5 Changes That Would Have Improved Pulp Fiction

pulpfiction-main Pulp Fiction: almost twenty years old and still inspiring, delighting and intriguing a new generation of movie watchers and film fanatics. I should know as I only saw Pulp Fiction in the summer of last year, during a self-prescribed 'summer of film'. Fortunately, the film confirmed what I thought I knew after seeing Kill Bill and Death Proof: Quentin Tarantino is a genius. With new movie Django Unchained coming out very soon, the universally positive early reviews seem to indicate a return to the mixture of humour, blood, action and strong characters that have become part of Tarantino's love letters to pop culture and film genres and as recognisable as the Bride's yellow jumpsuit, Michael Madsen's dark dance to "Stuck In The Middle With You" and that Quarter Pounder conversation. However, rather than being a big gushing love letter to one of cinema's most prolific and inventive writers, producers and directors, this article is a critique of suggestions that could have elevated Pulp Fiction even further into something stronger, even more fun and enjoyable and perhaps a deeper, more existential and a more contemplative film about society and life itself.

5. Actually Show 'Fox Force Five'

pulpfiction-fiveforcefive This is definitely a fanservice and one dear to my heart, but when Uma Thurman's Mia Wallace, a one-time-actress-turned-trophy-wife describes her failed pilot, Fox Force Five, we should have seen more. FFF was about a team of five heroic and utterly badass women all with special talents and expertise in different skills (knives, demolitions, espionage, sex...) and I instantly wanted to see even just a few minutes of this pilot, which still, after almost twenty years, sounds better than about 70% of TV. Not only do a lot of the descriptions of the women sound uncannily like precursors to the women warriors Tarantino would envision and create for Kill Bill, but it also sounds like a great, Charlie's Angels-esque blast of fun that would have made for one hell of a DVD extra.

4. Lose the S&M Angle

pulpfiction-rape Butch's story is easily the 'odd one out' in terms of narrative - his life intersects the main threads of Marsellus, Vincent and Jules and is largely separate in comparison. However, it's also a damn good story and has Bruce Willis at his comedic and acting prime as he plays Butch, a washed-out boxer who has just beaten his opponent in the ring to death in order to rig the results and escape his life, betraying his boss. However, through trying to retrieve his father's golden watch, he and Marsellus (the man he just betrayed) are kidnapped and placed inside a basement dungeon where sadistic owners Maynard and Zed proceed to rape Marsellus in a frighteningly quiet and underplayed sequence. The most jarring thing about this whole section is that the rape is played utterly at odds with the violent but light attitude to the rest of the film - there's no eleventh-hour rescue before Marsellus is brutally violated, it's a bitterly dark section that I suspect could have done with hinting at without going the whole hog.

3. Give the Supporting Characters More To Do

pulpfiction-supporting The supporting and side characters truly add to the texture of the film with their presence and personalities, propelling not just the main characters' arcs but also giving the sense that while each segment is seemingly self-contained, there is a wider world outside of Pulp Fiction's Los Angeles and that the random people that intersect there on a regular basis, have their own unique stories and histories. My two favourite examples for this are Esmarelda Villalobos, Butch's taxi driver, and Winston Wolf, a 'clean up' expert in the pay of Marsellus. Both of them get a limited amount of screentime and while they certainly work and move the storyline along, they're both immensely fun to watch and listen to. Villalobos is a wonderfully macabre, mortality-obsessed riot, poking underneath the rough veneer of Butch's boxer stereotype with her questioning about death and we'd have loved to have seen her interacting with other characters. Winston Wolf meanwhile, we could watch for an hour without getting bored, particularly as he seems at odds with his life but remains utterly cool and professional - from taking a call at a party he seems to be hosting with his family to ordering about trained hitmen without batting an eyelid, I personally would love to be as cool as Winston. Or have him as my life organiser.

2. Give Fabienne Something To Do

pulpfiction-fabienne That isn't to say that Fabienne isn't likeable - from her introduction, the French girlfriend to Bruce Willis' Butch is at times sweet and funny and even sexy. The real problem comes through the fact that while most of the other women in the film are developed and have some dimensions to them, Fabienne comes across as a rather weak and watery character in comparison. For example, when Bruce Willis returns from his adventures retrieving his watch, Fabienne becomes emotional and bursts into tears when he scolds her - and while there's some hinting in the film that she is actually pregnant with Butch's child, it seems a shame that Fabienne could not have had some element of strength inside her or some further development - she does play an important and central role in Butch's story and it's a shame that there's not really anything for her to do, no side-story or mini-arc she could go through alone. She comes across as kind of childlike in her on-screen appearances and rather bland to be honest - not a critique on actress Maria de Medeiros' skills but rather on a character designed to be solely a love interest (however half-heartedly) and nothing much else, sadly.

1. Focus More On 'The Briefcase'

pulpfiction-briefcase The most infamous and widely debated part of the entire film, the mysterious briefcase which Vincent Vega and Jules Winnfield have been dispatched to retrieve, remains an Easter Egg and McGuffin of the highest order. Quite simply the most intriguing and symbolic part of the film, the briefcase (which is unlocked by the numbers 666), while definitely a focus for part of the film, loses a lot of its relevance and intrigue once it's out of our sights - which is an obvious shame, as I personally feel that it could have added some gravitas, intrigue and a dark, symbolic emphasis to a largely fun film. While theories have raged since the film's release about it being anything from diamonds, nuclear materials or even Marsellus' soul (my personal favourite), the point is that if the film had had a slightly stronger focus or lead around the briefcase, it would have made the contents more intriguing and something that the lead characters could have been drawn to, both literally and figuratively. In the final scene in the diner, Jules in his moment of redemption, acceptance and transition from a killing machine into someone much better, still refuses to hand over the briefcase, showing the contents to a startled and mesmerised Ringo/Pumpkin. The briefcase and its contents at once symbolise a monstrous thing, a thing worth killing people over, and simultaneously something beautiful, something capable and inherently aimed at inspiring awe and reverence in the people who view it. Ringo himself says, "it's beautiful". It's a shame then that Tarantino didn't add more of the mysterious briefcase's origins into the movie to pique our curiosity even further - all without revealing its origins, identity or purpose of course. After all, what's a good McGuffin if people know what it's for? Well, those were my five choices for ways that Pulp Fiction could have been improved - if you have any other choices for ways to improve this postmodern classic, sound off in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Leeds native, film fanatic, TV obsessive and relentless pop music fan. Sings off-key at any chance.