14 Simple Fixes That Could Have Made Suicide Squad Awesome
How about not making The Joker a love-sick emo?
Incredibly, there is a great film lost in Suicide Squad. It's just so clouded over by poor decisions and ridiculous, jaw-dropping moments of stupidity that it's impossible to actually notice it for the most part. The characters are mostly appealing, until you get into the substance of them, and they would have been better served by a more concise plot that didn't have false drama in for effect.
And even more pertinently, the film deserved to be critically acclaimed as an idea a hell of a lot more than the execution actually warranted. It deserved more care and attention than it got, and it deserved less of a messed up production, which more than likely doomed it from day one.
Since we're always accused of not being able to do better, it's time to actually test that theory a bit more. Because there are some pretty simple fixes - aside from simply fixing the awful editing and the tone generally - that could have made an awesome Suicide Squad.
So how do you save it? Well, this would be a good way to start...
14. Make The Joker The Main Antagonist
The Problem
The Joker doesn't matter. Like at all. He's just there as a side-concern, whose importance was mostly removed in the over-zealous edit.
The Solution
Give him the top-billing he deserves.
It is preposterous to think that Ayer had the Joker at his disposal and chose instead to focus on a nefarious plot by Enchantress to reunite with her brother - a non-entity and mostly unheard of comic book villain - to get revenge on humanity for some reason or other. Whatever, it doesn't ring true.
Here's how it should have gone: Enchantress should have started as a member of the squad, rather than having Waller drop the ball and letting her escape, only for the Joker - still on a mission to reunite with his love - sabotages her from within to destabilise her. He already worked his way in with Griggs, but that ended only with a mobile phone being passed on - stupidly in other words. He should have been used to steal Enchantress' heart to give to the Joker, a far better story.
The Joker should have been the mastermind, pulling the strings to manipulate Enchantress into becoming a massive threat as a distraction to getting his Harley back. That would have removed the importance of Incubus (which the script never followed through on), would have removed the need to give Enchantress some hollow motivation, and would have celebrated The Joker as he deserved. It would also have actually validated his being there.
13. Replace Incubus With Monster T/Tattoo Man (And Tone Down The CGI)
The Problem
Incubus. Basically everything about him in fact. In an attempt to ramp up the threat, Incubus was introduced as a secondary villain, with no motivation other than mindless violence, while the film tried REALLY hard to insist that he's at all important.
The Solution
Remove him completely, and promote Monster T to being at all important.
Look, Common was screwed by the way Suicide Squad presented him, so it's time to right that wrong as well. He was presented as the film version of Tattoo Man (right down to the same facial piercings and tattoos), and then Joker killed him off without any suggestion that he actually had the comic book villain's powers.
Those powers manifest as him being able to bring his tattoos to like, including snakes on his head, tendrils and other assorted silliness. In short, he could very, very easily have taken the place of Incubus without compromising those rampage scenes that were designed to escalate the action.
Instead of having a 100% CGI rendered character (with awful effects, mostly), Ayer could have had Monster T working with the Joker as a means to draw out the Squad before he turned Enchantress to the dark side. And we'd have had Common performing as the villain with CGI augmentations, which would have been a far better solution all round than the Incubus debacle.
12. Remove The Unnecessary Romantic Sub-Plot
The Problem
Did anyone really care about Rick Flag loving June Moone? Like, seriously? They're the blandest couple in the history of comic book movies, with zero chemistry and absolutely no reason to root for them.
The Solution
Forget it entirely, it's not necessary. Flag/Moone was introduced mostly to give the film some emotional heart, which entirely missed the point that both Deadshot's back-story and Diablo's had more than enough heart, had they actually been focused on properly.
We didn't need to see Flag and Moone forced together, regardless of it being used as Waller's means of manipulating Flag. All that relationship needed was Flag to be duty-bound (and then for his internal conflict to play out more traditionally later in the film). He doesn't need to be bound to the Squad by a romance that is significantly less believable than Boomerang's love of a stuffed unicorn.
So just cut it out - the pair can exist without f*cking each other, and Flag is far more interesting if he starts out as a military man simply compelled by honour to do his job. That way he also doesn't have to be in on all of Waller's plotting.
11. Play Up Harley And Joker's Abusive Relationship
The Problem
The Joker and Harley Quinn's relationship never quite rings true: it feels half-developed and full of half-ideas. This is probably in no small part down to the fact that the edit apparently cut out some pretty key scenes between the two establishing their abusive relationship, explaining why Harley is as she is and furthering the image of the Joker as an arch-controller.
Without those, he just looks like an emo puppy dog in love.
The Solution
It might be controversial, but the film was missing an explicit portrait of The Joker's abuse of Harley Quinn (and before her Harleen Quinzel of course). That is a massive part of their dynamic and it's the only way to make the tragedy of Harley's backstory actually sing through. Without it in Suicide Squad we were presented with the idea that Dr Quinzel - a professional - simply got a crush on The Joker and didn't fight it.
There was no conditioning, none of him showing his evil genius, it just sort of happened incidentally, and that is catastrophic for his image. And so too is the removal of the volatility of their relationship: he's a monster, not a romantic, and his striving to get Harley back should never, ever have been about loving her. He needs her as a symbol of his control, a play-thing that he's angry at losing ownership of.
That won't jive with outrage over the portrayal of destructive relationships, but it would address the fact that this Joker is just about the most unJokerish Joker there has ever been.
10. Just Do Slipknot Better
The Problem
Slipknot has a Dead Meat label on his head the second he appears. Twelve seconds after that, he's dead, and not a single person either cared or was shocked.
He also wasn't deemed important enough to even get a backstory or a rap-sheet. And the result was that you end up wondering whether he's there simply because he's a bit of a dick who is super good at climbing.
The Solution
Spend like, I don't know, two bloody minutes establishing Slipknot as a character on an equal par with the rest of the crew. Actually leave in the fact that he's a serial rapist, maybe give him a few lines that paint him as detestable even in villain circles and make him expendable in a way that is actually satisfying before he's killed off.
Also, how about having a bit of backstory that explains what value he has to the team. Saying "he's the guy who can climb anything" is fatal considering he's immediately lower down in the pecking order than a guy who literally just throws boomerangs.
In short, actually bother to write a character if you're going to use him as a narrative device.
9. Cut Out The False Start And The Repetition
The Problem
Before the actual Suicide Squad go to take down Enchantress, Amanda Waller sends Enchantress and Rick Flag in to battle Incubus basically on their own with a bomb and literally plan. This is disastrous, not only because it means Enchantress can escape, but also because it made Waller - who is supposed to be an infallible genius remember - look like a bloody idiot.
And even worse, it was only in there as a contrived way of getting the bomb that ultimately kills Incubus, GQ and Diablo under the train station. It's such an eye-rolling development that you might have died on the spot if you weren't already numbed by the rest of the film.
And as for repetition. THERE ARE THREE BLOODY HELICOPTER CRASHES IN A MATTER OF ABOUT TWENTY MINUTES. Grow an imagination.
The Solution
Excise the false start mission entirely: diluting Waller's standing is unnecessarily reductive, and it's too contrived when the Squad have already been called into action. You don't need that to be how Enchantress escapes any more, and you don't even really need the bomb, so it's better off gone.
And to replace the bomb, simply have Diablo super-charge to the point that he implodes fatally. It's the same effect, but with a magical element that makes Incubus' death more fitting.
The solution to the repetition is far simpler. Just stop doing it.
8. Introduce Nightwing
The Problem
There are no shades of morality (other than Scott Eastwood being a good guy), so the "bad guys" end up being dragged into anti-hero territory rather than remaining villains. Thus, the script repeatedly requires them to tell the audience OUT LOUD that they're the bad guys, because it's way too easy to forget that.
The Solution
Bring in a hero, but crucially make him alienated and make damn sure he's got an inbuilt reason not to immediately go to Batman to tell him about the Squad's existence. In short, make him Nightwing.
The lore to introduce him was right there: Robin was established in Batman v Superman (and not only that, it was Jason Todd, so the implication is that Dick Grayson at least exists). And then there's the ready built assumption that he and Batman are estranged, since he didn't show up to help in BvS: it wouldn't be difficult to say they fell out over Todd's death, and that Nightwing disagrees with Batman's approach to superheroism.
Having Nightwing there as an overseer - even if he only encounters the Squad in a single scene - not only means you get a fan favourite in the DCEU, it also introduces the other moral extreme that the film needed. There was nothing for the "bad guys" to bounce off other than other evil, and having a good guy in the mix would have cemented them more firmly as villains without having to constantly reassure themselves.
And then having Nightwing realise at the end that they are a necessary evil who Batman didn't need to know about would have fit without having to imply either than Batman knew about them and did nothing, or that he wasn't actually smart enough to work it out despite Enchantress destroying military targets around the US and in space.
7. Have Killer Croc Actually Be A Monster
The Problem
Despite his looks, Killer Croc is a pretty hopeless monster. He never lives up to his billing in battle, and you end up wondering whether he's just counted as a villain because of his skin condition. That's just racist, dog.
The Solution
Have him actually be a monster. David Ayer cut out the impact of his own character by removing his backstory (and expecting his single moment saying "I'm beautiful" was a substantial enough stand-in - it wasn't), and into that vacuum crept doubt over his actual villainy or use as a Squad member.
Even something as simple as engineering a Croc versus multiple enemies scene (perhaps even as part of his backstory) would establish him as a special team (the Suicide Squad's Hulk, basically). And having him actually fight a bit more rather than standing around pulling faces would have sold him far better too.
You know, instead of basically making him Lenny from Of Mice And Men and then immediately regretting the decision.
6. Make Diablo's Sacrifice Ring Truer
The Problem
Ultimately, Diablo sacrifices himself in order to protect his "new family", despite there being absolutely no hint up to that point that he felt like he belonged to them. You know, since they kept shouting at him, calling him a pussy and him just generally wandering around the battlefield with no villains bothering to fight him.
The sacrifice ends up feeling hollow, because there's no way they deserved him giving up his life for them.
The Solution
Jettison the ridiculous contrivance that Diablo actually loved the Squad like a family. His whole arc is supposed to be about avoiding the ghosts of his past by moth-balling his powers and silently punishing himself for killing his real family. Why not have his death actually mean something to that arc specifically?
Diablo should have sacrificed himself by allowing the demon inside him to let loose completely and exploding, and his reasoning should simply have been to see his family again. Enchantress had just shown him his fantasy of being with them again, so it would have fit perfectly, rather than the awkward, out-of-the-blue revelation that he feels attached to this band of sociopaths and psychos.
5. Keep Enchantress' Powers
The Problems
1. June Moone couldn't possibly have survived her chest being sliced open and then being blown up.
2. Bruce Wayne gets a portfolio on her as a meta-human, despite the fact that Enchantress is vanquished and she's gone back to being the world's worst archeologist.
The Solution
In the comics, Moone actually manages to exorcise the evil element of Enchantress but retain her powers in order to become a superhero. That's almost exactly what Suicide Squad should have done: having her survival at the end be revealed as the result of Enchantress' powers leaving an imprint on her, but the alternate personality being removed.
That way we could have a reason to accept that she didn't die, as well as making June Moone an interesting character for any sequel (not that she actually deserves it). She could have been locked up in Belle Reve as a security risk and thus retained as an active member of the Squad.
It would also explain why Batman would be remotely interested in her, and could set up her joining up with Justice League Dark.
4. Kill More Characters
The Problem
It's called Suicide Squad, it positions itself as the Dirty Dozen of the DCEU and pretty much nobody actually dies. Not even some of the characters the film definitely paints as the most expendable/pointless (Boomerang, Croc, Katana, Flag, Griggs).
That meant that they had to manipulate the kill count, by bringing in Slipknot, Monster T and GQ to kill off for effect, despite them not having any substance. The impact, inevitably was absent.
The Solution
Be braver with your kill count. Everyone came into Suicide Squad expecting the Dead Meat characters to actually be Dead Meat. Having Harley Quinn escape, and then leaving only one or two survivors at most would have been a far better option - mostly because it fits Amanda Waller's vision of success being an accomplished mission and some dead bad guys rolled into one.
As likeable as the idea of Killer Croc and Katana are, having them die in battle would have served a purpose in terms of establishing that all bets are off here. And Boomerang should have died because he was a pig (as much as I enjoyed him as a character). Literally the only people who should have survived were Harley, GQ (in order to pass on the horrors from a morally good perspective), and Deadshot.
Maybe Boomerang could have lived to get locked up again, because the last shot of him screaming in prison to be let out was a lovely moment, but you get the idea: everyone was expendable, but in the end nobody really was. (Apart from Slipknot).
And specifically...
3. Have Rick Flag Sacrifice Himself
The Problem
Well, aside from not liking Rick Flag personally, he had absolutely no progression to his narrative arc. He was just a grump who picked fights with Deadshot and then stood around in the third act calling plays and talking like he was reading out stage directions.
The Solution
The guy needed to die. Even for the romantic angle that should have been removed, the correct end was to have him sacrifice himself to save his lover.
But with that unnecessary relationship gone, Flag's dynamic and leadership friction with Deadshot should have been played up more. They should have gone through stages, with Flag hating him for what he represents, then learning his backstory and learning to respect him for his actions in battle. Okay, so I'm basically borrowing the plot of Fast & Furious there, but who cares?
Then Flag should have ultimately sacrificed himself to let Deadshot take over as the real leader, laying down his life so that Deadshot could live to see his daughter. I would even have allowed some horribly cheesy dialogue about brotherhood and about morality not being black and white.
2. Let Deadshot Get Away
The Problem
I want a Deadshot spin-off. With him locked up, I can't have that. This is a problem.
The Solution
In all seriousness, Deadshot needed to escape Amanda Waller's clutches at the end of the movie (arguably more than Harley Quinn, in fact) and the easiest solution would be to have him assumed dead.
With Rick Flag making a heroic sacrifice, we could have had a The Rock moment with Deadshot taking the place of Sean Connery and getting a chance to go and see his daughter (please no Pythagoras though, that'd just be silly...) and then disappearing into the night.
That would open up a possible spin-off, or a sub-plot for the second movie, because Will Smith is legitimately still the star of this vehicle and pushing him forward is a no-brainer. It also gives someone even a slight victory over Waller, whose victory at the end would have been better served with a little sweetener.
1. Just Be More Silly
The Problem
Despite being a Suicide Squad movie - which is one of the most deranged, silly comic series of all time - David Ayer ended up having to make something more fitting to Zack Snyder's image of the DCEU and grounded it a little too much in reality.
That wasn't the right way to go, considering the comics saw the Squad battle dinosaurs and various more daft villains, including a giant cyclops.
The Solution
Suicide Squad should have been defined by difference, and being a lot more silly would have served it well. Consider Deadpool: a film that was a difficult sell if it was going to be made in traditional superhero movie terms. It wasn't, Fox dialled up the silliness and the outrageous elements and it was a triumphant success.
Ayer's film should have embraced more of the humour and controversy of the comics, and not cared so much about fitting an established tone - particularly since Warner Bros then apparently strode in and insisted on more humour and levity, making for an awful disjointed experience.
That silliness doesn't mean a CGI villain stomping around with no human element (ie Incubus), but rather a more outrageous, unified tone. It's not rocket science, just actually deliver on the idea of being a wildcard movie, and have a threat that actually warrants a black ops Suicide Squad mission, rather than just something any old hero could sort out.
How would you have improved Suicide Squad Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.