director James Cameron, T3 is by any other standard a pretty decent sci-fi actioner with entertaining action and solid performances...but following on from two of the genre's best-ever movies, it can't help but pale in comparison.
There's some super-goofy comic relief, the T-X feels like a step back from the T-1000, and some of the CGI is pretty dodgy too. It's still miles better than the rancid sequels that followed, though, and it's got one Hell of an ending.
8. Spider-Man 3
The Originals: Director Sam Raimi and star Tobey Maguire made a formidable team in the web-slinger's first two cinematic outings, folding the hero's inherent goofiness into fun, heartfelt and action-packed superhero extravaganzas.
The Threequel: Few superheroes movies have ever been as wildly anticipated as Spider-Man 3, which saw Peter taking on not only the Sandman and Venom, but also James Franco's Green Goblin Mk. 2.
Ultimately, the movie had way too many villain plotlines to juggle, introduced a contrived ret-con regarding Uncle Ben's death, was full of cringe-worthy humour, botched Venom, and was so disheartening to fans that it led to a full-on 2012 reboot that basically remade the original 2002 movie. Boo.
7. Beverly Hills Cop III
The Originals: Eddie Murphy's signature role (live action-wise, anyway) shot him to fame with 1984's original Oscar-nominated action comedy classic, and while the 1987 sequel wasn't anywhere near as good, it was still a solid sequel.
The Threequel: Beverly Hills Cop III slithered into cinemas in 1994 and remains one of the worst movie threequels to actually gain a theatrical release.
Everyone's here for the easy payday, the tone is considerably lighter than the last two movies, the central theme park storyline is goofy as Hell, and even Eddie Murphy eventually came out to call it "atrocious", while it landed Razzie nominations for Worst Director and Worst Remake or Sequel.
And what the Hell is that totally random George Lucas cameo about? It's super distracting...
6. Superman III
The Originals: Richard Donner's 1978 Superman has an inestimable legacy, in large part thanks to Christopher Reeve's unforgettable performance as the Man of Steel. Though the sequel isn't as iconic and suffered through some severe production setbacks, it was nevertheless a worthy successor.
The Threequel: The series sadly fell off a cliff with 1983's Superman III, which placed far too much focus on Richard Pryor's comic relief villain Gus Gorman, touted a generally sillier tone, and felt inferior to the first two movies in every way.
Sure, seeing Clark Kent fight a corrupted version of Superman was pretty cool, but most everything else here was a bust. Still, at least it wasn't Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, which somehow ended up being even worse...
5. Scream 3
The Originals: Wes Craven reinvented the slasher film with the subversive 1996 horror flick Scream. It poked fun at the genre's tropes and basically treated the viewer like an intelligent person rather than a foaming gore-hound, and despite releasing just one year later, Scream 2 was a surprisingly consistent follow-up.
The Threequel: Scream 3 unfortunately ups the goofiness, downplays the violence and in many ways revels in the lame horror cliches the series originally set out to lampoon.
The cast is still game, but a number of the subplots are dull, the kills aren't as entertaining, and the end killer reveal is more of an eye-roller than a satisfying "gotcha" moment.
Despite Scream 3 being a solid box office hit, the series took an extended sabbatical until 2011's Scream 4, which while not quite up there with the originals, was a surprising return to form.
4. Return Of The Jedi
The Originals: George Lucas kickstarted a pop-culture phenomenon with 1977's original Star Wars, while taking the set-pieces and character work to bold new heights with the darker 1980 sequel The Empire Strikes Back.
The Threequel: Following Empire was never going to be easy, and though Return of the Jedi is an undeniably enjoyable film, it just lacks the finesse and sure-mindedness of its predecessors.
Boba Fett's death sucked, the Ewoks were annoying and represented Lucas pandering more to young children, and despite a strong close, it just wasn't as gripping as what came before.
It's still miles ahead of those damn prequels, though.
3. Blair Witch
The Originals: 1999's found footage masterpiece was a real game-changer for the horror genre, creating an altogether more intimate horror movie that benefited hugely from its highly convincing viral marketing campaign.
Sadly 2000's meta-sequel, Blair Witch: Book of Shadows, was an absolute trainwreck, essentially killing the franchise for more than 15 years.
The Threequel: Last year's Blair Witch arrived out of nowhere, secretly made under its previous title The Woods before being finally revealed as a Blair Witch sequel at its Comic-Con premiere, where it received rave reviews deeming it "one of the scariest movies ever made".
As it turned out, Blair Witch was a mediocre soft reboot of the franchise, treading back over the original's most memorable beats with a few forgettable high-tech additions.
Once more discerning critics got to see the movie, the Rotten Tomatoes score quickly tanked and its real mediocrity was fully revealed. It's a damn shame, as this could've been something really special.
2. The Dark Knight Rises
The Originals: Christopher Nolan reinvented Batman in unforgettable fashion with 2005's gritty, technically superb and sharply-acted Batman Begins, before following up three years later with the superior The Dark Knight, which remains for many the best-ever entry into the superhero genre.
The Threequel: Though The Dark Knight Rises is indeed a good film, and even a very good film, it just doesn't live up to the brilliance of The Dark Knight. Neither its villain nor its overall narrative feels anywhere near as refined, there are some woeful plot holes, a terrible death scene from Marion Cotillard, and an ending that chickens out on being truly daring.
Again, it is a solid entry into Nolan's saga, but having had some critical distance from it over the years, it definitely fell a little short of what fans were expecting.
1. The Godfather Part III
The Originals: Francis Ford Coppola did the unthinkable, by releasing not only a 1972 adaptation of Mario Puzo's crime novel that's popularly deemed the greatest film ever made, but also following it up just two years later with a sequel considered to be as-good if not better than the original.
In a hugely improbable feat, both films even ended up winning Best Picture Oscars and have been enormously influential pop-culture mainstays ever since.
The Threequel: Some sixteen years after the last movie, The Godfather Part III finally arrived, and though by any typical metric it's a solid crime drama, coming after two of the most acclaimed movies of all time, that just wasn't good enough.
Though it was still nominated for seven Oscars, including Best Picture, the plot was decidedly more cartoonish than its predecessors, the stakes didn't feel high enough, and Sofia Coppola's atrocious performance damn near sinks the emotional core.
At least Pacino was still legitimately great in it, but given the near-perfection of its predecessors, this was a huge comedown overall.
Which movie threequels have disappointed you the most over the years? Shout them out in the comments!