7 Most Disappointing MCU Movies (So Far)

They can't all be Black Panther.

Disappointing MCU Movies
Marvel Studios

The Marvel Cinematic Universe is the most commercially successful movie franchise in cinema history, grossing a ludicrous $18 billion at the box office over the last decade-and-a-bit.

But what's arguably even more impressive is the relative consistency of the movies, where even after 21 films, not a single one has scored a Rotten rating from Rotten Tomatoes critics - that's 59% and under.

However, not all the movies are created equal, and it's fair to say that the franchise has nevertheless delivered a number of underwhelming efforts even if they weren't outright bad.

Thankfully the MCU tends to deliver the goods when it matters most, but from lacklustre origin stories to weirdly generic sequels and epic team-up movies that fell short of the expected mark, these 7 films are the MCU's most disappointing to date.

It's remarkable that a cinematic universe this sprawling and complex hasn't delivered a DCEU-calibre dud yet, but make no mistake, the following movies all should've made more of an impact than they did...


7. Thor: The Dark World

Thor The Dark World Loki
Marvel Studios

The first Thor wasn't a great film by any means, but Kenneth Branagh did a solid job exploiting the campy Shakespearean tenor of the material, while leaving plenty of room for a sequel to build on its foundation.

But from its laughably generic sub-title onward, Thor: The Dark World is the closest thing the MCU has to a bad movie. It is soulless, dull blockbuster mediocrity.

From forgettable antagonist Malekith (Christopher Eccleston) - the MCU's worst, by the way - to the needlessly continued romance between Thor (Chris Hemsworth) and Jane Foster (a comatose Natalie Portman), the drab visuals, TV-like cinematography and cringe-worthy comedic subplots, the MCU has never felt this listless and unnecessary.

Sure, Loki's (Tom Hiddleston) Machiavellian scheming still raises a smirk and the Captain America (Chris Evans) cameo is hilarious, but if you're ever starting an MCU rewatch, it's the most skippable movie of the lot.

Thankfully Thor: Ragnarok finally gave the Asgardian the solo outing he deserved from the beginning, only further underlining how utterly unremarkable The Dark World truly is.


6. The Incredible Hulk

The Incredible Hulk
Marvel Studios

It did The Incredible Hulk no favours at all that it released barely a month after the MCU's very first outing, the effortlessly superior Iron Man.

And though it's a good deal more coherent and pacier than Ang Lee's divisive 2003 Hulk, it still fails to fully capitalise on one of the most distinct Avengers.

Despite mercifully glossing over Bruce Banner's (Edward Norton) origin story and benefiting from Norton's intense central performance, the script is a jumbled, awkward mish-mash of tones and ideas that don't really resolve into a particularly compelling whole.

Liv Tyler's charmless performance kills the romance dead and Abomination (Tim Roth) is a generic villain, ensuring the film never really aspires to be much more than a watchable summer entertainment.

Considering the enormous potential of a Hulk solo movie, it's a shame that the film's $263.4 million box office - the MCU's lowest to date and probably ever - made the prospect of any future Hulk movies extremely slim.


5. Ant-Man & The Wasp

Ant Man And The Wasp
Marvel Studios

Ant-Man and the Wasp really felt like it would be a solid step up in quality from its middling predecessor - and more on that film later - but ultimately it turned out a totally workmanlike, also-ran sequel that merely cleansed the palette after Avengers: Infinity War.

Introducing the Wasp (Evangeline Lilly) should've majorly changed the game and given the MCU another marquee female superhero, yet as a coming-out party for the character, it was a pretty mild affair.

Sure, the action sings and there are some hilarious one-liners, but the narrative is ultra-low effort, the villains stink and it wastes a number of terrific actors, namely Michelle Pfeiffer, Walton Goggins and Laurence Fishburne.

It's not a bad sequel, but only about as good as the first, which is to say middle-of-the-road. Given the unique abilities of Ant-Man and his new cohort, this follow-up was oddly lacking in imagination and ingenuity, not to mention flatly shot.


4. Captain Marvel

Captain Marvel Brie Larson
Marvel Studios

To be totally fair to Captain Marvel, it had an enormous weight of expectations laid upon it, being the MCU's first (and very belated) female-led superhero film.

But even accepting that, it's rather disappointing that the origin story for the MCU's most powerful Avenger - that's in Kevin Feige's own words, by the way - is just a decent, unremarkable movie.

Captain Marvel should've been the MCU's Wonder Woman: a lush, heart-on-sleeve feminist battle cry which upended expectations and made everyone fall in love with the character.

But from the flat direction to the just-OK script and mixed visuals, it failed to give Brie Larson the barnstorming material she deserved.

Larson at least made for a fine pairing with Samuel L. Jackson, and Ben Mendelsohn gave a typically entertaining performance in the antagonist role, but overall it felt far more typical and familiar than just about anybody wanted it to.

Perhaps back in Phase One a film this formulaic wouldn't invite so much indifference, but 21 movies in, they really should be trying harder than this, especially with a hero so presumably pivotal to the outcome of Avengers: Endgame.


3. Ant-Man

Ant Man
Marvel Studios

Ant-Man's disappointment started long before the movie was even released, what with original writer-director Edgar Wright bailing from the project due to "creative differences" with Marvel.

Filling his directorial shoes - with a re-worked script, no less - was always going to be a tough sell, and though the film turned out decently entertaining, it ultimately just left fans pining for Wright's unfulfilled vision.

From its washed-out, TV-aping visuals to Peyton Reed's mediocre direction, wasting the brilliant Corey Stoll with a mediocre villain and the groan-worthy Baskin Robbins product placement, Ant-Man turned out a cinematic shoulder shrug.

Paul Rudd and Michael Pena did their best, but without a captivating creative spark the film failed to make the most of their talents or the pint-sized superhero at the forefront.


2. Avengers: Age Of Ultron

Avengers Age of Ultron Ending
Marvel Studios

Living up to the crowd-pleasing brilliance of The Avengers was a thankless and near-impossible task, and duly, Joss Whedon clearly struggled to recapture the same novel magic.

A giant step down from the original, you can practically hear Whedon straining to make this sequel as exciting, funny and important as its predecessor, delivering a bloated, overstuffed follow-up that too often felt a bit, well, lazy.

From the overabundance of quippy dialogue to the shoehorned subplots - especially the romance between Bruce Banner (Mark Ruffalo) and Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson) - to the throwaway treatment of Quicksilver (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) and disappointing depiction of Ultron (James Spader), it's a far more generic movie than just about anyone expected.

It has some great individual scenes - the party in particular - and the performances are reliably solid, but it is a textbook example of a sequel which lacks the freshness of what came before.

And the production was such a stress on Whedon that he decided to part ways with Marvel Studios shortly thereafter.


1. Iron Man 2

Iron Man 2 Pepper Potts Birthday Party Scene 2
Marvel Studios

Though Age of Ultron didn't meet expectations, there's no single MCU movie which fell as short of the hype as Iron Man 2.

The third entry into the universe and released just two years after the original Iron Man, fan excitement was at a fever pitch after the success of the first film, with the marketing promising a bigger and more ambitious, universe-expanding follow-up.

And though Iron Man 2 certainly has its moments - most of them courtesy of Sam Rockwell - it thoroughly wastes Mickey Rourke as Whiplash, the action sequences are goofy and boring (especially the party fight), the dynamic between Tony (Robert Downey Jr.) and Black Widow has aged horribly, and the final battle is absurdly anti-climactic.

In retrospect it got a fairly easy ride from critics - who generally liked the film well enough - because the MCU formula hadn't yet become firmly established, but in terms of living up to its predecessor, Iron Man 2 was shockingly meh.

Which MCU movies have disappointed you the most so far? Agree or disagree with our picks? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.