15 Worst Comic Book Movie Sequels Ever

Sometimes, second and third time's really not the charm.

Doomsday Batman V Superman
Warner Bros.

To a certain extent hitting on to a winner first time out isn't always the most impressive thing, the real art is in doing it again. The specific indicators of success in a sequel, after all, are more complex than an original: you not only have to make a fundamentally great film, but you also have to outdo everything the original did.

There's an unwritten rule that the threat has to be bigger, the spectacle more spectacular and the defining characteristics of the characters more pronounced. It's like the ideal is offering an undiluted, beefed up remake, with enough new material to make it all feel fresh. In short, it shouldn't be all that hard once you've done it well once.

Sadly, Hollywood - and comic book movie makers in particular - tend to get these things wrong a worrying amount. There are more disappointing superhero sequels than there really ought to be in the single defining genre of the last decade or so, and it's a wonder so many franchises even survived.

But which are the very worst? Which do the studios probably wish they never bothered spunking their money on?


15. The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Amazing Spider Man 2
Columbia Pictures

Given how exceptional Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 2 was, Sony will have been hoping for a similar uplift in quality with Marc Webb's reboot sequel. Unfortunately, they skipped ahead a film and it ended up being more like Spider-Man 3: over-stuffed, split by too many villains and a fumbled mishandling of a great concept.

There are some things to enjoy in it - Jamie Foxx's Electro for instance - but it tries way too much and Webb fails quite badly to balance it all. There's way too much focus on setting up sequels and spin-offs and when earnest focus on the Gwen Stacy story is required it feels a little like a secondary concern.

Time might remember it a little more fondly, but with Marvel releasing their MCU Spider-Man movie might make it even worse by proximity.


14. X-Men: The Last Stand

XMen The Last Stand
Fox

If X-Men: Origins Wolverine were a straight sequel, rather than a prequel, it would absolutely be on this list in place of The Last Stand, as it is far and away the worst film in the entire franchise. Sure, The Last Stand is deeply flawed, but it's a picnic compared to that particular dumpster fire.

The film has lots of great ideas that aren't quite delivered upon, some great sequences and some truly great performances. Sir Ian McKellen is on great form for instance, and the addition of Kelsey Grammar as Beast is genius.

The problem is in the story delivery and the direction - and also the dead-eyed spirit of Famke Janssen's Dark Phoenix (it's just never explosive enough). And it creates a rod for its own back, including Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut (bitch), the terrible de-ageing and also the focus on inferior new mutants, and those tend to be way too memorable.


13. Blade: Trinity

Blade Trinity Wesley Snipes.jpg
New Line Cinema

Guillermo Del Toro was always going to be the best creative partner for Blade movies, which is precisely why his Blade II is the best in the series (at least so far). Unfortunately for David S Goyer - the man charged with following him in the franchise - he also left big shoes to fill.

If this film proves one thing more than any other, it's that Goyer - known for being an instrumental part of Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy - has a "patchy" record at best. And he should probably stick to writing.

In his hands, what really should have been another R-rated, attitude-filled ballet of violence became a commercially minded, boring affair starring Triple H and criminally wasting Ryan Reynolds. No wonder Wesley Snipes is so obviously asleep for most of it.


12. Spider-Man 3

Spider-Man 3 Venom
Sony Pictures

Spider-Man 3 is yet another piece of compelling evidence in the case against studio interference in film-making. Instead of Sam Raimi's intended follow-up to the excellent Spider-Man 2, Sony decided they needed to give fans Venom, but then also had him joined by Sand-Man AND a new Green Goblin just to make sure Raimi couldn't possibly hope to balance it all.

The result is a crowded mess with hyperactivity issues that delivers on precisely none of its individual parts or the whole. And as a final insult to the studio's crowd-pleasing manifesto, Venom is reduced to being an emo nightmare, making Peter Parker dance his cringe-worthy way around New York and develop a new fringe. That's not adding complexity and darkness, that's a f*cking teenage cry for attention.

Rather understandably, it never feels like Raimi is entirely on board, and given the level of studio interference (and the hints of what he wanted the film to be) it's not all that hard to see why.


11. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III: Turtles In Time

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3
New Line Cinema

Often over-looked as actual comic book movies (it is, whether you care to admit it or not), the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movies are almost uniformly terrible. There is some nostalgia to be had in remembering the sight of Vanilla Ice rapping out of nowhere or Elias Koteas as Casey Jones, but remembering them generally as anything but fluffy garbage is insanity.

That said, there is a special place in movie hell reserved for the third film in the franchise - the deplorably titled Turtles In Time - which followed up series highlight The Secret Of The Ooze and threw all logic out of the window. It's the archetypal silly escalation sequel, dropping in a time travel plot because why the f*ck not.

It all starts badly when April O'Neal accidentally buys a sacred ancient sabre from a flea market and accidentally teleports herself to feudal Japan and ends with Splinter doing an impression of Elvis with a lampshade on his head. These are the least ridiculous parts, somehow.


10. The Return Of The Swamp Thing

The Return Of The Swamp Thing
Lightyear Entertainment

Unfortunately for abused anti-hero Alec Holland - but fortunately for your sanity - everyone seems to forget about his two movies when they're doing run-downs of comic book movie history. Looking back on this low-budget, Heather Locklear-starring sequel, it's hard not to think that that much is probably for the best.

1989's Return Of The Swamp Thing stripped away all of what made the comic so popular: the pulpy darkness was sucked out and replaced by daft comedy that ultimately earned Locklear a Razzie for Worst Actress. The script is similarly terrible, studded with painful gags that wouldn't look out of place in a Superhero Movie parody.

There is some attempt at least to go for a self-conscious B-movie vibe, but it's never intelligent enough or complex enough to really deliver on that and it's probably best left forgotten.


9. Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance

Ghost Rider Spirit Of Vengeance
Columbia Pictures

When Nic Cage and Columbia announced their plans to revive the Ghost Rider series just five years after the first movie proved to be a hilarious dud, eyebrows were raised. But the idea to hand the reins to Crank's directors Neveldine and Taylor actually looked to inject some confidence in the project.

Surely they'd be able to channel the comic, bat-sh*t spirit of their Jason Statham-starring actioners and make Ghost Rider as fun as it was silly?

Nope.

The pair singularly failed to improve on the first Ghost Rider (though the CGI is great), hampered by a terrible script, undeveloped characters and Nic Cage going fully off-the-scale crazy. It still made some money, but it should really be remembered as the film that ultimately led to Marvel reclaiming the rights to Ghost Rider (as well as the one that basically ensured we won't get him in a movie for a LONG time).


8. Iron Man 2

Iron Man 2 Whiplash
Marvel Studios

Iron Man caught lightning in a bottle when it launched the MCU, thanks to a combination of strong story-telling, excellent casting and the charisma of Robert Downey Jr. Inevitably, the follow-up was even more hyped - particularly as it was set to add Mickey Rourke (when he wasn't a joke) and the always excellent Sam Rockwell as new villains.

Unfortunately, all of the film's good ideas - like Tony's dark spiral into alcoholism and depression and the idea of the villains - were lost in uncharacteristically sloppy fashion as Jon Favreau made easily his worst film. On reflection, it feels like the work of a disaffected director answering to his pay-masters (and watching Chef now feels like an allegory for making this film), but whatever the case, it remains one of the biggest low-points in the MCU.

And when the rest of it is so good (aside from a couple of exceptions), that lack of quality really shows.


7. Kick-Ass 2

Colonel Stars And Stripes Kick Ass 2
Paramount

After Mark Millar and Matthew Vaughn's excellent, off-kilter adaptation of the Kick-Ass comic and managed to make enough money to warrant a sequel, the hype for the follow-up jumped up several notches. It would surely be even more outrageous, even more R-rated and even more anti-mainstream, and there was the added kicker of Jim Carrey playing a larger than life pantomime character (as ever).

Unfortunately, the film as a whole is a mess, fudging pretty much everything that made the original good. Vaughn left as director and along with him went his subtlety that was the fine line Kick-Ass had tethered itself to moral decency with. While the first film was a smart commentary on superhero movie conventions, the sequel was juvenile, wrong-headed, violent nonsense without an idea of morality at all. It's vulgar and distasteful in all the wrong ways.

On reflection, Jim Carrey's decision to widely denounce the movie's violence before it even came out looks more like he realised he was involved in a turkey (though actually, he's very good in it).


6. Superman III

Superman III
Warner Bros.

As long as there are comic book movies - hell, as long as there are blockbusters - there will be comic relief characters, and that's fine when they're well written. Unfortunately, that's a rare thing, and way too often they're given way too much focus, ruining the balance of films and distracting from the main event. That is very much the case of Superman III, whose ludicrous plot feels like it has missed its calling as a Direct-To-DVD sequel.

Superman III wasn't entirely a disaster for Warner Bros (hence it inspiring a sequel), but comparing it to either version of Superman II is like comparing steak to giblets. It's unfavourable no matter how you dress it up, and most of that comes down to Richard Lester (the man who profited when Richard Donner was kicked off Superman II), who wasn't fit to serve the franchise.

In place of Lex Luthor, Lester brought in his three daft villains, failing to make any of them as interesting as when Superman goes grumpy and fights himself. And even that small flash of genius is botched.


5. Thor: The Dark World

Thor The Dark World
Marvel Studios

On paper, hiring Game Of Thrones' veteran Alan Taylor to replace the brilliant Kenneth Branagh for Thor: The Dark World should have meant that the sequel was a great follow-up to Branagh's high-concept, theatrical original. Unfortunately, the glum, bland sequel is a distant leader in the race for the worst MCU movie stakes.

The good things are predictable: Loki is great and having him reimagined as a sort of MCU Hannibal Lecter is delightful, and the war scenes are good... But that's about it. The decision to put way too much focus on the worst MCU side character to date (Darcy) should have seen Taylor sacked on the spot, but that sort of scape-goating just misses the point that the whole film is a mess.

It messes up good villains, turning them into Doctor Who monster of the weeks and the switch in tone to po-faced misery is not welcome at all. Particularly when they then attempted levity by turning Stellan Skarsgard's unfortunate Dr Selvig into a mental health parody.


4. Batman v Superman

Batman V Superman
Warner Bros.

Like even the worst comic book movies, Batman v Superman occasionally does flirt with greatness, and it does have its moments (particularly in the Ultimate Cut), but it's ultimately a disappointing follow-up to Man Of Steel.

Even with multiple seminal comic books to draw from and the addition of an excellent new Batman in Ben Affleck, the film has a major problem with restraint and tone - all of which can be pinned down to Zack Snyder. His interest in making an unconventional superhero movie and turning crowd-pleasing into a dirty concept comes at an almighty cost to the film's entertainment factor.

Sure, there is a commitment to spectacle, but having it so dark is just dumb - a bullish agenda to serve aesthetic and style over the audience's experience. Plus, Snyder should have been removed from the DCEU entirely for what he did to Lex Luthor and Doomsday.


3. Superman IV

Superman Iv The Quest For Peace Christopher Reeve
Warner Bros. Pictures

Here's all the indication of how good Superman IV is: it is classed not just as one of the worst sequels ever, or the worst comic book movies ever, but as one of the worst movies ever made. That puts it at the bottom of a pile of millions of films, tens of Nic Cage and Adam Sandler films and everything Uwe Boll has ever done. Well, maybe not that last one.

There is something to be said for the return of Gene Hackman as Lex Luthor, but unfortunately he's saddled with his version of Scrappy Doo (his nephew Lennie) and a ridiculous evil scheme that ends up unwittingly birthing Nuclear Man. Sure, there's camp value, but when you spend every second Nukes is on screen wondering how the hell he can be a clone of Superman and yet look precisely nothing like him, something is wrong.

It also doesn't help that the film tries for intellect, in its anti-Nuke embedded PSA and just comes off cloying and ill-conceived.


2. Batman & Robin

Arctic Suits Batman Robin
Warner Bros.

It's almost too easy to bash Joel Schumacher for what he did to the Batman movie franchise - particularly as he seems to acknowledge what he did wrong in hindsight, but he's a target for a reason. Given the rather unenviable task of reinventing the movies with a more family friendly tone (with the agenda to sell more toys), he went way too silly and turned absolutely every character in Batman & Robin into jokes.

He hadn't even done that poorly with Batman Forever (which gets way more hate than it deserves), but the follow-up reads like a case against good taste. He turned the super-costumes into fetish pieces, transformed Dr Freeze into a walking catch-phrase and turned Batman into a Punch & Judy side-show.

After audiences (both TV and comics) had rejected camp twice in the 60s, Schumacher attempted a mini-resurgence, and on reflection, his sequel still feels like a spoof. And not a particularly good one, either.


1. Fantastic Four: Rise of The Silver Surfer

Fantastic Four Rise Of The Silver Surfer
20th Century Fox

Fantastic Four movies have never been good. Even the first big budget one was pretty mediocre, but it made enough money to turn Fox's head towards a quick-fire sequel.

Buoyed by that success, the studio decided to go bigger and bolder - and you don't get much bigger than iconic Marvel villain Galactus. When the story was first announced, fans would have reacted with joy at the idea of seeing the seminal purple and pink clad giant threatening to chow down on Earth...

Only, Fox decided that would be too much, so instead they turned him into a great big nasty cloud.

Even more problematically, they also hired Tim Story, who failed to put any stamp on the material, which was also terrible, or get a single good performance out of his talented cast, who sleepwalk for the most part. It's just not fun at all, and it fails to live up to almost everything you'd want from a Fantastic Four movie.

Also nobody working on the sequel got the memo that there are absolutely no circumstances in which having superheroes dance is a good idea. See also, Spider-Man 3.

Which comic book movie sequels do you think are the worst? Share your suggestions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.