5 Franchises That Would Be Better With Other Studios

JJ Abrams' Transformers > Michael Bay's Transformers

Bad Robot Transformers
Paramount/Bad Robot

There is no blueprint to building a successful franchise, so assessing their big screen potential can be difficult. More often than not, it depends on the studios and production companies that acquire the properties.

Sometimes, there is a perfect pairing between property and producer/distributor. The Lord of the Rings could have landed at no better place than New Line Cinema. Warner Bros. did a fantastic job adapting the Harry Potter novels for audiences that would rather not read. Universal Pictures gave us the Bourne franchise, a complex and nuanced spy-thriller that superbly mirrored our 21st Century world.

Although these franchises found ideal homes, there are others that have not been so lucky. These studios may have had success with some franchises, but have not treated others with the same care.

Some franchises need a tear down from top to bottom, with a completely new take being built on its' ashes. Others could benefit from a fresh set of eyeballs and a slight change in direction. Then there are those that just seem ready to move on. In any case, a different studio could cure what ails them.

5. Minions With Warner Bros

Minions movie
Universal Pictures

The Minions were first introduced as the yellow, linguistically-limited companions of Felonious Gru in 2010's Despicable Me. As supplemental characters, their antics could steal a scene and the characters gained widespread popularity.

Universal Pictures took notice as the Minions were given a film of their own, which was released in Summer of 2015. The movie was a hit, grossing well over a billion dollars worldwide.

The film's box office considered, this list is focused on film quality and Minions was not as well-received among critics and audiences as its franchise counterpart. The characters don't have the depth to carry a decent movie, instead choosing to fall back on slapstick and cliché gags.

In Universal's defense, the goal was accomplished. Minions was an effort to stretch the franchise to not only sell tickets but merchandise as well. It worked, but that doesn't preclude making a good film.

If you want proof, look no further than what Warner Bros. did with 2014's The LEGO Movie. The obvious effort to sell LEGO cannot be ignored, but there is still a rich story about finding one's purpose and an inventive animation style with the film and its' spin-off, The LEGO Batman Movie.

The financial potential of the Minions, along with its inseparable ties to Despicable Me, means it will likely never be in another company's hands. Still, this is all hypothetical and Warner Bros Animation has been up to the task of creating fun narratives in the face of blatant commercialism.


4. Transformers With Bad Robot

Transformers: Age Of Extinction Ending
Paramount Pictures

Although it is one of the most financially successful franchises of all-time, there has been a diminishing return for audiences since the first installment released in 2007. This was finally felt with 2017's Transformers: The Last Knight, which was the lowest grossing film in the series.

The movies suffer from repetition of what was is a pretty hollow formula to begin with. There's only so many times people will go to see Autobots and Decepticons blow things up to the exact same end.

Transformers would benefit if they gave the apocalyptic dreck a rest and created a more intimate, heartfelt affair. To their credit, we may be getting that experience sooner rather than later with Bumblebee, which is giving off some much welcomed Iron Giant vibes.

Even if Bumblee doesn't provide the expected return, that doesn't mean the franchise should abandon the idea and revert back to empty explosions. The property would just need to be in more careful hands.

J.J. Abrams-led Bad Robot would be a perfect candidate to revamp the franchise. The studio has done an excellent job of taking major ideas and events and crafting personal stories around them, such as Cloverfield, 10 Cloverfield Lane and Super 8. They also produced Star Wars: The Force Awakens, so there is some reassurance they can go big when the time arrives.

Here's hoping Bumblebee delivers, but if not we'd like to see what a studio like Bad Robot could bring to the robots in disguise.


3. Dark Universe With Legendary

Russell Crowe the Mummy
Universal Pictures

When Universal Pictures released the Mummy, it was intended to be the first in a series of interconnected films dubbed The Dark Universe. This all seems inconsequential now, as The Mummy performed well under expectations both critically and financially, driving a steak in the heart of (no pun intended) Universal's expanded world plans.

There was plenty audiences didn't like about the Mummy, a film that lacked the frights any pseudo-horror film should have, nor provided the fun and adventure available in the 1999 iteration. The problem with the film was a familiar one: Too focused on setting up future movies while forgetting to create an enjoyable experience in the moment.

The lay of the land dictates all studios rummage through their intellectual property and find pieces with universe-building potential. However, a universe that would have eventually incorporated the likes of Dracula, the Invisible Man and Frankenstein was doomed to feel dated and susceptible to cynical ploys.

Still, there are cases of studios taking franchises that do not seem ideal for a 21st Century expanded universe that have performed well. Look no further than what Legendary Entertainment has done with their Monsterverse, featuring Godzilla and King Kong.

2014's Godzilla and 2017's Kong: Skull Island not only turned a profit but fared far better with critics than anyone anticipated. Both movies focused on building strong casts, creating impressive visual effects and grounding them with real world issues. There is also a more subtle approach to world-building with the involvement of the organization Monarch Sciences in both films.

There is no reason this couldn't be replicated to create The Dark Universe, but it would be in better hands with a studio like Legendary.


2. Alien/ Predator With Blumhouse

alien predator 1
20th Century Fox

The Predator and Alien franchises have been favorites among fans for over 30 years. The early efforts clearly bought plenty of goodwill, as both franchises have produced a bounty of mediocre films since the late-80's.

1979's Alien was one of the most inventive pieces of horror and science-fiction to date, one that was arguably topped with the release of its' sequel in '86. Alien 3 and Alien Resurrection, however, are not exactly apples in anyone's eyes. The prequel films Prometheus and Alien: Covenant have their redeeming qualities, but felt forced and contrived.

Predator has even less to brag about. The first was a classic and Arnold Schwarzenegger's turn as Dutch is still one of his career-defining roles, Governor of California included. Ever since its' inaugural outing, however, the franchise has seen little substance, with the forgettable 2010 Predators being the best installment in three decades.

Then there is the crossover films, Aliens vs. Predator and Alien vs. Predator: Requiem. Let's just not, okay?

Both franchises seem to suffer from the same problem: gimmicks. There is a line between natural escalation of a property and lazy ploys. Having the extraterrestrials fight in an underground pyramid in the artic was never a decision based in creative integrity.

Both properties need a return to basics. The Alien and Predator franchises need to forget the Engineers and Super-Predators, respectively, and embrace the purity that made them great.

Perhaps no studio is better for this purpose than Blumhouse, which have produced some of the best modern horror films and thrillers, including Get Out, Upgrade, and this year's Halloween reboot.

The studio keeps tight budgets, usually no more than $10 million, which would be a good change for both Alien and Predator. The smaller scale would encourage a more simple project - an approach which has been best for the franchises in the past.


1. X-Men/Fantastic Four With Marvel Studios

X Men 2000 Patrick Stewart
Fox

It is finally time for the X-Men and Fantastic Four to join their Marvel Comics contemporaries at Marvel Studios.

Credit must be given where credit is due: Fox has created some of the best comic book film adaptations of all-time with the X-Men franchise. However, their efforts have been inconsistent. For every Logan, Deadpool and X2, there is a X-Men: The Last Stand, X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men: Apocalypse.

It feels like a time for transition for the X-Men, as Hugh Jackman and Patrick Stewart are finished playing their respective roles as Wolverine and Professor Charles Xavier. The X-Men spinoff, The New Mutants, has been pushed back and Gambit has been delayed so much it feels as if it will never happen.

There's also the upcoming Dark Phoenix, which hasn't generated as much buzz as past X-Men films. The lone exception is Ryan Reynold's Deadpool, whose fourth wall-breaking ability makes him an ideal character to throw into a different universe following a franchise revamp.

The case for Fantastic Four is even stronger, as Fox has never been able to get the property off the ground. The studio has released three movies adapting Marvel's first family, all of which have fielded a mediocre response from fans and have been torched (pun intended) by critics. The latest effort, Fant4stic was panned as one of the biggest flops in recent memory.

For varying reasons, both the X-Men and Fantastic Four seem ready for a change. This seems as if it will happen, as approval of the Fox-Disney merger grows likelier by the day. Anything that gets the Merc with a Mouth in the same playing field with Spider-Man will be welcomed.


In this post: 
Transformers
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Digital Artist | Writer | UKY Alumnus | Fan of Comics, Sports & Film Find my portfolio and blog at dalanoverstreet.com