3 Gangster Films That Explore The American Immigrant Experience

The United States has become the broth of international culture. Migrating from a mother country to the €˜land of opportunity€™ has become a trend for various nationalities through generations. This was €“ and continues to be €“ as a result of social and economic anxieties, from which different cultures hoped to escape. Post-World War I America, especially, developed into a lucrative to live, since €œa new conservatism was replacing progressive politics, a burgeoning industrial growth was signaling unparalleled prosperity, and new technologies were changing the face of society and communications€ (Rollins, 2003, p. 15). Cinema, unsurprisingly, also benefitted from this urban modernization, and the immigrant experience that affected America since its inception turned into one of the many subjects that filmmakers survey even until today. This article will explore how the immigrant experience is addressed within the Hollywood gangster genre in relation to the Irish, Jewish, and Italian ethnicities within three different films.

3. Gangs Of New York

Bill the Butcher

Irish Americans started immigrating to the United States many decades prior to the Revolutionary War, but their population peaked to new levels during the potato famine years of 1846 to 1855. The Irish American claims €œthe Irish made up 45.6 per cent of all immigrants in the United States (in the 1840s), and 35.2 percent in the 1850s€ (Kenny, 2000, p. 104). Additional factors like €œdiscriminatory British laws (and) the enclosure movement on the land€ (Rollins, 2003, p. 249) prompted Irish Catholics to settle in foreign areas, and their legacy has not been ignored in cinema. The Irish American has been portrayed in Hollywood gangster films as early as the The Public Enemy (1931), but one gangster film that specifically depicts this period of substantial immigration is Gangs of New York. Leonardo DiCaprio plays Amsterdam, an American-born Irish immigrant who witnesses the death of his father at the hands of Bill €˜The Butcher€™ Cutting (Daniel Day-Lewis), a €œfirst generation mob boss based on the real life William [€] Poole (1821-1855)€ (McCarty, 2004, p. 204). Amsterdam€™s father (Liam Neeson) is killed in a battle between Irish immigrants and the €˜natives€™, who consider themselves Americans solely due to their elongated ancestry in the United States. The film takes place in 1846 at this point of the narrative, which coincides with the early stages of the Irish famine. Naturally, the film then flash-forwards to 1862, when Amsterdam returns as a grown up and when €œone-fourth of the population of New York City [€] was Irish-born€ (Kenny, 2000, p. 106). The immigrant experience is directly addressed in the scenes following Amsterdam€™s arrival. They constantly endure public discrimination and humiliation by the Americans as soon as stepping off the ships, since they are branded as €œtargets of an American nativism that insisted on a homogenous society based on Anglo-Saxon, Protestant cultural values€ (McCaffrey, 1976, p. 85). As Amsterdam rekindles himself with his home city, the crowds of Irish laborers are immediately noticeable. McCaffrey adds that €œwomen took jobs as servants or shirt makers [€] (and) men worked as stable boys; bartenders, bouncers, and potboys in saloons; street sweepers; dockers; and canal diggers€ (1976, p. 64). As stated by Kenny, the Irish immigrants were clearly at the bottom of the social scale and €œhad to take whatever positions were available; they could not afford to be too choosy, given that most of them were virtually penniless and many were hungry, diseased, and dying€ (2000, p. 209). Amsterdam seeks to avenge his father€™s death by slaying Cutting, but, as said by Cutting himself, €œeverything you see belongs to me, to one degree or another [€] everybody owes, everybody pays because that€™s how you stand up against the rising of the tide€. Cutting has risen to the top of the gangster chain since the death of Amsterdam€™s father at €œFive Points, where the seeds of organized crime in America took root€ (McCarty, 2004, p. 205). Amsterdam€™s only feasible method of revenge is by befriending the enemy first and backstabbing him later. In order to accomplish this, Amsterdam has to prove himself through thievery at the lower stages of the gangster chain. Criminality amongst Irish immigrants rooted in America over a century before the events in Gangs. Kenny writes, €œat least 10000 of the indentured servants who left Ireland for the American colonies between 1700 and 1775 did so as convicts (who were) vagrants and petty thieves [€] sentenced to long terms of involuntary servitude and transported to America€ (2000, p. 21). Irish crime only intensified throughout the years, and from €œ1856 to 1863, at least half of the inmates of the Boston House of Correction were Irish€ (McCaffrey, 1976, p. 68). With crime a common practice in the north east, thievery is one of Amsterdam€™s virtues, such as when he stuffs his pockets with various costly materials prior to saving Johnny Sirocco from a fire €“ two acts which finally garner Cutting€™s attention. Cutting may dream of butchering every single Irish limb from his city, but he values €œsuch qualities as respect and honor, particularly in (his) enemies€ (McCarty, 2004, p. 206) €“ assets that €œwould later become hard, sometimes lethal, currency to the American mafia, which [€] is still a quarter of a century away from blossoming€ (ibid). He notices Amsterdam€™s potential after this, and he takes him under his wing. A sub-plot in the film has to be mentioned at this point, and it revolves around the drafts for the ongoing Civil War. Cutting and the natives despise the thought of the abolishment of slavery, which is expressed plainly when Cutting darts one of his knives to a poster of Abraham Lincoln. Amsterdam, meanwhile, expresses indifference (along with tones of curiosity) about the war when he is handed a flier that promotes enlisting for the Union. The drafting process was not as lenient and optional as portrayed in Gangs, since a new draft law €œpermitted men to purchase substitutes to satisfy their military obligations€ (McCaffrey, 1976, p. 68). Evidently, the Irish lower class could not afford these replacements. Scorsese foreshadows the film€™s climax using this Irish demoralization with the aforementioned examples. In short, Cutting eventually uncovers Amsterdam€™s true intentions. This eventually leads to a climactic battle, which mirrors the one at the film€™s start €“ a battle between Cutting€™s natives and Amsterdam€™s immigrants. However, €œthey all find themselves in the middle of the Draft Riots (of 1863), provoked by immigrant opposition to conscription by the Union Army, which destroy both gangs and irrevocably alter the immigrant experience€ (Nochimson, 2007, p. 207). In reality, €œthe Irish believed themselves to be in competition for jobs with African Americans€ (Kenny, 2000, pp. 125-126) €“ a factor completely ignored in the film. Kenny continues by saying that €œfor four days, mobs of Irish workers [€] roamed the waterfront in search of black workers, beating lynching, and driving them out€ (ibid), which is one of the historical deviations in Gangs€™ narrative. The film reaches its denouement after Amsterdam kills Cutting, and a montage of Manhattan€™s subsequent modernization from 1863 to the present ends the picture. One of the many messages delivered through this montage encapsulates the immigrant experience. The Irish immigrants after 1870 lowered €œthe Irish crime rate in the United States [€] and the Irish American community began to build a more respectable image€ (McCaffrey, 1976, p. 76). Nevertheless, other ethnicities would migrate to America in the near future, and they would cement their legacies €“ good and bad €“ into cities that would soon mature into major metropolises. Amsterdam€™s final words are, €œthe rest of time would be like no one even knew we was ever here€; the Jewish Americans prove otherwise.

2. Once Upon A Time In America

Once Upon a Time in America

Jewish American immigrants started €œarriving in New Amsterdam as early as 1654, but the crew of Christopher Columbus [€] included €˜marranos€™ (Jews who hid their religion to escape the Spanish Inquisition) and €˜conversos€™ (Jews who converted during the Inquisition)€ (Rollins, 2003, p. 263). However, the highest levels of Jewish immigration occurred from 1880 to 1920, where €œnearly 2.5 million Jews left Eastern Europe (and) nine out of ten chose the United States as their destination€ (Gay, 1996, p. 3). Reasons for their interest in America differed from country to country, but these generally involved poverty, war, and social seclusion at home. For instance, the Romanian regime €œrefused to grant its Jewish inhabitants the right of citizenship€ (Gay, 1996, p. 19) after the Russo-Turkish War, which established Romania as an independent kingdom in 1878. As a result, the Jewish American gangster rose after this period of immigration; the €œJewish success in organized crime in the 1920s and 1930s [€] transformed crime from a haphazard, small-scale activity into a [€] well-financed business operation€ (Brodkin, 1998, p. 33). It all started with the talents of Arnold Rothstein and Big Jack Zelig, but these two €œcame out of good solid middle class homes; others completely circumvented youth gangs in arriving at their criminal vocations€ (Fried, 1980, p. 40). The gangster genre portrayed Jewish gangsters like in Fried€™s description as early as 1928 with William Nigh€™s Four Walls. Sergio Leone€™s Once Upon a Time in America, though, would staple the rise of the Jewish American through €œan epic tale of how a group of people went after their share of the American dream, in the only way that bright but uneducated, streetwise males knew how to proceed€ (Brode, 1995, p. 101). Shadoian describes Leone€™s characters as €œa group of thugs who take their ghetto life of hard survival as a springboard of how to get ahead: exercising power, racking up profits, [€] (and) never thinking twice of the justifiability of violence€ (2003, p. 285). The film starts chronologically-wise €œby portraying the origins of the youth gang they form in order to protect themselves from the brutality of their environment€ (Mason, 2002, p. 143), and these ghettos deliver the immigrant experience as soon as they appear on screen, since the €œLower East Side (as the neighborhood is called) underworld was a culture of young people€ (Fried, 1980, p. 36). Noodles€™ (Robert DeNiro) and Max€™s (James Woods) youth gang and lifestyle are exhibited through the former€™s flashbacks. A similar environment to the one in Gangs, Leone€™s Lower East Side is firstly seen when a young Noodles chases after a young Deborah. However, the labor in America is dissimilar to Gangs in various levels. Jewish workforce is immediately identifiable between the crowds, and it correlates with Gay€™s description: €œmany Jewish couples opened little stores in the neighborhoods where they lived €“ groceries, dry goods, butchers, fish stores€ (1996, p. 159). In other words, immigrant jobs appeared to improve in the social scale since the mid-19th century, but they were not any easier. It must be noted that this was during the American industrial revolution and immigrants €œbecame its factory workers [€] (and) the majority of mining [€] workers€ (Brodkin, 1998, p. 55). These jobs were the main reason why immigration to America in the early 20th century sounded promising, but the dissatisfaction of €œsix or seven dollars a week€ (Fried, 1980, p. 7) founded the ascension of organized crime. Prohibition is the film€™s epicenter, and this was an era of the illegalization of manufacturing and selling alcohol, which €œfostered the growth of large-scale enterprises that could monopolize production and distribution, just as a few [€] corporations dominated the steel, oil, and automobile industries€ (Newburn, 2007, p. 409). Prohibition is referenced a few of scenes later, where Noodles, Max, and the rest of the gang develop a floating device that would guarantee their success in the art of bootlegging. After witnessing that their device works, a scene follows in which their clothing switches from old rags to distinguished suits. Their rise €“ and their background €“ is comparable to Waxey Gordon€™s, a Jewish gangster who €œworked for one or another of the gangs that still roamed the neighborhood streets, variously as a labor goon, strikebreaker, dope peddler, burglar, extortionist, etc; prohibition allowed him to add booze to his repertoire€ (Fried, 1980, pp. 94-95). In fact, Fried uncovers the irony behind the Prohibition, since banning the €˜devil€™s drink€™ served as the catalyst for the rise of Jewish American gangsters as shown in America. He writes: €œprohibition had come along [€] (and) we observed the effects of change: how the Waxey Gordons of America had been raised from obscurity to wealth and power, how [€] Jewish gangsters had been granted a [€] new lease on life€ (1980, p. 132). Without the Prohibition, gangster criminality may have been contained to €˜only€™ gambling and prostitution, with the latter taking place in America €œafter a beat cop steals (the gang€™s) booty, (and) they catch him having sex with the underage prostitute Peggy (Julie Cohen) and blackmail him into cooperation€ (Yaquinto, 1998, p. 145).

1. The Godfather: Part II

The Jewish gangster has constantly been overshadowed by the Italian, however, and there have been countless films depicting its cultural background since the establishment of the Little Italies. The Italian American is more commonly associated with organized crime than any other ethnicity, and Coppola€™s The Godfather II offers the immigrant experience through Vito Corleone€™s storyline. Alike the Jews, a great number of Italians migrated to the Americas during 1880 to 1920, and most €œwere peasants who left Southern Italy only to exchange rural for urban poverty€ (Rollins, 2003, p. 256). According to Ferraro, the main aspiration to a life in America was the transition to a city of opportunity, since most Italians came from villages where €œa train did not go, electricity was scarcely a rumor, and [€] women still lugged water by donkey and on their heads€ (2005, p. 31). This diverges away from the Jews and the Irish, who migrated to the New World partially to escape social reclusion; Italy actually underwent peacetime throughout the majority of this period of immigration. 1870 to 1914 went through €œthe technologies of the Second Industrial Revolution (that) allowed nations to reinvent their economies, [€] 1896 marked the end of the international depression, and (it was) the liquidation of Italy€™s Ethiopian War€ (Choate, 2008, p. 76). Even so, Italian laborers could earn higher wages abroad, and due to €œthe pressures of industrialization and changing markets, transoceanic emigration became more attractive and more necessary€ (Choate, 2008, p. 3). Vito€™s (Robert DeNiro) immigrant experience in Godfather II differs to the one of the average Italian, since the mafia€™s intervention prompted young Vito€™sescape to the Americas. His father and his brother are assassinated by Don Ciccio, who also wishes to kill the remaining son in order to avoid any revenge plot in the near future. Vito€™s mother sacrifices herself in order to save him, and Vito runs away. He is then smuggled onto a ship heading to Ellis Island. Once in America, though, Vito endures an entire process in order to enter the country, which differs significantly with Amsterdam€™s liberal experience in Gangs. In this period, immigration restrictions were severe. Between 1875 to 1917, €œconvicts and prostitutes, the Chinese, lunatics, [€] people with contagious diseases, [€] (and others) were put in the list of undesirables€ (Mauk & Oakland, 1995, p. 70). Vito is diagnosed with smallpox, and therefore is separated into this crowd of the €™undesired€™. Coppola follows up with a tracking shot displaying the magnitude of America€™s multiculturalism, and the many languages provide the audible essence of an immigrant experience prior to legally entering America. Years pass, and Vito works at Abbandando Grosseria as an adult. He lives in the Lower East Side, and theenvironment is nearly identical to the one in America. The main difference are the ethnicities that fill the frame, given that the community in America is predominantly Jewish, whereas in Coppola€™s film, Italian. Several events begin to lure Vito away from his conventional lifestyle, such as losing his €œjob because the grocer is forced to hire the nephew of the Black Hand €“ the local extortionist named Fanucci who makes everyone in the neighborhood pay protection money€ (Yaquinto, 1998, p. 136). The Black Hand did not represent €œan actual organization but a criminal phenomenology, a form of crime practiced by groups that operated independently [€] (and) focused on skimming from the economic transactions of the poor€ (Lupo, 2009, p. 145). Vito, although composed, is upset after how Fanucci has affected his life. Conversely, he also learns that €œevery man can and should make his own success, while society at large benefits from this competition and regulates it for maximum efficiency€ (Browne, 2000, p. 60). He despises Fanucci for various reasons, but as he says himself, €œif he€™s Italian, why does he bother other Italians?€. Ferraro explains that €œItalians in America had turned to crime not only because they didn€™t yet have the forms of knowledge and cultural capital, [€] but also [€] because [€] underground entrepreneurship is effective at keeping families together€ (2005, p. 110). Vito personifies this quote exquisitely, since the humbleness that he proffers to his immigrant compatriots €“ the very same one visible in The Godfather (Coppola, 1972) €“ turns into his forte. Vito takes over the neighborhoods control after killing Fanucci, and he becomes €œa beneficial feudal lord [€] (that) helped all. Not only that, but he helped them with goodwill, with encouraging words to take the bitter sting out of the charity he gave them€ (Gardaphé, 2006, p. 39). In a way, Vito€™s higher concern for others than for himself may be what allowed him to climb to the level seen in the prequel, which someone with Fanucci€™s character would not accomplish. The immigrant experience is applicable in this context because it €œcontrasts the highly regulated and ruthlessly enforced codes of honor and obedience imported from Sicily with the ineffectual and corrupt forces of authority that immigrants encounter in America€ (Silver & Ursini, 2007, p. 171). Vito€™s methods may be on the dirty side of the law, but naming him a self-appointed benevolent dictator may be too rough. If anything, he is a harsh democrat who wanders around, listens, and complies with the wishes of his immigrant brothers and sisters.


I Am An American As beautifully printed by Clarens, €œwhen pictures started to talk and sing and make noises, they altered forever the way we perceive reality€ (1997, p. 40). The immigrant experience in the gangster films above offer a dimension unfound in ones prior to New Hollywood. With the influences of Italian Neo-Realism, these films can also be considered as documentaries due to their truthful environments and societies. Films like The Public Enemy, Four Walls, and Little Caesar (1931) may be classics in the gangster genre because of the heritage that they initiated through the €˜talkies€™; Scorsese, Leone, and Coppola only perfected it. Scorsese focuses on the tensions between the €˜natives€™ and the Irish Catholics; Leone focuses on the astonishing age in which crime swayed the Jewish underworld during the Prohibition; Coppola focuses on Vito€™s arrival to America as a child, and the care for his fellow immigrants as an adult. As printed in Newburn€™s book, €œthe Irish came first, [€] (then) were succeeded by Jews, and the Italians came last [€] on the rungs of time€ (2007, p. 413). No other quote could be more appropriate.

Bibliography

Brode, D., 1995. Money, Women, and Guns: Crime Movies from Bonnie and Clyde to Present. New York: Carol Publishing Group. Browne, N. ed., 2000. Francis Ford Coppola€™s The Godfather Trilogy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Brodkin, K., 1998. How Jews Became White Folks & What That Says About Race in America. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. Clarens, C., 1997. Crime Movies: An Illustrated History of the Gangster Genre from D.W. Griffith to Pulp Fiction. New York: Da Capo Press. Choate, M. I., 2008. Emigrant Nation: The Making of Italy Abroad. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Ferraro, T. J., 2005. Feeling Italian: The Art of Ethnicity in America. New York: New York University Press. Fried, A., 1980. The Rise and Fall of the Jewish Gangster in America. New York: Columbia University Press. Gardaphé, F. L., 2006. From Wiseguys to Wise Men. New York: Routledge. Gay, R., 1996. Unfinished People: Eastern European Jews Encounter America. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc. Kenny, K., 2000. The American Irish: A History. Essex: Pearson Education Ltd. Lupo, S., 2009. History of the Mafia. Translated from Italian to English by Antony Shuggar. New York: Columbia University Press. Mason, F., 2002. American Gangster Cinema: From Little Caesar to Pulp Fiction. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Mauk, D. and Oakland, J., 1995. American Civilization. New York: Routledge. McCaffrey, L. J., 1976. The Irish Diaspora in America. London: Indiana University Press. McCarty, J., 2004. Bullets Over Hollywood: The American Gangster Picture from the Silents to €œThe Sopranos€. Cambridge: Da Capo Press. Newburn, T., 2007. Criminology. Portland: Willan Publishing. Nochimson, M. P., 2007. Dying to Belong: Gangster Movies in Hollywood and Hong Kong. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing. Rollins, P. C. ed., 2003. The Columbia Companion to American History on Film. New York: Columbia University Press. Shadoian, J., 2003. Dreams and Dead Ends: The American Gangster Film. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Silver, A. and Ursini, J. eds., 2007. Gangster Film Reader. Pompton Plains: Limelight Editions. Yaquinto, M., 1998. Pump €˜Em Full of Lead: A Look at Gangsters on Film. New York: Twayne Publishers.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm currently enrolled in the Film Studies program at the University of Copenhagen in Denmark. If you haven't guessed by now, movies and media are as a big of a passion for me as they are for you and would love to hear what you've gotta say as well!