20 Things You Didn't Know About Star Trek Generations

Revisiting perhaps the most controversial Star Trek movie ever.

Star Trek Generations Picard Kirk
Paramount

Star Trek Generations occupies something of a liminal space (pun intended) in the sci-fi franchise - it's not all that good, nor is it all that bad. It's... basically OK?

The extensively marketed team-up between Captains Kirk (William Shatner) and Picard (Patrick Stewart) is bafflingly brief and Kirk's demise remains shockingly underwhelming to this day, but director David Carson still manages to squeeze some torch-passing fun out of the whole endeavour.

Despite its massively novel and unique hook, of bridging the gap between two epochs of Trek, Generations isn't discussed much outside of the hardcore fanbase these days, and so you couldn't really be blamed for knowing little of what went on behind the scenes.

From those inevitable production stumbles to storylines that almost made it to the screen, and implications made in other peripheral media, you almost certainly aren't aware of these 20 fascinating factoids about one of the more contentious entries in the cinematic Star Trek canon.

If you've ever wondered why a certain scene felt a little off, or why a specific character was bizarrely missing from the fray, here are the answers you've been looking for...

20. Gene Roddenberry Was Firmly Opposed To A TOS/TNG Team-Up

Star Trek Generations James T Kirk Jean Luc Picard William Shatner Patrick Stewart
Paramount

Generations was the first Trek movie to be produced following the death of creator Gene Roddenberry in 1991, and given Roddenberry's obstinate approach to deciding which stories could and couldn't be told, the creatives decided to push forward with bold new ideas following his death.

One such concept was the creative team's suggestion of a movie that teamed the Original Series cast up with the Next Generation roster, to which Roddenberry had previously expressed firm opposition.

While it'd be easy for fans to view such posthumous chicanery as disrespectful, especially so soon after Roddenberry's death, considering the man's reputation for being stubborn, difficult, and slow to accept change, there was shockingly little outcry.

Plus, how could any card-carrying Trekkie hear about a Kirk/Picard team-up and not get excited?


19. Paramount Allowed It To Go 40% Over Budget

Star Trek Generations Picard
Paramount

The budgets of the Star Trek movies have been all over the map, and though Generations' era-bridging premise was an easy sell to even the most casual Trek fan, Paramount nevertheless wanted to keep the budget tight.

An initial budget proposal was set at just over $30 million, slightly above Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country's $27 million price tag, with the extra costs largely incurred by planned shoots in Hawaii, Idaho, and the Midwestern United States.

But Paramount ended up nixing some of the location shoots to get the budget down to a svelte $25 million.

However, production overages and the necessity to spend an extra $5 million reshooting Kirk's (William Shatner) death following poor test reactions bloated the budget out to $35 million.

All in all Generations went 40% over-budget, though Paramount were smart enough to know that it was worth throwing extra cash at something as important as Kirk's death, even if in the eyes of many fans they ultimately still whiffed it.


18. Why The Uniforms Are Totally Random

Star Trek Generations
Paramount

Fans often question why the Starfleet crew throughout the film are wearing combinations of costumes from The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine, with seemingly no explanation or even basic consistency whatsoever.

The reason for this is that new uniforms had actually been designed for the Enterprise-D's crew, which would've included minor military-style variations on The Next Generation's uniforms, including coloured collars matching the rest of the outfit, rank pips on the shoulder, and rank braiding along the wrist.

Ultimately producer Rick Berman wasn't a fan, and so all the changes were scrapped save for a new angular comms badge design.

This decision occurred late enough in production that Jonathan Frakes and Levar Burton were forced to borrow costumes from Deep Space Nine's Avery Brooks and Colm Meaney, which naturally didn't fit so well.

Though there sadly aren't any surviving images of the planned new uniforms, the call was made too late to prevent a series of Playmates action figures based on the designs being produced and released.


17. The Saucer Crash Landing Was Originally Written For TNG's Season 6's Cliffhanger Ending

Star Trek Generations
Paramount

One of the most spectacular moments in the movie is the crash landing of the Enterprise's saucer-section, which impacts into the jungle on the planet Veridian III.

As unforgettable as it is, the sequence was actually originally written for The Next Generation's season six cliffhanger "Descent: Part I," but the SFX team insisted that they would struggle to execute the scene to satisfaction on a TV budget, and so recommended that it be saved for the next film.

And so, that's precisely what happened, with co-writer Brannon Braga holding onto the idea and finding a way to slot it into Generations.

Given that the sequence's VFX are impressively well-aged for the most part, it was absolutely the right call to hang on and wait for the money to match the scale of the idea.


16. Paramount Requested Carol Marcus' Removal From The Script

Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan Carol Marcus Kirk Bones
Paramount

The film's original script included a part for Captain Kirk's historic love interest Dr. Carol Marcus (Bibi Besch), for while Kirk and Marcus were long estranged by this point, Generations' novelisation presented them as friends - albeit not without Kirk making one more attempt to rekindle things.

Paramount execs ended up requesting that Carol be removed from the script, though, with the film's co-writer Ronald D. Moore explaining that the studio was worried about audiences getting confused by Carol's re-appearance.

Instead, Kirk gets saddled with the veritable non-character of Antonia (Lynn Salvatori), a woman scarcely seen throughout the film and to whom the audience has no emotional attachment whatsoever.

In a movie that has to explain the Nexus to audiences, worrying about Carol causing confusion is very much beside the point.


15. The Next Generation Cast Shot Their Scenes FOUR DAYS After Wrapping The Series

Star Trek Generations
Paramount

Generations was actually shot in conjunction with the final episodes of The Next Generation, resulting in a hectic production where principal photography was completed in just 51 days - a frankly impossibly short length of time for a modern Star Trek film.

To add to the stress, filming began less than eight months before the movie was due to hit cinemas, which again for any contemporary blockbuster is an absurd turnaround time.

The scenes that didn't require The Next Generation's cast members were filmed first while they wrapped up production on the series, and just four days after wrapping the show, they headed over to a separate soundstage to start filming the movie.

From the moment TNG's cast finished working on the series, there was a mere six months to go until Generations was due to release. That's what you call pressure.


14. Spock, Bones & Sulu Were Originally Meant To Appear

Star Trek IV
Paramount

Ultimately only three of the Original Series' crew appear in the film - Kirk, Scotty (James Doohan), and Chekov (Walter Koenig), though Spock (Leonard Nimoy), Bones (DeForest Kelley), and Sulu (George Takei) were originally meant to show up.

For starters, Leonard Nimoy was invited to both play Spock and direct the film, but felt the script didn't give him anything to do, and so his lines were largely given to Scotty instead.

In the case of DeForest Kelley, it was sadly down to the actor's ailing health, meaning he couldn't receive on-set insurance required to shoot any scenes, resulting in his dialogue being given to Chekov.

George Takei was called back to command the Enterprise-B, but refused on the grounds that serving under Kirk again would require Sulu's rank to be demoted. Instead, his daughter Demora (Jacqueline Kim) was introduced and given most of his lines.

Sadly some of the cast weren't informed about the Original Series cast members' absences, such as Whoopi Goldberg, who arrived to set expecting to share the screen with Nichelle Nichols.


13. Numerous Shots Were Recycled To Save Money

Star Trek Klingon
CBS

Because Paramount was desperately attempting to save money during the production, they ended up recycling expensive spaceship shots from prior Trek movies and TV.

Most infamously, shots of the Klingon Bird of Prey - namely its destruction - were lifted from Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, which was quite shamelessly released just three years earlier.

Also, some shots of the Enterprise-D were simply re-used from The Next Generation. Are these things the end of the world? No, but they make it clear just how eager Paramount was to cut corners, even if it made the production seem a little lazy and shoddy to fans eagle-eyed enough to notice.

The Bird of Prey explosion is especially unforgiveable - just imagine a new MCU movie trying to get away with recycling one of its many distinctive shots from a few years ago.


12. An Early Concept Involved The Two Enterprise Crews Fighting

Star Trek Generations Picard Kirk
CBS

One of the earliest concepts for Generations involved having the two generations of Enterprise crews battle one another. Co-writer Ronald D. Moore said, "We were obsessed with the poster image of the two Enterprises locked in combat: Kirk vs. Picard, One Must Die!"

In terms of an image that would easily sell to fans, Moore certainly wasn't wrong, but unsurprisingly problems quickly arose when the writers attempted to develop the idea further - namely, what event could possibly bring Kirk and Picard into deathly conflict?

As Batman v Superman proved a few years ago, the circumstances that could make two beloved heroes fight tend to be contrived and unconvincing at best.

While seeing the two Enterprises fire on one another or Kirk and Picard throw down would've generated thermonuclear levels of fan service, would it have actually made a lick of sense?


11. Kirk's Death Was Spoiled Before It Was Even Shot

Star Trek Generations Kirk Death William Shatner
Paramount Pictures

Though script leaks are infinitely more disastrous today where everybody has a portable camera-equipped computer in their pocket, they weren't exactly a picnic three decades ago either.

By March 1994, when Generations was just starting principal photography, a script had been leaked in fan circles and online, revealing both the film's energy ribbon conceit and, most alarmingly, the death of Kirk.

To make matters worse, Scotty actor James Doohan confirmed the script's legitimacy at a fan convention the very same month, causing his presumably panicked agent to claim that he hadn't actually seen the completed script.

In September 1994, some two months before Generations was due to release, another copy leaked online, ensuring the fandom was well aware of what was coming before it happened.

Hilariously, Paramount delayed the release of the film's musical score until three weeks after the movie hit cinemas to protect against spoilers, what with one of the climactic tracks being bluntly entitled "Kirk's Death."

Could they really have not just... named the track something else?

Hollywood evidently didn't learn its lesson, though, as five years later John Williams' score for Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace infamously included a track called "Qui-Gon's Noble End." Worse still in that case, it was available more than two weeks before the movie's release. Oof.


10. It Was The First Film Ever Marketed With A Website

Star Trek Generations
Paramount

Though the Internet was certainly a thing by 1994, believe it or not Generations was the first film in history to have its own official promotional website.

The site, generations.viacom.com, went online three weeks prior to the movie's release, and presented an interface in the style of the Enterprise's iconic Library Computer Access/Retrieval System (LCARS) operating system.

The site included a trailer for the film, sound clips and photos, behind-the-scenes materials, and a Star Trek shop.

For a short while it was one of the most popular sites on the Web, though unlike other promotional websites of the era - such as the Space Jam site from 1996, which is still online today - it didn't stand the test of time and eventually disappeared into the cyber-ether.


9. The Novelisation Features The Original Ending & Kirk's Funeral

Star Trek: Generations
Paramount

The first edition of Generations' novelisation contains a number of ideas from earlier scripts that were ultimately discarded, as well as the original ending that was eventually reshot.

The novel includes Kirk's original death where he's fatally shot in the back by Soran (Malcolm McDowell), and Soran is then killed when Picard shoots him with his own disruptor pistol.

This edition also included Kirk's funeral, with a scene where Spock would hesitate to enter the church because it meant admitting that Kirk really was dead, before Bones convinces him to enter.

Soon enough a second edition of the novelisation was released which was more movie-faithful, especially with regard to Kirk's demise.


8. Data Uses Profanity To Avoid A "G" Rating

Star Trek: Generations Data
CBS Media Ventures

It's of course no secret that the vast majority of blockbuster movie releases aim for a PG-13 rating, because a more adult-skewing R-rating can be incredibly risky where larger-budget material is concerned.

But there's also a fascinating, largely unspoken phenomenon that goes the other way, whereby studios prefer to avoid their bigger-budget live-action movies getting a mild G-rating, because it has historically stunted the box office of films that aren't strictly family-friendly.

G gives the impression that a film is harmlessly inoffensive to all, and in the context of Star Trek that might imply it's toothless and sanitised to a fault.

And so, the decision was made to include a single piece of profanity to boost it to a PG rating, when Data (Brent Spiner) memorably says, "Oh s**t!" as the Enterprise takes a dive.

Ultimately only one more Trek film after this, Insurrection, was rated PG, with the franchise deferring to the blockbuster-typical PG-13 from that point onward. First Contact, sandwiched between the two movies, was meanwhile the series' first PG-13 entry.


7. The Death Of Picard's Family Was Patrick Stewart's Suggestion

Star Trek Generations Picard
Paramount

One of the most memorable aspects of Generations' plot is the revelation that Picard's brother Robert and nephew René died in a fire, though Picard's anguish was originally considerably less dramatic than this.

The script initially had Picard learn that his brother had died of a heart attack while in his vineyard, but Patrick Stewart suggested that the news had to be more dire and upsetting than this by extending to the future of his family name.

Further still, Stewart also said it had to be a harsh, unpleasant means of death, hence the fire. To Stewart's credit he absolutely commits to the heartbreak of these scenes, deepening Picard's characterisation as a result.


6. Captain Harriman's Family Are A Ferris Bueller Easter Egg

Star Trek Generations Alan Ruck
Paramount Pictures

Enterprise-B captain John Harriman (Alan Ruck) will never rank among anyone's favourite Trek captains, but it's probably not entirely fair to disparage him with such a brief amount of screen time, especially when he's commanding an under-stocked ship, wasn't expecting anything beyond a gentle cruise, and has to deal with the abject stress of Kirk watching him work.

But one of the most amusing nuggets of information about an otherwise bland and uninteresting character comes from Harriman's personnel file in the 1998 video game Star Trek: Starship Creator.

The file mentions that Harriman has "a wife named Sloane and a son named Ferris who both live in Chicago, as well as interests in 20th century Italian sports automobiles."

This is of course all a big cutesy reference to actor Alan Ruck's much-loved role as Cameron in Ferris Bueller's Day Off, and while the canonicity of this file can perhaps be disputed, does anything in Harriman's brief screen time actually contradict it? Nope.


5. Reshoots Were Completed Just Weeks Before Release

Star Trek Generations Picard
Paramount

The film's massively rushed production schedule was exacerbated by the fact that crucial reshoots had to be conducted in October 1994, literally weeks before it opened.

The scene where Picard is in the Nexus and imagines himself at home with his family was shot in an actual house in California, and while the initial shoot occurred in May 1994 along with principal photography, the crew had to return there five months later to add Picard's nephew René to the scene.

While these reshoots obviously weren't technically complex as they didn't require much, if anything, in terms of VFX, the production was still cutting it massively fine to get the picture locked and completed before release date.


4. Kirk Can Be Saved In The Video Game Ending

Star Trek Generations Game Soran
Paramount

A video game based on the movie and bearing the very same title was released for PC in May 1997, some six months after Generations' movie sequel First Contact had actually been released. Oops.

The game was a first-person shooter which touted the novel feature of allowing players to effectively save Kirk's life and prevent his controversial demise.

While you can have things play out as in the movie if you so wish, you're also able to capture Soran before he visits Veridian III and defeat his starship, preventing the Enterprise-D's destruction and in turn negating Kirk's death.

In this scenario, Kirk isn't actually involved in the game's story and is presumed to simply remain safe and happy within the Nexus.


3. The Nexus Gave Guinan Her "Sixth Sense" In An Early Draft

Star Trek Generations Picard Guinan
Paramount PIctures

A fascinating element of Generations' story that was frustratingly removed from the script is the implication that when Guinan enters the Nexus along with some of the other El-Aurians in 2293, this is responsible for developing her famous "sixth sense" to see beyond the bounds of time and space.

This of course runs counter to the assertion from fans of The Next Generation that this is a trait common to the El-Aurians. But it's backed up by the movie's companion comic book, which similarly mentions that Guinan was fundamentally changed by her brief stint in the Nexus.

It's certainly one of the film's more interesting story ideas, and so quite a frustration exclusion.


2. William Shatner Wrote A Sequel Novel "Fixing" Kirk's Death

Star Trek The Return
Pocket Books

Following the overwhelmingly negative fan response to Kirk's death - more the nature of it than the actual death itself - William Shatner decided to write his own sequel novel, The Return, with fellow scribes Garfield Reeves-Stevens and Judith Reeves-Stevens.

Published in April 1996, the novel saw the Romulans align with the Borg to bring Kirk back to life using alien technology, before implanting false memories in his mind to turn him against Picard and the crew of the Enterprise.

In the end Kirk is broken free of his conditioning and sacrifices himself to destroy the Borg, but given that Spock can still sense him via their mind-meld, he doesn't really believe Kirk is dead.

It's in many ways a more satisfying send-off for Kirk than Generations, except that the next entry in the "Shatnerverse" series of novels, 1997's Avenger, swiftly confirmed Kirk's survival thanks to a lucky last-minute transporter beam-out.


1. The Nexus Energy Ribbon Was An Extremely Complicated Effect

Star Trek Generations
Paramount

Despite the aforementioned budget cuts, many of the movie's visual effects have actually aged pretty well, such as the Nexus' beautiful-but-terrifying energy ribbon.

Director David Carson has famously called the energy ribbon the "true villain" of the movie, due to the enormous time and general resources its creation expended during the hurried production.

Due to there being no direct frame of reference for the ribbon in nature, Industrial Light and Magic had to conceptualise it themselves, with legendary effects supervisor John Knoll modelling aspects of the ribbon from magnetic fields around Uranus and electrical storms.

It's incredibly easy to take such effects for granted today, but back in the early days of complex CGI, stuff like this was just a massive headache. The end result was well worth it, at least.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.