8 Actors Who Should Have Won Oscars (But Never Will)
So close to gold yet so far...
When it comes to film awards, the Oscars are undoubtedly the most prestigious and revered. Every year millions of dollars are spent courting the Academy, putting forth certain films and actors for voting consideration.
It's an accolade that not only recognises the quality of a film (and its cast and crew) but that comes with an immensely powerful marketing boost, rocketing DVD and Blu-ray sales and increasing the overall commercial value of a film. That being said, the Oscars are undeniably influenced by politics, and popularity, and a sort of social Zeitgeist. There's also the fact that a massive percentage of Academy voters are white, male and around sixty years old. For these reasons, the results on Oscars night are often out of step with critical and popular consensus, and every year it feels like an actor was robbed or a film neglected. And with so many brilliant performers out there, it's only natural that there are those who don't win. Nevertheless, an Academy Award is something that many actors and actresses chase their whole career, and there are those who sadly miss their one and only chance of winning.8. Tom Cruise

Why They Should Have Won: Across his career Tom Cruise has been nominated for three Oscars. The first was for Best Actor in 1990's Born On The Fourth Of July. The second was for Best Actor in 1997's Jerry Maguire. The third and most worthy was for Best Supporting Actor in 1999s Magnolia.
Magnolia was directed by acclaimed film-maker Paul Thomas Anderson, and explored the lives of a bunch of different characters, each of whom crossed paths and influenced one another's destiny. Cruise played Frank Mackey, a self-help guru with an incredibly troubled relationship with his past. Cruise's performance is eccentric, psychotic and deeply broken. In the end, the Oscar went to Michael Caine for his performance as Dr. Wilbur Larch in The Cider House Rules, but it's a performance that is nowhere near as versatile or interesting. Why They Never Will: Tom Cruise has always been an action star. From the beginning of his mainstream career, Cruise has played the charismatic everyman with the winning smile. As with Adam Sandler in 2002's Punch-Drunk Love, Paul Thomas Anderson managed to hone in on that charisma and tweak it slightly, revealing the rather deranged aspects of Cruise's performances. What's brilliant, then, is the subversion of Cruise's usual characters. It's a once-in-a-career trick, and was supported by an absolutely stellar writer and director. Since then, Cruise has largely reverted back to his typical hero aesthetic, reprising his role as Ethan Hunt in various Mission: Impossible films and appearing in a bunch of other loud (albeit often great) action films.7. Jim Carrey

Why They Should Have Won: Though mostly known for his comedic roles, Jim Carrey has shown some seriously fantastic dramatic chops over the course of his lengthy career. Despite being laced with comedy, The Truman Show is a dark, satirical drama that centres on a man named Truman Burbank, a man whose entire life is the centre of a reality television show.
Despite winning the Golden Globe for Best Actor in a Motion Picture Drama for his performance, Carrey wasn't even nominated for an Oscar (even though he should have been nominated over Nick Nolte in Affliction). Chance struck again in 2004 with the release of critically acclaimed film Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind. Once again, Carrey was lauded for his portrayal of Joel Barish, but despite co-star Kate Winslet receiving a nomination for Best Actress, Carrey was ignored. Why They Never Will: These days, Jim Carrey just isn't a particularly relevant actor. In recent years he has appeared in the commercial flop The Incredible Burt Wonderstone, critical stinker Dumb And Dumber To and cameoed in Kick-Ass 2, which he later claimed to deeply regret. It's been many years since Carrey tried his hand at anything dramatic, and he's no longer a guarantee of financial success. It doesn't help that Carrey has become picky over which roles he takes, denouncing films that depict strong levels of violence. Though currently slated to appear in crime thriller True Crimes in 2016, the project is helmed by an unknown director and is unlikely to make much of a splash.6. Alan Rickman
Why They Should Have Won: Yet another case of franchise-based performances being ignored by Academy critics. Known for his stage acting (Rickman was awarded a place at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art in London) and roles in Die Hard, Love Actually and Sweeney Todd, Rickman's Magnum Opus as an on-screen performer is undoubtedly Severus Snape in the Harry Potter series.
Over the course of the series, Snape goes from a deeply hateful to a deeply sympathetic character, and plays a key role in shaping the events of the series. Snape has a relentlessly enigmatic relationship with Daniel Radcliffe's Harry Potter and is masterfully balanced by Rickman up until the character's tragic death. Many critics were crying out for Rickman to be recognised by the Academy, and believed he finally would be after the release of 2011's final instalment in the series, Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows Part 2. Sadly, a nomination never came. Why They Never Will: Put simply, Rickman's role of a lifetime has come and gone. His portrayal of Snape encompassed everything great about the actor, from his deep, monotonous voice to his potentially sinister physical appearance. Ever since Harry Potter, Rickman has had a string of relativity low-key support roles, none of which have garnered much attention. His upcoming appearance as the CGI caterpillar in the sequel to Tim Burton's Alice In Wonderland is unlikely to be the celebrated role he needs.5. Sigourney Weaver

Why They Should Have Won: Though many people are unaware, Sigourney Weaver was nominated for Best Actress for her portrayal of Ellen Ripley in Ridley Scott's Alien. It makes sense. The portrayal of Ripley is absolutely crucial to the success of the film, and the progression of the plot is carried squarely on her shoulders (shoulders which are alone on-screen for a large portion of the movie).
The nomination itself was a landmark achievement, the first major awards recognition for an actress in a horror or sci-fi role. To go on to win, then, would have been an incredibly significant Academy Awards victory.As it stands the award went to Marlee Matlin for her role as Sarah Norman in Children Of A Lesser God a film that much fewer people remember and that's nowhere near as important a part of film history (not to mention the fact that Weaver was the better actress).
Why They Never Will: Despite receiving three Oscar nominations over the course of her career (the others were for Best Actress and Best Supporting Actress, both in 1988, for Gorillas In The Mist and Working Girl respectively) it's been almost three decades since one of her performances was recognised by the Academy. Like Alan Rickman, Weaver's role as Ellen Ripley far out-shadows everything else she has done, and the fact that she was nominated but didn't win is likely indicative of the fact she never will.Weaver was actually set to reprise her role as Ripley in a new Neill Blomkamp-helmed Alien movie, but due to Ridley Scott's upcoming Prometheus sequel, the project has been indefinitely shelved. Other than that, Weaver has three Avatar films and a role in the Ghostbusters reboot, none of which are likely to be worthy of Academy recognition.
4. Liam Neeson

Why They Should Have Won: Though Tom Hanks' performance in Philadelphia is great, many consider Neeson's role as Oskar Schindler to be the better of the two.
Neeson's portrayal of the German spy who saved the lives of hundreds of Jews during the Holocaust was absolutely stunning, and at times heartbreaking, and absolutely worthy of Academy recogntion. Not only that, but while Schindler's List was unanimously viewed by critics as being a masterpiece, Philadelphia fared less well, with some criticizing its overly preachy tone and simplistic narrative. Why They Never Will: After Schindler's List, Neeson had a string of great dramatic roles, including Michael Collins in film Michael Collins, Valjean in Les Miserable and Rob Roy in Rob Roy. Unfortunately, however, the release and success of 2008's Taken completely shifted the course of Neeson's career, and he has since been playing flimsy, interchangeable characters in a string of action movies (including Taken 2 and 3, Unknown, and Run All Night). When he's not doing that, he's showing up in comedies, like Seth McFarland's A Million Ways To Die In The West and Ted 2. While Neeson remains endlessly entertaining to watch on-screen, it's unlikely he'll fall into a role as significant as Oskar Schindler ever again.3. Bill Murray

Why They Should Have Won: If any actor deserves to win an Oscar just for being themselves, it's Bill Murray, the famously friendly, down-to-earth actor known for showing up in random places and having an all around great time. Sadly, that's not how Oscars work.
Though largely known for his comedy roles (Groundhog Day, Caddyshack, Ghostbusters) Murray received critical acclaim for his starring role as Bob Harris in 2003's Lost In Translation. Murray was celebrated for portraying Harris as humorous, poignant and endlessly subtle. Many believed Murray's performance to be much stronger than Sean Penn's, who won the year Murray was nominated for his role in Clint Eastwood's Mystic River. Murray's victory was reportedly so certain that the actor didn't applaud victor Sean Penn. Why They Never Will: It's the classic case of a comedic actor finding a character that facilitates all their strengths. Murray emerged from his typical, bumbling roles to capture audiences in Lost In Translation, and though he has continued to mix heavier drama into his roles (his collaboration with director Wes Anderson is a continued joy) there just hasn't been much in the way of opportunity. Now too old to play the leading man, Murray's best shot at bagging an Oscar is through a supporting role, but a quick look at some of his more recent work shows a lot of comedy, critically panned drama and voice work.2. Viggo Mortensen
Why They Should Have Won: Mortensen's portrayal of Aragorn in The Lord Of The Rings films was easily one of the best, most complex performances in the trilogy and with co-stars like Sean Bean, Hugo Weaving, Cate Blanchett and Christopher Lee, that really is saying something.
Aragorn had to be likeable, relatable, mysterious, brave and insecure all at the same time. Sadly, fantasy films have never been particularly celebrated by the Academy, and Mortensen didn't receive a single nomination across the three films. What Mortensen was nominated for was a 2007 film named Eastern Promises, directed by David Cronenberg. Mortensen's performance as Russian gangster Nikolai Luzhin was widely celebrated, and he scooped up a huge number of nominations and accolades, but lost on the Academy Award to Daniel Day-Lewis in There Will Be Blood. Why They Never Will: Ever since then, Mortensen's performances haven't managed to capture that same electricity. While they're still great, most of his releases in recent years The Two Faces Of January, Jauja, Everybody Has A Plan have been critically lukewarm. He also seems to be doing less and less acting, with not a single film starring Mortensen being released in 2015, only two the year before, and again none in 2013. At present, he only has one upcoming project set for 2016.1. Samuel L. Jackson

Why They Should Have Won: Since his first on-screen role in 1972's Together For Days, Samuel L. Jackon has racked up over one-hundred and fifty acting credits, appearing in countless beloved films and franchises, and known for his repeated collaboration with writer / director Quentin Tarantino.
It's that collaboration with Tarantino that secured his first and only Oscar nomination. Jackson was nominated for Best Supporting Actor for his role in 1994's Pulp Fiction. In the film, Jackson played Jules Winnfield, a hilarious character who is nevertheless deeply intimidating.In the end, he lost out to Martin Landau as Bela Lugosi in Tim Burton's brilliant Ed Wood. And while Ed Wood is indeed brilliant, Jackson's role far outshines Landau's both in skill and memorability.
Why They Never Will: Samuel L. Jackson has yet to receive a single other Academy Award nomination, despite his extremely prolific career. While Jackson continues in immense success, his roles are not particularly dramatic, and are often franchise-based (he played Mace Windu in the Star Wars prequels and currently plays Nick Fury in the Marvel superhero franchise). Aside from that, Jackson continues to play bit parts in Tarantino films and show up in more light-hearted, action-orientated roles. Miramax Films pushed heavily for Jackson's nomination in Pulp Fiction, but there just hasn't been a role critics have deemed particularly worthy since.