5 Greatest Ever Alternative Christmas Carol Adaptations

Doctor Who XMAS Carol

A Christmas Carol is without doubt one of the great stories of our times. You€™d have to go to a very remote place in the world to meet someone who hasn€™t heard of Charles Dickens€™ classic tale of Ebenezer Scrooge, and his redemption at the hands of three spectres. Naturally, because of the popularity and resonance of the A Christmas Carol, it has been ripe for adaptation. They range from the good (Alistair Sim) to the bad (Mo-Cap Jim Carrey), but what if you want to see the tale in a new light, or want to bring it down to the level of someone you want to inspire with it? Well, read on, dear reader, for five of the best alternative tellings of A Christmas Carol that offer something a little different whilst still being mighty entertaining. In no particular order...

5. A Muppet Christmas Carol

cc1x

Of course, the classic. It has been scientifically proven that if you don€™t like this film, you have no soul. Adding The Muppets to anything makes its 27% better, and this s no exception. But the reason it is not only a great film but perhaps the best adaptation of Dickens€™ tale- period- is that it best captures the spirit of the novel. It€™s bizarre to think a film with The Muppets in it would be the most faithful telling of a literary classic, but it€™s true- It€™s also very dark and bloody scary in parts- still gives me shudders when I watch it every year. Of course, Michael Caine just makes the film. No matter how funny Gonzo et al are, and no matter how catchy the songs are, Caine brings gravitas, emotional dignity, and most importantly he brings heart to the film. You just believe this world where Puppet urchins co-exist with Jack Carter, and it€™s one of the films with a rare and unexplainable quality- if you catch it on TV, whatever point the film is at, you have to watch what€™s left. Funny, scary, sweet, and despite having felt characters hardly diverts from a flawless tale. The best adaptation, and certainly the best alternative adaptation! If you haven€™t seen this already, why are you reading this? Go and watch it, now!

4. Doctor Who: 'A Christmas Carol' (2010 Christmas Special)

Doctor Who XMAS Carol

I€™ve certainly never cried at Doctor Who, but I€™ve only got misty-eyed watching either The End of Time, or this. Once again, Michael Gambon as the €˜Scrooge€™ character steals the show and makes us invest whole-heartedly. The clever sci-fi twist involving a impending spaceship crash is merely background. This rests entirely on the shoulders of Gambon, Matt Smith (rarely better), and the surprisingly-good Katherine Jenkins. It has a beautiful central song, and captures the spirit of Dickens€™ original better than most, despite involving Flying Sharks and Frank Sinatra. Things begin with a deliciously dark streak that is seldom present in Moffat€™s run on Who, and three equally convincing stages of Kazran Sardick- boy, young man and Gambon- win us over. It is equally clever, funny and heartbreaking. I would always attempt to show this to people who don€™t like Doctor Who, because it€™s another genius alternative adaptation.

3. The Simpsons, 'Tis The Fifteenth Season (Season 15, Episode 7)

Simpsons Christmas Carol The Simpsons has always been brilliant€ let me start again. The Simpsons was brilliant to watch between 1989 and about 2000, and has always had a great deal of heart when it wants, so you€™d expect their telling of A Christmas Carol to be full of heart and sentimentality. Well, no. Whilst the episode itself is a rather traditional telling of A Christmas Carol- where Homer is spurred on by past greed to become to nicest man in town, much to Ned Flanders€™ chagrin- it is the adaptations within the episode that are brilliant. They€™re just pure funny. First off is a very brief Star Trek Christmas special, then we briefly see Urkel, and of course there is the Christmas special that spurs on Homer to change his ways, Mr. MacGrew€™s Christmas Carol. None are particularly lengthy, but they are fantastic cutaway gags and tie in nicely with a generally top-notch alternative adaptation- a miracle considering this is later Simpsons!

2. A Blackadder Christmas Carol

Blackadder Christmas Carol This just chucks faithfulness to the novel out the window. This is purely funny, nasty, cynical British comedy. It€™s not the best Blackadder ever, but it€™s up there. Here we see a nice little twist, where Ebenezer Blackadder is a kind and generous man who is taken advantage of. When a ghost accidentally gets the wrong address- he€™s supposed to be scaring an old miser- he shows Blackadder his past ancestors, and what the future holds if he stays the way he is. Of course, Blackadder changes into the selfish, nasty man we all know and love. Of course it comes back to bite him, as is want to do, but it€™s a clever twist, with a lot of funny moments including new flashbacks with the Elizabethan and Georgian Blackadders, even if it doesn€™t quite all gel together. Still, if you want a darker, cynical version of the tale, look no further!

1. Scrooged

Scrooged And speaking of nasty, cynical versions of A Christmas Carol, this is the best of all. Like Gambon and Cain, Bill Murray€™s brilliant €˜Scrooge€™ figure, Frank Cross, simply makes the movie. It hits a nice heartfelt note towards the end, but a few well-placed poignant moments aside, this is a scathing, blackly funny retelling, and a must if you hate christmas. Not only does it have three wonderful ghosts, and a great supporting cast (Karen Allen! Robert Mitchum! Bobcat Goldthwait!), but Richard Donner€™s direction si superb. Like A Muppet Christmas Carol, is stands up as a great comedy and a great film as well as a great alternative adaptation. The Americans have never done a better adaptation of A Christmas Carol than this! So, ho, ho! There you have it, you festive crackerjacks! If you want to revisit the greatest Christmas story of all time, here are five different ways in which to do so. If I€™ve missed any out, please comment below or tweet me @IAmOscarHarding.

Contributor
Contributor

Aspiring Director, Screenwriter and Actor. Film is my passion, but I indulge in TV, Theatre and Literature as well! Any comments or suggestions, please tweet me @IAmOscarHarding