5 Disappointing Stephen King Adaptations

Children of the Corn Stephen King has had more movie and television adaptations of his work than any other novelist. The man is easily one of the greatest storytellers of our time and his spectrum of work is so varied and so enormous, it's easy to understand his mass appeal. Millions of people buy his books, and millions of people watch the films based on these books. King can create a world and put you, as a reader, right there in it. Among the many adaptations, there are plenty of good, and even positively great films and TV movies/minseries; Carrie, Misery and Salem's Lot to name but a few. Perhaps it is having such high caliber screenwriters and directors attached to projects like this that make them such a success, or the level of attention paid to King's source work, or maybe it's just the fact that some of his stories are simply better than others, and some books are just better-suited for the big screen. Either way, for the number of great adaptations, there are just as many bad ones to rival them. The disappointment in these weaker films can spout from any number of reasons. Obviously the main cause of disappointment of a film adaptation is that it doesn't live up to it's source material. Sometimes, no matter how good the film might be in it's own right, it will never compare to the book it's based on, and this so often comes down to individual opinions and tastes. Another reason for disappointment could be that, despite King's original story not being one of his stronger efforts, you thought, "Maaybe with the right talent attached, a great re-imagining could result in the form of a film." It's happened before. Good books have gone on to make great movies when the person adapting it decided to make some creative changes to the story. Just look at The Shining. A terrific book, sure. King had lots of great ideas, and it's a very interesting read, but the film adaptation is what truly made the tale a classic. In this case, Kubrick was the right man to take the book and make a stronger film. These things can happen, and sometimes we have pre-conceived notions about how excellent a film is going to be, based on certain factors like the cast and crew involved. Hell, sometimes we even have pre-conceived notions based on nothing but the basic premise of the film. There are lots of reasons why we would get our hopes up for a Stephen King film adaptation, and so, once in a while, we're going to be disappointed. Here's a selection of such films, each with their own set of disappointments...

Honourable Mention: Firestarter

Firestarter Drew Barrymore Firestarter was released in 1984 to a lukewarm reception and an underwhelming box office. It holds a Rotten Tomatoes rating of just 41%. The book, released 3 years earlier, was highly regarded and nominated as Best Novel for the British Fantasy Awards. Big Names Attached: David Keith, Martin Sheen and a young Drew Barrymore are all in the cast. Is The Book Better?: I've only read the start of it myself, but in terms of critical reception, it's higher regarded. Now, the reason I place Firestarter in the Honourable Mentions category is because, although the film was certainly a dissapointment for the majority of people, I actually really like the film. Having pretty much no notion of what the film was before seeing it, only that it was based on a Stephen King book, it didn't have much to live up to for me. And although I know it's pretty lame at times, I think it's a solid film. I'm throwing it in here for the sake of people yelling at me if I don't, and to make the point that I have the potential to like mediocre films too! But now, on with the list...

5. Cujo

Cujo Cujo was released in 1983 to a mixed reception, more positive than negative. It was a modest box office success and holds a 61% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The novel won the British Fantasy Award in 1982. Big Names Attached: No one really, other than one or two semi-familiar faces. Is The Book Better?: Yeah. It's by no means one of King's best, but it's a nice short novel with a Hell of a lot more intensity than the film. The main problem with Cujo is the fact that it is in no way at all scary or intense. Sure, the book isn't his biggest for nightmares or thrills, but it at least conjured up a sense of the fear you'd be feeling in such a situation. In the book, you felt like you were there with the woman and her son, dying an agonizingly slow death, feeling so utterly helpless. And the ending of the book, although bleak as hell, felt more engaging. At least you felt like something actually happened in the story. Unfortunately, the movie altered it quite drastically, and it ends the same way it begins; boringly.

4. Desperation (TV Movie)

Desperation Desperation aired as a TV movie in 2006 on ABC to an underwhelming reception. It currently holds a rating of 44 on Metacritic. The book of the same name was published 10 years prior to its release. Big Names Attached: Ron Perlman and Tom Skerrit lead the cast, which isn't too bad for a TV movie. King himself wrote the script and acted as Producer. Mick Garris directed it. I guess you could say he's a big name to S.K fans. He directed a number of King adaptations. Although, not many good ones... Is The Book Better?: Yep. Although it really seems to run off on a bit of a tangent towards the end, the book paints an unbelievably vivid picture of the town and the characters are much better developed. Desperation, although not Godawful, was certainly a disappointing adaptation, given the source. The book really delves into some terrifically deep themes and puts you in the world of Desperation far better than the movie does. The main issue is probably just the sad fact that it's a made-for-TV movie, and naturally, it has to be censored. The book is a book for adults, and at times, the movie can sometimes feel a lot more juvenile. Ron Perlman does a good job as the creepy possessed sheriff, and is easily the most memorable part of the film. The rest of the cast, and most of the film are, sadly, forgettable.

3. The Dark Half

Dark Half

The Dark Half came out in 1993 and performed quite poorly in the box office. Critics were torn between it and it holds a 61% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. King released the book in 1989 and it was the second best-selling book that year. Big Names Attached: Timothy Hutton stars, as does cult favourite Michael Rooker. Oh, and just the Grand-Daddy of horror, George A. Romero. Yep, Romero penned and directed this. Is The Book Better?: Yeah. The main issue with this film is that the collaboration of King and Romero promises to be a dream team. It's like a horror fan's ultimate dream to have one of these adapt the other one's work. They worked together before on Creepshow in 1982 and it was brilliant, so perhaps that's where so much of the disappointment stems from. The Dark Half could have been much more. Hutton does a good job and there's one or two decent moments, but ultimately, the film is just incredibly dull. Romero's films are usually much more passionate than this, and it's hard to place a finger on where things actually go wrong with this film. It's not a terrible film at all, it just lacks excitement and engagement. And considering the talent involved, scares.

2. Children of the Corn

Children of the Corn Children of the Corn was released in 1984, doing well in the box office but not charming the critics, with a Rotten Tomatoes rating of 39%. King had the short story first published back in 1977. Big Names Attached: Linda Hamilton (aka Sarah Connor) stars, but I guess that's about it. Is The Book Better?: I'll admit, I haven't read this one yet. Alright, so there's not much to say about this one. I haven't seen the book, and there's no exciting talent attached to the film, so there really isn't a good reason to have such high hopes for this in the first place. But, it's the overall premise that promises something exciting and well, scary. The whole idea of a demonic entity that entices all the children in the town to murder all the adults in a ritual-like fashion. That. Sounds. Amazing. Alas, the film doesn't live up. The premise is so brilliant and really demands a good adaptation, but the script, acting and production values all fall short. It's just nowhere near as creepy or iconic as it could've been. A damn shame, really. The vast majority of the child actors are woefully unconvincing; especially annoying is the ginger kid, Malaki, who is far too over the top to be effectively creepy. Props to Isaac though; he's probably the only one of the bunch worth remembering. Still, it's not enough...

1. Dreamcatcher

Dreamcatcher Dreamcatcher was released in 2003, performing poorly in the box office and regarded just as poorly by critics and fans alike. It holds a 30% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The book was released two years prior, originally intended to be called "Cancer", but changed upon request of King's wife. Big Names Attached: Terrifc cast including Morgan Freeman, Damian Lewis, Timothy Olyphant and Donnie Walhberg. Lawrence Kasdan, the director and writer, was the guy who scriped Empire Strikes Back and Raiders of the Lost Ark, among other classics. Is The Book Better?: Hard to say, really. It starts off well enough, but after a certain point, it becomes a bit of a chore. The majority of the disappointment in this one would fall with the writing and acting talent involved with the film, and the size of the budget. The book is a bit of a mess in it's own right, but there was enough good material and ideas in there to make something great out of it. Some of the concepts just screamed to be made into a film. Given Kasdan's track record, you think he might be the right man to salvage some sort of decent script out of it. Unfortunately not. The screenplay is all over the place, and not even such a high calibur cast can save it from utter doom. The whole thing is just so ridiculous, and even though that can sometimes work in a so-bad-it's-good kinda' way, it doesn't in this instance. The film just seems to take itself too seriously, and that's probably mostly down to the direction. At 136 minutes, it's easily the hardest Stephen King adaptation to sit through, and I can only imagine the horrors of subjecting oneself to it more than once. Hope you've enjoyed the article. Keep in mind that there are a number of S.K. adaptations that I have still yet to see. I'm sure there are even more disappointing films/TV movies. Also note that although I'm tearing these films up, I actually don't hate some of them. Children of the Corn and Desperation definitely do have a certain charm to them, and I actually enjoyed them above the rest. And I see some merit in The Dark Half, but it just didn't do it for me. Looking forward to opinions and suggestions from you guys...

Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a television junkie. A film fanatic. A pop culture know-it-all. An interactive media masters student, and a bass player. 22 years old and Irish. Thinks Netflix is a Godsend.