20 Things You Didn't Know About Goodfellas
Family cameos, near-castings, and real mobsters on set...
Want to be reminded of how old or young you are? No? Too bad, because Goodfellas turns 30 years old this year.
Martin Scorsese's masterpiece has been been watched, re-watched, adored, and admired for three decades now. Whether you're watching it for the first time or the 30th, there's always enjoyment to be had from the gangster classic.
As with any movie, there's also plenty of interesting trivia from behind-the-scenes, obscure facts about the production, and details on screen that you may have completely missed.
So, let's take a look at the some of the things that you may or may not know about the gangster classic.
20. It Could Have Starred Tom Cruise And Madonna
It's tough to imagine anyone other than Ray Liotta and Lorraine Bracco as Henry and Karen Hill, respectively, but as with any movie, they weren't the only ones running for the roles.
Tom Cruise was also considered for the part of Henry Hill. While Cruise could have potentially pulled off the role, it's jarring to think of anyone other than Liotta as the suave mobster. Fortunately, Liotta managed to convince producer Irwin Winkler that he was a better fit than Cruise.
Madonna, on the other hand, was a more questionable potential casting choice. She hasn't exactly had a great track record for acting roles, but somehow she was "in the mix" for the emotionally demanding part of Hill's wife. Thankfully it went to Bracco instead.
19. Al Pacino Turned Down The Role Of Jimmy
It took until 2019 for Al Pacino to finally star in a Martin Scorsese movie with The Irishman, but it wasn't the first time Pacino was offered a role in one of his films.
Pacino was initially offered the role of Jimmy Conway, the Irish-American associate of the Lucchese crime family, who was ultimately, of course, played by Robert De Niro.
According to IMDb, Pacino allegedly turned the part down due to fear of bring typecasted.
Funnily enough, Pacino played Alphonse "Big Boy" Caprice, a sterotypical gangster, in Dick Tracy that same year, a decision that Pacino has since admitted he regrets. So much for avoiding typecasting.
18. The "Funny, How?" Scene Wasn't In The Script (And Was Based On Joe Pesci's Real Experience)
Although it's arguably the most well-known scene of the entire film, the "Funny How?" scene wasn't actually in the script.
In fact, the moment is based on an experience that actor Joe Pesci had when he was working at a restaurant. As we all know from the film, Hill (Ray Liotta) tells Tommy (Joe Pesci) that he's funny, to which Tommy has a less-than-enthused reaction.
Pesci said something along those lines to a mobster at the restaurant one night, and he got a similarly unenthusiastic response.
Once Pesci relayed the anecdote to Martin Scorsese, he decided to include it in the film. However, Scorsese chose not to include the scene in the shooting script, so as to elicit genuine shocked reactions from the cast.
17. Edward McDonald Appeared As Himself
Towards the end of the film, Henry and Karen meet with U.S. Attorney Edward McDonald to enroll in the witness protection program, as the couple did in real life.
McDonald, however, isn't portrayed by an actor. It's actually the man himself.
Apparently, when McDonald's office was being scouted for research on the movie, he volunteered to appear as himself. Scorsese cast him after successful screen tests.
The cast and crew put in a lot of effort to make the film as authentic as possible, so why not cast someone who was involved in the real-life events?
16. Martin Scorsese's Parents Have Cameos
You wouldn't expect to see a director's parents playing roles in their son's movie, let alone a violent affair like Goodfellas, but that's exactly what Scorsese's parents did. Their roles are brief, but significant.
Catherine Scorsese plays Tommy's mother in the film, who of course appears after the boys kill Billy Batts (unbeknownst to her) and cooks them dinner. When Scorsese directed his mother in the scene, he didn't tell her that the characters in the movie had just killed someone and had the body hidden in their car, so she was just as naive as her character was.
Charles Scorsese appears as Vinnie, the man in prison who made the tomato sauce which Henry felt had too many onions, but was "still a very good sauce." Vinnie is later present at Tommy's execution.
15. The Painting Was Painted By Nicolas Pileggi's Mother
Continuing with familial relations, this time with Nicolas Pileggi, the author of the book on which the film's based, Wiseguy, who also co-wrote the screenplay with Scorsese.
Pileggi's mother sort of has a cameo in the movie. She doesn't physically appear, but a certain artwork that she painted does.
That would be the painting that Tommy's mother shows the boys in the dinner scene, the one with the man and two dogs in the boat, each dog facing different directions.
It's a nice little detail that Pileggi's mother got to have her painting featured in a feature film her son co-wrote.
14. 27 Actors From The Film Appeared On The Sopranos
Fans of The Sopranos will recognize a lot of familiar faces in Goodfellas. Lorraine Bracco is the clear standout, since she has central roles in both the film as Karen Hill, and in the show as Dr. Melfi.
Michael Imperioli and Frank Vincent also have memorable roles too. In Goodfellas, Imperioli plays Spider, the boy who Tommy shoots in the foot and later kills. Imperioli later played Christopher Moltisanti in The Sopranos for the duration of its run.
Frank Vincent plays Billy Batts in Goodfellas, who was viciously beat to death by Tommy (Joe Pesci) over a comment on Tommy's shoeshining days. Vincent later portayed Phil Leotardo on The Sopranos in its fifth and sixth seasons.
However, they're far from the only actors in the film to appear on the show. Vincent Pastore, who played Salvatore Bonpensiero on The Sopranos, has a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo early on in the film as "Man with Coat Rack." Tony Sirico, aka Paulie Gualtieri on The Sopranos, appears as Tony Stacks in Goodfellas.
You can check out the full list here.
13. Scorsese Played Layla During The Shooting Of Those Scenes
The piano-laden second half of Eric Clapton's Layla is used brilliantly in the film as it plays over the montage of the Lufthansa crew's bodies being found.
However, the song wasn't just important to the scenes in the actual movie, but while they were being filmed as well.
Such was the significance of the song in tying the scenes together that Scorsese actually played it over the shooting of those scenes.
Scorsese did this so as to match certain bars of the piano coda with certain shots of the film, which probably proved beneficial in post-production.
12. The Final Shot Is A Homage To The Great Train Robbery
At the end of the film, after Hill's narration of becoming an "average nobody," we see Tommy point a gun at the camera and shoot it six times, which Scorsese included as a homage to one of the earliest films in history: The Great Train Robbery.
Released in 1903, The Great Train Robbery was only twelve minutes long, but it was a pioneer in filmmaking. It was a milestone in elements of film such as multiple camera angles, editing, and a flowing narrative.
The final shot of that film sees the leader of the bandits, played by Justus D. Barnes, fire his pistol six times at the camera.
To show his appreciation for the film, Scorsese directly paid homage to it here.
11. Lorraine Bracco's Two Daughters Played The Same Daughter On Screen
We see Henry and Karen's children grow up over the course of the film, and one of them, Judy Hill, happened to be played by both of Lorraine Bracco's daughters.
Her younger daughter, Stella Keitel (Bracco's daughter from her relationship with Harvey Keitel) played the four- or five-year-old Judy in the earlier parts of the film.
After time passes, Bracco's older daughter, Margaux Guerard (from Bracco's marriage to Daniel Guerard) played the 10-year-Judy.
While it's common to see twins play the same role at younger ages, or real-life siblings to play siblings on screen, for two separate siblings to play the same character at different ages is more unique, and quite fascinating.
10. Ten Frames Of Blood Had To Be Removed To Get The R-Rating
As we all know, the MPAA has strict guidelines over the content in movies that determines the rating it gets. Language and nudity can raise a PG-13 to an R, while the more extreme the violence is, the higher the rating.
In the case of Goodfellas, the violence was apparently just a bit too much for the MPAA's standards, according to IMDb.
Apparently, ten frames of blood had to be cut out of the movie in order to get it down to an R-Rating. It was just too much for their standards.
9. Some Of The Extras Were Allegedly Real Mobsters
Next time you watch the movie, you'll want to bear in mind that some of the extras in the film are actually real mobsters...at least, that's what Nicholas Pileggi claims.
According to Pileggi, actual mobsters were hired as extras to lend authenticity to scenes.
Given their, erm, occupations, they supposedly gave fake social security numbers to Warner Bros., so it's unknown how they received their paychecks.
Unless Pileggi's just pulling our legs, this certainly made the production a lot more interesting, and scary.
8. The Body Count Is Surprisingly Low
Goodfellas is a violent movie, but it has a shockingly low body count of 10, and only five are murders we actually see take place.
For the deaths that we do see happen, that list includes Spider (Michael Imperioli), Billy Batts (Frank Vincent), Stacks Edwards (Samuel L. Jackson), Morrie (Chuck Low), and Tommy (Joe Pesci).
The rest of the list includes the five bodies that we see following the Lufthansa heist, in the aforementioned "Layla sequence."
Make no mistake, Goodfellas is a very violent movie, and there are constant threats of violence throughout, but the actual body count is surprisingly tame. The Departed actually has more than twice this film's body count (22).
7. The Morrie's Wigs Commercial Was The First Scene Filmed
Movies typically don't have their scenes shot in order, so the first scene of a movie is rarely, if ever, the first scene that was actually shot. And the first scene filmed for Goodfellas is a pretty surprising one.
The low-budget Morrie's Wigs infomercial was actually the first scene that was shot for the movie, and interestingly it wasn't even directed by Scorsese.
Inspired by a low-budget commercial for a replacement window company, Scorsese contacted the company. The person in the ad, Stephen R. Pacca, owned the company and created the ad himself.
In order to make it look like an authentic local ad, Scorsese hired Pacca to write, direct, and edit the commerical for Morrie's Wigs. Pacca definitely nailed its low-budget, amateur nature.
6. Joe Pesci Didn't Expect To Win An Oscar
Although it was nominated for a total of six Academy Awards, the film criminally only won one of them, that being the best supporting actor award for Joe Pesci.
Pesci, however, didn't think he was going to win, so when he was announced as the winner, he was taken entirely by surprise.
Since he didn't think he would win, he had no acceptance speech, so all he managed to utter out was "It's my privilege. Thank you." This is reportedly the sixth shortest acceptance speech in Academy Award history.
Strange how a film expected to win big at the Oscars only took home one award, which the recipient didn't even expect.
5. The Vindicator
In the final scene of the film, Hill emerges from his witness protection house and picks up a newspaper from the porch, like another "average nobody" who gets to live the rest of his life "like a schnook."
On the surface, it doesn't look like there's anything of significance here, but Scorsese carefully and intentionally placed a subtle detail with the newspaper that Hill picks up.
That newspaper is a copy of The Vindicator, a paper that runs in Youngstown, Ohio, a town that has had history with the mafia.
Scorsese included the paper as a homage to Youngstown, or as it's sometimes called, "Mobtown, USA."
4. Scorsese Did Not Want Liotta To Meet With Hill
For the duration of the film's production, the cast and crew contacted many of the people involved in the true story to make the film as authentic as possible. Nicolas Pileggi contacted Henry Hill many times while writing the script. However, there was one person that Scorsese didn't want to contact Hill, that being Ray Liotta.
Scorsese reportedly didn't want Liotta to meet with Hill because he had never directed him before, and he was afraid that Hill would have an influence on Liotta's performance, which he wanted to avoid.
After Hill died in 2012, Liotta claimed that he did have a few meetings with Hill, but only a few, and he never got to know him well.
Liotta also revealed that he would listen to taped interviews of Hill and Nicholas Pileggi while driving to and from set, noting that Hill casually discussed murders and other crimes while eating potato chips.
3. The Copa Tracking Shot Wasn't Planned
The long tracking shot through the Copacobana nightclub is one of the film's most memorable sequences, but it was never a planned part of the movie.
The filmmakers couldn't get permission to go in the short way, so they were forced to go in around the back. Martin Scorsese decided to go ahead and film the sequence in one unbroken shot.
Scorsese said this scene symbolizes that Henry's entire life was ahead of him. "It's his seduction of her (Karen), and it's also the lifestyle seducing him."
According to Illeana Douglas, Scorsese was inspired by the long Steadicam shot in another classic gangster film, Brian De Palma's The Untouchables.
The sequence was also shot eight times before they finally got it right.
2. The Actors Didn't Quite Match Their Real-Life Counterparts
When adapting a movie from real-life events, creative liberties are going to be taken, even if it's mostly historically accurate.
In the case of Goodfellas, some of those liberties came with the actors' portrayals, according to this piece.
Ray Liotta was "tall, stylish, slender and handsome", while the real Henry Hill was "short, homely and slovenly." Hill also spoke in a heavy working-class Brooklyn accent, while Liotta had a more Suburban voice. Also, Liotta portrayed Hill as a calm and intelligent young man, while the real Hill was an erratic and hopeless drug addict.
Joe Pesci's Tommy DeVito was based on Tommy DeSimone, and Hill himself said that Pesci's portrayal was 90-99% accurate. There was just one problem: the real Tommy was massively built, and had a moustache and long hair, pretty much the polar opposite of Pesci's appearance. Also, Pesci was in his 40s at the time, while DeSimone died at age 28.
Finally, Robert De Niro's Jimmy Conway looked nothing like his real-life counterpart, Jimmy Burke, who was tall and powerfully built, and had blue eyes and blondish-gray hair.
1. The Preview Screenings Didn't Go So Well
Goodfellas is one of the most critically acclaimed movies of all time, but no one would have predicted that based on the reactions of preview screenings.
Due to the extreme violence and language, the studio was nervous about the film, and it seemed their fears were justified after terrible preview screenings.
Nicolas Pileggi said that 70 people walked out of a screening in Orange County, California, because of how violent the film was.
According to an executive producer, one screening was so bad that the team hid in a bowling alley from an angry audience. One of the moviegoers even wrote "f**k you" on a comment card.
Overall, the film reportedly received the worst preview response in Warner Bros.' history, but that didn't stop the film from releasing unaltered and leaving behind a legacy as one of the greatest films ever.
Clearly, audiences back then just weren't as accustomed to the extreme violence and profanity we're used to today.