15 Actors Almost Cast In The Hunger Games

The odds weren't in these guy's favour.

The Hunger Games has become a most unique hit. While young adult adaptations tend to pander to the converted, all but alienating those not already addicted to the source novels (hello Twilight), the dystopian sci-fi has managed to tap into the mainstream, balancing the swoon-inducing romance with confident, large-scale action. Everyone knew it would be big, but no one expected it to be this good. It's now the franchise to beat, with countless other similar series being brought to life, albeit to distinctly less success. What The Hunger Games has that Divergent or The Maze Runner intrinsically lack (aside from a first movie that actually worked on its own) is the characters, who feel like real people, rather than avatars of teenage angst. The quality of acting involved certainly helps. We're so used to Josh Hutcherson as Peeta Mellark, Sam Claflin as Finnick Odair, Jena Malone as Johanna Mason and, of course, Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen that it's nigh on impossible to imagine a group of other actors inhabiting Panem. But obviously - the cast could have been very different. With The Hunger Games: Mockingjay: Part 1 flying into cinemas this week, take a look back through the series' production and see who could have been heading up the revolution instead.

15. Abigail Breslin - Katniss Everdeen

OK, so it's been almost ten years since Abigail Breslin played Olive in the indie hit Little Miss Sunshine, but that remains her most memorable role; in the proceeding decade she's had a few interesting parts (Zombieland), but mostly has starred in tat (The Call, New Years Eve, Ender's Game). Thankfully her convincing turn as the Miss America-obsessed Hoover offspring ensures that she remains a notable young actress. Breslin's name was connected to the part of Katniss from early on, with Variety reporting she was down to the final three. That's strange as she's almost the anti-thesis of J-Law; she was actually younger than Katniss is meant to be at the time, whereas Lawrence is much older. It show's a real initial uncertainty in how to portray the character.

14. Mia Wasikowska - Johanna Mason

When it was apparent The Hunger Games was a hit there was a massive scramble as Hollywood's best not already tied down to a franchise vied to get in on the action. One of the key roles up for grabs was Johanna Mason, the initially-antagonistic former victor, which eventually went to long-rising star Jena Malone. She wasn't always the front-runner, with Mia Wasikowska's name (which wouldn't be out of place in Panem itself) consistently linked to the part. Not getting cast is another knock to a career that looked set to explode; Wasikowska starred in Alice In Wonderland, one of the biggest movies of the past decade, and yet it didn't do much to boost her reputation.

13. Melissa Leo - Mags

For those who aren't rabid Hunger Games fans (Hungeys? Gameys? Teenagers?), Mags is the old lady who volunteers to enter the Quarter Quell alongside Finnick Odair in Catching Fire. In the finished film she's played by Lynn Cohen, but had things gone differently it could have been Melissa Leo choking in that fog. It's better that a lesser known actress (Cohen is best known for playing Magda in Sex And The City) to take the minor role, but the real slight against Leo is that she's inconceivably young - Mags is supposed to be thirty years older than the Oscar winner. Perhaps there was going to be a flashback of sorts to a younger Mags, but otherwise it smacks of star power for star power's sake, something The Hunger Games has mostly kept restrained.

12. Armie Hammer - Finnick Odair

The introduction of victors of previous games into the mix for the Quarter Quell meant that for Catching Fire the series could cast older - no need to get people who look like teenagers any more. This led to a mad scramble amongst Hollywood twenty-somethings for the role of Finnick Odair, a key character in the final two books/three films. According to E! Online, several big twenty-something stars were in the running for the role, including Armie Hammer. Hammer was then filming The Lone Ranger, which, coupled with the potential of a part in this franchise, looked set to push his career into the stratosphere. It didn't really go to plan, with Ranger bombing spectacularly at the box office and Catching Fire casting a relative unknown, but there's still time.

11. Chloë Grace Moretz - Katniss Everdeen

When a massively popular young adult property starts casting young adults, you're naturally going to get fans of the material eager to get involved. It happened on a mass scale with Harry Potter and you can bet it happened with the wizarding adventure's successor to the teenage box office throne. Chloë Moretz, who rose to fame playing the foul-mouthed, pre-teen assassin Hit-Girl, was linked with Katniss from the off. She was clear fan favourite and, as a lover of the books herself, incredibly eager to be involved. Even younger than Breslin, it's unlikely she was as seriously considered as other candidates, but there was always the potential. Moretz accidentally fuelled rumours of her involvement - in an interview with MTV she said she'd "just booked a huge project€ You€™re gonna die when you find out, it€™s huge!" That project ended up being Dark Shadows. She needs to learn the definition of huge (and read scripts before signing on).

10. Lyndsy Fonseca - Katniss Everdeen

Lyndsy Fonseca is best known as a central element of a show she was barely a part of - she was one of Ted's long-suffering children in How I Met Your Mother. Given that her involvement in the show was finished way back in 2006 (the scene in the finale with the kids was shot ahead of time to combat ageing), Fonseca has been hunting for a more note-worthy big break. Jumping off the success of action TV drama Nikita, Fonseca became a popular name linked to central hero, according to interviews making it to the final few, going as far as doing extended acting work with the director. Things could have got really weird had David Henrie, who played her on screen brother in HIMYM and auditioned for Gale, got his part too - we'd have had The Fault In Our Stars levels of awkwardness.

9. Aaron Taylor-Johnson - Peeta Mellark

Here's one of the most intriguing almost-castings; Aaron Taylor-Johnson auditioned to play Peeta. Can you imagine him getting all romantic with a Chloë Grace Moretz Katniss? Just weird. Although the real issue is that he's just not as much a fit as Josh Hutcherson - Aaron's a great actor, just not right for the role. Evan Peters, Johnson's on-screen best bud in Kick-Ass, also auditioned and although he's typically a goofier actor, he'd have been a better fit for Peeta than that film's star. Taylor-Johnson's career hasn't really been hurt by missing out. He the central (if much maligned by the movie's critics) role in Godzilla and will appear as Quicksilver in Avengers: Age Of Ultron, which is set to be one of the biggest movies of 2015.

8. Hunter Parrish - Peeta Mellark/Finnick Odair

It's always nice to see a friend do well, although for Hunter Parrish seeing RV co-star Josh Hutcherson get the very role he was so close to getting himself must be a little painful. The Weeds star and sometimes singer has been trying to break into the big leagues for a while now, and a central part in one of the world's largest new franchises would have certainly made that transition happen. Parrish and Hutcherson were linked to the part from the off, although fan opinion of the former was mixed; some thought he perfectly captured the character's essence, while others found him a bit dopey. The actor auditioned for the series again with Catching Fire, angling for Finnick Odair (although this time probably knowing his chances were slight against the massive competition).

7. Saoirse Ronan - Katniss Everdeen

Although Jennifer Lawrence actually won her Oscar after The Hunger Games made her the biggest star in the world, she already had an Academy Award on her belt when she first went to Panem. Clearly the aims of Gary Ross and his casting team knew no limits, so it's only to be expected that a few other award-praised actresses were considered to play Katniss. Saoirse Ronan had bagged a Best Supporting Actress nom for Atonement and, although the film itself was a self-involved dud from Peter Jackson, she shone in The Lovely Bones. A role in a major franchise would have done for her career what, well, The Hunger Games did for Lawrence. Ronan wasn't a producer-favourite for the part, but as a major young actress of course her name was linked. Her career since has been more steady (although she did get to do a bit of young adult action in the overlooked Hanna).

6. Garrett Hedlund - Finnick Odair

Whenever you're looking at the casting of a twenty-something in a major blockbuster movie you can bet Garrett Hedlund narrowly missed out. He's a perfectly competent actor (see Inside Llewyn Davis), but doesn't have either enough star power to win big roles, nor uniqueness to get something smaller. Maybe the collective "ooh, but meh" reaction to TRON: Legacy has hurt its star. Although even if it has, with Hunger Games: Catching Fire, for which Hedlund was approached to play Finnick, it was actually the actor himself who pulled himself out of the running. Francis Lawrence and co. wanted him to be involved, but the actor's schedule meant there was no way to fit in the massive shooting schedule.

5. Taylor Kitsch - Finnick Odair

The third actor in the trio of possible Finnicks rumoured by E!, Taylor Kitsch would have been an interesting addition, considerably older than the character (and cast actor Sam Claflin). While he may have benefited the film, the real boost would have been to the actor's waning career. Kitsch looked set to be the next big thing, but some utterly disastrous career decisions have hurt him - 2012 was a particularly bad time, with lead roles in box office bomb John Carter and critical hate-object Battleship leading to very few roles in the years since. But, as with Hedlund, it wasn't past form that got in the way, but his schedule - one of his few recent projects, Lone Survivor, was filming at the same time as Catching Fire.

4. Emily Browning - Katniss Everdeen

Emily Browning rose to fame in a young adult adaptation (A Series Of Unfortunate Events) and made the transition to more "adult" fare in what was essentailly a young adult fantasy (Sucker Punch), so you wouldn't be surprised if she wanted to go in a different career direction. Still, she did read a couple of times for The Hunger Games, clearly not dissatisfied enough (she almost quit acting after the Lemony Snicket film) to pass on a massive opportunity. Although by the actress' own admission she wasn't that bothered to miss out, having never read the books and being rather blaze about the whole series. Bet she feels differently now. This wasn't Browning's first brush with young adult adaptations - author Stephanie Meyer pegged her as her favourite to play Bella Swan in Twilight, but the actress declined an audition, at that point not wanting to commit to a franchise.

3. Alex Pettyfer - Peeta Mellark

Alex Pettyfer has everything he needs to be a big star - good looks, solid American accent and a mildly embarrassing younger performance to be referenced in articles on his fame (thanks Alex Rider) - and yet instead remains on the sidelines with supporting roles in the likes of Magic Mike. It doesn't help that he has a pretty bad track record of picking leading roles, although that could have changed with Peeta. Pettyfer was a name tossed about in the weeks leading up to Josh Hutcherson's casting, as much a contender as the ultimate star or Hunter Parrish. He's so intriguing a choice because he's almost too dashing for the role, which would have probably pushed the love triangle element of the film to greater prominence. Probably for the best he missed out then.

2. Shailene Woodley - Katniss Everdeen

Shailene Woodley almost being cast as Katniss has become a more interesting "what if?" as time's gone by. At the time a minor child actress who'd had some minor TV success, her career has started to directly mimic Jennifer Lawrence's - a big hit with an Oscar-nominated indie before branching out into a couple of mainstream franchises (Divergent and The Amazing Spider-Man, from which her Mary Jane was cut). That Divergent, in which she plays protagonist Tris, is heavily inspired (read: copied) from The Hunger Games only furthers that comparison Woodley is a great actor and would have likely delivered a performance similar to Lawrence. It's very likely that over time, as her star continues to rise, she'll become the most popular alternate casting of Katniss. But that doesn't mean she'd have been the best...

1. Hailee Steinfeld - Katniss Everdeen

Woodley may be quite like Lawrence, but in terms of who'd have been the best Katniss had Mystique not come aboard, you can't get better than Hailee Steinfeld. Another Oscar nominee (Best Supporting Actress for True Grit), she's got what it takes to lead a revolution. The actress is totally unshowy and rather down to Earth (the same can't be said of some of the other contenders on this list). She's on the younger side, actually being the same age as Katniss, but that's hardly a detraction when she's a competent actress - True Grit showed that she could play someone trying and only half-succeeding at pretending to be mature (pretty hard when you think about it), which would work for the put-upon Katniss we're first introduced in the first film. Although she missed out on the incredible part, Steinfeld has still kept working, keeping mostly to indies - could a second Oscar nom be on the horizon? Would any of these actors been better than those who were cast? Who else almost ended up in The Hunger Games? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.