6 Major Concerns From Ready Player One Trailer
Nostalgia can only take you so far.
Steven Spielberg's adaptation of Ernest Cline's nostalgia-powered novel has certainly earned some buzz among film fans, and for good reason. The original book offered up so much love and adoration to the 80's that it would make the creators of Stranger Things blush. Now, with current pop culture definitely feeling that same level of love towards nostalgia-powered entertainment, Ready Player One is ready to capitalize on that.
However, after one teaser trailer and the first official trailer, there are some worthy concerns to bring up in response to what has been shown so far. The source material suffered from heavy exposition, a somewhat uninteresting character and a lack of real substance outside of a plethora of references to nerd culture.
Unfortunately, the film seems to be following suit in that regard, leading this author to fear that this undoubtedly entertaining-looking journey may disappoint.
While the footage shown is worthy of some merit, the fairly muted response so far is most likely because of worrisome elements that may lead to expectations not being met.
6. It's A Spielberg Film (Without Any Evident Spielberg Charm)
When you hear that Steven Spielberg is in charge of a film, you expect a certain level of quality and heart infused within every part of it. However, any semblance of Spielberg's involvement is lost amongst a standard, big-budget, CGI-filled affair, as it feels less like a film helmed by one of Hollywood's finest directors.
Considering that Spielberg used to be a king of modern blockbusters, it seems odd that his presence is so absent in both trailers so far. This may be more the fault of the writing and the trailers hiding some of the film's deeper moments, but the overall lack of charm or deeper joys outside of nostalgic references is concerning.
Yes, what we have is certainly impressive and offers creative visuals, but none of it seems like it's on-par with what Spielberg has continually offered in his previous work. Here's hoping the trailers are just an oversimplification of the film as a whole, rather than an accurate representation of how deep the experience will be.
5. The Writing Team
When looking at the screenwriting team, it's worth noting the relative lack of actual screenwriting experience between the two.
Zak Penn, while credited for story credits throughout the years, doesn't have much experience when it comes to screenplays. Worse yet, when he DID do them, it was for films like X-Men 3, Elektra, and The Incredible Hulk.
Ernest Cline obviously wrote the book, but considering that also had its problems, it's unclear if the movie can avoid the same issues.
The book, out of necessity, was filled with exposition in which the world was explained from the protagonist's perspective. This is where RPO can improve on the source material as it has the option of visual storytelling. However, considering Zak Penn was brought in to rewrite the initial script penned by Erik Eason and Cline, it's possible that Cline was already having troubles with the script and with Penn's own struggles with solo screenwriting, the screenplay is by no means a certainty.
Zak Penn has been a part of strong writing teams (albeit they were for the 'story' rather than 'screenplay' credits) and Cline definitely has shown charm in his writing, so it's still very possible that this duo ends up beating expectations and offering audiences a deeper experience than initially expected.
4. Characters That Get Lost In The Spectacle
While the movie was always going to be heavily spectacle-driven, it seems impossible for an audience to care about the characters when visuals are receiving the most attention. Not only that, but since we're dealing with two different realities (the Oasis and a dystopian future), RPO may face the same problem as Assassin's Creed's Animus and jarring real-world settings. The Animus (or Oasis in this case) represents the most interesting setting and set of locations, but the story keeps going back to the real world, leading to a drop in intrigue and a drag in the plot's pacing.
Not only that, but since much of the movie involves characters playing as avatars, audiences may end up forgetting the real people controlling these created personalities. Besides, it seems that while there will be plenty of characters in the Oasis, there are only a handful of people in the real-world that prove to be relevant: Tye Sheridan's Wade, Olivia Cooke's Samantha, Ben Mendelsohn's Nolan and Mark Rylance's Halliday.
Ready Player One may prove to have an adequately-balanced runtime between both realities, but real-world characters are in danger of being forgotten whenever we re-enter the Oasis.
3. Far Too Familiar Themes And Story
At the beginning of the trailer, the story set-up of an all-out treasure hunt in a massive digital space sounds unique and fresh.
Yet, halfway through the trailer, it becomes a story of rebellion and fighting 'The Man,' leading to the teased story coming across as far more familiar than it should. When you think about how Wade's background and story lead-in is like an amalgamation of several other rags-to-riches stories (primarily Charlie Bucket in Willy Wonka), the lack of innovative storytelling begins to wear down the appeal.
As more plot details come out, it seems this reference-filled homage to nerd culture has a relatively standard core, especially with the antagonist being a part of an evil corporation that only wants to control the Oasis and all of its players.
This story could be something pretty unique if they play their cards right, but they need to be willing to be unfamiliar and different. So far, it seems that this tale may follow a well-treaded (but heavily reference-filled) path.
2. Over-Reliance On Nostalgia And Easter Eggs
Now now, 80's nostalgia may have been the primary appeal of the source novel, but in the trailer, it seems like the easter eggs and nostalgic appeals are present less because they assist the story and more because the film is trying to get everyone to go "Ooh, it's that character from that one game/movie!"
It lacks purpose and feels forced into it rather than something that serves the story.
Shots of characters like King Kong, Joker and even Tracer from Overwatch are awesome easter eggs that add to RPO's aesthetic, but they don't really add anything of substance to the film itself. Considering the sheer amount of easter eggs and background icons present in both trailers so far, it's highly unlikely that the rest of the movie won't be similar to this.
The book did something similar in that Cline would consistently name-drop random popular things from the 80's like Atari's and Pac-Man (among others), so this isn't dissimilar from the source material.
That said, the trailer's noteworthy moments feel like they're more based on the "OMG is that the Back to the Future jingle at the end?" moments, and less on actual plot details.
1. A Bland Protagonist
Ready Player One's writing team were always going to have difficulty establishing a particularly-interesting protagonist since the Oasis is the real star (and the book's version of the Wade Watts character wasn't particularly noteworthy either), but it's difficult to ignore just how bland and uninteresting Wade seems to be, especially in comparison to the incredibly interesting world that surrounds him.
The book sets up Wade as a Charlie Bucket-like underdog that comes from hardship to become a key player in this massive competition. It's definitely a worthy backstory, but Wade as a character isn't really all that interesting. The flair and intrigue comes from the craziness within the Oasis that he must endure, but it's never really him that's the interesting part. It's the unfortunate framing of Cline's source novel, and it doesn't seem like it'll be much different for the film.
Tye Sheridan is a talented young actor, but so far, it doesn't seem like he has a strong archetype to work with that'll help him add much memorability or charisma to the role (since Wade is supposed to be a nerdy, overweight kid who doesn't socialize well).
Here's hoping he can avoid being the dull centerpiece in a heavily-flashy overall experience.