20 Best Comedy Film Sequels Of All-Time

Can the same joke prove just as funny the second time around?

Waynes World 21 Comedy sequels, generally speaking, tend to suck. The same joke told twice is rarely as funny as the first time, after all - which is why comedic follow-ups tend to fall by the wayside, desperate to tap into those original hi-jinks, but unable to find new and creative ways of doing so. The best comedy sequels, of course, are those that manage to transfer what worked about the first film into a second whilst maintaining a sense of freshness that stops it from feeling like just a "lazy rehash" (cough: The Hangover: Part II - awful). Truth is, there are very few comedy sequels that are actually better than the movies they were inspired by. That's not to say there aren't a few exceptions to that rule, but for the most part it's one that sticks. It's also not to say that there aren't any worthwhile comedy sequels at all; there are, in fact, a good number of funny follow-ups that managed to both live up to the hype and offer fans the chance to relive the magic of those first flicks. Here, then, are the 20 greatest comedy sequels of all-time; every one of which managed to make franchises out of great comedy movies without tarnishing all of the good will brought on by the first installments in their respective series. Most importantly, they're all hilarious. Please Note: In order for a movie to make the list, its primary genre has to be that of "comedy." Back to the Future: Part II wouldn't count, for example, as it's mainly a sci-fi adventure flick. Lethal Weapon 2, though hilarious throughout, is still an action movie. Also: this list is confined to live-action flicks only (for fear that Pixar sequels would saturate it).

20. This Is 40

Described as a "sort-of sequel" to Knocked Up, given that it features two of that movie's secondary characters as its leads, This Is 40 was met with mixed reception upon first realise. But one can't help but think that said reviews were a little on the harsh side, especially given that - for the most part - Judd Apatow's semi-sequel proved entertaining. No, it doesn't come close to the genius of the film it was spun from, but who honestly expected it to? The film's plot hones in on "set in their ways" couple Paul and Debbie, both played brilliantly by the likes of Paul Rudd and Leslie Mann (Apatow's real life wife, don't you know?). There's no a driving narrative, as such; the movie is more meandering in nature, as it explores the trials and tribulations of life at 40 - family, friends, sex, the whole package. Yes, for an Apatow movie, This Is 40 is a little underwhelming throughout; still, as far as comedy sequels go, this is - at least - a successful attempt to do something different. And though there are clear moments of indulgence (Apatow's actual kids play Paul and Debbie's kids, for example), there's enough funny to warrant a viewing. Also: Megan Fox.

19. Ghostbusters II

From the off, it's plain to see that there's something wrong with Ghostbusters II. The energy and the passion that were clearly there in abundance across the span of the first movie seem entirely absent, almost as if - compelled by contract - the entire cast and crew were summoned back to the set just a few hours after they'd finished shooting the original picture and were forced to start work on a sequel without taking any time out to relax. Which isn't really the tone you want to set for what is supposed to be a "rollicking comedy sequel," is it? So whilst Ghostbusters II was met with mostly critical distain upon its first release, in which both critics and movie-goers alike branded it "toxic," is it now safe to say that time has been a little kinder to this sequel? It would be untrue to say that Ghostbusters II (which sees pretty much everyone from the original back again doing exactly the same thing as they did before) is anything but a rehash, because it so very clearly is: the approach here, obviously, was to reproduce the same movie all over. But there are a lot of neat gags here, most of them courtesy of Bill Murray, with the samey plot serving as a canvas for the improv to thrive. It's no classic, and it doesn't have a patch on the original, but as a funny, curious oddity, Ghostbusters II is worthwhile.

18. Beverly Hills Cop II

Beverly Hills Cop II was met with mixed to negative reviews upon first release, with many critics taking aim at the movie's willingness to be... well, exactly the same movie as the original, really. Whilst this particular approach to sequel creation proved more successful than it did on say, Ghostbusters II, Beverly Hills Cop II still feels like well-worn material. But considering that these movies are all about Eddie Murphy's performances and nothing else, who cares? That's to say, Beverly Hills Cop II succeeds on the back of Murphy's cop character Axel Foley, a funky soundtrack, and a breezy, entertaining tone that sticks throughout. And whilst elements of Beverly Hills Cop II are ripped straight out of the first flick - his teaming with the likes of Billy Rosewood and John Aston, for example - it's still an entertaining comedy romp that will leave you feeling (for the most part) satisfied.

17. Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me

Ridiculous in every capacity, Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me - the 1999 sequel to Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery - is the sort of follow-up that works perfectly if you like Austin Powers. If the first movie wasn't your cup of tea, though, the second is likely to go down even worse. But who, really, can deny the absurd charms of what is arguably Mike Myers' most appealing comic creation? The Spy Who Shagged Me, whose provocative title seemed near-on unbelievable to UK teens back in '99, follows on from its predecessor as a bizzaro world Bond spoof, this time tackling the likes of Diamonds Are Forever, You Only Live Twice, Moonraker and The Man With the Golden Gun. It is an entirely juvenile experience, wherein most of the laughs are just rehashed versions of jokes sprung from the original - somehow, it's still funny. Indeed, there are presumably lots of Austin Powers aficionados (is there such a thing?) who would be quick to cite this flick as "better than the the first." Indeed, Heather Graham makes for an effortlessly cool and sexy sidekick to Myers' own Austin Powers, and the jokes - fairly hit and miss at times - are admirably relentless. All in all, it's hard to imagine how Myers could have contrived a better sequel given the property he had to work with.

16. National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation

After the relative calamity that was National Lampoon's European Vacation, a sequel that served only to tarnish the likes of the original flick through uninspired "comic" sequences and questionable characterisation, Christmas Vacation was something of a return to form for the franchise. No, it's not a classic in the same sense as the first iconic movie, but it is a worthwhile comic feat in its own right. Generally speaking, the years have been kind to Christmas Vacation, given its standing now as something of a cult flick. Indeed, there are many who would argue that this is actually the funniest Vacation movie of all. Mostly, it's a series of sight gags and slapstick hi-jinks, but there are enough to keep you interested for the entire length of the flick. From a script written by the legend who is John Hughes, and with Chevy Chase firmly on form from the very first scene to the very last, Christmas Vacation more than justifies its existence; it also brought some credibility back to the National Lampoon name.

15. Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey

Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey has a title that makes it sound like a NES spin-off game or something - but to have avoided this little-seen sequel on account of its terrible name is to have also avoided a sequel that is probably a lot better than you'd expect it to be. That's to say, Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey isn't at all the unnecessary sequel that it appears to be, but a lively, charismatic and surprisingly intelligent follow-up. Seriously: intelligent. There's a reference to an Ingmar Bergman film and everything! Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter reprise their roles as the clueless heroes of the first movie, of course, and the results are downright watchable. What should have felt pointless and arbitrary instead feels rendered entirely with love - odd, considering that director Pete Hewitt had nothing to do with the first installment. The plot is ridiculous, but there are tons of great jokes; all said and done, it might even be funnier than the first.

14. Clerks II

Kevin Smith's cult classic, Clerks, probably didn't need a sequel. On Smith's part, a belated follow-up - 12 years after the original - felt a little bit like an attempt to rebuild some integrity after the critical and commercial failure of Jersey Girl. And yet the writer/director managed to avoid rendering something akin to a disaster with Clerks II, which - though not perfect - at least felt like it belonged. Not to mention the fact that, hey, it's pretty funny! The plot, as expected, picks up 10 years after the events of the first flick, with hapless duo Hicks and Graves now working at a fast food joint. Whilst much of the humour on show is juvenile and occasionally dumb, Clerks II is also filled with some keen observations about growing up, life after thirty, sex and relationships. To say that it is "smarter" than Clerks would probably be going a little too far, but you could certainly argue the case. If you hated Clerks, there's not much in Clerks II that will convince you of this franchise's merits. Much of the joy here relies on the nostalgia brought on by the first flick, after all. But where Kevin Smith could have been lazy, he - at least - attempts to pull together a sequel that has something real to say about these characters, even if said observations are clouded through layers of vulgarity that appear to have been implemented for vulgarity's sake.

13. Rush Hour 2

Whilst the belated and mostly dreadful Rush Hour 3 was racist to a point unseen in previous entries in the series, both Rush Hour and its sequel, Rush Hour 2, are certified proof that director Brett Ratner was put on this Earth for a good reason: to make two good comedy movies starring Jackie Chan and Chris Rock and disappearing before he got his filthy mitts around the likes of X-Men: The Last Stand (ouch - too late for that one, then). So Rush Hour 2 is - in fairness - a slight and somewhat unimaginative sequel. The plot picks up directly after the events of the first movie, with bickering buddy cops Lee (Chan) and Carter (Rock) on vacation in Hong Kong. Then, almost immediately, the pair find themselves caught up in a conspiracy that goes back to the death of Lee's father. What renders this sequel as worthwhile, however, is the chemistry: Chan and Rock are an absolute hoot to watch as they move relentlessly between explosive set-pieces and hilarious dialogue segments, and their interactions have an improvised feel that marks the movie as ripe for re-watching. It's all over in a brisk 90 minutes, and though it suffers slightly from some rehashing, Rush Hour 2 is - ultimately - a hilarious, compulsive action riot.

12. American Pie 2

Given the success of the original American Pie movie, a follow-up seemed inevitable. The premise of the first movie honed in on four teenagers and their crazy quest to each lose their virginity before prom night. How does a sequel get by without that plot to cling to? On the backs of its characters, of course - which is where American Pie 2 thrives. After all, the gang inherent to these flicks are super likeable, so why not make use of that? So American Pie 2 swaps out its goal-orientated plot and opts, instead, to be something of a vacation hangout movie. This opens up the sequel as a canvas for more nudity-inspired antics, crude Stifler moments, and a bunch of sentimental scenes where the guys discuss the fact that they're growing older and moving on - without any major narrative hook. The lack of narrative hook proves to be both the movie's best asset and its biggest weakness; though it's great just hanging with Jim, Finch, Oz and Kevin at the beach, the lack of "purpose" occasionally allows American 2 to feel meandering. But as a comedy sequel, you can't really argue against it; there are enough laughs, memorable moments, hot girls in bikinis, in-jokes and nostalgic soundtrack cues to keep fans of the original classic happy.

Contributor

Sam Hill is an ardent cinephile and has been writing about film professionally since 2008. He harbours a particular fondness for western and sci-fi movies.