5 Directions Joker 2 Could Take

A sequel is inevitable, where can Mr. J go next?

Joker 2
Warner Bros.

The unprecedented success of Joker has created a whole host of opportunities for R-rated comic book movies. DC produced a sub-hundred million dollar thriller that granted them over a billion dollars for their trouble, so making a sequel should be one of their top priorities.

Director Todd Phillips has made it clear that he has not signed a contract with Warner Bros. to direct a follow-up. However, money talks and there is a heap of cash left on the table if Joker 2 isn't in the pipeline. Aside from the obvious financial incentive, there is a breadth of creative freedom that comes with a second instalment.

Joker was a period piece that played things vaguely, leaving so many options with a revisit to the character. The direction of the traditional comic book narrative could be the road they take, or the formula might be shook up and turned on its head once more.

Do we simply get a straight forward narrative continuation? Do things get slightly abstract? Here are a few ideas to get the ball rolling with Joker 2.

5. Crossover With The Batman

robert pattinson batman
Warner Bros

It's an obvious choice but not one to rule out. The Joker can exist as his own character as the first film demonstrates, but he is still a villain. He needs his greatest adversary to give him purpose.

A young Bruce Wayne plays a minor role in Joker, establishing that the boy who will become Batman exists in this universe. What's more, his parents are gunned down by one of Arthur Fleck's acolytes during the movie's climax. Bruce has already been set on that path towards donning the cowl and cape with a ready-made enemy waiting for him.

Batman might stand for justice, but he still has to be driven by something. As carnal and primitive a motivator as it is, revenge against Joker and his followers is a perfect psychological driver for young Master Wayne to become 'The Dark Knight'. The big question is which Batman shows up? Matt Reeves and Robert Pattinson are working on their own interpretetation. Whether or not The Batman ends up being a part of DC's cinematic universe remains to be seen. If it's standalone in the same vein as Joker, what reason is there to not merge the two narratives?

Arthur would be a good 35 years older than Bruce, so The Joker has to be in his 60s if Batman is around Pattinson's age. This doesn't pose a problem though. The Joker is a schemer and manipulator, he can torment someone no matter how old he is.


4. The Three Jokers

Batman Joker Endgame
DC Comics

It was revealed in 2016's Darkseid War that there have been three Jokers over the course of Batman's crime fighting career. While a fan vote will determine whether this becomes official canon or not, the idea itself works in the cinematic arena.

Jumping ahead to Joker 3, what if a trilogy of movies gets produced? The first is set in 1981. The second jumping ahead to 2001, with the third and final instalment tying all three together with a contemporary 2021 setting.

Arthur Fleck might not operate as The Joker for the rest of his days. There's a strong chance he just sits in a padded cell for decades. The core theme of the first movie is that anyone can be The Joker. This idea's been explored in the comics and TV. Arthur's influence can continue outside of the confines of Arkham Asylum, creating multiple people given the label of The Joker.

After three movies of different maniacs reaking havoc in their own paint and purple suit, the three could meet up for one final, hellacious spectacle. An aged, withered Arthur Fleck serves as a pseudo deity for two younger worshipers at his altar. The best part? Batman can still show up, because nobody else is gonna be able to take on three Jokers at once.

It would be an ambitious project. The hardest part would be locking down two more actors who could match what Joaquin Phoenix did in the original. Each new portrayal of the character adds an extra layer that fans will look for in the next incarnation.

Comparisons to the greats like Ledger and Hamill will always permeate, so picking the right actor is key. Given the period setting of Joker, making each follow-up specific to its time period and reflecting that in the title character is a way to contextualise them. The Joker is usually timeless and undefined. Maybe it's time to go in the opposite direction and make them a product of their time?


3. Old Man Joker

Joker Batman Return
Warner Bros.

Building on the previous entry, the idea of The Joker growing old and decrepit is yet to explored in a live action movie. A time skip from the first film to present day places Arthur Fleck in his seventies, with all sorts of mischief in between to reflect on. Sure, he could sit in Arkham the whole time, but we know there's no facility that can hold him for too long.

With age comes the deterioration of both body and mind. The Joker's not a man who gets work done physically, it's his relentless insanity that drives him. Watching a senior citizen Arthur Fleck lose total grip on reality - while still trying to be a self-fashioned criminal mastermind - creates a space in which his psychology can be explored properly.

Joker as a film is focused on the external. It deals with the effect of society shunning people in need of help and the monsters that sort of negligence creates. Joker 2 can flip the script with an internal focus. Arthur's had nothing but time to grow the Joker mythos. Towards the end of his life, he can look back on the horrors he's committed and feel a sense of accomplishment. He's been a menace for so long and essentially got away with it, filling in the blanks of what he got up to with the underbelly of Gotham city.

At this point, the older Fleck must pay for his sins. This can be done in all manner of ways. Hell, one final punch-up with an aged Bruce Wayne (Michael Keaton, anybody?) wouldn't go amiss. A life of making things miserable for others can't go unpunished, so seeing Fleck's generation-spanning brand of chaos via flashbacks sets up his demise as a veteran of the crime world.


2. Set Inside Arkham

Joker Arkham
Warner Bros.

When in doubt, pick up where the last movie left off. Joker's chilling ending within Arkham sets up a logical sequel in the facility. Arkham has a mythic status in the Batman lore. It's spawned an acclaimed video game series, a deeply disturbing standalone comic, and has played a part in multiple movies already.

What we're yet to see is an entire film set inside its walls. Grant Morrison's Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth is a comic told mostly through visuals, with little dialogue accompanying the panels. It's an outright horror story that gets inside the warped mind of Batman. Every villain appears as a distorted representation of themselves. This sort of intensity is screaming out for a big screen outing. You don't need Batman to tell that story, either. The crux of Arkham Asylum's existence is that it houses the most dangerous people alive.

There are multiple paths the story can take. It could be as cut an dry as Arthur attempting an escape. In this respect, it would be akin to a classic prison movie. Alternatively, he could thrive in the hospital and gather followers like he did in the outside world. He's a figure of infamy, after all. The hospital becomes The Joker's home, his DNA running through its foundations. This is where the classical take on the character can be implemented. Arthur Fleck goes inside Arkham as a delusional psychopath in facepaint, he comes out a criminally insane maestro.

Many of The Joker's key traits can be developed inside Arkham. His psychological manipulation of doctors, his odd affection for the place, perhaps even the creation of Harley Quinn if you want to go that route. The character is eternally tied to the asylum (or state hospital in the movie), not exploring his role inside would be a missed opportunity.


1. A Second Origin Story

Joker Killing Joke
DC Comics

"If I'm going to have a past, I prefer it to be multiple choice." This iconic line from The Killing Joke has defined the character for over 30 years. Alan Moore's seminal comic makes it clear that The Joker is not to be trusted in anything he says. No matter what he tells you, it's just an attempt to mess with your head. Heath Ledger's portrayal leaned into this with the changing story of how he got those scars. Joker 2 could take things one step further.

Arthur is an unreliable narrator. There is no reason to believe any of the events portrayed in Joker happened how he describes them. At best, he's embellishing the past. At worst, he's pulled a Usual Suspects and made the whole thing up.

Joker made so much money that there's little risk in going way out there with the sequel. So why not go big? I'm suggesting that the second movie disregards the entirety of the first's events and gives a second origin. It's still Joaquin Phoenix in the lead, but that's the only similarity. It's not set in 1981, he's not a stand-up comedian, he's not even called Arthur Fleck. These are the stories of a sick man who lies for fun. Why would he ever be honest about where he came from?

The Joker can be whatever he wants to be. There's no reason why Joker 2 can't be set in a totally different time period with the same actor in a contradictory story. Sure, this could potentially upset those who are invested in the tale of Arthur Fleck, but hasn't the most consistent element of The Joker been that we'll never know who he really is?


In this post: 
Joker II
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Broome Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.