20 Things You Didn't Know About Batman Forever

The old-guard may have changed, but the remainder is weirdly faithful.

Val Kilmer Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Long-running franchises are prone to reboots, re-interpretations and even re-invention. The James Bond series launched with Sean Connery's suave, charming run before scrambling to find a replacement (that wasn't George Lazenby) and wound up with Roger Moore, whose Bondian-era is far more jokey and relaxed in tone. Today, it seems, we're prepared for unvarnished Bond - the blunt instrument of Her Majesty that happens to be the correct tool for the job.

We were just as ready for the same from Christopher Nolan, whose work on the Batman franchise draws heavily and faithfully from the source material. Inspired by popular aristocratic heroes of the 30s with dual identities and movies like Roland West's The Bat Whispers, Bob Kane and Bill Finger collaborated to bring about their own great mystery detective/hero.

But the most drastic changing of the guard occurred when Joel Schumacher took the reigns from Tim Burton in 1995. The stark difference between the two's approach to Gotham is evident from the first shot. And though synergy was a part of the deal since 1989, Batman Forever strove to be more kid-friendly than Burton's border-line R-rated entries.

The colour, flamboyance and humour were all lighter, the performances more over-the-top wacky and the action setpieces were straight out of a 9-year-old's fever dream. To die hard fans, it was an insult.

Alas, a lot went into the planning and production of Batman Forever, some of which you may have glossed over. Here's a bit of a primer.

20. Robin Williams Was Too Bitter To Participate

Robin Williams Riddler
Deviantart - Elmic-Toboo

When it was first announced that producer/Barbara Steisand's hairdresser Jon Peters had acquired the rights to Batman, there was a frenzy of actors chomping at the bit for roles. Most notably, Robin Williams actively campaigned to play Jack Napier AKA The Joker in Tim Burton's 1989 film. He felt a connection to the role and appeared to be excited to get an offer.

Later, however, he learned producers had their hearts set on Jack Nicholson, who had refused initially. They had pushed Williams forward as bait to attract Nicholson back to the role, a casting decision they were so devoted to they ensured top billing. When Williams learned he was just being dangled like a shiny object in front of a dog, it left a bitter taste in his mouth.

So when he was approached more seriously for Batman Forever to play The Riddler - a role for which he'd be infinitely more well-suited - he outright refused without an apology from the studio for past behaviour that never came.


19. Micky Dolenz Was Up For The Riddler

Micky Dolenz in The Monkees
NBC

Tim Burton has always been inventive with casting, unless he is having a particularly lazy Sunday and thinks, "Screw it, I'll just get Johnny [Depp]". He made a habit, particularly in his early career of casting his icons - such as Vincent Price in Edward Scissorhands. So it's no surprise that, before backing away from the project, he had some out-there ideas for who should play Edward Nygma AKA The Riddler.

It's easy to forget that vocalist and drummer for Beatles knock-off band The Monkees Micky Dolenz got his start as a child actor on a show called Circus Boy. It's even hard to recall that The Monkees, at the height of their popularity, had their own weekly sitcom.

Burton certainly remembered, and wanted to bring him back to the screen once again.


18. Jim Carrey Wanted A Question Mark Carved Into His Head, But Felt The Judge Might Not Approve

Jim Carrey in Batman Forever
Warner Bros. Pictures

When it was darker in tone, The Riddler was intended to have a shaved head with a large question mark engraved in his brow. Jim Carrey was on board with the decision, and even reportedly looked forward to taking his career to places outside of Ace Ventura.

He was, however, going through divorce proceedings during shooting, and feared he might not appear to be the most stable individual in court. One could always remove the make-up, however time constraints would make it difficult. So the lesson is, if you are set to appear before a court of law, it's best not to accept a role that makes you look like a curious white supremacist beforehand.


17. Robin Was Supposed To Already Be There

Chris O'Donnell in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Upon release, Batman Forever's big gimmick was the fact that they were finally adding Robin, Batman's young protege and sidekick, in the mix. But had Batman Returns stuck to its script, Robin's appearance wouldn't have come as a surprise. The script initially featured Robin as the African American leader of a gang and part-time auto-mechanic. He was to be played by Marlon Wayans. His part was the addition of an uncredited rewrite by Wesley Strick.

When Sam Hamm and Daniel Waters were brought on board, however, the character was the first to go. Waters went as far as describing Robin as the "most worthless character in the world" particular in a Batman story - one about the ultimate loner. Having a sidekick, the writers felt, cheapened the affair.


16. Val Kilmer And Jim Carrey Were BFFs

jim carrey val kilmer batman forever
Warner Bros.

Despite all the chaos behind the scenes of Batman Forever between studio, director, actors and writers, one genuine friendship managed to form. Both Jim Carrey and Val Kilmer had both recently lost their fathers and had similar backgrounds, growing up in families under dire financial situations.

Carrey, in fact, has gone on record stating that had show business not worked out, he'd be working in a steel mill somewhere in Ontario today. Their backgrounds and grief helped them through the otherwise difficult shoot.


15. Contrarily, Tommy Lee Jones Hated Jim Carrey

Tommy Lee Jones and Jim Carrey in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Perhaps the most famous (and funny) story behind Batman Forever came from Carrey years later but has since been confirmed by director Joel Schumacher. It turns out that all those crowd shots of Tommy Lee Jones at awards shows where he sits silently glowering while the host tries to tell a joke were not an intentional part of the act. Off-set stories range from requesting a waitress to be fired for politely acknowledging his career to Carrey's now-famous tale.

Carrey spotted Jones at a restaurant before filming began and thought he'd do the honourable thing and introduce himself. The two embraced, at which point Jones said, "I hate you. I cannot sanction your buffoonery."

What can one expect from the former dormmate of Al Gore? Lighthearted banter?


14. Val Kilmer Lived Up To His "Difficult" Reputation

Chuck Klosterman wrote a piece about spending a weekend at Val Kilmer's ranch, during which came to a few conclusions that are both surprising and contradictory to what we knew about Kilmer circa 1995. First, Kilmer is a bit of a name-dropper, often bringing up famous people he met. Second, he believes that, if he were to play a character in the Vietnam war, he would have a complete and accurate and understanding of what it was like to face live combat only to be spat on upon returning home. And third, Val Kilmer is actually a pretty nice guy.

In 1995, however, he was not. After filming the last of his scenes for The Island of Dr. Moreau, director John Frankenheimer said, "Now get that bastard off my set".

Kilmer was going through a divorce from Joanne Whalley, and it was certainly taking its toll on his personality. Schumacher was no fan, eiither, though he admits the actor delivered a solid performance despite.


13. Dick Grayson Was Forethinking

Chris O'Donnell and Val Kilmer in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

After discovering the Batcave, it was a foregone conclusion that Dick Grayson's lust for revenge against Two-Face for the death of his family and eventual role as Batman's lackey was going to drive the film into its final act.

But where would Grayson go after he got his just cause? Continue under Batman's tutelage or go off on his own? It turns out, without even realizing it, the supposedly teenaged boy (O'Donnell was 25 at the time) already knew. When spouting out potential names for his alter ego, he passes over "Nightwing", a name the adult Grayson adopts years later.

Happy now, nerds?


12. As Much As Chris O'Donnell Wanted To Drive The Batmobile, He Kinda Sucked At It

The Batmobile Batman Forever
Warner Bros. Pictures

If there is a young boy or teenager or comic book store owner in the world whose dream isn't to one day be at the helm of the Batmobile - no matter which incarnation - we haven't met him. The actual car was typically manned by stunt drivers, but O'Donnell was insistent that he get a turn at the wheel when Robin takes it out for a joyride.

As one can imagine, though, the car is as impractical as it looks, and O'Donnell didn't really know how to handle it. Almost right away, he crashed it, denting the fender.

Which makes one wonder - where do you buff that out?


11. Will Shortz Created The Riddler's Riddles

One of the riddles in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

The Riddler taunts Batman throughout the film, mailing him riddles that inevitably lead to his true identity. Jim Carrey figured out that Einhorn was a man because a dog sat on a magazine in Ace Ventura, but cut Jim Carrey's hair and dye it red and the world's greatest detective needs to Sherlock it.

But the riddles themselves were actually quite complex - dare say, clever, and that's no accident. They were written and designed by Will Shortz, creator of the New York Times crossword puzzle.


10. Val Kilmer Was Literally In A Batcave When He Learned Of The Role

Batman Forever batcave
Warner Bros.

Accidents will happen, coincidences occur, but knowing what we do about Val Kilmer, it's highly unlikely he didn't take the following chain of events as a sign of fate or destiny. Kilmer was in Africa, doing research for his next picture, The Ghost and the Darkness. The film, directed by Stephen Hopkins, is the sort-of true story of two man-eating lions who attacked countless railroad workers who were linking Uganda to the Indian Ocean.

When he was approached for the role, he was literally in a batcave. He accepted it immediately without even glancing at the script.


9. Believe It Or Not, Schumacher Wanted It Darker

Val Kilmer in Joel Schumacher's neon Gotham in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Joel Schumacher is often credited for the neon, strobe-lit flamboyant, goofy tone of his two entries in the Batman franchise, and it's earned. The director has a penchant for rave-like decor. Initially, however, the director intended to stay true to Burton's much darker vision.

It was actually the producers and studio that pushed for a lighter, more kid-friendly tone. By the time he got around to Batman and Robin, Schumacher's heart wasn't in it at all. Before each take, he would announce to cast and crew that they were essentially just shooting one, long toy commercial.


8. When Burton Was Still Involved, So Was Scarecrow

Val Kilmer Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Tim Burton had originally planned to make Batman Forever, a title both he and Schumacher hated. Schumacher likened the "forever" part to some dumb crap you put on a T-shirt or a prison tattoo, not a movie. So Burton aimed for Batman Continues, and intended it to be the closure of a trilogy, each exploring a different theme surrounding the character.

His first film would deal with coping with tragedy, the second with redemption and the third would probe overcoming fear after suffering loss. So naturally, Burton would include Scarecrow, the villainous doctor who used his fear toxin to send his victims into a panicked frenzy. He even knew he wanted Brad Douriff for the role.

The studio wasn't keen on Burton's new ideas, and that's around the time when the changing of the guard began.


7. They Bought Out Billy Dee Williams

Billy Dee Wiliams in Batman
Warner Bros.

Harvey Dent AKA Two Face has been a staple of the comics and film franchise since his first appearance as the district attorney of Gotham in Burton's film. He was played by Billy Dee Williams, who signed on for the sequel and was a part of the first script. It was Dent, not Christopher Walken's Max Schreck, who would be shocked by Catwoman's tazer at the end, causing half of his face to be horrifically scarred.

By the time Batman Forever was in production, the studio didn't want to include Williams, to they bought out his contract and recast him with the more popular Jones (who had just won an Oscar for The Fugitive).

Williams did eventually get to reprise the role, voicing Dent in The Lego Batman Movie.


6. Schumacher Wanted Nicole Kidman For Poison Ivy

Val Kilmer and Nicole Kidman in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Superhero sequels, particularly after Spider-Man 3, are notorious targets of derision from fans for being overstuffed of bloated. The third entry in Sam Raimi's trilogy of Spidey films features just as many villains, one of which (Venom) he had no interest in including.

But the history of adding in more bad guys for the hero to go up against stretches back further, and Schumacher initially wanted Poison Ivy to show up in Forever before she finally did in Batman and Robin (by Uma Thurman). He wanted Nicole Kidman's character to be Ivy, but everyone else involved felt that two villains were enough.

As a result, Kidman played Batman's love interest and psychiatrist Chase Meridian, a character never a part of the mythology before or since.


5. Bob Kane's Wife Is In It

Gossip Gerty in Batman and Robin
Warner Bros.

13 minutes into Tim Burton's Batman, reporter Alexander Knox (Robert Wuhl) walks by a cartoonist's desk in the newsroom and mocks a cartoon sketch of Batman in a pin-striped suit. It's a cute in-joke, as the cartoonist is actually creator Bob Kane.

Still respectful of its history, Schumacher included a similar cameo for Kane's wife. She plays Gossip Gerty, the irritating reporter desperate to get a few words from the now-famous Edward Nygma during a gala where he premieres "The Box" - the device that allows him to tap into all Gothamite's brainwaves and, ultimately, uncover who Batman really is. She reprises the role in Batman and Robin.


4. Bob Kane Liked Val Kilmer The Most

Val Kilmer in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

Bob Kane lived a long and storied life in the comic world, there to witness his creation do the Batuisi, wear an anti-shark belt, kill many, many thugs, and inadvertently lead to the deaths of The Joker, The Penguin and Two-Face.

He passed away in 1998, meaning he also probably saw bat-nipples and bat-ass, but he was coherent and at peace with what his creation had meant to so many generations, and he never didn't have an opinion to offer.

Of all the Batmen that had appeared onscreen, he said that Val Kilmer offered the best interpretation to date. He didn't live to see Christian Bale or Ben Affleck take the role nor will he see Robert Pattinson don the cowl in the future, and one wonders what he'd make of it.


3. It Led To Jim Carrey Covering The Beatles

Show business makes strange bedfellows. After watching Carrey mug his way through the role, legendary Beatles producer George Martin approached him with the intent that the actor record a cover of "I Am The Walrus" for a tribute album he was in the process of putting together.

Carrey, being Jim Carrey, accepted immediately, and it wasn't long before he was in the studio. It's difficult to imagine any actor refusing a request from the guy who produced The Beatles. It's a fine performance, too, both respectful of the material but still inflected with Carrey's own brand of wackiness.


2. Steve Martin Was Offered The Riddler

Steve Martin in The Man With Two Brains
Warner Bros.

The role of The Joker almost felt tailor-made for someone like Jim Carrey, so it's somewhat of a surprise that the studio actually struggled to cast it properly. Before the right light went off in the right head, they offered the role to comedian, actor, writer, poet and playwright Steve Martin. It's one of those "wouldn't-it-have-been-interesting" facts. It even made vague sense, given that Martin's previous work, The Man With Two Brains, had his character deal with mind control/swapping like The Riddler.

But at the time, Martin was going through a divorce from his wife actress Victoria Tennant (a better title for the film apparently would have been "Batman Divorced" given the number of relationships that fell apart surrounding production) and his friend John Candy had just died of a heart attack.

Neeedless to say, Martin wasn't up to the task.


1. Contrary To Popular Belief, Two Face Is Not Cheating

Tommy Lee Jones in Batman Forever
Warner Bros.

It's a common misconception that, when Two Face and the Riddler invade Wayne manor and the latter flips his double-sided coin, he cheats, flipping it three times until it lands in favour of shooting Bruce Wayne. In the comics, and the Nolan films, Two Face is a slave to the coin, following its first decision no matter the outcome.

But what people don't realize is that there are others in the room beyond just Wayne fighting off his goons. He's not cheating, it just happens to land on the desired side when it was Wayne's turn.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Kenny Hedges is carbon-based. So I suppose a simple top 5 in no order will do: Halloween, Crimes and Misdemeanors, L.A. Confidential, Billy Liar, Blow Out He has his own website - thefilmreal.com - and is always looking for new writers with differing views to broaden the discussion.