7 Reasons The MCU Is Better Off Without Joss Whedon
Break-ups are never easy but soemtimes they're necessary.
Along with Jon Favreau and (of course) Kevin Feige, Joss
Whedon was a key figure in getting the Marvel Cinematic Universe off
the ground. Yes, by the time Avengers was released things were well underway,
but if the first superhero team-up had failed, the whole universe would have collapsed.
But Whedon pulled off a miracle and made an extremely entertaining film that
showed the potential of the MCU.
Age of Ultron was a disappointing follow-up, and while not a failure by any means, it highlighted some major issues between Whedon and Marvel. Whedon quickly cut ties with the studio, saying that the sequel broke him and hinted at behind the scenes disagreements. At the time, it seemed like a major loss for Marvel but they've proven to not only survive without Whedon, but thrive.
The truth is, despite all Whedon’s talents, the MCU is better off without him. Despite collaborating on one great film, it was apparent that the creative minds at work here just did not mesh well.
But just as Whedon has moved onto projects more suited to his own tastes, the MCU has improved in his absence. So, with all due respect to the very talented Joss Whedon, let’s look at why the MCU is better off without him.
7. He’s To Blame For Age Of Ultron
Whedon spoke openly during the press tour for Age of Ultron about the compromises he was forced to make on the film. Many fans took this to mean that flawed final product was the result of studio meddling and if Marvel had left Whedon to his own devices, we would have gotten the Avengers sequel we’d hoped for. However, the truth of the matter is that much of the flaws in the film are Whedon’s fault.
One item the studio did push was Thor's awkward cave visions. According to Whedon, Marvel gave him two options; do the cave sequence or lose the sequence at the farm. For starters, the farm sequence isn't much better than the cave. It really only serves as reparations for Hawkeye's character and to bloat the plot. Secondly, as bad as the cave sequence was, Whedon admits to taking a lazy approach to it. With a little more effort he could have made it feel more organic to the plot.
Beyond that, Whedon’s own ideas contributed to the film’s problems. You might think that the overstuffed cast was Marvel’s attempt to fit in as many heroes as possible but it was Whedon who insisted on The Vision, Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver all appearing in the same film. He also chose Ultron as the villain and came up with his bizarre characterization. The flimsy plot, mismatched tone, lack of stakes- all these issues fall to the writer-director.
Whedon made one brilliant superhero film, but he also made a lackluster one. Given a third chance he might have bounced back, or he might have stumbled even more.
6. The Quips Got Out Of Hand
Part of what makes the Marvel films click with audiences is
that they don't take themselves too seriously. The films have always done a
great job balancing the superhero action with moments of comedy.
Whedon really excelled at this with The Avengers. His signature quippy, pop-culture-filled dialogue worked surprisingly well when delivered by these iconic characters. He found the humor in all of the characters and it made for a genuinely hilarious film.
Sadly for the sequel, Whedon forgot that the humor should aid the story and instead put far too much focus on the jokes. It seems as though he was trying to out-do himself and crammed every scene with endless one-liners and superhero bantering. There were still quite a few funny bits but whereas the jokes in the first Avengers were true to the characters, this time everyone sounded like Tony Stark which got a little tiring.
Worst of all, he inexplicably decided to make Ultron, a villain with great potential, into a sarcastic, sassy nuisance for the Avengers. Marvel certainly has a history of bland baddies, but this was not the way to fix the problem.
Whedon can craft some great dialogue, there's no disputing that, but he can also get carried away with himself.
5. New Filmmakers Can Stand On Their Own
Whedon services for the MCU didn’t stop at writing and
directing The Avengers films- he was also their secret weapon. Given his gift
for dialogue and long career as a Hollywood script doctor, Marvel had Whedon
work on several of the other of the universe’s films. He reportedly did
punch-ups to the scripts for Captain America: The First Avenger and Thor: The
Dark World, trying to add in some what made the Avengers so special.
It’s a smart move to put someone like Whedon in a consultant position, especially in the early days of the MCU while they were still trying to find the right voice for their films. The success of The Avengers gave them something to aim for and they hoped to replicate that success.
However, as the universe evolved, it became clear that the individual movies can feel different from one another. They began bringing in filmmakers like James Gunn and Shane Black to infuse their unique voices into the films.
Since that revelation, Marvel has made some really exciting choices when hiring filmmakers. No one could have anticipated that Taika Waititi would helm a Thor movie, or that Ryan Coogler would go from gritty indies to Black Panther. They’re bold choices but these filmmakers all have strong and unique voices of their own, and Marvel has learned enough to trust their filmmakers.
4. He Doesn't Get All The Characters
Part of what made Whedon such a solid choice for the Avengers was his love of this world. Whedon is a massive comic book fan and brings that passion to many of the caharcters- but not all them.
While Whedon did a great job of bringing together all these characters, it seems he really only wants to focus on a few main ones and let the others fall by the wayside. He seems to enjoy the virtue of Captain America and has a real knack for writing dialogue for Tony Stark, but many of the other Avengers don’t get the same love. Despite being one of the main Marvel characters, Thor is given very little to do in Whedon’s films. And while he tried to make up for his handling of Hawkeye, it’s pretty clear he’s not too interested in the character.
When it comes to introducing new characters, Whedon also seems to have some trouble. As much as he insisted on including Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver, he doesn’t have anything interesting for them to do and they’re sort of just there. The Vision is an interesting character but he’s introduced so late in the film we never really get a grasp on who he is.
Then there’s Whedon’s treatment of Black Widow in Age of Ultron. I don’t want to criticize too harshly here because Whedon has been beat up a lot on this issue and I don’t feel he made malicious intentions. The fact remains, however, that throwing your one female character into a pointless and out-of-nowhere romantic relationship just so she has something to do is misguided.
3. The Russos Have Proven Themselves
Credit where credit is due, Whedon directed one of the best
Marvel movies to date. The Avengers will go down as a near-perfect superhero
film and the massive success of the film rightly made him Marvel’s golden boy.
But since his departure, Marvel has found a new golden boy- well, boys
actually.
Many people scratched their heads when Marvel handed over the Captain America franchise to Anthony and Joe Russo, brothers known for their small screen work on Community and Arrested Development. But skeptics were quickly made true believers as Captain America: The Winter Solider proved to be a stellar action film, engrossing thriller and the film that made Captain America cool.
Proving that the first time wasn’t a fluke, the brothers followed up with Captain America: Civil War, one of this year’s biggest hits. The sequel did an amazing job of juggling the biggest cast of the MCU so far, servicing all our favorite characters and even introducing some new key players. No wonder Marvel named them as the ones to helm the epic two-part Avengers: Infinity War.
This will be the first Avengers film without Whedon as director and yet there has been little concern over his absence. That’s a true testament to what the Russos have shown us so far. They are surprisingly skilled action directors, they understand this world and how to build upon it, and they evidently have a great love of these characters.
It’s safe to say the Avengers are in good hands.
2. So Have Markus And McFeely
Although the Russos deserve heaps of praise for what they've accomplished with the Captain America films, the unsung heroes of those films are undoubtedly writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely.
Plot-wise, The Winter Soldier and Civil War and far and away the best written films in the MCU. The Winter Solider is an extremely tight political thriller in the guise of a superhero film. It’s made some interesting and brilliant choices in transplanting Captain America in the muddied world of modern espionage while proving to be a real game-changer for the whole universe.
Civil War was an even more complex plot which they handled beautifully. Unlike Batman V Superman, the reason for fighting is somehow rational on both side, the character motivations are believable and the conclusion seems earned.
Markus and McFeely have even shown to succeed where Whedon has struggled. Characters like Scarlet Witch and The Vision were given a lot more depth in Civil War and new characters like Spider-Man and Black Panther were introduced without feeling shoehorned in. The writers have also shown an awareness of appropriate tone. The airport sequence in Civil War has some of the funniest moments from any MCU film, while the film confrontation is among the universe’s darker moments.
With all their strengths, it’s then good news for all Marvel fans that Markus and McFeely will be joining the Russos for the Infinity War films.
1. He Wasn't The Team Player They Needed
A common complaint leveled against Marvel is that they don’t let their filmmakers make their own movie. Critics say they put too much emphasis on serving the bigger picture so filmmakers are restricted in what they can do. It’s said that this insistence on connective tissue to the rest of the MCU is what caused Edgar Wright to walk away from Ant-Man. While that departure hurt, Marvel was totally in the right.
The MCU is a series of films all connecting to one another and as much as you can say Iron Man 3 is a standalone film, what happens in one film affects the rest of the films. It’s completely understandable if some filmmakers are turned off by that but anyone who agrees to join the MCU needs to know that they’re just one player on a much bigger team.
It’s disappointing then, that after several years of involvement, Whedon still didn’t seem to care about the bigger picture. He made his films with little regard for what came before or what had to follow. The Bifrost is destroyed? Thor still gets to Earth no problem. Iron Man retired and destroyed all his suits?
He’s back in action with a new suit. Whedon had ideas for how he wants his films to be and expected the rest of the universe to cater to those visions. He even spoke about wanting to throw in a two-second cameo from Spider-Man and Captain Marvel at the end of Age of Ultron? Is that really how you want those characters to be introduced?
Whedon has done a lot for the MCU, but as the universe continues to expand it needs collaborators who are onboard with serving the overall all series rather than focusing solely on their film.
Do you agree? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.