5 Greatest Ever Alternative Christmas Carol Adaptations

5. A Muppet Christmas Carol
4. Doctor Who: 'A Christmas Carol' (2010 Christmas Special)

3. The Simpsons, 'Tis The Fifteenth Season (Season 15, Episode 7)
The Simpsons has always been brilliant let me start again. The Simpsons was brilliant to watch between 1989 and about 2000, and has always had a great deal of heart when it wants, so youd expect their telling of A Christmas Carol to be full of heart and sentimentality. Well, no. Whilst the episode itself is a rather traditional telling of A Christmas Carol- where Homer is spurred on by past greed to become to nicest man in town, much to Ned Flanders chagrin- it is the adaptations within the episode that are brilliant. Theyre just pure funny. First off is a very brief Star Trek Christmas special, then we briefly see Urkel, and of course there is the Christmas special that spurs on Homer to change his ways, Mr. MacGrews Christmas Carol. None are particularly lengthy, but they are fantastic cutaway gags and tie in nicely with a generally top-notch alternative adaptation- a miracle considering this is later Simpsons!
2. A Blackadder Christmas Carol
This just chucks faithfulness to the novel out the window. This is purely funny, nasty, cynical British comedy. Its not the best Blackadder ever, but its up there. Here we see a nice little twist, where Ebenezer Blackadder is a kind and generous man who is taken advantage of. When a ghost accidentally gets the wrong address- hes supposed to be scaring an old miser- he shows Blackadder his past ancestors, and what the future holds if he stays the way he is. Of course, Blackadder changes into the selfish, nasty man we all know and love. Of course it comes back to bite him, as is want to do, but its a clever twist, with a lot of funny moments including new flashbacks with the Elizabethan and Georgian Blackadders, even if it doesnt quite all gel together. Still, if you want a darker, cynical version of the tale, look no further!
1. Scrooged
And speaking of nasty, cynical versions of A Christmas Carol, this is the best of all. Like Gambon and Cain, Bill Murrays brilliant Scrooge figure, Frank Cross, simply makes the movie. It hits a nice heartfelt note towards the end, but a few well-placed poignant moments aside, this is a scathing, blackly funny retelling, and a must if you hate christmas. Not only does it have three wonderful ghosts, and a great supporting cast (Karen Allen! Robert Mitchum! Bobcat Goldthwait!), but Richard Donners direction si superb. Like A Muppet Christmas Carol, is stands up as a great comedy and a great film as well as a great alternative adaptation. The Americans have never done a better adaptation of A Christmas Carol than this! So, ho, ho! There you have it, you festive crackerjacks! If you want to revisit the greatest Christmas story of all time, here are five different ways in which to do so. If Ive missed any out, please comment below or tweet me @IAmOscarHarding.
