20 Idiotic Decisions Made By Characters In The Harry Potter Films

The Boy Who Screwed Up?

As they say, hindsight is 20-20. And in the big, sprawling universe that is the Harry Potter films, there€™s a lot of things that can be subjected to hindsight. So it€™s time to turn a critical eye on the film characters and second-guess what they did and could have done. While Harry commits some serious mistakes (which to be honest, is what makes for good storytelling), there€™s also plenty of blame to go around on the adults surrounding him and his friends. Harry€™s unwelcoming relatives, the Dursleys, are obviously on the list; but the Ministry of Magic is a lot worse than anyone else when it comes to egregious errors. We know that some of the following points can be refuted in the books; but our focus here is on the film series. Why? Because, while the Potter series is the most read book series of the past 17 years, not everyone wants to read the books. They depend on the films for their knowledge of the Potterverse. Some deleted scenes may answer the points we bring up. However, since they are deleted, they are not canon, and are therefore ineligible for consideration. We€™re also going to skip admitted mistakes, such as Dumbledore admitting he had erred in not telling Harry the full story about his life in The Order of the Phoenix. Let the sniping begin by casting the snarking spell: €œCriticius reviewus!€

20. The Dursleys locking Harry in The Cupboard Under The Stairs

Harry Potter is an orphan. He was left in a basket at the doorstep of the Dursleys, along with a note explaining his parents€™ death and Dumbledore€™s wishes that they would raise him as their own son. We assume that Petunia Dursley felt an obligation to her sister Lily, even though they were estranged. Flash forward ten years. The Dursleys son, Dudley, has everything that he wants. He€™s a pudgy, spoiled brat. Harry, in contrast, is The Boy Who Almost Isn€™t There. His bedroom is a cupboard under the stairs. He wears Dudley€™s overlarge clothes. He€™s essentially a manservant to the Dursleys, fixing their breakfasts and regarded as barely tolerable, blamed for everything that goes wrong. Reality check: It€™s €œHarry Potter,€ not €œHarry Dursley.€ Harry attends a Muggle primary school, so the bureaucracy knows he is a ward of the Dursleys. Yet no teacher notices that this kid is wearing oversized clothes, has damaged glasses, and has the emotional look of someone who is suffering from severe bullying? No social worker has ever come to the Dursleys to check to see how he lives at home? His €œbedroom€ should be enough evidence to have the Dursleys locked up for child abuse. Even if the Muggle bureaucracy is oblivious to Harry€™s situation, the wizarding world is not. All of the Hogwarts invitation letters addressed to Harry are stamped €œThe Cupboard Under The Stairs.€ Doesn€™t anyone in the wizarding world find this alarming? Especially for The Boy Who Lived?

19. Using a Muggle train station As The Embarkation Point To Hogwarts When Portkeys And The Floo Network Exist

Kings Cross Station and Platform 9 and 3/4 make for very interesting and picturesque locations. Trains are magical conveyances even in the Muggle world, and have been the site of much intrigue and romance for decades of storytelling. But if there€™s a whole Ministry of Magic bureaucracy devoted to keeping the magical world secret, why are wizards using public transportation hubs in order to get to magical destinations? We find out about the existence of the Floo network (using fireplaces to travel between wizard abodes and businesses) in The Chamber of Secrets; and of Portkeys (objects with a spell cast upon them to transport the one possessing it to a specific destination) in The Goblet of Fire. There€™s also the use of broomsticks and Apparation (the wizard version of Star Trek€™s transporter) for those inclined to use those methods. With all of these alternative methods that wizards can use to travel, why are students still taking the Hogwarts Express? Children born into wizarding families already know about the wizard modes of transport, and children from Muggle families can be told to report to Diagon Alley in order to be transported directly to the school. And as a quick aside, why is King€™s Cross the only embarkation point to Hogwarts?

18. Dumbledore€™s Hiring Of The Pompous Gilderoy Lockhart

Gilderoy Lockhart is a pompous windbag. He writes bestselling books for the wizarding world, all of which are adorned with his smiling photo. He luxuriates in the spotlight, seeking it whenever he can. He has legions of fans who write to him, and he joyfully responds in kind. Why then, did Albus Dumbledore hire him as Defence Against The Dark Arts teacher? Lockhart€™s €œexpertise€ in fighting the Dark Arts is documented in his books, but his appointment should have been put on hold once he submitted his book list, which included his complete collection of published works. Sounds a tad too opportunist. If that wasn€™t enough, his ineptitude as a teacher, exemplified by his first disastrous lesson in which he releases a swarm of pixies into the classroom and then can€™t control them, should have been enough for his suspension. There may have been a lack of applicants for the DADA position, but surely Dumbledore could come down from his tower and substitute?

17. Lucius Malfoy Giving The Diary To Ginny Weasley

Lucius Malfoy€™s contempt for all things non-wizard is obvious, as is his disdain for lesser creatures such as Dobby. However, his stature as a well-heeled employee at the Ministry of Magic (especially to Cornelius Fudge) not only keeps him out of trouble, but also gives him insight into the workings of the Ministry and the ability to influence it. It also keeps him off the official radar of the Auror squad, but not all wizards are fooled by his public mask, especially Arthur Weasley. Malfoy was given Tom Riddle€™s diary by Voldemort himself. Not knowing the importance of the diary (a Horcrux), he decided to plant it on Ginny Weasley in the hopes of discrediting her father. After Harry destroys the diary and returns to Dumbledore€™s office, Malfoy bursts in, angry about Dumbledore€™s return after Malfoy had contrived to have him suspended. Dumbledore makes a veiled reference to the fact that he knows that Malfoy planted the diary on Ginny, and Harry accuses him of it outright. As the senior Death Eater not serving in Azkaban, Malfoy should have regarded any personal possessions of the Dark Lord as holy objects. Even though it was a good plan to both rid himself of an incriminating object and take down a threat to his power, it was nearly too risky to him and his stature at the Ministry.

16. Harry And Ron€™s Decision To Steal The Flying Car

The flying Ford Anglia. How many violations of Ministry laws can we total on this one? Arthur should have lost his Ministry job over this, as just the simple act of enchanting the car to fly is something of a huge offence in the Ministry's eyes. Molly Weasley€™s Howler to Ron indicates that he does face an inquiry, but there€™s no word on what happens after that. Fred, George and Ron using the car to rescue Harry? The Ministry of Magic can detect the use of illegal magic by juveniles, and use it to charge Harry with illegally producing a Patronus Charm in the presence of a Muggle (Dudley) in The Order of the Phoenix. Yet no-one from the Ministry comes to check when a flying car pulls out the burglar bars at the Dursley home? Truly baffling. Finally, Ron convinces Harry that since the platform at the train station has sealed them off, they should take the car to Hogwarts. First, it would have been simpler and wiser just to wait. Mr. and Mrs. Weasley would have noticed that Ron and Harry weren€™t on the train, and would come back out to look for them. Second, Harry has Hedwig, who can fly a message to Hogwarts explaining their situation. Even if Dobby had foiled both of these plans, someone would have noticed their absence and found them eventually. It's not like Harry is a famous person, after all.

15. Wormtail€™s Decision To Stay With The Weasleys After Sirius Black Escapes

Scabbers has been in the Weasley family for several years now. He was originally Percy€™s rat; now he€™s been handed down to Ron. That makes it rather gross when we find out that Scabbers is actually Peter Pettigrew, a.k.a. Wormtail. Worse than that, he€™s the one who €œsold Lilly and James to Voldemort,€ then framed Sirius Black for the murder. It€™s obvious that Wormtail has been using his ability as an Animagus to keep his identity secret - since he€™s been declared dead, this is necessary. But once it was announced that Sirius had escaped from Azkaban, Wormtail should have immediately packed it off to find Voldemort. Yet he stays with Ron, even though Hermione has just acquired a pet cat that isn€™t fooled by his disguise. And even after he does leave Ron, where does he go? Hagrid€™s cabin! Some might say it was because he was a rat instead of a human, and therefore had limited intelligence. Nope. He knew enough to stay with the Weasleys for news, and also to flee when it started to get dangerous for him.

14. The Ministry of Magic Giving A Time-Turner To A 13-Year-Old

Hermione Granger is the most brilliant witch for her age; everyone says so. She gets the Hogwarts staff to issue her a Time-Turner, which allows her to take twice the number of classes of every other student at Hogwarts. One can assume that the Ministry is in charge of such devices (indeed, in the books there's a 'Time Room' in the Department of Mysteries), as it has so much potential for misuse, especially for practitioners of the Dark Arts. So that means the Ministry had to sign off on the request. Now, if you can€™t trust the average fully-qualified wizard with a Time-Turner, how can you give one to a 13-year-old? Why is she so much more responsible? Forget €œbooks and cleverness.€ This is an Absolute Power device, and as the saying goes, €œabsolute power corrupts absolutely.€ Again, she's 13 - teenagers don't tend to be the most responsible people in the world, even if they are prodigiously intelligent. Hermione did only use the device as she was instructed, with Dumbledore giving her permission to use it to rescue Sirius (and Buckbeak). Granted, everything did go right in the end, but it€™s doubtful the Ministry would be too happy if they really knew the truth about how Hermione used their device to circumvent Ministry decrees.

13. Posting Dementors Around Hogwarts And Hogsmeade

Dementors are the guards of Azkaban, who use their abilities as happiness vacuums to keep their prisoners docile and inert. Their most powerful weapon is the threat of the Kiss, which sucks the soul out of their victim, leaving him worse than dead. The Ministry of Magic, in its infinite wisdom, has decided to place a platoon of them around the Hogwarts grounds in the hopes they will catch Azkaban escapee Sirius Black, and protect Harry Potter in the process. Did it occur to the Ministry that since Sirius was able to escape the emotionally draining effect the Dementors had on him when he was captive in Azkaban, he might figure out a way to avoid them around Hogwarts? As for protecting Harry: they affected him to the point where he passed out on the Hogwarts Express. They caused him to fall off his broom and nearly fall to his death during a Quidditch match. Plus, they nearly performed the Kiss on Harry as well. It€™s obvious that the Dementors don€™t discriminate between free wizards and prisoners, and Dumbledore warns the students of this at the opening-of-term feast. Madame Rosmerta rips into Cornelius Fudge about the Dementors scaring all of her customers away from her pub in Hogsmeade, because clearly, these are not the creatures you want guarding anything, especially your children.

12. Creating A Binding Magical Contract That Allowed For No Disqualifications

If your name comes out of the Goblet of Fire, you are magically bound to compete in the Triwizard Tournament. No exceptions. Barty Crouch informs the Hogwarts students that, due to the extreme risks involved in competing in the tournament, no one under age 17 (legal age in the wizarding world) will be allowed to enter in the tournament. Dumbledore draws an Age Line around the Goblet that keeps out younger students, as the Weasley twins learn to their discomfort. Yet Harry€™s name comes out of the Goblet after the three champions have already been chosen. Did someone forget to inform the Goblet that underage students weren€™t allowed in? Or that €œTri€ is a prefix that means €œthree,€ not €œfour?€ Dumbledore€™s question, €œDid you get an older student to put your name in for you?€ indicates that he was at least smart enough to admit that his Age Line had failed in its task. But at this point, Dumbledore should have insisted that Harry be disqualified, and Crouch should have agreed. But that €œbinding contract€ was written without anticipating that someone might not follow their restrictions. One could assume that there was no €œfree will€ clause inserted, as Harry was definitely not interested in entering the contest.

In this post: 
Harry Potter
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Mr. Thomas is primarily a graphic artist for the San Antonio Express-News, but also finds time to write the DVD Extra blog for the paper’s website.