15 Actors You Didn't Know Almost Played Superman
Superman Returns was far from the worst thing that could have happened to Superman...

15. Will Smith

The last Superman I got offered, the script came, and I was like, There is no way Im playing Superman! Because I had already done Jim West and you cant be messing up white peoples heroes in Hollywood. You mess up white peoples heroes in Hollywood, youll never work in this town again!Putting aside the clearly false suggestion that Wild Wild West failed because of his casting, it's not a great leap to believe that Smith might have been on to something. Or maybe he just knew that Singer's Superman train was on a quick track to apathy. Would He Have Worked? Undoubtedly. Though Smith is probably right in his assertion that "messing with" Superman's race would have caused some outrage amongst hardcore fans - and racists - he boasts the perfect blend of bravado and vulnerability that would have worked for both sides of the Superman/Clark Kent divide, and he proved in Ali and Hancock that he has the physicality to match the requirements of the role.
14. Ashton Kutcher

"I think theres a bit of a curse behind that role the things that have happened to people. Also, I think once youve played that role then youre just forever known as Superman. Its kind of hard to play other things. I have a lot of other characters Id rather play."He might have been right to swerve the role, but the second part of his reasoning was a bit rich. Would He Have Worked? Well, he can't act, but that wasn't really a requirement for Brandon Routh in Superman Lives either, so possibly. Unfortunately for Kutcher, it's too difficult to detach him from his stoner/surfer roles in That 70s Show and Dude Where's My Car, and that could only have hurt Supes.
13. Jude Law

12. James Caan

"When Clark Kent is just devastated cause she (Lois Lane) is so in love with Superman. Physically the office is setup in the paper (Daily Planet)... In order to get to Clark Kent's office you must pass through Lois Lane's office. So, there is no other way in. So, one day Clark is so pissed off (laughs) that she is in love with Superman, he says, aw screw it. And he rips his clothes off and he's got his Superman thing (costume) on under there. And he says, "Lois, come in here!" She comes in and looks at him, "That's sweet Clark, but you're no Superman." And she walks out. He looks and the mirror and says, "Maybe a little tuck here." It was all tongue-in-cheek."Would He Have Worked? He might have in a different film, but not in the one he says was offered to him. He could also have been a great Lex Luthor.
11. Muhammad Ali
Could The World's Greatest have been a believable component of Earth's Finest? He did go on to fight Superman in comic form, but he almost got a chance to play the character on screen before that happened. What Happened? There was a period in the 1970s when Ilya and Alexander Salkind were trying to get Superman made that it looked unlikely that they'd ever be able to sort out the excruciatingly complex issue of rights with DC, which is perhaps why they went a bit mad with who should play the titular hero. For a while, the producers entertained the idea of bringing in Ali, despite his lack of experience in acting. Would He Have Worked? As Superman, unquestionably, thanks to his physique and that super-human spirit he already exuded, but it's hard to imagine The Greatest toning himself down to play Clark Kent. Occasionally, in his more reflective moments, Ali's vulnerability did shine through in interviews - particularly in times of turmoil - but there's not exactly a very grand history of sportsmen taking up acting roles that required a strong acting performance. And the lasting caveat that should always come with that suggestion is the ominous memory of what Vinnie Jones did to Juggernaut in X-Men: The Last Stand.10. Clint Eastwood

"This was when they first started to think about making it. was like, Superman? Nah, nah, thats not for me. Not that theres anything wrong with it. Its for somebody, but not me. I always liked characters that were more grounded in reality."And reality has been kind to Eastwood, no matter how tantalising the prospect of seeing him spread his wings (or cape) might have been. Would He Have Worked? He would have been great cast in the 1970s, even if became a lot cooler 20 or 30 years later to imagine him playing an aged Batman. In playing cowboys at the end of the genre's success, Eastwood knew exactly what it meant to play complex characters marked by internal conflict and by an inherent doubleness in their appearance. And he remains one of the finest actors in selling a character on the most minimal of outward performance; instead he has that intangible, irresistible ability to inhabit roles entirely without effort, like Philip Seymour Hoffman. So, Superman would have been in great hands. If anything would be amiss, it would be that his persona tended to lend itself to gruffer characters (hence the link to Batman), but that could have led to a more layered Superman performance.
9. Al Pacino

8. Brendan Fraser

"It seems as if then the big monster studio machine and all the machinations behind it, all the cogs and wheels rolling, suddenly it went from an 'offer' to 'subject to a screen test' blah, blah, blah, 'subject to approval'..."He did however confirm that the film would have been better than Superman Returns:
"In my view, and I say this with respect, it's far superior t... J.J. had a vision that was larger. It spanned galaxies. It was Lord of the Rings. I mean, it was that huge. It was like a Third World War on Earth involving different planets and universes, and brotherhoods - sibling rivalry and the collision of enormous powers. I mean, come on, it wasn't smacking you over the head with a symbolic hammer till you weren't paying attention. That's how good J.J. is."Would He Have Worked? Had it been a comedy, perhaps. But it wasn't, so that's a big negatory. Even though casting a comedic actor for Batman worked with Michael Keaton, that was very much a blip, and casting Fraser would have been more like casting George Clooney, which didn't turn out very well.
7. Zac Efron

6. Nick Nolte

"We found guys with fabulous physique who couldn't act, or wonderful actors who did not look remotely like Superman."But then despite the urge to classify Nolte as one of those rejected actors, the imposing figure - then a relative unknown - was actually signed for the part of Superman when Mario Puzo came on board to script, with Brando and Gene Hackman already signed up. Unfortunately for him, Richard Donner wasn't overly impressed with Puzo's script and delayed the production for some substantial rewrites, forcing Nolte to drop out. Would He Have Worked? It would at least have been interesting. Nolte isn't exactly known for his restraint, and the idea of an angry slurring Superman is an intriguing one, even if it would have horribly tainted the original movie.
5. Dustin Hoffman

4. Arnold Schwarzenegger

"When I met [Arnold] at the premiere of the first film, he said 'Ahhh I should've been Superman'. With that accent... not too good."Would He Have Worked? Arnie certainly had the size for a super man, but he would have been the least convincing Clark Kent in the history of the character, and his size and accent wouldn't exactly have fit the need to hide in plain sight. As fellow almost Superman Jon Voight later confirmed, Arnie had actually offered to help him bulk up when he thought he wasn't a good physical fit for the character.
"He said: 'Will you do me a favour? Talk to a friend of mine. Do you know who Arnold Schwarzenegger is?'. So I said 'Yeah, I know who Arnold is and I think he's terrific'. "He gets Arnold on the phone and he says: 'Jon, listen! Take the part!'. I said, 'Arnold. I'm not right for it'. He said: 'Take the part. In two months I make you as big as a house!'. I said 'Arnold. I don't want to be as big as a house!'. It was a cute conversation and Arnold was very charming, and enthusiastic, and he was trying to help his buddy."
3. Burt Reynolds

Everyone said put Burt Reynolds in a Superman suit. Well, for a certain kind of movie where you want to camp it up, Burt Reynolds would have been wonderful.
2. Neil Diamond

"After meeting a lot of actors, such as Jon Voight we even met Neil Diamond, dont ask me why - I knew in my heart of hearts it had to be an unknown."So, apparently he was turned down because he was too famous, and not because of the glaringly obvious fact that he was Neil Diamond and should never have been suggested in the first place. Would He Have Worked? No. Just no.
1. Sylvester Stallone
