7 More Horror Films That Eerily Came True

The scariest monsters are the real ones.

Dead Silence
Universal Pictures

Horror movies are supposed to be a fun deviation from the everyday - a little insight into the dark and scary that we would never usually experience.

Bringing the supernatural hurtling into our own reality, creating crazy original monsters, and depicting terrifying situations with artistic flair, horror cinema is best enjoyed knowing that we're watching something that would never ACTUALLY creep into our own lives, as much as it tries to make us believe otherwise.

But for some, it's an entirely different story, and the line between fact and fiction no longer exists.

These entries explore the horrifying reality of some movies that have breached the fourth wall, climbing out of the television set like a demented Samara to bring the genre to life. Be warned, this isn't for the squeamish - tragedy is at the heart of all these terrible crimes.

7. Recreating The Blair Witch Project Turned Out Far Worse Than Any Witch In The Woods

Blair Witch Project
Artisan

Bringing about a world of shaky cam and terrifying campers out of the woods for good, The Blair Witch Project inspired more than the horror industry when it came out in 1999. With aspiring filmmakers desperate to replicate the Blair Witch effect and taking found footage into their own hands, Blaine Norris was one such person with a shaky cam dream - attempting to make his own movie with Through A Hike: A Ghost Story.

It was through a friend, Brian Trimble, that he managed to secure a cameraman - but when Trimble became diagnosed with Multiple Sclerosis and could no longer keep up with the physical demands of filming, Norris’s movie lost its funding, and he was thrust into desperation. So was Trimble - left financially struggling by his condition.

The pair devised a plan to kill Trimble’s wife for the insurance payout, and inadvertently created a plot much better than the Blair Witch rip they’d originally planned. With poor Randi Trimble’s death scene looking obviously set up, police soon discovered the truth, and the pair were sentenced to life in prison.


6. Two Girls Wanted To Avoid The Wrath Of The Slender Man

MV5BNTEyNzZhMjktM2EzNC00ZWYyLTkxYzItNzYyYzliYmVmYzdiXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMzU0NzkwMDg _V1_SY1000_CR0 0 694 1000_AL_
Super Movie Bros

The little known Slender Man movie that came before 2018 is not a good film. Released in 2013 and generally considered terrible, it’s influence was just as bad as its presentation - bringing the creepypasta favourite to life in a way that inspired an attempted murder.

Quite famously now, 2014 saw two 12 year old girls attack their friend whilst playing a game of hide and seek in the woods. Taking a 5-inch kitchen knife, they held her down and stabbed her repeatedly - apparently so they could become proxies for the Slenderman and prevent their families from being targeted by him.

They were under the impression that a murder would be the only way to gain his favour, and they’d then be considered loyal and allowed to live in his mansion.

Of course, they were denounced as batshit insane. The pair were convicted and found guilty by insanity, and will remain locked up for the next 25 years at the very, very least. I guess the Slender Man mansion comes with its own bars.


5. Creepy Puppets And Crazy Ventriloquists Aren't Confined To Dead Silence

Dead Silent
Universal Pictures

James Wan’s foray into the world of haunted dolls was done with the irrefutably creepy Dead Silence, starring Billy as the glass-eyed vessel for a ventriloquist spirit to wreak revenge on the Ashen family.

Whilst the real life counterpart that follows this story isn’t dead, he doesn’t need to be for this horror story to hit home. Ronald Brown, a TV ventriloquist from Florida with his own terrifying wooden pal named Marty, was arrested in 2012 for having reams of child pornography, bolstered with journals on his desire to cook and eat children.

Mary Shaw might have only stolen tongues, but upon searching Brown’s house, officials found a butcher’s diagram of how to cut a whole child into steaks, just to really drive the whole cannibal thing home.

It’s some strange irony that the tale of a insane ventriloquist in reality is far scarier than that on screen - but there’s some comfort to be taken in knowing that Brown was arrested and put away before he could actually eat anyone. Remember folks - it’s not the doll that’s scary, it’s the baby-eating monster with their hand up its butt you’ve got to watch out for.


4. The Lost Boys Aren't The Only Ones Drinking Blood

The Lost Boys
Warner Bros.

Joel Schumacher’s vampire horror is the peak of 80s cinema, proving a cult classic over the years since release and a transformation of the vampire trope into much younger and sexier bloodsuckers than the Draculas of old. Whilst one side of the movie is about slaying vampires, the other is about becoming one - and it’s this that inspired a young boy to take his chances as one of the undead.

A particular scene in The Lost Boys sees Michael drink blood in an initiation test from the other angsty vampires, and unfortunately, it was enough to inspire one such watcher to try it out for themselves.

One year after the film’s release, 30-year-old Donald Gall went on a camping trip with four teenage boys, who consequently beat and stabbed the man to death after a fight broke out on the campsite. Becoming ‘very interested’ in vampirism ever since watching the 1987 movie, one of the perpetrators then drank Gall’s spilled blood - though seemingly had no urge to transform into a bat, go on moonlit walks, or hiss at garlic bread afterwards.

The boys were only caught when another friend turned them in after they spoke about their crime to him.


3. The Exorcist Inspired Other Cases Of Demon Possession... Or So Some Believed

The exorcist
Warner Bros.

Infamous throughout the world for its groundbreaking presentation of a little girl possessed by a demon and one of the most profitable horror movies ever made, The Exorcist is the story of Regan’s battle for her soul after she’s taken over by Pazuzu and ultimately saved by a Catholic priest, aka, a professional demon wrangler. Considering how controversial the film was, and still is really, it’s unsurprising that it’s garnered its share of blame for the actions of the unhinged in the wake of its release.

Just two days after The Exorcist aired on TV, Patricia Frazier came under the assumption that her daughter must be possessed by demons. The circumstances of this we will never know, as taking extreme action and not employing the titular solution to the film’s problem, she instead decided to cut out her daughter’s heart and leave it in the footwell of her car.

Now, in 1976, the film was enough evidence for psychologists to claim ‘cinematic trauma’ influenced Frazier’s actions, even though it was known she was suffering from paranoid schizophrenia.


2. The Collector Wasn't The Only One Kidnapping Women

The Collector 9
Columbia Pictures

It might be debatable as to whether 1965’s The Collector is technically a horror film - even though the events it depicts are terrifying to imagine - but the horrific actions it inspired in its wake offer no such ambiguity.

The story of The Collector follows a man obsessed with Miranda, an art student in his town, driven to kidnap her and keep her in his basement by his own intense desire. An avid collector of butterflies, he treats her like one of his specimens - until she accidentally dies of an illness contracted by trying to escape in the rain.

Two men, Leonard Lake and Charles Ng, took no stock of Freddie’s lack of sexual interest, nor his mostly non-violent ways, and instead conducted what they called ‘Operation Miranda’ on anywhere between 11 and 25 people they abducted at will. Torturing and eventually murdering the girls they stole, they kept them in a soundproof bunker, nicknamed a ‘dungeon’, where they couldn’t be heard from the outside.

Lake was caught shoplifting, leading police to find Ng and all the evidence revealing their horrific crimes.


1. Sweeney Todd's Mystery Meat Pies Are A Real Life Specialty

Sweeney Todd
Dream Works

Sweeney Todd, a horror-comedy featuring the Fleet Street barber that killed his patrons and turned them into pies, was originally based on English folklore and transformed into Broadway musical by Stephen Sondheim - before grabbing Johnny Depp by the stringy mustache and pulling him in for the film adaptation. It’s campy, fun, and mostly ridiculous, slathered in Tim Burton charm and a whole load of blood.

But of course, we can’t have nice things, and instead of simply serving as a popular interpretation of a dark fairy tale: Sweeney Todd is also tarred with being a troubling starting point for a string of murders.

A year after the film’s release, Jorge Beltrao Negromonte da Silveira, along with his wife and mistress, started killing young women in a small town in Brazil; forming their own cult intent on murdering those that they believed would only bring ‘bad souls’ into the world as a form of population purification. They then took their victims flesh, packed it into their meat pies and empanadas, and sold it to the general populace.

And you thought the horse meat scandal was bad.


In this post: 
Dead-Silence
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Horror film junkie, burrito connoisseur, and serial cat stroker. WhatCulture's least favourite ginger.