8 Best Ghost Stories For Christmas

Festive hauntings to you all!

Back in the 1800s there was a Christmas tradition. As the days grew cold and the nights grew dark people would gather round the fire and tell festive stories. Long before the Christmas story became nothing but a pile of sentimental codswallop, people would have enjoyed something that brought a little fear into their Yuletide cheer: the Christmas Chiller. Magazines like All the Year Round devoted their pages to stories of spooks and ghouls and haunted houses and writers usually known for socially conscious realism (Elizabeth Gaskell, Charles Dickens) or lovable children's stories (Edith Nesbit) conspired to bring their readers the Christmas gift of something spookily chilling. While this may not have remained a core part of everybody's Christmas, there have been various attempts to revive the tradition onscreen, most notably with the BBC's annual 1970s series A Ghost Story for Christmas. The series ended after 1978's silly The Ice House, but has been revisited periodically in the 00s. This year will see a new Ghost Story for Christmas, adapted, like many of the classic 70s series, from a story by M.R. James. Written by Mark Gatiss (who, with a repeat of his early Doctor Who drama An Adventure in Space and Time and a new series of Sherlock, occupies a privileged position in the festive schedule), The Tractate Middoth will air on Christmas Day itself. If that gets you in the mood for more festive hauntings, here are eight of the best.

8. The Stone Tape

Originally planned as part of the BBC's horror anthology series Dead of Night and shown on Christmas Day 1972, The Stone Tape merges the classic haunted house narrative with 1970s science and technology to create a Christmas Chiller very much of its time. In fact everything from the fashion to the technology to the ridiculous casual sexism is so 70s it occasionally almost feels like an over-egged parody of the decade made much later (one character appears to be wearing a shirt made out of the carpet in The Shining). Fortunately there is a strong edge of humour in the writing, satirising the attitudes of the day and the computer programmer protagonists' endless rivalry with "the Japanese" and a research project into washing machines from their own company. At the same time, however, there is a real sense of optimism that rapidly advancing new technology may allow us to answer questions that had forever seemed unanswerable. The Stone Tape was written by Nigel Kneale, perhaps the most influential writer of genre stories on British TV, who had already explored a combination of classic horror tropes and contemporary sci-fi with his Quatermass series. Kneale's teleplay has a group of scientists and engineers set up in a Victorian mansion mid-way through being renovated as they look to try and develop better recording equipment. As they discover the ghostly figure repeating the same action of running up stairs and falling, they theorise that hauntings are a form of residual recorded images preserved in the building's stone. This they seek to record using their own equipment, but only succeed in uncovering a darker, more malevolent presence. A young Jane Asher, who had previously appeared as a child in the Hammer film of Kneale's Quatermass Xperiment (the X makes it look cool), stars as the only woman in the group, programmer Jill. Her position as the only woman in a man's world gives her the level of isolation required for a good ghost story and this makes her more receptive than most to the spirits in the stone tape recordings. Asher gives a perfectly decent performance, but it's Kneale's ideas and originality that most impress about The Stone Tape. Its legacy is clear in any of the myriad modern stories of attempts to track and record ghosts with digital equipment and in the real world tgeory that ghosts exist as residual recordings, known, known in honour of this film, as the Stone Tape theory.

7. The Muppet Christmas Carol

Not all festive ghost stories end on a dark and disturbing note and this is readily apparent in the most beloved and enduring Victorian Christmas ghost story: Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol. It's a story that has been adapted endlessly in various degrees of faithfulness from the 1901 five minute short Scrooge; or Marley's Ghost, whose use of superimposed images was a cutting edge effect, to the 2009 Robert Zemeckis version whose own state of the art effects allowed a motion captured Jim Carrey to play almost all the leading roles.

When it comes to the best version of the perennial Christmas favourite, however, there is plenty of debate. While many swear by the classic 1951 version starring Alastair Sim, others prefer the brashly modernised 1988 Scrooged with Bill Murray. The Christmas Carol that really delivers on warmth, wit and charm, though, is this 1992 effort starring Michael Caine and a whole load of muppets.

Arguably Jim Henson's fuzzy puppet creatures' finest big screen outing, The Muppet Christmas Carol is an impressively faithful rendering of the Dickens story that hits all the major plot beats while rattling along at a cracking pace with catchy songs and the sense of anarchic DIY style the muppets always bring. Each of Scrooge's three ghostly visitors is a brilliantly imaginative and individual piece of puppetry, some of the Henson Company's best work. And, if you think that this is far too cosy a ghost story to provide any scares, then the Grim Reaper-esque Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is sinister enough to put the fear of God into any watching children as it does for Scrooge. Surrounded by muppet-y chaos Michael Caine gives a good natured performance, more convincing as somebody seeing the error of his ways and embracing the Christmas spirit than as a miserable miser, but always bringing humour and a happy willingness to share the limelight with his amphibious co-star. More likely to bring warmth to your heart than a chill, The Muppet Christmas Carol is nevertheless a festive haunting essential.

6. Crooked House

Long before the announcement of The Tractate Middoth it's been apparent that Mark Gatiss is a big fan of the ghost story for Christmas. The finest episode of The League of Gentleman was the genuinely disturbing Christmas special modelled after the classic Amicus portmanteau horrors, while the first episode of his many dabblings with Doctor Who threw in an actual Christmas ghost encounter for Dickens himself in the form of career-Dickens Simon Callow. It came as no surprise then when, after the BBC aired a couple of fairly decent M.R. James Christmas ghost stories in the mid-00s, they decided to commission an original script from Gatiss: Crooked House. Like the League of Gentleman special, Crooked House takes the form of a portmanteau of three stories linked by a frame narrative, in this case a museum curator (Gatiss) tells Lee Ingleby's Ben about the morbid history of Geap Manor, the Tudor home of an heirless aristocrat with an interest in dark magic. It was originally aired as three separate episodes in the days leading up to Christmas 2008 and then as a complete film, which is where it works best. The first two stories - The Wainscoting, set in the Georgian period of failed economic speculation and the South Sea Bubble, and Something Old, involving a Roaring Twenties party of Bright Young Things - are affectionate pastiches of the style and turns of phrase of their era. Though the former, in particular, is a creative ghost concept anchored by a strong performance from veteran TV actor Philip Jackson. Andy Nyman, who appears here in a supporting role, would go on to create the acclaimed stage play Ghost Stories with Gatiss' former League of Gentleman writing partner Jeremy Dyson (author of The Haunted Book). It is the final, contemporary set, story The Knocker that provides Crooked House with some honest to goodness scary stuff, however, as Ben finds Geap Manor's dark past reaching out to him through the house's old door knocker. There is less pastiche-y fun here and more of a truly creepy conclusion.

5. The Woman In Black

Susan Hill's The Woman in Black is perhaps the best loved classic style ghost story of the last 50 years and had already been running as a stage play for decades and had a TV film, written by Nigel Kneale, under its belt before the revived Hammer Films brought it to the big screen in 2012. Both films may dispense with Hill's framing device, which very consciously places this story in the context of Christmas ghost storytelling, but all the ingredients of a classic British haunted house story are still there, meaning that they remain ideal viewing for the holiday season. Kneale's version, written for ITV for Christmas Eve in 1989, may be more faithful to the plot details Hill's original story (aside from Kneale's curious insistence on changing all of Hill's joyously Dickensian character names), but it's the Hammer film, adapted by Kick Ass screenwriter and Mrs Jonathan Ross Jane Goldman and directed by Eden Lake's James Watkins, that really packs a punch when it comes to edge of your seat tension. Not all of its adaptation choices work completely, the amount of grim child death in the village is a little over the top, but the 20 minute sequence of grieving lawyer's clerk Arthur Kipps alone in the isolated Eel Marsh House with the vindictive spirit of Jennet Humfrye is one of the most tense and scary of any ghost story. Former Harry Potter Daniel Radcliffe (the 1989 version starred the Potter films' James Potter: Adrian Rawlins) sometimes struggles with the material that has him as a depressed widower with a young son, but he is superb at reacting to the hauntingly disturbing events of this sequence. Hammer have a sequel, Angels of Death, in pre-production with Hill's tacit approval. Really, though, many of us would rather see some of her other original stories, such as The Man in the Picture or The Small Hand, follow it to the screen.

4. The Others

Although an original story written and directed by a Spaniard, Alejandro Amenabar (Open Your Eyes, The Sea Inside), in the 21st century, The Others perfectly captures the tone and style of a classic British Christmas Chiller. Its influences in this area are obvious, most clearly Henry James' entry into the Christmas ghost market The Turn of the Screw, but it has enough style and confidence to stand out on its own account. Nicole Kidman, riding high from the success of Moulin Rouge! earlier that year, gives a career best performance as Grace, slowly unravelling in a remote house in Nazi occupied Jersey while her husband (Christopher Eccleston at his most depressing) is away fighting in the war. This setting, a reminder that the Nazis did invade and take control of British territory, is an original one, as is the device that allows Amenabar to shoot most of the film in suggestive low light and shadows. Grace's two children are extremely photosensitive, meaning that they must remain shut indoors with all doors and curtains shut at all times. Not only does this give them a creepily pale, ghostly appearance, but it means the whole film is full of suggestive shadows and a moment of a room being filled with sunlight becomes something truly tense. Some criticism has been levelled at the film for sharing a similar conclusion to The Sixth Sense, released two years earlier, but The Others suggests its twist with greater subtlety than Shyamalan's film, which telegraphs it from the start, and the specifics of this narrative make for a more emotionally powerful conclusion. Amenabar was nominated for a Bafta for his screenplay, an extreme rarity for a horror film, and, regardless of whether you know the ending, it is very easy to get sucked into the atmospheric elegance of this haunted house picture.

3. Whistle And I'll Come to You

The inspiration for the BBC's Ghost Story for Christmas strand was this earlier M.R. James adaptation made as part of the Omnibus series in 1968 (that Omnibus was typically a documentary series means that the story comes with an odd and unnecessary explanatory voiceover to kick it off). Oh, Whistle and I'll Come to You, My Lad is probably the best known and most highly regarded of the canon of James ghost stories and certainly the archetype of his take on the ghost genre. The conceit of an arrogant academic, an isolated coastal location and an ancient artefact that reveals to the protagonist a dark and scary world beyond his dismissive imagination, or variants on it, was used repeatedly by James and his imitators. The similar A Warning to the Curious was adapted as the second BBC Ghost Story for Christmas in 1972 and is the best James adaptation of the 70s series. This is the original, though, and remains the best of all. Whistle and I'll Come to You (a few words shed from the title for brevity's sake) was written and directed by Jonathan Miller, part of the Beyond the Fringe team with Peter Cook and Dudley Moore. Miller's comedy background can be seen in the speech patterns of Professor Parkin, whose incomprehensibly-mumble-for-six-words-and-then-enunciate-the-seventh cadences appear to be the inspiration for The Fast Show's Rowley Birkin. James' story features a smart, neat young man, but Miller's decision to make Parkin a messy, absent minded middle aged character more used to talking to himself than others serves well to further cut him off from everyone else. Michael Hordern, who played Parkin, had some previous haunting experience as the ghost of Jacob Marley opposite Alastair Sim's Scrooge and would go on to record a series of audiobooks of James stories. Here he throws himself impressively into a role where he is constantly on screen and much of his dialogue is with himself. As a director Miller makes an asset of the low budget and monochrome photography with lots of long takes and interesting angles, while the huge, flat beaches of the Norfolk coast make for the perfect creepy setting to suggest watching or following figures. A much more loosely adapted remake appeared in 2010 starring John Hurt and written by Neil Cross (Mama, the haunted house Doctor Who episode Hide). More tragically poignant than scary and not for James purists, it remains worth a look, but doesn't quite measure up to the original.

2. The Signalman

While there is a sense that the BBC's A Ghost Story for Christmas is synoymous with the works of M.R. James, and indeed the majority of the official series including the new one are James adaptations, it really hit its height in 1976 when it left James behind for the first time to present a version of this classic Dickens story. While A Christmas Carol may be the best remembered of Dickens' festive hauntings, this is comfortably his scariest. The teleplay was an early writing job for Andrew Davies who would make his name as a regular adapter of literary classics for the small screen, penning the Gillian Anderson starring version of Dickens' Bleak House and the much loved Jennifer Ehle-Colin Firth Pride and Prejudice. Here, though, he worked on a much smaller scale that fit the much lower Ghost Story for Christmas budget and regular series director Lawrence Gordon Clark. The Severn Valley heritage railway provides a setting reminiscent of the cosy charms of The Railway Children (a novel also written by one of the great ghost story writers), but turns it to something sinister and foreboding. Denholm Elliott, Indiana Jones' easily lost buddy Dr. Marcus Brody, is convincingly haunted and troubled as the eponymous Signalman, who has visions of a ghostly figure going through the same words and motions before accidents occur on the line. The story was inspired by a real train accident that Dickens was involved in and has a strong sense of the dark underside of the white heat of rapidly advancing technology in the Industrial Age. Clark rings the maximum hellish quality from the beast of fire and steam emerging from the long, dark, suggestive tunnel. A railway accident is something genuinely horrific and this adaptation does a great job of indicating that without expensive large scale scenes of gore and destruction.

1. The Innocents

While much of this list has made reference to the influential ghost writings of Montague Rhodes James, another James also entered the world of the Christmas ghost story: Henry James. Perhaps unsurprisingly given the Portrait of a Lady writer's somewhat wordy, occasionally turgid, prose, what we got was more a full length ghost novella than a simple story. This book, The Turn of the Screw, has been adapted on various occasions in different media, including a relatively recent BBC version broadcast for Christmas 2009 and rather pointlessly updated to the 1920s. However, it is The Innocents, released in cinemas in the build up to Christmas 1961, that stands out as by far the best.

Like The Woman in Black, this film ditches the original's festive framing device, but otherwise feels right at home amongst the other Christmas Chillers. Adapted from the stage play by William Archibald rather than directly from James' novella, The Innocents also had additional material written by Truman Capote for director-producer Jack Clayton, so the eventual product was very much a collaborative effort. Perhaps because of this it is the best example of a ghost movie where the details are left open to the viewers' interpretation. The unreliability of James' governess protagonist as a narrator has led many to conclude the "ghosts" are nothing but the product of her fragile mental state. The film retains this potential interpretation whilst leaving the possibility open of a real ghostly presence. It is genuinely ambiguous in a way that few ghost films are when they get down to their final scenes. Whether you believe in the presence of ghosts or not, Clayton's film has a slow burning sinister quality and its two children, Martin Stephens' Miles and Pamela Franklin's Flora, represent something of a golden age in disturbing movie kids alongside Village of the Damned, released a year earlier. At the height of her fame Deborah Kerr, as governess Miss Giddens, gives a good sense of a woman not sure if she can believe her suspicions or whether she's losing it completely. It's a performance that is clearly a strong influence in Nicole Kidman in The Others in a film that remains influential on almost any haunted house picture since. That is why it's our number one Christmas ghost story. Disagree? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies