5 Western Movie Remakes That Are Better Than The Original

A Fist

It is a well-known fact that cowboys are cool as hell. In fact, they are so cool that countless movies have been made about them. Some, of course, are better than others; Tombstone is way better, for instance, than Cowboys and Aliens. However, this article's focus is on remakes. Specifically, films of any genre that were redone as gunslingin', yee-hawin', tobacco-spittin' cowboy movies.

Remakes are often the cardinal sins of the movie industry. There's a good reason for that: a lot of the time, the filmmakers are banking on the name alone to bring them box-office success. Unfortunately, we, the viewing public, are often duped into paying our hard-earned cash to go and see them. Every now and then, though, there is a remake that totally defies the trend. It doesn't just avoid total and utter disappointment - it's actually a good film. Sometimes - dare I say it? - a great film. Here are five movies that, in my humble opinion, actually improved on the respective titles that inspired them - some more than others. As always, don't hesitate to vent your disagreements, criticisms etc in the comments section.

5. Ned Kelly (2003)

Ned Kelly 1970's Ned Kelly, starring Mick Jagger (yes, that Mick Jagger; which other one could it be?) in the title role, was based on the true story of a once-innocent, fairly normal Australian man in the outback who descends into a life of crime. Like many Australian outback cowboy criminals, he starts off stealing horses - before long, though, he is drawn into murder. In doing so, he became one of the most wanted men in the world. Think Walter White, but with more horses and less blue crystal meth (but about the same amount of murder). The only thing was, it was pretty poor; Mick Jagger was never going to be a good option to play such a well-known historical figure, let alone an Australian one. The dialogue and pacing of the action didn't really help either, and the movie suffered as a result. Screen Shot 2013 11 05 At 20 15 50 The 2003 edition sought to remedy some of those issues; actual Aussies Heath Ledger and Naomi Watts were cast in the lead roles for a start. This went some way - along with better dialogue, music and cinematography - to improving on the original. That is not to say it was a great movie, mind - though it was good, and certainly improved on the 1970 version. Bonus points to those of you who know that the Heath Ledger movie is not strictly a remake. The Ned Kelly of 1970 was based on an original screenplay written by Ian Jones and Tony Richardson, while the material for the 2003 film was taken from a novel. Still, it warrants a place on this list because both movies focus on the same character's story. Also, the movie posters are rather alike, wouldn't you say?

4. The Magnificent Seven (1960)

Themagnificentseven Still2 A slightly controversial entry here, given that the film on which The Magnificent Seven is based - Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai - is widely considered the pinnacle of Asian cinema. The plot of both movies revolves around a group of men who are tasked with protecting a village and its defenceless denizens. The main difference between the two is that in one movie, it's a group of Samurai (and Kikuchiyo), and in the other, it's cowboys. Seven Samurai Of course, which movie you prefer is a matter of personal taste. For me, music is often a hugely important part of great films, and in my opinion The Magnificent Seven is superior in that regard. Also, I am a fan of Steve McQueen, Eli Wallach and Charles Bronson, so I am swayed in that respect as well. Furthermore, while watching Seven Samurai, I didn't always feel connected to what was going on; whether this was a cultural or cinematic complaint I am still not sure. I am certain of one thing, however: I enjoyed watching The Magnificent Seven more, and that is what counts.

3. A Fistful Of Dollars (1964)

A Fistful Of Dollars - edited for article The first instalment of Sergio Leone's lauded 'Dollars Trilogy' focuses on the arrival of a mysterious stranger at a town run by two rival gangs. It doesn't take long before he decides to play the two against each other for his own benefit, and, incidentally, the townspeople's. It is Leone's Spaghetti Western take on Akira Kurosawa's Yojimbo, which was released three years prior. Despite the clear similarities - such as an antagonist fawning over his fancy weapon (Unosuke's revolver and Ramon's rifle) and the stranger informing the coffin maker that he's got work to do - credit wasn't quite given where it was due. Needless to say, Kurosawa was none too happy about this, and proceeded to sue the Italian. He was awarded 15% of all revenue generated by the remake, and later admitted that he made more money off it than he did his own film. yojimbofaceoff There are a few reasons I consider A Fistful of Dollars the superior film of the two. Clint Eastwood, for a start. Also, the OST, composed by the legendary Ennio Morricone, is awesome. On the whole, like many things, it comes down to personal preference, which isn't always something you can put your finger on.

2. 3:10 to Yuma (2007)

3:10 To Yuma The awesomely-cast 3:10 to Yuma, released in 2007, follows notorious outlaw Ben Wade (Russell Crowe) and his escort as they endeavour to get him on the 3:10 train to Yuma prison, where he is to be tried and hanged for his numerous crimes. Christian Bale co-stars as Dan Evans, a ranch owner in need of cash and the good fortune of rain to fall on his land; he volunteers to join the escort for $200. Much of the film revolves around the trials and tribulations (read: gunfights) of the journey to Yuma. However, the action is never over the top, and the suspense is kept at a high as the viewer knows that Wade's men are hot on the trail of the escort. A major highlight of the movie, where the tension reaches nail-biting levels, comes in the hotel scene - but I won't spoil that here. The original, released half a century earlier, takes very much the same path as the remake, but with the hallmarks of a classic Western. For instance, where the 2010 release relies on ambient noises and subtle tones to generate atmosphere, the '57 version has a cool theme tune, like so many westerns of the era. Elsewhere1 Both movies are good in their own ways, but I consider the Crowe/Bale Yuma the better of the two - though they aren't miles apart in terms of the overall enjoyment factor.

1. True Grit (2010)

true-grit-2010-rooster-cogburn-jeff-bridges-billboard-600x300 The second film in this list which is not strictly a remake of another movie, the Coen brothers' True Grit is their own take on the same novel on which Henry Hathaway's 1969 version was based. Mattie Ross, played by the increasingly popular Hailee Steinfeld, is a 14-year-old girl who takes the law into her own hands after her father is murdered by Tom Chaney (Josh Brolin) and no-one seems bothered enough to track him down and hold him to account for this heinous crime. Despite her young age, and her status as a female in a patriarchal society, Mattie is noticeably sharper than most of the characters she comes across, and fearless to boot. However, she is also smart enough to know that she simply isn't capable of bringing Chaney to justice by herself, and so enlists - after some bargaining - the assistance of Texas Ranger LaBouef (Matt Damon) and Rooster Cogburn (Jeff Bridges), a grizzly, battle-hardened marshal. What follows is a genuinely entertaining and decidedly tense affair, with excellent performances from all the stars. true grit blu ray The 1969 release featured Hollywood legend and manly-man John Wayne in the role of Cogburn, and between this version and the Coen brothers', I would argue that the difference in quality is smaller than any other two movies on this list. Bridges isn't necessarily better than Wayne - just different. The music in the '69 version is marginally better, too. But there are certain cinematic details that tip the scale in favour of the Coens' movie: the gunshots sound more realistic, and the barrels visibly smoke when shots are fired; Steinfeld's Mattie is the better of the two; and the authentic dialogue of the 2010 edition is as memorable as it is unusual to listen to at first. So, that concludes this list. Like I said at the beginning, I have no doubt that some of my opinions will cause some readers to spray their coffee/tea/Irn Bru all over their screens, but at the end of the day, they are my opinions. I hope you enjoyed the article nonetheless.

Contributor
Contributor

I am a football obsessive from Durham in the north-east of England. My interests also include but are not limited to music, video games, TV and film. Follow me on Twitter @liamgilchrist88