15 Great Actors Who Have Never Won An Oscar

So much greatness, not enough praise.

Actor Ralph Fiennes poses for photographers upon arrival for the 20th Empire Film Awards at a hotel in central London, Sunday, 29 March, 2015. (Photo by Joel Ryan/Invision/AP)
Joel Ryan/AP

The Academy Awards are a tricky institution, marred over the years by mounting controversies, bizarre gaffs and ceremony switch-ups. All that aside though, to win an Oscar is still seen as one of the highest honours an actor or filmmaker can achieve in their careers.

Some of the Academy's favourite stars include Meryl Streep (with a monumental 21 nominations), Jack Nicholson, Daniel Day-Lewis, Denzel Washington, Jessica Lange and Katherine Hepburn.

All of these Oscar winners are more than deserving of praise, but instead of celebrating the victors, this article will take a look at the great actors who've somehow gone unrewarded over the years, despite the fact they should really have a statue or two on their desk by now.

From innovative outsiders to veteran favourites who seem doomed to Oscar jail forever, these stars have turned out numerous brilliant performances, appearing in countless enduring classics and fan favourites.

For some, the Oscars are a warped and unnecessary Hollywood phenomena, but whatever your thoughts on the matter, it sure sucks that these stars haven't been properly paid their dues for so much hard work.

15. Helena Bonham Carter

Helena Bonham Carter The King's Speech
Momentum Pictures

Helena Bonham Carter is one of Britain's most esteemed and successful character actors, having carved a career out of her uncanny ability to play eccentric but fully realised characters in a wide variety of movies.

Best known for her twisted portrayal of Bellatrix Lestrange in the Harry Potter franchise, as well as her work with former partner Tim Burton, Carter has had a hand in everything from wildly popular blockbusters to cult thrillers, and zany comedies to historical biopics.

Aside from Bellatrix, her best roles can be found in Fight Club, with her darkly humorous and iconic turn as the disturbed Marla Singer. Also, The King's Speech, where she portrayed the Queen Mother and secured her second Oscar nomination, and The Wings of the Dove, where she nabbed her first nod over ten years earlier.

Despite her enduring popularity and exceptional range, victory at the Academy has long eluded Carter. Given the right project, she's sure to sweep up at awards season - but she's yet to find the role that blows the Academy away.


14. Taraji P. Henson

Hidden Figures 2017 Taraji P Henson
20th Century Fox

Taraji P. Henson has one Oscar nomination under her belt, and for some unfathomable reason it's not for her work in Hidden Figures, but her supporting turn in the overwrought drama The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.

Though it would be fair to say that Henson's best work has stemmed from her extensive career as a TV actress - Empire, Boston Legal and Person of Interest being her most acclaimed work to date - Henson has over the years shown herself a major awards contender with her work in the movies.

As noted, she gave a searing portrayal of NASA mathematician Katherine Johnson in Hidden Figures, offering up some of the films most powerful scenes in the process. She's nothing short of a revelation in the criminally under-seen drama The Best of Enemies, which charts the relationship of civil rights activist Ann Atwater and prominent KKK leader C. P. Ellis (Sam Rockwell).

A powerful and commanding performer, Henson has really hit her stride of late, and is sure to secure some Academy love in the near future. Fingers crossed.


13. Ralph Fiennes

Grand Budapest Hotel
Fox Searchlight

Ralph Fiennes lost his first Oscar nomination, for the epic Spielberg classic Schindler's List, to Tommy Lee Jones' role in The Fugitive. He then lost his second nomination, this time for the English Patient, to Geoffrey Rush's performance in Shine.

In other words, Fiennes is seriously unlucky, since he should have two statues under this belt (at least), and yet he's been denied at every turn.

Worse still, he wasn't even recognised for his work in Grand Budapest Hotel, The Constant Gardener or The End of the Affair.

Fiennes is one of England's most recognisable actors, and has proven more than once that he has no problem moving between productions of Shakespeare's tragedies to massive Hollywood blockbusters like Harry Potter and the James Bond franchise.

With an uncanny ability to play things hilariously straight (In Bruges), brutally tragic (The English Patient) and action-heavy (The Hurt Locker), Fiennes is a star capable of pulling off everything he sets his mind to. Despite the number of Oscar-winning productions under his belt, the Academy has yet to recognise his work personally. Shocking.


12. Glenn Close

Glenn Close The Wife
Sony Pictures Classics

It wouldn't be an article about Oscar shockers without mentioning Glenn Close, who's been nominated a heartbreaking eight times without a win.

A powerful, scene-stealing presence in every one of her movies, Close has made her career playing women who are as strong as they vulnerable, with performances that range from horribly tragic to uncompromisingly hard-edged.

Between 1983 and 2021, she's received nominations for such all-timers as The World According to Garp, Fatal Attraction and Dangerous Liaisons, and seemed poised to win her overdue statue for her career-best turn in 2019's The Wife. Instead, Close lost out to Olivia Colman's admittedly stellar (but not quite better) work in The Favourite.

One of modern cinema's most beloved icons, Glenn Close will inevitably stretch her nomination total in the coming years. Hopefully the Academy gives her an award in the process, as it's about time.


11. Will Smith

Pursuit of Happyness
Sony Pictures

Will Smith has certainly tried to win an Oscar over his career. He put in a hell of a lot of work and passion to portray Muhammad Ali in Michael Mann's mostly affecting Ali biopic, and he gave a tear-inducing portrayal of parental grief and suffering in The Pursuit of Happyness.

Alas, both were to no avail, as was his obviously Oscar-baiting turn in Seven Pounds just a couple of years later.

Smith is one of those actors who makes every film he stars in that little bit more enjoyable (except maybe After Earth and Gemini Man; they couldn't be saved by anyone), offering performances that always transcend the movies themselves.

Better still, there's his staggering ability to shift between genre, balancing his career with searing dramas, over-the-top comedies and thoughtful biopics.

Next set to portray the father of Venus and Serena Williams in the sports drama King Richard, it could be that Smith ends his Academy drought soon. Given his luck (and a strained relationship with the Academy), that also might be wishful thinking.


10. Michelle Williams

Blue Valentine
The Weinstein Company

Michelle Williams remains one of the most empathetic and endearing portrayers of the human condition in all of Hollywood. Her characters are not particularly glamorous or flashy, but they're each devastatingly human and true.

She currently has four Oscar nominations under her belt, including for her work in the romantic drama Brokeback Mountain and her portrayal of Marilyn Monroe in the brilliant My Week with Marilyn.

Her best performances to date can be found in Blue Valentine, another Oscar contender which charted the begins and the end of an ill-fated marriage, and Manchester by the Sea, where her grief is palpable throughout every scene.

At this rate, Williams seems doomed to the multiple-nominations-without-a-win club, but if she keeps up her remarkable work and keeps choosing such challenging projects, the Academy will have no choice but to recognise her talent in the near future.


9. Mark Ruffalo

Infinitely Polar Bear Mark Ruffalo
Sony

Mark Ruffalo is a Hollywood heavyweight through-and-through. Not only is he one of the stars of the MCU, playing Bruce Banner/The Hulk with just the right amount of restraint and humour, but he's also balanced his role as a franchise mainstay with a series of challenging indie and Oscar-winning dramas.

The Normal Heart remains perhaps his best performance to date, and his role in the Best Picture-winning drama Spotlight easily stole the entire film.

But you only need to look at the sheer volume of phenomenal performances he's had over the years to realise how destined he is for future Oscar glory:

The Kids Are All Right, Infinitely Polar Bear, Begin Again, Zodiac, Foxcatcher, Shutter Island and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind all offer the image of an actor at the height of his powers, willing to challenge and push himself.

He has three nominations as of this writing, and with his enduring popularity working in his favour, I think it's safe to say he's not backing down until he nabs a well-deserved victory at the Academy.


8. Naomi Watts

The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo Rooney Mara
Sony

Though her career got off to something of a slow start - with only small TV appearances and indie movie flops to keep her company - Naomi Watts was shot to superstardom thanks to her enrapturing lead performance in the David Lynch mind-melter Mulholland Drive.

Since then, Watts has proved time and time again that she's one of the most challenging and powerful actors in Hollywood, having brilliant performances in the horror film The Ring, disaster drama The Impossible, and troubling crime flick 21 Grams - the latter of the two securing her an Oscar nod.

At her best when portraying women in deeply uncertain situations and forced to face things they'd never had dreamed possible, Watts plays scared and unsure like a champ, but always carries herself with an inner-strength and resilience that's rarely seen from other stars of her generation.

Sure to keep surprising audiences for years to come, Watts is in desperate need for some Academy recognition, so long as she keeps pushing herself.


7. Woody Harrelson

Woody Harrelson No Country For Old Men
Paramount Vantage

A three-time Oscar nominee, Woody Harrelson got his start on the seminal sitcom Cheers, and has since become one of Hollywood's most recognisable movie stars.

Known for his intimidating presence as well as his ability to play strangely endearing men under insurmountable pressure, Harrelson's appeared in everything from epic war dramas (The Thin Red Line) to unconventional biopics (The People vs Larry Flynt), and classic comedies (Zombieland) to dark neo-Westerns (No Country for Old Men).

His best performances can be found in the aforementioned Larry Flynt drama, and the excellent Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, for which he secured his most recent nomination.

Constantly taking risks and appearing in everything from big blockbusters like The Hunger Games and Star Wars, to small dramas like Rampart and Out of the Furnace, Harrelson can be lovable, terrifying and everything in-between, often in the same scene.

Oscar glory has so far eluded him, but there's sure to be some victory in his future if he lands the right role.


6. Amy Adams

Arrival Amy Adams
Paramount Pictures

Like Glenn Close, Amy Adams is an actress seemingly stuck in a rut, unable to win an Oscar despite the Academy nominating her at every turn.

Adams has given truly phenomenal performances in the likes of Arrival, The Fighter, American Hustle and Junebug, as well as a series of films she wasn't even nominated for, including Julie and Julia (opposite a nominated Meryl Streep), Her and Nocturnal Animals.

A self-described "obsessive" when it comes to her acting style, Adams has been known to work for hours to understand the ins-and-outs of her characters, and usually stays in character on set in order to better embody the person she's portraying.

Of course, this has all paid off wonderfully. If Adams is in a film, chances are she's going to be one of the best things in it.

Currently holding six Oscar nominations without a win, Adams is chasing Close to her unfortunate record, but given her consistent high calibre output and how often she works with Oscar-favourite directors (David O. Russell, Denis Villeneuve) there's sure to be a win in her future.


5. Annette Bening

Annette Bening American beauty
DreamWorks Pictures

The fact that Annette Bening has never won an Oscar is a strange one, especially when you consider her longevity and the sheer volume of brilliant roles she's produced over the years.

Bening has lead the likes of American Beauty, Being Julia, The American President, The Kids Are All Right and many rom-com, sci-fi flick and indie dramas in-between, offering up commanding and fully realised portrayals of a wide range of characters.

With an ability to play funny (Mars Attacks! is just a blast of a Bening performance), conflicted (American Beauty) and absolutely heartbreaking (The Kids Are All Right), Bening has been shining on screen for decades now. She has four Oscar nods to her name, a couple Golden Globe wins, and countless movies where she should really have swept up at award season.

Thanks to an appearance in the MCU's Captain Marvel, it could be that we're looking at a new era of her career, complete with more risks and increased popularity, and hopefully some long overdue industry accolades.


4. Ethan Hawke

First Reformed Ethan Hawke
A24

Simply put, Ethan Hawke is hard to pin down. He never does the same film twice, refuses to pander too much to mainstream cinema, and tends to constantly switch things up with every role he takes on.

He's done comedy, romance, horror, drama, biopics, coming-of-age experiments and sci-fi genre-benders; he's played troubled family men, bewildered police officers, hopeless romantics, and disillusioned drifters. And, of course, he's nailed every one.

Hawke's best work can be found in his collaborations with Richard Linklater, which includes the spotless Before Trilogy and the experimental drama Boyhood, but he's also pulled no punches in crime thrillers like Training Day and troubling dramas like First Reformed.

Actor, director, writer and producer, Hawke shines no matter what role he's playing behind or in front of the camera, and given his extensive career and impressive variety, it's a wonder why he's been so unlucky at the Academy over the years.


3. Rooney Mara

The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo Rooney Mara
Sony

Initially getting her career started in a series of bad-to-atrocious horror flicks like the clunky 2010 Nightmare of Elm Street remake, Rooney Mara received wide acclaim for her supporting turn in David Fincher's searing drama, The Social Network.

The following year, she teamed up with Fincher again for the incredibly dark Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, which saw Mara slip effortlessly into the most complex and challenging role of her career as vigilante Lisbeth Salander.

An actress with the ability to shift between terrifyingly intense and tragically sensitive, Mara followed up on her major break-out with roles in the thriller Side Effects, the biopic Lion, the beautiful romantic drama Carol - which earned her a second Oscar nod - and the massively under-appreciated Mary Magdalene.

Constantly challenging herself and willing to push the boundaries of what she can achieve, you can be sure she'll scope an Oscar or two later in her career, if the Academy has any sense.


2. Willem Dafoe

At Eternity S Gate Willem Dafoe
CBS Films

Okay, Ethan Hawke - as noted - has had an incredibly varied career over the years, but even he doesn't hold a candle to the sheer insanity that is Willem Dafoe's work ethic.

Dafoe is known for starring in damn near everything he's offered, regardless of genre, story or character. He's as comfortable in a Lars von Trier horror as he is in a major blockbuster action flick like Spider-Man. He's starred in war classics (Platoon), biopics (At Eternity's Gate), zany action-comedies (The Boondock Saints) and slice-of-life dramas (The Florida Project).

One of Hollywood's most prolific and hardworking actors, Dafoe has had massively successful partnerships with directors like Wes Anderson and Paul Schrader, and his best roles - as Max Schreck in Shadow of the Vampire and van Gogh in At Eternity's Gate - really should have won him an Oscar at their respective ceremonies.

With five films coming out this year alone, Dafoe is sure to add more Oscar nods to his tally in the coming years, and win the Oscar that has somehow long eluded him.


1. Andy Serkis

Andy Serkis Jungle Book
Warner Bros.

The craziest thing about Andy Serkis is that he's never even been nominated for an Oscar during his career, which is ridiculous when you consider how much he's done for cinema - and how well he's done it.

Fondly remembered for his remarkable performances as Gollum in the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the great ape Caesar in the Planet of the Apes franchise, Serkis is best known for his work using motion capture technology to play completely computer-generated characters in madly popular movie franchises.

Ushering in a whole new acting technique to cinema, Serkis - and the supremely talented animators in his corner - has created some of the most enduring characters in recent memory, but he's been snubbed by the Academy at every turn.

Outside of his motion capture work, Serkis has also shone in brilliant live-action roles, such as in Sex & Drugs & Rock & Roll and Black Panther.

Due to the complexities of his motion capture work, it's likely he'll be stuck in Oscar jail for a long time to come, but even then Serkis going so long without so much as a nomination remains one of the Academy's biggest mistakes.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/