5 Sci-Fi Movies That Should Have Had Sequels... But Never Will

Iron Man 2... but more often than not, especially within this pretty vast genre, sequels are better... which is good news for the horde of super-hero and science fiction sequels expected out within the next couple of years. Having said this, most of the films listed would technically not be the second in their franchise (though most would) and superhero/sci-fi films usually epically fail after film number 2. Good luck Iron Man 3!!! The following 5 films set up a sequel but were either not popular enough to warrant one- critically or at the box office- or in a few cases, the franchise branched off in separate directions (mostly not very successfully). Even still, all of the films in the following list, in my opinion, deserved a sequel- though many likely wouldn't have been very good.


5. Spider-Man 3

I don't know about you, although I've heard opinion is pretty divided, but I hated the recent Spider-Man reboot passionately, and no amount of casting news will makes me excited for the sequel to that film. The only thing that has the potential to get me excited is if I hear that they are planning on introducing the Black Cat into the franchise- and bear in mind that I am a fan of both Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone (though not in this movie). Much of the reason I hated "The Amazing Spider-Man" so much was because I loved loved loved Raimi's Spider-Man world to the point that, even though I could recognize Spider-Man 3 was definitely the weaker film (mostly due to appalling choices and executions of villains) I still thought this film was far better than the rebooted version. By the time Spider-Man 3 rolled around I was already so invested in this film universe and these characters. I for one really wanted to follow Peter Parker and Mary Jane Watson's relationship to its natural end, so obviously I was upset when I heard that instead of the planned Spider-Man 4, a reboot would be made instead. This was one of the darker news days in movie history I can remember, because the Spider-Man films (1 and 2 at least) were my favorite films as a teenager. Spider-Man 4 could have had the potential to be truly epic. Sam Raimi obviously was himself not happy about the way Spider-Man 3 turned out, and the reasons he decided not to do a fourth was because the studio was rushing him to completion much like with the third, and if he wasn't able to make a fantastic movie, he would rather make no movie at all. But the studio and the people around him should have given him his time and should have encouraged him to see this saga through, and to give a satisfying ending to this brilliant series of films. Even though I didn't agree with what they were planning on doing to the Black Cat to make that character clearly distinctive from Catwoman (funny then that Anne Hathaway was cast as the Black Cat in Spider-Man 4) I still very much wanted to see this character in the films, and Sam Raimi was going to give the world this never seen on screen before character. It is a shame that the world isn't really ready to have two different Spider-Man films out at the same time, because I would still love for Spider-Man 4 to be a possibility, and I am sure so many people out in the world would agree with me. My dream would be for Tobey Maguire's Peter Parker to be introduced into The Avengers films somewhere down the line... and I think this particular Spider-Man would suit that universe far more than Andrew Garfield's more teen focused Spider-Man would. In my dreams this is happening, but there is pretty much zero chance this will happen in reality.

4. Jumper

Do you remember this film, because if you don't you really should. I watched this film in the cinema on its initial release and I remember leaving the cinema very satisfied with what I had just watched. I enjoyed this film more at the time than I enjoyed Iron Man 2, Thor and certainly more than I enjoyed any of the Hulks or Captain America. Jumper had stacks of potential and a great but fairly simple science-fiction storyline. This film also completely set up a sequel, and the film without a sequel makes little sense. There is so much to the mythology of this film that the sequel could have explored, and because the original (and only one) spent a lot of the time explaining what the Jumpers are and what powers they have, the sequel would have been free to be a much funner, more action filled film than the first. It is a great shame we will never see a sequel to Jumper (although there is a novel in which this film is based that maybe I should read). The ending of the first movie, and this storyline was built up all the way through the film, left us with the knowledge that Max's (Hayden Christensen) mother, played by Diane Lane, is a "Paladin", whose job it is to kill Jumper's like Max- though obviously she will not kill her own son. This film was planned and written as the first of a trilogy, and this is a trilogy that (even though the film had many negative critiques) I would very much like to see a conclusion to. At least the film was successful in making it's two leading stars (Hayden and Rachel Bilson of O.C fame) a romantic item, even to this very day... so at the very least this film can be considered one of the most expensive first dates in the history of the world.


3. Superman Returns

For the life of me I do not understand why this film has as much hatred as it does. I love this movie, and many critics do too. This film was given many 5 stars and features on Empire Magazine's 500 Greatest Movies Of All Time... and I honestly think it deserves its place on that list (I even voted for it). OK, so it is hardly action packed and full of thrills... but we as an audience are mature enough to deal with and accept a Superhero film more about its characters than about its action scenes... aren't we? Despite the slightly lackluster performance by Kate Bosworth as Lois Lane, in my opinion Brandon Routh is fantastic in the role of Superman... he is personally my favorite screen version of this character. If you watch the original Christopher Reeve Superman film a day or so before watching this film (as I did) you will appreciate what a real love letter this film is to the originals, and though I probably just about prefer X2 to this film, I still think Bryan Singer has never directed a film better. And for all you action lovers, the plane scene is pretty terrific isn't it? I guess the reason this film wasn't all that much of a success with comic book geeks and action movie lovers is that Superman Returns was arguably more of a romance story than the classic superhero film. Superman is such a complex and sympathetic character, and unlike superheroes like Iron Man and Thor, Superman (despite being the most powerful of them all) is the more sympathetic character- and sympathetic characters work better as protagonists. Strangely also, despite the fact that Superman is an alien from another planet, he is probably the most human superhero there is. I would really have loved to have seen a sequel to this great movie, although having said this, when a sequel was rumored I didn't at all like what I was hearing about it, and perhaps for this reason a reboot is the wiser option. Superman Returns was mature, brave and unique, and the superhero genre is the one movie genre that is in desperate need of being shaken up just a little or it will certainly face death somewhere down the line. Plus, the movie ended with Superman realizing he had a super-powered child with Lois Lane... and I for one would love to see where this story was intended to be heading.

2. Batman Returns

Forget Nolan's Batman films... Tim Burton's Batman Returns is the greatest Batman movie and one of the, if not THE, most interesting and visual superhero movies of all time. I am sure most of you disagree with me, but considering Batman Returns is 20 years old it shows how great it must have been to still be this fondly remembered years later. OK, so you could maybe argue that Batman Forever is kind of a sequel to this movie, although because this film wasn't directed by Burton, and because this film recast Batman and featured so few of the original characters... but most people, including myself, would rather forget Forever and Batman and Robin and wish it were completely wiped off the planet and no one speak of them ever again. Instead of rebooting Batman, I would much prefer Tim Burton to step back into this world once again, and create a new Batman in his darkly unique version of Gotham... perhaps even recast Michael Keaton as an older Batman in this world- dealing with being an over the hill superhero much like Pixar did with The Incredibles (FYI... I'd love to see a sequel to The Incredibles too, but I we will see this film within the next 10 years anyway). Although I am sure a Tim Burton Batman wouldn't fit the same world as "Man of Steel's" Superman reboot for the Justice League movie- personally I can't see another Batman who is supposed to exist in a realistic universe working so soon after Nolan's Batman did they exact same thing. Plus, I think it's just about time for Batman to play around with camp and distinguish itself from Nolan's fine legacy.


1. Planet of the Apes (2001)

Another Burton film here and in my opinion his last interesting feature film to date. OK, so this is widely considered to be a terrible movie, but I honestly think it wasn't all that bad. If you re-watch the so called classic first "Planet of the Apes" movie, it is pretty terrible... a good concept but hardly a great movie (but with one of the greatest endings ever). The only reason I have included this particular film on this list though is because of the strange cliffhanger ending. The ending, in which Mark Wahlberg returns to his present day version of earth to see that apes have taken over humans and are living as if there never were humans- doing very human things- was loathed by most critics. I remember at the time being pretty horrified by the image of Ape-raham Lincoln's stone "monkey" face staring back at me, but now I am older, I appreciate that as much as I liked this ending at the time, it was pretty much just placed at the end of this movie to create a shocking cliffhanger ending that made very little sense... ... But this is why I want to see a sequel. I want to see Tim Burton try to make sense of this. I want to see that strange Ape run universe set in a present day human city. I want to know why and how apes have suddenly taken the place of humans, and I want to know how Abraham Lincoln is an ape. Forget that this is Planet of the Apes for a second, and this universe shown in the last 5 minutes of this movie is a pretty messed up, surreal, but interesting world to explore for a science fiction movie- it is pretty much in itself an episode of The Twilight Zone. Apes in human clothing creep me out, and the Planet of the Apes apes creep me out more than any scary movie monster ever has, so I would watch this film simply to be terrified. I am sure Tim Burton has no idea how any of this makes sense, and would struggle to make sense of this for a sequel, but if he were to hire some really smart science fiction writers, who knows, this cliffhanger may end up blowing our minds and I would certainly watch that film just out of curiosity and I am sure many many people would do the same. Any/ Many films I have missed out? Go crazy in the comments section below... or likewise, tell me why you'd love to see a sequel/ a real sequel to one of the films I listed above...

 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I am a recent Screenwriting for Film and Television graduate from the UK. I am an unashamed geek who loves everything Marvel, and anything Joss Whedon has ever touched (except for maybe Alien Resurrection and Titan A.E). My current favorite TV shows are Breaking Bad, Family Guy, House of Cards, Game of Thrones, American Horror Story, Homeland and Glee. I look forward to debating things with all of you in the future. (As of January 2013 I have had over 1 million views since joining WhatCulture in September 2012. You can reach me at danieljamesbowen@hotmail.co.uk)