20 Best Performances In Horror Movies

The best horror movie performances - Jack Nicholson, Toni Collette & more!

Midsommar Ending Dani Smile
A24

Horror, as a genre, is an actor's paradise, even if the award season is rarely in a rush to hand out trophies to horror movies or their stars.

These are films designed to unsettle and scare, where actors are, in the best of them, committed wholeheartedly to telling a great story and crafting a memorable character.

Think Dracula, Norman Bates, Frankenstein, Carrie White - some of the most iconic characters in cinema have come from the horror genre, and all them have an actor working tirelessly to bring them to life.

For this list, we're going to take a look at the best horror movie performances of them all. From recent fan favourites to old school classics, innovative trailblazers to misunderstood gems, these films weren't just brought to life by the scares lurking within their mysteries or the exhilarating direction, but by the actors at their centre.

With that in mind, here are the 20 greatest performances in horror movie history. Some spoilers follow.

20. Bela Lugosi - Dracula (1931)

Bela Lugosi Dracula
Universal Pictures

There have been plenty of brilliant Dracula portrayals over the years - specifically from Christopher Lee, Klaus Kinski and Gary Oldman - but none of them really hold a candle to Bela Lugosi's original performance in Tod Browning's 1931 iconic horror masterpiece.

Dracula was the first big-budget adaptation of Bram Stoker's timeless novel, and today it still holds up as a terrifying addition the vampire genre.

At the centre of the story, boosting the film to greatness and giving the performance of a lifetime, stands Bela Lugosi, whose turn as the devilish bloodsucker set the blueprint for every future portrayal. He's terrifying and gleefully theatrical, but also charming and haunted in equal measure, perfectly capturing Dracula's alluring mystery and hidden evil.

Dracula '31 was a rousing success and kickstarted the Universal Monsters franchise, and none of it would have been possible without Lugosi's truly game-changing performance.


19. Jamie Lee Curtis - Halloween (2018)

Halloween 2018
Universal Pictures

David Gordon Green had a fantastic idea when it came to crafting his vision of Halloween, which involved teaming up with co-writers Danny McBride and Jeff Fradley to make the film a direct sequel to the 1978 original movie, thereby forgetting all the films in the middle of the franchise.

This proved to be a stroke of creative genius, as 2018's Halloween was a perfect homage to the iconic original, as well as a bloodthirsty and thrilling horror sequel in its own right.

The best part, though, was the return of renowned scream queen Jamie Lee Curtis to the role of series heroine Laurie Strode, who in the film is shown suffering from PTSD and struggling to heal her relationship with her estranged daughter (Judy Greer).

Much like in the original movie, Curtis is the glue holding the film together, offering up a typically compelling scream queen masterclass whilst giving Laurie an added edge of trauma and grief that makes her more sympathetic and badass than ever.

It's an enthralling performance, and with two sequels on the horizon, fans can rest assured that Curtis is far from done with the role.


18. Marilyn Burns - The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974)

Texas Chainsaw Massacre Marilyn Burns
Bryanston Pictures

Before Halloween and Friday the 13th took the world by storm, and long after the likes of Psycho and Peeping Tom, there was Tobe Hooper's relentlessly horrifying Texas Chain Saw Massacre, which kickstarted the modern slasher craze.

Between the petrifying musical score and Gunnar Hansen's monstrous turn as Leatherface, the true standout of the movie is Marilyn Burns, who played Sally Hardesty, one of the genre's original final girls.

In the role, Burns is said to have suffered through an increasingly difficult shoot, which left her injured, fatigued and coated in fake blood. But, boy, was it worth it, because her performance as the film's unfortunate protagonist is viscerally intense and unflinching.

She's tortured, traumatised, but strong and fighting, and Burns' ability to balance Sally's desperation, survival instincts and emotional turmoil remains one of the finest achievements in the slasher movie genre, setting the near-unrivalled blueprint for every slasher heroine to come.


17. Haley Joel Osment - The Sixth Sense (1999)

The Sixth Sense Haley Joel Osment
Buena Vista

Aside from sporting one of the most talked about plot twists in movie history and launching M. Night Shyamalan to superstardom, The Sixth Sense also introduced the world to Haley Joel Osment with a performance that stole the film and secured him an Oscar nod.

The ins-and-outs of The Sixth Sense and its iconic final twist have been analysed and reviewed to death, but one thing that's faded from discussion over the years has been Osment's turn as Cole Sear - a young boy with the ability to talk to the dead.

In the role, Osment is haunting and far beyond his years. From his fondly remembered "I see dead people" line, the building trauma caused by his unfathomable abilities and his remarkable maturity, he turns Cole into a young boy forced to confront a cruel reality and the ghost story forming around him.

It's rare for a young star to burst so confidently into acting, but Osment made it looked easy.


16. Sissy Spacek - Carrie (1976)

Carrie Blood
United Artists

Brian De Palma's tragic horror flick cemented Stephen King as a household name, and stands today as one of the most recognisable horror movies ever made.

The image of Carrie covered head to toe in pig's blood is a sight for the ages, as is her final revenge, and though much of the film's fame lies on the direction of De Palma, equal praise deserves to be thrown Sissy Spacek's way for her turn as the ill-fated and deeply complex title character.

Carrie is a film made up of images: the shower scene; the prom; the death of Carrie's mother (Piper Laurie). But the truth is that the film is at its best in-between these admittedly fantastic moments, where things so slow down and Spacek gets a chance to dig into Carrie's personal conflicts, troubled home life, and her hopes and dreams.

Spacek plays Carrie exactly as King wrote her in his debut novel. She's shy, sweet, and innocent, but she's also naive and traumatised. It's a searing portrayal of adolescent turmoil and abuse, and really no one (not even Chloe Grace Moretz in the 2013 remake) could have played it better.


15. Sid Haig - The Devil's Rejects (2005)

Captain Spaulding
Lions Gate

Clowns in horror films have always been scary, but never have they been as gleefully horrifying as Captain Spaulding, a nightmare-inducing murderer played to spine-tingling perfection by the late, great horror legend Sid Haig.

Haig had been acting in film for decades before securing the role of Spaulding in Rob Zombie's House of 1000 Corpses, and though his debut was an undeniably stellar performance, he really one-upped himself in the sequel, The Devil's Rejects.

In the role, Haig is nothing short of a nightmare in face paint, threatening his way through the trio's latest deadly misadventures and roaring with laughter every step of the way. He switches between darkly funny and psychotic without pause, forcing uneasy laughs from the audience as they recoil in terror.

It's a performance that begs to be seen, and is guaranteed to cause some sleepless nights.

In other words, Haig nailed it.


14. Mia Farrow - Rosemary's Baby (1968)

Rosemarys Baby
Paramount Pictures

Ruth Gordon may have secured an Oscar for her work in Rosemary's Baby, but the truth is that it's Mia Farrow's frantic, tragic and horrified portrayal of a woman forced to confront Satanism and her own physical trauma after she falls pregnant that steals the show and lives in mind of the modern moviegoer.

In truth, Rosemary's Baby has lost some of its shock value over the years, but Farrow's performance as Rosemary Woodhouse has managed to endure as a horror icon.

At its core, the film is a tragedy, driven forward by Farrow's horrified, moving, disturbed and pained performance. She balances the film's more obscene imagery with a genuinely affecting portrayal of grief and paranoia, growing more assured and unsettled with every passing scene as the horrors of her life come to a head.

Being scared sh*tless has never looked so good.


13. Boris Karloff - Frankenstein (1931)

Frankenstein Boris Karloff
Universal Pictures

Dracula kicked off the Universal Monsters boom, but Frankenstein cemented it as a franchise for the ages. Directed by James Whale, the monster feature remains one of the horror genre's best movies, with its top rate scares, unsettling themes of creationism and lonliness, and, of course, Boris Karloff's pitch perfect turn as Frankenstein's Monster.

Playing the Monster is no easy task, because he's so much more complicated than the iconic characters (Dracula, The Wolfman) around him.

Boris Karloff played the Monster for a number of brilliant films, and perfectly portrayed every complex twist of his personality along the way. Tragic, innocent, horrifying and regrettably evil, Karloff understood right from the off what made this twisted and tortured soul such a monumental presence, and backed up his compelling performance with his intimidating physicality.

Much like Bela Lugosi's turn as Dracula, Karloff's time as Frankenstein's Monster will forever be a gold standard of horror movie performances, as well as one of the most influential roles ever put to film. Watching it again after all this time, it's easy to see why.


12. Linda Blair - The Exorcist (1973)

Linda Blair in The Exorcist
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Exorcist might just be the scariest horror movie ever made, and a lot of that comes down to the film's bewildering special effects - the stairs-running, head-spinning madness of it all.

But amongst the gore and violent scares, The Exorcist's secret weapon comes from the raging performance of child star Linda Blair, who plays ill-fated Reagan MacNeil. From the vulgar taunts to the physical contortions, the switches between innocent victim to embodiment of evil, Blair commits herself to every aspect of Reagan's unpredictable character trait and volcanic personality change.

Blair shouldn't get all the credit, however - although her physical performance is truly remarkable in its own right - as her voice when possessed was actually provided by Mercedes McCambridge, whose vocal work, mixed with Blair's contorting, bed-ridden portrayal of possession, made Reagan the horror icon she is today.


11. Jeff Goldblum - The Fly (1986)

The Fly
20th Century Fox

Jeff Goldblum's defining role (save his crowd-pleasing turn in the Jurassic Park franchise) cast him as Seth Brundle, an undeniably ingenious scientist who finds his DNA fused with a fly after an experiment gone wrong.

The Fly shows director David Cronenberg at the height of his powers, and the visual effects are to die for, but it's Goldblum who steals the show with his unsettling lead performance.

In the role, Goldblum is eccentric, strange but lovable, and eventually arrogant, crass and dismissive. It's a startling juggling act, making Seth at once the good guy and the bad in a frantic 90-minute stretch, but Goldblum balances every one of Seth's fears, desires and pains with remarkable ease.

A lesser actor would have seen their performance lost under the character's prosthetics, but Goldblum cuts through the gore and physical deterioration to give the performance of his career.


10. Jack Nicholson - The Shining (1980)

the shining
Warner Bros

What is there to say about Jack Nicholson's disturbing performance in Stanley Kubrick's Stephen King adaptation that hasn't already been said?

The Shining - despite King's issues with the final product - is one of the most famous and beloved horror movies ever made, and central to the film's success stands Jack Nicholson as the menacing family-man-turned-murderer Jack Torrance.

Nicholson has had a plethora of daring and energetic roles over the years, but he's never been as all-out terrifying and committed to his evil ways than he is here. Every laugh, violent outburst and threat is delivered with twisted delight, ensuring that the scare factor of the movie is ramped up to eleven whenever Nicholson's on the screen.

Between the film's haunting visuals, impressive quotability (you know the one) and Kubrick's painstakingly perfect direction, The Shining is undeniably an all-timer, and Nicholson performance as a loving family man lost to insanity remains its crowning achievement.


9. Florence Pugh - Midsommar (2019)

Midsommar Florence Pugh
A24

Ari Aster has emerged over the last few years as one of cinema's best new talents, kicking his career off with the revelatory Hereditary in 2018, and following it up here with the slow-burn folk horror masterclass Midsommar.

The film is made up of a series of seriously shocking plot twists and grisly images of human sacrifice and cult insanity, and guiding the story forward - aside from Aster's assured and purposefully slow, tension-building direction - is Florence Pugh, who plays grieving protagonist Dani as she and her friends journey to Sweden and find themselves involved with a disturbing Pagan cult.

Midsommar contains Pugh's best work yet - a hypnotising dramatic role that allows her to play a strong-willed woman beaten up by the world around her and forced to combat her despair, her friends and the new world she doesn't fully understand but can't help but be drawn to.

Alongside her work in Fighting with My Family and Little Women, Midsommar shows how destined Pugh is for future Oscar glory.


8. Kathy Bates - Misery (1990)

Kathy Bates Misery
Columbia Pictures

Reading Stephen King's Misery without seeing Rob Reiner's 1990 adaptation, it would be fair to think that no one - surely no one - could possibly play demented fan Annie Wilkes as she's written.

Enter Kathy Bates, who won an Oscar for her obsessive portrayal of a woman driven mad by her love for captive writer Paul Sheldon (James Caan) and his most acclaimed work.

Caan is on top form as the wounded writer, holed up in Wilkes' house and forced to write a novel for her enjoyment, but Misery is Bates' show through-and-through. Cruel, inhumane, insane and intimidating, every time she walks into the room you can't help but assume the worst is still to come, even when she's playing nice and acting jovial.

It's an acting masterclass from a formidable talent - a juggling act that demands constant attention to detail - and cemented Bates' place in the history books.


7. Max Schreck - Nosferatu (1922)

Schreck Orlok Nosferatu
Film Arts Guild

Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror may be approaching its one hundredth birthday, but Max Schreck's portrayal of the discomforting vampire Count Orlock - based partially on Bram Stoker's Dracula - still feels as fresh and disturbing now as it did when the film first stunned audiences all those years ago.

What makes Schreck's performance so memorably bloodcurdling is the fact that Nosferatu is a silent film, and all the movie's palpable tension is created by eerie music that amplifies Schreck's twisted mannerisms. He was tall, and looks even more imposing on camera, and the make-up and wardrobe effects only accentuate his more noticeable and creepy features.

Every shadow, head tilt and hand gesture is perfectly placed by F. W. Murnau's direction, allowing Schreck to lean into the more physically disturbing attributes of fiction's most famous bloodsucker.

The fact that Nosferatu still scares today just goes to show how masterful the film is, and how incredibly petrifying Schreck's game-changing performance remains.

On that note, it's worth giving a shout-out to the indispensable Willem Dafoe, who portrays Schreck as an actual creature of the night in the brilliant Shadow of the Vampire, a film that hinges on the idea that Max Schreck was so good in the role, he surely couldn't be human...


6. Anthony Hopkins - The Silence Of The Lambs (1991)

Awkward Moments In Film - Silence Of The Lambs
Orion Pictures

During his portrayal of the infamous Hannibal Lecter, Sir Anthony Hopkins doesn't blink even once whilst he's on camera. Between the sneering close-ups, spine-tingling tics and thinly veiled threats via psychoanalysis, Hopkins makes sure to keep Hannibal as calm, composed, and therefore as sinister as humanly possible.

Hopkins secured himself an Oscar for his portrayal of the imprisoned murderer, despite only be on screen for a fraction of the film's runtime, and all these years later it's fair to say the Academy - for a nice change of pace - didn't drop the ball.

Lecter is about as unforgettable a horror villain there has ever been. Whether he's intimidating Clarice (Jodie Foster), making creepy phone calls or escaping from prison like a feral beast, Hopkins is a constant source of composed threat and dread, dominating the film as one of cinema's most memorable and disturbing antagonists.


5. Toni Collette - Hereditary (2018)

Hereditary Movie
A24

Florence Pugh was undeniably fantastic in Midsommar, but the best performance Ari Aster has directed thus far has to be from Toni Collette in the staggeringly disturbing Hereditary.

In the film, Collette delivers a powerhouse performance as Annie Graham, a woman who, following a massive tragedy, struggles to keep her family together as her grief begins to swallow her whole and a series of family secrets begin to emerge around her.

Collette's performance is an all-consuming portrayal of the grieving process, one that constantly manages to move between endearing and tragic to terrifying and dangerously unhinged. She's ultimately sympathetic, but her anger and emotional distress is so raw it's impossible not to be utterly petrified of her.

That she wasn't nominated for an Oscar is sure to be remembered in time as one of the Academy's biggest travesties, but even without the formal industry recognition, Collette's performance is unquestionably one of the best of the 2010s, and a sure-fire horror classic.


4. Anthony Perkins - Psycho (1960)

How Psycho Tricks You Into Becoming An Accomplice In Murder Thumb
Universal Pictures

Alfred Hitchcock, also known as the Master of Suspense, created a wide range of undisputed classics over his career, from Vertigo to North by Northwest, Rope to Rear Window, but none are as instantly recognisable as his genre-defining work in the 1960 masterpiece Psycho.

A timeless assault on your senses that constantly takes audience expectation and turns it on its head, Psycho sports a slew of brilliant performances (Janet Leigh and Vera Miles shine) and memorable quotes ("We all go a little mad sometimes"), but no part of the film remains as fresh, disturbing and unexpected as Anthony Perkins' turn as unassuming serial killer Norman Bates.

Sure, people remember the shower scene and Mother's final fate, but the truth is Perkins is the true standout of the movie, crafting out of his deliberate, Freudian and even charming performance a villain for the ages, capable of great violence and rage but hiding it under a measured and approachable demeanor.


3. Isabelle Adjani - Possession (1981)

Possession 1981
Gaumont

Cult classic gem Possession received a so-so reception upon its initial release, but over the years the appreciation for Andrzej Żuławski's frightening vision has only grown louder and more positive.

The psychological drama is, in its simplest form, the tale of a deteriorating marriage and its troubling effects on wife Anna (Isabelle Adjani). It's a very disturbing but highly symbolic and challenging movie, which shifts between its human melodrama and shocking scenes of violence without fault.

In the lead role, Adjani is nothing short of a revelation, gamely taking viewers on a journey of self-destruction, emotional and physical deterioration, and anguish.

She'd make this list for the subway possession scene alone, but luckily there's more to Adjani's performance than the film's most infamously grotesque sequence. Anna is played as innocent and delicate, but also frightening and unpredictable, and watching Adjani act her heart out makes it all the more tragic the film was banned for so long after it came out.


2. Natalie Portman - Black Swan (2010)

Black Swan Natalie Portman
20th Century Fox

Darren Aronofsky is an innovative and challenging director, and Black Swan remains his best and most affecting film.

It stars Natalie Portman as ballerina Nina, who gets her dream job when she's cast in a production of Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake, but soon begins to crumble under her professional and personal pressures and slowly loses her mind.

Portman won an Oscar for her role, creating one of the rawest portrayals of obsession and mental instability you're ever likely to see on screen.

Nina is seen in a number of different states, ranging from fragile and embattled to passionate and strong, from unpredictable to straight-up terrifying, and Portman embodies every shocking aspect of her character without losing sight of the film's biggest themes.

To call Portman's greatest role a tour de force would sound cliched, and yet it's without question the best phrase to describe her performance here.


1. Christian Bale - American Psycho (2000)

American Psycho Christian Bale
Lionsgate

The amount of things Christian Bale achieves in American Psycho truly has to be seen to be believed. After years acting in a series of poor to bad productions (despite a solid break-out role in Spielberg's Empire of the Sun), American Psycho finally launched Bale to superstardom and gave the actor a chance to show what he was made of.

In the deranged slasher, Bale stars as Patrick Bateman, a successful investment banker who revels in his wealth, attractiveness and need to be better than everyone in the room. He's arrogant, casually cruel, and is shown to have a second, secret life in which he kills sex workers and homeless people to quench an unrelenting bloodlust.

Bale gives the performance of a lifetime - which has been unfairly overshadowed through the years by his frightening commitment to method acting - playing Bateman with remarkable intensity and dark humour. He's misogynistic, a liar and a cheat, and yet he's often uncomfortably funny and brilliantly manipulative.

Bale controls every complex angle of his character to perfection, allowing audiences to watch Bateman lose his mind, kill, dance, and lie his way to the film's expertly crafted final scene.


Watch Next


Match The Horror Movie Villain To Their Film

Halloween Michael Myers
Compass International Pictures

1. Michael Myers

Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/