15 Directors Who Do The Same Thing In Every Movie

It's a good bet Tarantino will include feet and obligatory trunk shots no matter what the subject.

Pulpfiction Feet01 Ever watch two movies by your favourite filmmaker back-to-back and get the odd feeling that you might have just seen the same thing twice? You're not alone. It could be that they like to use the same actors for every film (like David O.Russell) or favour certain shots, but occasionally they'll re-use entire plots or characters and hope nobody notices (Luc Besson, anyone?). Being wholly original is hard, especially for filmmakers, who have a wealth of history and time-tested techniques to fall back on and make their movie work as a piece of entertainment. They might pull off something unique once, sure. But twice? Forget about it! Once a director figures out a trick that works for them, you can bet they'll keep it in their back pocket for safe keeping until the next time they need to use it, either to establish their auteur status or simply just because they know it's safe ground. The following list of 15 film directors is a collection of artists who, for better or worse, repeat themselves in various ways throughout all their movies. Some are understandable tropes and themes, some are favourite shots and music cues, but some of them are just plain lazy. Some entries might surprise you. Others? Not so much.

15. Quentin Tarantino Loves Feet, Trunk Shots And Profanity

Tarantino GifIf Tarantino had made Die Hard, you can bet your ass that he would have found a way for John McClane not to have to run across broken glass and end up with bloody, lacerated feet. Because Quentin Tarantino doesn't want anything bad to happen to your feet; he wants them preserved, immaculately pedicured, the nails painted in front of his eyes, and preferably elevated to an optimum shooting angle, usually out of a car window (Death Proof) or on the edge of a couch (Jackie Brown), but the director'll still settle for following Uma Thurman's bare feet around from behind with a floor-height camera. It'll come as a surprise to no-one that QT loves to have his characters swear almost as much as he does himself, and the phrase "motherfucker" is basically the Tarantinoverse equivalent of "please", not to mention the racist slurs casually dropped into every other conversation. The writer/director of Reservoir Dogs has also included shots from the trunks of cars ever since his feature debut, whether there's a mysterious package or just a tied-up cop in there. He's nothing if not consistent with his own fake product placement too, having his characters smoke Red Apple cigarettes and eat Big Kahuna burgers (they even make an appearance in the Robert Rodriguez-directed From Dusk Till Dawn), although you'd be hard pressed to track them down in Django Unchained - drive-thrus weren't really a big thing in the Old West.

14. Wes Anderson Explores His Daddy Issues

Anderson Gif On the surface, all of Wes Anderson's father figures are rather charming, none more so than in his latest, The Grand Budapest Hotel, starring a never-slicker Ralph Fiennes as the silver-tongued concierge Gustave H. Unfortunately, that surface is inevitably paper-thin and the charm never survives a perfunctory squint that reveals each man is as self-obsessed, self-serving and self-indulgent an individual as conceivably possible. It would be no surprise to learn that The Royal Tenenbaums director Wes Anderson had a dysfunctional family growing up - that's what all of his films are really about; the families we're stuck with and the families we make, as messy as both are - but it's more often and not the older men in the cast who take top billing and the biggest chunk of screentime, which suggests that Anderson has some unfinished business with his own dad, hugely affected by his parents' divorce as a young child. Let's run the figures down: there's James Caan's initially fatherly but ultimately conniving criminal in Bottle Rocket; Bill Murray's romantic rival-turned best friend to Jason Schwartzman's precocious high schooler in Rushmore; there are three father figures in The Royal Tenenbaums - Gene Hackman & Danny Glover's biological fathers and Bill Murray's surrogate daddy to Hackman's screen daughter Gwyneth Paltrow; the titular arrogant oceanographer (again Bill Murray) in The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou; a father conspicuous by his absence from The Darjeeling Limited, the road (well, tracks really) film about three brothers on a journey of self-discovery a year after his death; George Clooney's Fantastic Mr. Fox, a Royal Tenenbaum stand-in by way of whimsical anthropomorphism; the many surrogates of Moonrise Kingdom, from Ed Norton's well-meaning scout troop leader to Bruce Willis' desperate, sensitive sheriff and (yet again) Bill Murray as kind of an a-hole dad; and, of course, Fiennes' Gustave, who fails to be a father to his charge Zero on a number of occasions until he gets his act together and teaches him how to be a man. In reality, it's probably the other way around in almost every film.

13. Steven Spielberg Gives Us Broken Homes And Slack Jaws

Spileberg Gif Wes Anderson's not the only big name in Hollywood with daddy issues, and he certainly wasn't the first. It'd be a reasonable wager that a good deal of directors have some unresolved parental issues, but the most prominent of these - and the most obvious - has to be Steven Spielberg, who includes an estranged or absent father in every film he can, from Jaws' Chief Brodie (Roy Scheider) and Richard Dreyfus' deranged dad in Close Encounters Of The Third Kind to Christopher Walken in Catch Me If You Can and Tom Cruise's well-meaning deadbeat in War Of The Worlds. Perhaps Spielberg's trying to exorcise feelings of dissatisfaction with his own father, or maybe he's just expressing guilt at abandoning his children to run off and shoot films when he could have spent time with them instead. There are, of course, a number of other significant tropes in Spielberg's films, the most famous of these probably being close-ups of awestruck faces (also known as "The Spielberg Face") and using music composed by John Williams in nearly every single movie he's ever made. Other telltale signs are broken/breaking marriages, intense streams of light bearing down on characters and close-ups of characters with what they're looking at reflected in the window in front of them.

12. Joss Whedon Kills Your Favourite Characters

Whedon 2 Gif Whedon has something of a dodgy reputation for murder in his past, being held responsible for every premature death in his TV shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Tara, Jenny Calendar, even Buffy herself!) and never shying away from offing a key supporting character or two in the films he's written and directed. This reputation for being a deathmonger is often backed up by the sheer body count from Whedon's productions but of course that doesn't account for the fact that every death is justified in some emotional or plot-motivating way. He's not interested in torture porn or killing for shock value; Whedon wants us to feel for every character that shuffles off the mortal coil in his 'verse, which is probably why he picks the most sympathetic characters (Wash in Serenity, Coulson in The Avengers) for audiences to get weepy over. But killing beloved characters isn't the Firefly creator's unique repeat offence: after all, Shakespeare did it all the time. It's killing them in more or less the exact same way: in two of the three of t feature films he's directed, Whedon skewers a character through the chest with an unexpected blade and has them die mid-sentence. In Serenity, Wash utters the immortal half-line, "I am a leaf on the wind. Watch as I--" before a Reaver harpoon takes his life. In The Avengers, Coulson's already been gutted by Loki before he whispers to Fury, "It was never going to work if they didn't have something...to..." and checks out for good. Somewhat unsurprisingly, Whedon has previously been quoted as saying that Avengers: Age of Ultron will be "about death."

11. Nicolas Winding Refn Loves A Brooding Man Or Ten

Refn 2 Gif Drive. Only God Forgives. Valhalla Rising. All films with stoic male protagonists who talk little, brood much and occasionally lash out at people in brutally violent manner, and all films directed by Nicolas Winding Refn. It's not a stretch to say that Winding Refn has a distinct visual style: his strong use of colour, lingering close ups and long stretches of film where nothing very much happens only to be punctuated by an act of startling violence have all been on display in recent years, for better or worse. Drive was a critical hit, whereas God Only Forgives was panned as a turgid mess even though both featured Ryan Gosling trying not to move his face for much of their running time (although it should probably be mentioned that Drive's screenplay was written by Hossein Amini and Only God Forgives by Winding Refn himself). Though the director's earlier work like Bronson and the Pusher trilogy is more conventional in terms of genre and plotting (and especially dialogue - you can tell even from the trailers that the two aforementioned films are a lot wordier than Drive or Only God Forgives), Nicolas Winding Refn still shows an affinity for the brooding, possibly (probably) unstable male and revels in studying every tiny non-movement of their faces, like Sergio Leone on anti-depressants.

10. Martin Scorsese's Religious Symbolism

Scorcese Gif It's one of modern Hollywood's more famous origin stories: Martin Scorsese almost joined the priesthood before deciding to become a filmmaker, a slightly less holy but slightly more wholesome career path if modern Catholicism is anything to go by. Even if you didn't know that, the religious influence on the Raging Bull filmmaker is evident from even a cursory glance of his filmography and the characters he's chosen to make movies about: Italian-Americans (Mean Streets, Goodfellas, Italianamerican - which is about his own Catholic parents), Irish-Americans (The Departed, Gangs Of New York), hell, even Jesus himself in The Last Temptation Of Christ. The recurring themes of suffering, doubt and sacrifice are all there, even from his earliest short The Big Shave, in which a man persists in shaving and cutting his face until the only dry spot is his own neck, which he saves for the big finish. Scorsese usually deals in characters with huge internal conflicts, as many people of faith have, as in Harvey Keitel's character in Mean Streets who tries to square his life of crime and debauchery with God by confessing at church, or the protagonists of the Paul Schrader-written Taxi Driver and Bringing Out The Dead, who both live in a world they perceive as filled with sin and unnecessary suffering. Schrader also wrote Scorsese's alternate-Biblical-reality The Last Temptation of Christ in which Willem Defoe's Messiah struggles with trying to get out of dying on the cross and saving humanity. Even in Goodfellas, a film where religion isn't often explicitly mentioned and the lead Henry Hill (Ray Liotta) doesn't express any particular guilt about his crimes, the ritualistic and familial nature of the Mafia in which he lives and breathes can easily be seen as a religion in and of itself.

9. Edgar Wright Whips, Zooms And Tools Up

Wright Gif You've seen them all dozens of times; they might even be your favourite parts of his movies. Edgar Wright loves a good close-up and whip-pan, and that's more than obvious from a look at his brief but significant filmography: Shaun Of The Dead, Hot Fuzz, Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World and The World's End all feature variations on the same few shots, and he even used them in his very first feature, a no-budget spaghetti western spoof called A Fistful Of Fingers. But then, if you're going to make a Sergio Leone knock-off, you have to love close-ups. Wright also owes a debt to Scorsese, Sam Raimi and James Cameron as he acknowledges in Dave Chen's excellent video essay Edgar Wright And The Art Of Close-Ups. While he definitely inherited the techniques needed to produce the sequences, Wright may well have perfected "tooling up" sequences: they're used for comic effect in Shaun Of The Dead and Scott Pilgrim and to capture the spirit of a certain type of action movie in Hot Fuzz, and the director owes much of his films' fast paces and high energy to the brevity afforded him by the shots. Oh, and did we mention that Simon Pegg and Nick Frost play variations on exactly the same characters in 3/4 of Wright's major movies? Just sayin'.

8. Terrence Malick Loves Tall Grass (And Pondering The Meaning Of Life)

Mallick GifIf you're seeing a hand in close-up, brushing delicately through a field of wheat as an ethereal yet crucial orchestra soundtracks the moment and an oh-so-slight voiceover details the simultaneous fragility and epic import of life and its meaning, chances are you're watching a Terrence Malick picture. The cornfields and the lost, thoughtful protagonists are there in Badlands, Malick's first feature, and they return with spiritual overtones but less plot in Days Of Heaven. From there on out the man who epitomises (and occasionally comes close to parodying) the word 'auteur' turned to big, multi-character dramas with a much wider scope (The Thin Red Line, The Tree Of Life) but the exact same sense of childlike wonder at the universe, marvelling and getting lost in the minutiae of the world - there's a sequence in The Thin Red Line, a WWII drama set in the Pacific Theater, that follows the lives of snails and wildlife in the warzone the characters are occupying, and The Tree Of Life regularly diverges from its '50s suburban family drama to explore the compassion of dinosaurs and the beginning of the universe. Yep. Dinosaurs. There are many imitators of Terence Malick's style (occasionally himself, as with To The Wonder), but few manage to come close to the sense of mystery and romantic faith that exudes from every frame of his films. No-one shoots grass quite like Terrence, that's for sure.

7. Woody Allen Never Stops Talking About Death And Sex

Allen Gif Death and sex are two things you can count on to be present in film made by Woody Allen, or at least people having conversations about them. The most famous example is probably from Annie Hall, in which Allen's character Alvy Singer buys The Denial Of Death for Diane Keaton's Hall and tells her that he thinks it's a "very important" subject, which really isn't the half of it. He also made Love & Death, which proves the argument rather succinctly without you even needing to watch the film, and Allen's preoccupation with the slim mortal coil can be seen from his earliest stand-up and prose comedy right up to his most recent films Blue Jasmine and Midnight In Paris - most of the characters from the latter of which are, themselves, actually dead. There's also more often than not Mr. Allen himself in the film, a bundled-up mess of neuroses that still manages to have a more active sex life than that of your average charming, handsome writer, and if the prolific filmmaker doesn't make an appearance himself you can bet he's got a similarly nebbish surrogate to play the part for him, like Owen Wilson's nostalgic writer in Midnight In Paris or Jesse Eisenberg's pretentious would-be adulterer in To Rome With Love.

6. Zack Snyder Slows Everything Down... Just Before He Speeds It Up

Snyder Gif For a guy who makes action movies, Zack Snyder sure is remembered more for his slow motion than his speed and economy of screentime. From his feature film debut - the first in a long line of derivative products - Dawn Of The Dead introduced Snyder's signature slo-mo ramping shots that were perfected in his macho-but-definitely-not-gay-even-though-we're-all-basically-naked-and-yelling "historical" fiction 300 and became more and more prominent with every subsequent film, from the agonisingly stilted and overly stylised leathery superhero action and boning of Watchmen to the uncomfortably unironic adolescent imaginings of Sucker Punch and the slightly more wholesome owl-on-owl warfare of Legend Of The Guardians: The Owls Of Ga'Hoole. Snyder has valued style over substance in every film he's made, crafting inarguably pretty images that unfortunately remain hollow and devoid of any discernible emotion other than "holy shit, look how cool Superman punching this guy through a highly-populated building looks!" There are approximations of innocence and at the very least nostalgia in Man Of Steel's flashback sequences, but Snyder's attempts to remind us of Clark Kent's mostly grounded, human upbringing ultimately serve to undercut the callous destruction and murder Supes is a party to in the remainder of that film. Though it could have been worse; Snyder could have written the film and we might have ended up with a teenage Lois Lane with a penchant for schoolgirl clothes, katanas and an unhealthy fixation with strange, older men...

5. Sam Raimi Puts His Actors Through Hell

Raimi Gif If you get cast as the lead in a Sam Raimi-directed film, you better brace yourself for some pain, as the Evil Dead creator tends to put his stars through the wringer seemingly as often as he can. Whether it's covering Bruce Campbell in mud, blood and Deadite innards (not to mention chopping off limbs and replacing them with chainsaws and magic metal hands) in the Evil Dead movies, putting Spider-Man through the wringer (almost literally) with sand, blades and metal tentacles rending his costume and flesh to shreds, not to mention the hideous mouth-and-throat horror he commits to Alison Lohman in Drag Me To Hell - a movie which many audience members didn't quite gather was actually really about eating disorders but probably caused more than a few itself...and let's not forget Darkman, Raimi's superhero whose origin story includes the lead being burned almost to death. Raimi's also known for tossing his camera around and incorporating fast-paced editing and whip-pans, much like Edgar Wright, and invented the by now infamous running-with-a-camera-on-a-tree-branch shot used in Evil Dead to illustrate a demonic spirit's point of view that really ought to be in all of his films because it's so damn weird.

4. Judd Apatow Tells The Story Of A Man-Child Learning To Grow Up (And Vice-Versa)

Apatow Gif Quite possibly the director who changes the least from film to film, Apatow has a litany of tropes that populate his films, the least (or most, depending on your preference for affable-ish man-children) of which is Paul Rudd, the most being an inability to contain a semi-sophisticated story without resorting to toilet humour at least once every five minutes. Granted, Rudd doesn't appear in Funny People, but that's one out of the four films Apatow has written and directed and all share many other common traits. One of the more obvious tropes is the story that revolves around a man who didn't grow up when he should have and decides to grow up,usually with the help or hindrance of his similarly maladjusted bonehead friends. Examples: Steve Carrell hasn't had sex in The 40 Year Old Virgin, he also collects toys - and then when he finally looks like he's about to have sex, he sells all his toys. Seth Rogen lives with his buddies and smokes pot in Knocked Up: he has sex with Katherine Heigl, gets her pregnant and decides to get a job and move into an apartment so he can be a responsible adult. In Funny Games... well, Adam Sandler pretends to be grown up but reveals, to no-one's surprise, that he's still an adolescent-minded little twerp. And the whole trope comes full circle in This Is 40, where Paul Rudd starts out grown up and decides his life would be better if he devolved on an emotional level. It's rather a sad decline when you look at it like that. But who cares about being disillusioned by false change when there are so many HILARIOUS overlong improv sequences to laugh at for two and a half hours until there's no joy left in your body and you wish you'd left the cinema half an hour ago or at least started reading some classic literature?

3. David Fincher Shoots His Films In Different Shades Of Brown

Fincher Gif For most of his career, David Fincher has shot almost exclusively in different shades of brown. The Game, Fight Club, Panic Room, even The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button: all are decidedly dark, and not just in tone. Not that that's a bad thing, of course; an auteur's got to have a style, and with most of Fincher's ouvre the director can be identified as the author of film from a cursory glance at a single frame from one of his films. Even since his feature debut with Alien 3, the director has used a washed-out colour palette and incredibly crisp and precise composition, demonstrating a craftsmanship that's rarely levelled and never bettered by his peers. It's easy to sometimes go too dark, though, as his Girl With The Dragon Tattoo remake and the opening episodes of House Of Cards that Fincher directed proved all too well. They look exceptional when you can make out who's on screen... Another, less obvious Fincher trope that you might not know of is the director's tendency to include a shot where a single character starts out of focus and then walks toward the camera and into focus. The Social Network has one, Fight Club, Seven...the list goes on. It's real blink and you'll miss it stuff, but see if you can track them down!

2. Alexander Payne Loves Miserable Men In Cars

Payne Gif With the exception of his first and second features Citizen Ruth and Election, Alexander Payne deals almost exclusively in road trip movies starring curmudgeonly middle-aged (Sideways, The Descendants) or old (About Schmidt, Nebraska) men. He regularly features a unironic voiceover from his lead characters, detailing the problems with their lives and how they could be fixed if everyone else just gave them a break without realising quite how complicit they are in their own suburban tragedies. Usually the tired anti-heroes learn something about themselves, usually with the assistance of a simpler or more hopeful companion, but it's a coin toss as to whether they'll actually use that information to make their life any better. Paul Giamatti and George Clooney in Sideways and The Descendants respectively are two of the more hopeful if ambiguous cases, whereas it's anybody's guess whether or not Bruce Dern (Nebraska) or Matthew Broderick (Election) will ever let themselves get another shot at happiness. The absurd mundanity of everyday life is never more precisely illustrated than in Payne's movies, where comedy and no small amount of pity can be gleaned from the strange mechanism of a self-buckling seatbelt in a car with absolutely nothing else going for it, as in Election, or the heartbreaking fact of Paul Giamatti's terminally lonely wine connoisseur drinking his best bottle at its prime out of a cardboard cup in a fast food restaurant. Payne's always been the chronicler of jokes that are hysterical until you realise how depressing they truly are.

1. Christopher Nolan Kills His Women

Nolan Gif The dark knight of superhero cinema and champion of cerebral blockbusters might not seem like a guy who likes to keep going back to the same well (Dark Knight Rises puns aside) for his tropes and movies, but appearances, as Bruce Wayne has taught us many times, can be deceptive. Normally that's no crime as long as it's a fresh well, but unfortunately Nolan's decided to drink from one of the mankiest on more than one occasion. That is to say that Christopher Nolan tends to victimise and villainise women in pretty much every film he's made. Let's start with the 'dead wives and girlfriends' (DWAGs?) trope first, since that's always a crowd-pleaser: Following, Memento, The Prestige, all three Batman films and Inception all feature women who are in relationships with central or supporting characters who die, usually in less than pleasant ways. The only woman in his debut Following dies; Hugh Jackman's wife Piper Perabo drowns and Christian Bale's - Rebecca Hall - hangs herself in The Prestige; Bruce's mother is shot in Batman Begins (with little fanfare; it's Thomas Wayne who receives most of the mourning), then Rachel explodes in TDK and Talia Al'Ghul (Marion Cotillard) is car-crashed to death (she's also a villain, natch); Cobb's wife Mal - again also a villain, again played by Cotillard - jumps off a building because she's nuts; hell, in Memento there are two dead wives - Guy Pearce's is raped and murdered and the possibly made-up Sammy Jenkis' is given an insulin overdose by her own husband. As if that weren't bad enough, most of the other women in Nolan's movies are villains, from Memento's conniving Natalie and the entirety of Marion Cotillard's history with the director to even Hilary Swank's character in Insomnia, whose only crime is being a good cop trying to do her job while the lead played by Al Pacino goes stark raving mad in Alaska. That's quite a list. Here's hoping Interstellar doesn't add to it... Did we miss any directors who use the same tropes in every movie? Share your own picks below.

Contributor

Film history obsessive, New Hollywood fetishist and comics evangelist.