5 Changes That Would've Improved Fight Club

Thirteen years after its general release, David Fincher's finest film still packs a punch. You stagger out of Fight Club woozy, concussed and blinking into the light. Contemporary cinema, however, has yet to recover. Nothing has come close to surpassing (let alone matching) the magnetic maelstrom that is Tyler Durden; leader, liberator, lunatic. It's impossible- even now- to see Pitt, Norton and Bonham-Carter as anything but their career-best characters; three corners of a particularly poisonous love-triangle.

How did a sleeper hit, adapted from Chuck Palahniuk's 1996 novel, transform soap, self-help and anti-consumerism into a darkly cynical masterpiece for modern times? Or, rather; near-masterpiece. Could it be improved? Should it?

Somewhat perversely, Fight Club strives for imperfection. After all, even the Mona Lisa's falling apart...

5.Show, Don't Tell

After Jack carelessly leaves a copy of Fight Club's rules for his boss to find by the photocopier, his response is less of an excuse and more of a direct threat. Slowly rising from his chair, he explains that the person who wrote it is 'dangerous', before describing a vision, a daydream, of that same person ''stalk from office to office... pumping round after round into colleagues and co-workers''; a fantasy that sits rather uneasily in a post-Columbine America. In this case, sensitivity may have led to censorship, yet one can only wonder how differently the scene could've turned out had we seen, not simply heard, Jack's reverie. Silence, slow-motion, a tsunami of paper stacks and fluorescent light fittings. Jack's lines delivered in voice-over; while appearing onscreen, half-asleep, mouth agape. Or as a spectator to the off-screen carnage, his expression as bored as when he anticipated the (imaginary) plane crash. Those who justified the film's violence highlighted the low correlation between firearms and fatalities (onscreen, at least), when compared to its contemporaries, such as, say, The Matrix. Perhaps the problem really was a question of fantasy: it's one thing to portray a killer as an anonymous, amorphous suit and quite another to portray him as the man in the cubicle next door...

4. Lose the Literature: The Trouble with Adaptations

What sets Fight Club apart from most adaptations is the fact that it rarely feels like chunks of the original text are being force-fed to the audience. So when it does, it rankles somewhat. While administering the lye burn to Jack€™s hand, Tyler turns an allegory about sacrifice into a diatribe against perfection, against God. It€™s a darkly ironic twist on a baptism, of sorts; hugely quotable and integral to the €˜conversion€™ of Jack. Yet this spiel seems slightly shoehorned in- a tad too literary to swallow. This is outdone by a later scene, moments before Tyler€™s disappearance, in which he describes his vision of an agrarian utopia: €˜€˜Tiny figures pounding corn, laying strips of venison in the empty car-pool lane€™€™. Admittedly, there is a rather dreamlike quality to this scene, as Jack drifts in and out of consciousness, but it doesn€™t quite fit with the overall tone of the film. Are these really Tyler€™s words? Is this the end product of Project Mayhem? Are Wat Tyler and the Luddite movement to be seen as inspirations - or a mere coincidence?

3. More Meat, Less Ham! Following the Big Reveal, Jack attempts to thwart Tyler€™s plan by defusing the bomb in the van packed full of nitroglycerin. Yes, cutting the correct wire before the timer runs to zero may be a tired action film trope but a spot of reverse psychology and double-bluff keeps things ticking away nicely (as it were). The wire is cut, the day is saved - but Tyler turns nasty. He punches, kicks and throws Jack down a flight of stairs- all the while making karate squawks and thoroughly hamming it up. The violence may be less graphic than in earlier scenes, but its comic intentions make it resemble a scene from Bottom (beating Jack with his own shoe, for instance). And we can all do without the CCTV images of Jack dragging himself across the floor or throwing himself downstairs. It doesn€™t make sense.


2. Spoil the Fun: Pick an Origin Story

Part of the film€™s appeal lies in working out precisely where Jack ends and Tyler begins. Is it on the very first subliminal flash of Tyler? Or their introduction on the plane (later assumed to be Jack talking to himself)? Or is it in the flashback following the Big Reveal, where we return to Jack and Tyler beating each other up in the dimly-lit parking lot of Lou's Tavern? The difference, this time, is the noticeable absence of the latter. Jack is punching himself, grabbing his own collar- rather like he did in his boss' office. We then see a couple of bemused passers-by approach this man (fortuitously, they're the perfect recruits)... and, lo and behold, Fight Club is born. Tyler could very well have been lying in wait for much longer, of course, but here is the catalyst. Everything, from blowing up an apartment to Bob€™s death, all boils down to a bloke battering himself outside a boozer? Wouldn't it be more plausible for these interlopers to beat up Jack themselves, or perhaps, simply walk away? Members of Fight Club may have grown accustomed to their leader€™s eccentricities, such as arguing with himself while driving, but it seems unlikely that a stranger knocking seven bells out of himself is the man they€™d call their saviour.

1. Revise the Ending

Even if you overlook the slightly annoying mind games that 'throw' the gun from Tyler's to Jack's hands, there are still a few niggling concerns in the final scene. Why would a non-fatal gunshot wound to Jack be a fatal blow to Tyler? Metaphorical though his €˜death€™ is, how does a bullet through the neck/jaw/whatever magically rid a man of his alter ego? Surely the only way to kill Tyler would be to kill Jack, too? It€™s by no means a terrible ending- albeit a somewhat slanted view on Hollywood€™s concept of closure- with Jack sustaining his injury for long enough to see Project Mayhem take full effect, taking Marla€™s hand for a surprisingly bittersweet finale. But wouldn€™t it be cool if his last line was actually, €˜€˜You met me at a very strange Tyler my life?€™€™ No? Just me, then.

Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshireman (hence the surname). Often spotted sacrificing sleep and sanity for the annual Leeds International Film Festival. For a sample of (fairly) recent film reviews, please visit whatsnottoblog.wordpress.com.