8 Actors You Didn't Know Secretly Directed Films

Edward Norton loves the directing process... even when he's just meant to be acting.

Tom Cruise The Mummy
Universal Pictures

"Ghost Directing" is an odd phenomenon in Hollywood. It's a strange case of being a very common, often vital act within the industry that no one likes to actually acknowledge.

After all, it would meddle with the auteur image somewhat if someone else on set could just sit in the director's chair when mister big shot is getting uppity and drag the production those last crucial days over the finish line.

Oh and Heaven forbid if an ACTOR got it into their heads they could do that.

So yeah, a lot of actors like to do just that. It's actually way more common than most would have you believe.

Whether credited or not, there are tons of films out there attributed to one director's vision while being hijacked at some point by either one of the actors on set or another director who also just happens to be an active screen actor when they aren't directing.

Either way, so long as the film started with a full director, but then got secretly shanghaied by an actor along the way, it counts for this list.

8. Edward Norton - American History X

Edward Norton American History X
New Line Cinema

Tony Kaye is best known for two things. One: the late nineties drama, American History X, and two; how hard he was to work with during production of late nineties drama, American History X.

It got so bad that New Line Cinema, desperate to get the film done on time for its August 1998 release date, contacted the film's lead, Edward Norton, who had experience in film editing, to put the last finishing touches on the movie. Rumor has it they even had to lock Kaye out of the editing room to make sure it actually got done.

Now, that last part is technically allegation, but it would certainly explain why Kaye proceeded to complain to the DGA to remove his name from the film's credits entirely. It also helps to explain why New Line had to reach out to the film's leading man to make sure the film was actually completed on time for its 1998 release.

There was at one point a director's cut of the movie, but that original version is considered lost to Hollywood history.


7. Kevin Costner - Waterworld

Waterworld Kevin Costner
Universal

Kevin Costner is no stranger to directing, especially during the nineties where he helmed some massive projects. Before Waterworld, he directed the Oscar winning Dances With Wolves, with frequent collaborator Kevin Reynolds helping him out. But rumor has it that the opposite happened with his following and most ambitious project, Waterworld.

Kevin Reynolds is the credited director, but stories abound about how Costner was not only the leading man, but also the one pulling the strings with both the directing and the story, as well as being just a nightmare to deal with in general. Which might explain why the whole film was one gigantic mess, considering it doesn't sound like Costner was offering help that wasn't asked for.

Either way, because of his meddling, the two had a massive falling out, ending with Reynolds either leaving the project entirely or being fired, depending on what source you consult. Costner then took over directing the film full time.

The two wouldn't collaborate on a project again until the mini-series Hatfields And McCoys in 2012, and Waterworld - while not a failure thanks to overseas box offices - would flop stateside. Maybe Costner should have left well enough alone.


6. Edward Norton - The Incredible Hulk

The Incredible Hulk
Marvel Studios

Hello again, Edward Norton.

Now, according to pretty much every source on this movie, Louis Leterrier was the sole director on this movie, and that isn't 100% false. He was in the director's chair from beginning to end of what was an apparently very hectic production.

A lot of things made the making of this film difficult, not the least of which being the producers despising Zak Penn's original screenplay for the picture. So they asked the film's star, Edward Norton, to touch up the script during production. And while he was at it, Norton also helped Leterrier with a lot of the directing hurtles he was having trouble crossing.

It's thanks to Norton working his magic on the final film that The Hulk is thematically tied to environmentalism, due to Norton's love of the environment. So Norton definitely helped to add more of a thematic subtext to this movie to give it that extra edge.

Alas, Norton was not credited for either his work on the screenplay, or his aid in directing the film alongside Leterrier.


5. Sylvester Stallone - Cobra

Sylvester Stallone Cobra
Warner Bros.

Now, officially, Sylvester Stallone is not the one who directed the 1986 action thriller, Cobra, but anyone who's seen even one of his other films will see his fingerprints all over what should be a George P. Cosmatos film.

Stallone is the one who pitched the film, and even wrote the screenplay for it, so it makes sense that he would micromanage how the film was directed as well. While Cosmatos ultimately got the directing credit for Cobra, it's clear that this is more of a Stallone movie.

Not just in how much Stallone worked on this one compared to Cosmatos, but in how much of Stallone's style is here. There isn't a lot of dialogue, since Stallone at his prime liked to prioritize atmosphere and action above all and let those two tell the story, and overall, his directing style overshadows Cosmatos at pretty much every turn.

He may not have gotten the directing credit at the end of the day, but rumors or otherwise, this is most definitely a Sylvester Stallone movie through and through.


4. Tom Cruise - The Mummy (2017)

The Mummy Tom Cruise
Universal

There are many, MANY reasons that you should not give Tom Cruise control of things in general, let alone movie projects. And we can officially add "killed off an entire cinematic universe before it began" to that list, thanks to his meddling on The Mummy.

While he was not the director of the project, Cruise was drawn to the film thanks to Universal giving him final creative say on pretty much everything, including the staff. So he hired writers and a director who would stay in line with his "vision" for the movie.

While this isn't technically directing the movie, Cruise controlled so much of what the actual director, Alex Kurtzman, did with the movie, and having final sign off on the script, that he may as well have.

It's thanks to him that the movie ended up such a confused, transparently corporate mess, that spent way too much time on Cruise's unlikable mercenary character instead of the creature that's actually in the title of the damn movie.

The Dark Universe was a bad joke before it even got off the ground, but Cruise definitely helped kill it in its crib.


3. Orson Welles - Black Magic

Orson Welles Black Magic
United Artists

If you know nothing else about Orson Welles, know this: dude was REALLY hard to work with.

While miles away from being the worst that the mid 20th century film auteur movement had to offer, the man was cursed with the kind of perfectionism and ego that so often plagues the auteur. If he had an idea for how a project should be done, it was usually his way or the highway.

Hence why it isn't hard for anyone to believe that, despite the 1949 film Black Magic maintaining to this day that its director was Gregory Ratoff, the good Mr. Welles had more than a little input on the finished product. Granted, these are mainly rumors, but Ratoff's biography in Britannica outright lists Welles as an uncredited co-director, so it has to be true.

While the finer points are mostly allegations, we do know that he helped direct several scenes, even as several different directors left the project before settling on Ratoff. So while Ratoff gets all the credit and royalties from the film as the director, you can plainly see Welles' fingerprints all over this movie, so it's anyone's guess who this movie's true director even is.


2. Sylvester Stallone - Rambo: First Blood Part 2

Rambo 2
TriStar

Hello again George P. Cosmatos, and hello again Sylvester Stallone.

George P. Cosmatos has been attached to a lot of really great movies, but there's this kinda hilarious trend where his most famous productions all share the same story element: someone on set was the "real" director behind the scenes.

In this case, Stallone did what he did back in Cobra all over again with First Blood Part 2, and made several executive decisions for how the story was going to be told. While, again, Cosmatos is the one who got all the credit, and the extent of Stallone's directing is unknown, we know enough to surmise that at least half of the final cut was a product of Stallone taking over directing.

It's equally unclear how much of this help Cosmatos ASKED for, but considering that this has happened to him three times - including the final entry - and has happened with Stallone twice, it's safe to assume he's at least partially okay with Sly Stallone putting in his two cents.


1. Kurt Russell - Tombstone

Tombstone 1993 Group Shot
Buena Vista Pictures

The best film George P. Cosmatos has his name attached to, bar none, is the western classic Tombstone. It's a solid movie through and through, just romantic enough to be a fun watch, while gritty and raw enough to not make its jaded nineties audience roll their eyes, diverging from the original events only when they have to in order to make a satisfying story, and sticking close to what matters.

And Cosmatos reportedly had VERY little input on the final product.

The film's original director and screenwriter was one Kevin Jarre, who left production right in the middle of filming. The studio then reached out to Kurt Russell to finish directing the movie. Kurt, however, knew that while he could do it, they'd need an actual director to pull things together and realize his vision, so he brought on George P. Cosmatos to essentially do what Russell told him to do. According to Doc Holiday actor, Val Kilmer, Russell "essentially directed Tombstone".

Cosmatos is the credited director of the film, but as was revealed shortly after his death in 2005, Russell was the one calling the shots from minute one, even giving Cosmatos a shot list of what he wanted Cosmatos to do each shooting day.

Whatever the methods used, if you've seen Tombstone, you know they paid off big time. And if you haven't seen Tombstone. Fix that.


Watch Next


Who Said It - Arnold Schwarzenegger Or Sylvester Stallone?

Sylvester Stallone The Expendables 3
Lionsgate

1. "You're Gonna Regret This For The Rest Of Your Life. Both Seconds Of It."

In this post: 
Tom Cruise
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?