5 Ways The Dark Knight Rises Goes Against The Comics

The end to Nolan's epic Batman saga has finally come and it has drastically changed some of the source material. Here's how.

(This article contains heavy spoilers and we DO NOT RECOMMEND that you read it before seeing the movie) I loved The Dark Knight Rises. I don't feel it is the best of Christopher Nolan's Batman films so much as the film that makes them a trilogy. I'm not being silly, what I mean is that they are a proper trilogy, not just a film with two sequels. TDKR unites the drastically different Batman Begins and The Dark Knight and makes the whole package work. If it wasn't for the slight hiccup with Katie Holmes you could cut the three movies into one uber-film and it would work. So don't think this is someone picking holes to find fault. I was happy, I was totally satisfied. Any niggles I had were lost in my appreciation of the film. That said, there are a few quite drastic differences between Nolan's epic and the source material and I would like to highlight and discuss them. Some of these differences I wasn't keen on and some I agreed with, after all this is Nolan's Batman. It has its own canon. I would like to point out now though that none of these things break TDKR. They are what they are and for the most part it works just fine.

5. The Non-Return of The Scarecrow

I thought The Scarecrow was pants in The Dark Knight. After his fiery horse antics in Batman Begins I had high hopes for The Scarecrow but it seems all he has ended up becoming is a petty drug dealer and a rather pointless judge. He only has one question to ask; death or exile? Surely he could have been more? The Scarecrow persona was diluted in TDK and completely lost in TDKR. This is a shame because, while he was never a physical threat to Batman, The Scarecrow is an adept trouble maker. I would have loved a small but pivotal role where, as an ex-collaborator with the League of Shadows, he uses his fear toxin to further demoralise Gotham city. The real disservice to Jonathan Crane is the total abandonment of his obsession with fear. He isn't The Scarecrow, just an excuse to bring Cillian Murphy back and why bother? Murphy was fine (if a little inconsistent) as crane but surely we aren't desperate to see him do something totally unrelated to the character? If nothing else they could have at least written his lines to include the word fear......

4. Talia Al Ghul

The twist that Miranda Tate turns out to be Talia Al Ghul was certainly called early on. I'm sure fans around the world felt remarkably smug at that moment. However, Talia's motivations are drastically different to her comic book counter-part. This is logical for the most part as unlike the comics, in which Ra's Al Ghul is still live and kicking, Talia has had to deal with the loss of her father. Still, lets look at a few ways that Nolan and co have changed this character drastically from the source material. Firstly, the relationship between Bruce and Talia isn't based on deception in the books. Ra's Al Ghul deems Bruce Wayne the only man worthy of marrying his daughter (Bane was his previous choice but wasn't to Talia's taste) and inherit the league of shadows. Bruce doesn't want the legacy of Ra's but is much more interested in Talia. The two have had a rocky and tense relationship since. They are ideologically at odds yet still very much in love. Bruce and Talia have also had a son, Damian, who has recently become the 5th Robin. Talia is also not a villain but more of an anti-hero. Much like Catwoman, Talia has her own moral compass that, while at odds with Batman's, doesn't make her a bad person. At least, not a super-villain. Nolan's Talia Al Ghul on the other hand is vengeful, manipulative and evil. She is arguably more extreme than even her father. Still, I think for the purposes of Nolan's vision of the Batman universe this makes a lot of sense.

3. The History of Bane

Bane grew up in a hellish prison and grew into a smart and incredibly powerful man who becomes the king of the prison. Sounds pretty close to Nolan's version right? Well yes, until that history is revealed to be Talia Al Ghul's and Bane ends up being the guy who looked after her. While in prison Bane was experimented on with a drug called venom. Venom drastically increased Bane's strength, increasing his body mass and his resistance to injury. Nolan decided on a more realistic contrivance for the mask; pain killers. Apparently Bane is in agony without a constant flow of some unspecified drug. What this doesn't explain is Bane's strength. Sure, he is built like a rhino but that doesn't explain how he over powers Batman so easily. I mean, Wayne is taller and also very buff. My one thought is that the pain killer makes him generally numb, so he can punch brick walls without feeling his hands break and he can push his body beyond normal limits. In the comics Bane is the son of a revolutionary, which works well with Nolan's re-imagining of the character. However, in reality we know pretty much nothing about Bane. He was in that prison, he saved Talia's life. His legend is actually Talia's legend so the man is really a faceless force of nature. I think this is very deliberate, it makes Bane a mystery. He clearly trained with the league of shadows, probably under Talia's reign rather than Ra's Al Ghul's. Other than that, we don't know anything. Still, many of the classic Bane moments were paid tribute to. He breaks Batman, he frees a ton of prisoners (not Arkham Asylum but Blackgate Prison) and he is hard. All in all, while not the Bane from the comics, he is a worthy adaptation of a great villain.

2. The Introduction of Robin... Sort Of.

Less an introduction and more of a wink to the audience. Of course, this is still a totally derivative of the source material. Firstly, no Robin has been called Robin. Secondly, Blake isn't going to be Robin but either become Batman or his own creation. In many ways this is an elegant way of the film-makers tipping their hat to a huge (and totally ignored) part of the Batman universe. No one would argue that Blake is a pretty cool guy. He is a bit of a goody goody but then he can kick ass pretty damn well. He would have been the perfect Robin and in many ways he was Batman's sidekick. He played a pivotal supporting role along with Catwoman, he just didn't wear a mask. There are certain aspects of Dick Grayson in Blake as well; Blake is an orphan and he lost a parent to murder. He was also partially raised by Bruce Wayne, through Wayne's commitment to the city's orphans. Yes it is a weak relationship but it made a strong impression on the man Blake became. Of all the changes to the source material, Blake is my favourite. If ever there was another sequel I could invest in Blake, be he Batman or someone else. It would have been cheesy to suit and boot him and come up with an excuse to call him Robin (some things don't work outside of the comics after all) so instead he played the role on the other side of the mask.

1. Batman Kills

This is the big one as it doesn't just go against the comics but also goes against the last two films. Believe it or not Batman kills. I'm not talking about not saving someone (although when you are responsible for a train crashing I don't think you can argue innocence to someone on board dying) I'm talking about pulling the trigger. Literally. Yes, Batman stops Catwoman from shooting people but then when the chips are down and there is a nuclear bomb about to wipe Gotham off the map he doesn't hesitate to shoot the crap out of the truck carrying the bomb. He shot the driver fair and square and he caused the truck to crash which offed Talia Al Ghul as well. Now, Talia could almost be gotten around, that was a consequence of her own actions to a degree. The driver, less so. He got shot by a very big gun on Batman's little flying tank. I'm not arguing that this wasn't the right call, and perhaps this is a part of Batman's resignation. He is finally giving Gotham everything. But we aren't talking about his life, Gotham has had that from day one, just no one could take it. It makes me think that perhaps what Batman meant when he said he hasn't given everything yet to Catwoman, what he means is he has yet to give Gotham his morals. This isn't explicit and with all the fast editing avoiding the blood and gore (and consequences) to keep that 12A rating, it is hard to keep track. Still, it certainly feels like the Batman that climbed out of the hole was willing to kill Bane if he had to. He certainly didn't hold back the gunfire aimed directly at the cab of that truck!

Contributor

A video editor by trade and a lover of movies, games and manga.