8 Actors Who Will Ruin Upcoming Films

The damage bad casting can do.

Ted Bundy Zack Efron
Wikimedia Commons/Instagram

Casting movies is a tricky business. Get it right and a great story comes to life on the big screen, cinemagoers head home happy, Academy Awards are handed over, and the studio can confidently proceed with its sequel plans.

Get it wrong, however, and the film dies, franchise plans come tumbling down and the fans take up their metaphorical torches and pitchforks to stage a revolt that shakes the internet to its digital foundations.

There's so much riding on the lead actors. A top-class performance has the ability to mask poor scriptwriting or ham-fisted directing, but it simply doesn't work the other way around. No matter how sharp your screenplay is, regardless of who's sitting in the director's chair, bad acting or a miscast lead cannot be ignored.

The protagonist isn't just the face of the film, he or she is its heart and soul too, and if the audience isn't buying what they're selling, everything comes crashing down like a house of cards.

There are countless examples of poor casting decisions killing off films. Did anyone really accept Jake Gyllenhaal as Middle Eastern royalty in Prince of Persia, or Denise Richards as a nuclear physicist in The World Is Not Enough? Sadly, this trend isn't going anywhere since the amount of upcoming movies with the wrong actors on board is staggeringly high.

8. Rihanna - Ocean's Eight

Oceans 8 2000
Warner Bros

Female-led spinoff Ocean's Eight is bound to cause controversy when it lands next summer. Just look at the stink the 2016 Ghostbusters kicked up when Sony boldly gender-swapped traditionally male roles.

Sadly for the Paul Feig-fronted reboot, it simply wasn't good enough to silence its critics, so the Ocean's Eleven spinoff will be in for a similarly rough ride unless it's something special.

The film's chances of success have been compromised somewhat by a weak link in the casting chain: Rihanna. She's a woman of many talents, sure - singing and dancing to name a few, but anyone who's sat through Battleship or Valerian & The City Of A Thousand Planets will tell you that acting isn't one of them.

The worst thing about this whole situation is that Ri-Ri will be starring in Ocean's Eight alongside some immensely skilled actresses - Cate Blanchett, Helena Bonham Carter, Anne Hathaway, Mindy Kaling, Sandra Bullock and Sarah Paulson - so her shortcomings will only be amplified by this stellar lineup.


7. Paul T. Taylor - Hellraiser: Judgement

Hellraiser Judgement
Dimension Films

Hellraiser fans don't have anything personal against Paul T. Taylor. He just doesn't have any business playing Pinhead while there's still life left in the great Doug Bradley.

Recasting these horror movie icons rarely goes down well because the actor who's been bringing them to life across the ages becomes synonymous with the character.

Michael Myers and Jason Voorhees you can get away with because it could be almost anyone beneath those masks, but it didn't work when they did it with Freddy Krueger and it's never going to work with Pinhead.

Dimension Films pulled the same stunt with 2011's Hellraiser: Revelations by casting Stephan Smith Collins as the Cenobite, and that failed miserably. Even if Collins's had remotely resembled the hell priest, the fans were never going to accept anyone other than Bradley.

Taylor might look the part when in full makeup, but nobody wants to see a Hellraiser movie with somebody else in the lead role, especially one that was seemingly made just so Dimension can hold onto the rights to the franchise.


6. Zac Efron - Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil And Vile

Zac Efron Ted Bundy
Focus Features/State Archives of Florida, Florida Memory, via Wikimedia Commons

Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile are some of the words that could be used to describe the decision to cast Zac Efron as the lead in the upcoming Ted Bundy biopic. It also happens to be the movie's title.

Efron, who's predominantly known for his heartthrob roles and mediocre comedies, is playing a notorious serial killer, rapist, kidnapper, thief and necrophile. Exactly what part of that did they think was going to work?

Sure, the High School Musical star has dabbled in darker roles such as Parkland and the downright weird Paperboy, but nothing that qualifies him to play a deeply disturbed murderer.

By all accounts, Bundy possessed a degree of superficial charm, something that Efron has in spades, but on the whole, the star's fresh-faced presence will be all too distracting and immersion shattering in this biopic.


5. James Corden - Peter Rabbit

Peter Rabbit
CBS/Frederick Warne & Co.

James Corden works well enough in small doses: half-hour sitcom episodes, talk shows and the occasion bit part in a Hollywood movie, but nobody wants to hear him voice a CGI rabbit for over an hour, any more than they want to hear him repeat that Harvey Weinstein joke which rightly landed him in hot water.

It's bad enough Peter Rabbit seems to go against everything the original Beatrix Potter books stood for. They were simple, heartwarming allegories for youngsters, while the movie is about a bunch of creatures holding the animal equivalent of Project X.

Perhaps this could be overlooked as a modern spin on the source material if its heart ends up being in the right place come the end credits, but Corden, with his over-the-top, slightly smarmy delivery, condemns it to failure.

Peter is supposed to be cute and endearing, but after hearing Corden rabbiting on for 90 minutes, nobody will care if he ends up as the filling for a farmer's pie.


4. Taron Egerton - Robin Hood

Robin Hood Taron Egerton
Taron Egerton Twitter

In fairness to Taron Egerton, he won't be the most miscast Robin Hood of all time as that honour will always got to Kevin Costner, but the Kingsman actor is a poor fit for English folklore nonetheless.

The Kingsman movies have propelled Egerton to Hollywood star status and are what most people know him for, but his stint as chav hero Eggsy is hardly the ideal preparation for Robin of Loxley.

Firstly, Egerton plays an exaggerated version of himself in the Kingsman series, and this kind of thing might have gone down well in a more lighthearted Robin Hood reboot, but Otto Bathurst's origin tale is being touted as a gritty reimagining that takes its tonal cues from Peaky Blinders.

So this version of the Prince of Thieves will likely be a brooding anti-hero, scarred by the Crusades. In other words, not a bleeding thing like any of the characters Egerton has made a name for himself playing.


3. Chris Pratt & Bryce Dallas Howard - Jurassic World 2

Chris Pratt Jurassic World
Universal Pictures

Chris Pratt and Bryce Dallas Howard are by no means bad actors, far from it, but as a couple they almost singlehandedly ruined Jurassic World, which is why the fans should be worried about their presence in the sequel.

In the runup to the movie's release, director Colin Trevorrow was forced to defend it from sexism claims based on the stereotypical exchanges the two lead characters shared in the trailers, a situation that didn't improve when Avengers director Joss Whedon added his voice to the opposition.

In fairness to Pratt and Howard, their characters are deconstructed during the events of the movie and come out the other side more credible... or at least Pratt's Owen Grady does. Howard's Claire Dearing is still wearing her high heels in the final act, even when she's fleeing from a T-Rex.

Although the sexism claims don't really hold water when viewed in context, that doesn't mean Owen and Claire are any more interesting as a couple than they are individually. In fact, they're worse, a cliche on-screen pairing who share trite dialogue and nothing more.

Unless plenty of character development has occurred between then and the beginning of Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdon, these two could be the death of the 2018 sequel.


2. Arnold Schwarzenegger - Terminator 6

Terminator 6
Skydance Productions

Admittedly this is a contentious one because nobody really wants to see a Terminator film without Arnold Schwarzenegger in it. They tried that before, and it didn't work.

But here's the thing, T6 finds itself in something of a catch-22 situation because it's unlikely to work with Arnie now that he's over 70 years of age.

There are two possible ways the sequel might use him. He could play an ageing T-800 again, like he did in Genisys, or he could portray the human these Terminators were originally based on, something James Cameron has strongly hinted at in interviews.

Neither of those scenarios are going to go down well. Arnie was unconvincing as a geriatric killing machine in the last movie, but having him in a Terminator movie in a non-Terminator role would be too distracting and just wouldn't sit right.

Playing human characters has never been Schwarzenegger's strong suit, unless they're clobbering hordes of bad guys and cracking one-liners. The T-800 role was tailor-made for him because he's an expert at stoic facial expressions and deadpan delivery.

It seems Cameron has cast Arnie in T6 purely because he feels he has to.


1. Sophie Turner - X-Men: Dark Phoenix

X Men Sophie Turner
20th Century Fox

Casting Game of Thrones stars in films regardless of their suitability for the part is a cynical move Hollywood keeps pulling, in the hope of tapping into the show's global success.

X-Men: Apocalypse did it by handing the role of Jean Grey to Sophie Turner, who gave an abominable performance as the telepathic mutant. To call her wooden is an insult to a useful raw material and fire fuel.

Turner, who has proved herself an increasingly capable actress during the course of GoT, failed to command any screen presence or even maintain an American accent throughout Apocalypse.

This is bad enough in a supporting role in an ensemble film, but Dark Phoenix will see her graduate to leading lady and her shortcomings will be all the more difficult to hide, and could even end up toppling the movie.

The X-Men series is standing by its choice of Jean for now, but perhaps Fox will take the opportunity to kill her off unless Turner has taken the criticism on board and addressed her Apocalypse failings.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Zac Efron
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw