8 Biggest Omissions From The Oscar Nominations 2014

This year the most talked about decisions are those films and performances that were not chosen.

Oscar season always brings with it plenty of shocks and surprises. 'American Hustle' and 'Philomena' not being completely ignored were certainly two of the largest in terms of making the cut, but this year the most talked about decisions are those films and performances that were not chosen. Some of the very early front runners for Best Actor and Best Actress have been left out of the nominations entirely and a number of tipped films have been snubbed. So here is a list of the eight most glaring omissions from the 2014 Academy Awards shortlists. Which are the biggest mistakes and more importantly, with surprises so early on, is this a sign that 2014 will be a year with a shock like 1977 where underdog 'Rocky' beat 'Taxi Driver' to Best Film? As always expect spoilers if you haven't seen the films mentioned in the headings.

8. Woody Allen - Best Director, 'Blue Jasmine.'

"Return to form." Those three words have been damning Woody Allen's films with faint praise for over a decade. Of course not all of his films are fantastic (Cassandra's Dream anyone?) but for a man who writes and directs a new film every year it is remarkable that his quality is so high. If proof were needed 'Match Point', 'Vicky Cristina Barcelona' and 'Midnight in Paris' have each been hailed as a return to form with the latter two winning Oscars of their own. It seems that critics have selective amnesia as the first comments made about 'Blue Jasmine' again chose to wheel out this phrase. Although he is a regular in the Original Screenplay category, Allen's work directing is often taken for granted due to the sheer number of films he produces. 'Blue Jasmine' is truly him at his directorial peak and he deserves to be among this year's contenders.

7. Tom Hanks - Best Actor, 'Captain Phillips.'

For many Tom Hanks is thought of as one of those actors who is nominated year in year out, but since 2000 the two-time winner and former darling has failed to receive a single nod from the Academy. If most of the praise for the film were to be believed it seemed that 'Captain Phillips' would be the role that gave Hanks a slew of nominations. The BAFTAs, the Golden Globes and the Screen Actors Guild all agreed but the Oscars panel were unmoved. Despite giving the film six nominations there was still nothing for Hanks in the Best Actor category in which he was last nominated for 'Cast Away.' The film itself was a solid Paul Greengrass project with all the expected style, tension and pace associated with that. Hanks seemed to relish being front and centre of a major action film. It was fun and exciting but not outstanding. For much of the film there was little else to comment on until in the final moments as the titular Captain Phillips is finally rescued. Where most films in this genre would either end or skip ahead to the lead character returning home to their family, the audience followed the Captain directly to medical where he is assessed, finally succumbs to shock and releases all the tension and emotion of his ordeal. It is in this incredible few minutes that Tom Hanks delivers one of the finest scenes of his long career. After so many years it is easy to become complacent about his abilities but here there is no doubt that he is one of the greatest actors of his generation. The intensity and power of his acting showed a rawness and vulnerability that few actors are capable of.

6. Emma Thompson - Best Actress, 'Saving Mr.Banks.'

After realising her surprising nomination for 'August: Osage County' had denied Emma Thompson a place on the Best Actress list, Meryl Streep wrote her a long, guilty email effectively apologising for being nominated for an 18th Oscar. Surely if a rival actress in the category is shocked into that kind of reaction then missing out Emma Thompson is a big mistake. It is fair to say that she was never a front runner as the early money fell towards Cate Blanchet but her place amongst the contenders was always assumed because she had given such a searing performance in 'Saving Mr.Banks.' By watching the end credits of the film there is an opportunity hear part of a recording of the real Travers meeting with writer Don DaGradi and songwriters the Sherman brothers. This highlights how practically perfect Emma Thompson's performance was as the voice and tone of the real Travers and the fictional version of her sounded interchangeable.

5. Saving Mr.Banks - Best Film

Historical? Check. Feel-good? Check. Focus on a cinematic golden age? Check. So how did the tale of Walt Disney's efforts to get the permission of author P.L.Travers to adapt her Mary Poppins books, fail to gain any attention from the Academy? With Tom Hanks and Emma Thompson both being overlooked in the lead roles it seems even more perplexing. 'Saving Mr.Banks' didn't suffer a total shutout however as it received a nomination for Original Score but this hardly seems enough for a film of such warmth. Take the 'Let's Go Fly A Kite' scene for example, it alone was charming enough to warrant recognition but add Hanks' superbly avuncular Walt Disney and Thompson's firm Travers and this becomes a huge oversight by the Academy.

4. Robert Redford - Best Actor, 'All Is Lost.'

'All Is Lost' shows genuine cinematic legend taking on the role of a man forced to sail into a storm during a solo voyage. With a stunning performance and with that legend being 77-year old Robert Redford, it is hard to imagine why the Oscars have ignored this performance. I could only come up with three suggestions; First, Bruce Dern seems to have taken the token 'old dog' nomination in the Best Actor category leaving no room for Redford. Second, it could be suggested that since this a film with very little dialogue and literally just one actor, it is not one for the mainstream. However, the same could have been said about 2012's near silent winner 'The Artist' which leads me to suspect that this is one instance where the promotional push for awards never got going, meaning that 'All Is Lost' itself got lost amongst the billboard-hogging likes of 'American Hustle' and '12 Years A Slave'. Regardless of promotion or hype, 'All Is Lost' is a heroic one man show that showcases Redford's extraordinary abilities and shows that, even aged 77, he is still capable of hitting career highs.

3. Inside Llewyn Davis - Best Film

The latest effort from the Coen Brothers brought T-Bone Burnett on board for a folk music-themed drama set just before Bob Dylan exploded onto the world stage. After much praise and hype the film received only two Oscar nominations and both of those came in technical categories. It seems that the slow groundswell that took Country music film 'Crazy Heart's' Geoff Bridges to victory won't be repeated this year, which is a shame for one nerdy reason in particular; Oscar Isaac would have become the first ever Academy Award winner to be called Oscar. The Coen Brothers' usual high quality and keen eye for period settings is maintained and, while it is not one of their greatest, it is warm, charming, engaging and deserves a place amongst the top nine films of the year.

2. Joaquin Phoenix - Best Actor, 'Her.'

Spike Jonze's heart-breaker is one of the most original near-future sci-fi films of recent times and really taps into the strange loneliness that comes from living in the modern world where everyone is virtually connected to everyone else. Without an actor of Joaquin Phoenix's supreme skill, the pathos and warmth of Theodore Twombly could have become strange and uncomfortable to cope with for the film's two hour running time. Since the film itself earned a Best Picture nomination it would be only logical that Phoenix would be in the running for Best Actor since, like 'Forrest Gump', this is a film all about one person's performance. It may be called 'Her' but is all about him.

1. Oprah Winfrey - Best Actress, 'The Butler.'

Lee Daniels' 'The Butler' tells the sweeping story of Cecil Gaines, (Forest Whitaker) a man who witnesses many major historical events during the thirty years that he spent working as a butler in the White House. Backed by The Weinstein Company and being a comfortable box office hit, it seemed that the First Lady of American culture, Oprah Winfrey, was nailed on for an Oscar nomination in her role as Cecil's wife, Gloria. But that was before the Golden Globes nominations were revealed to have snubbed her. Following suit the Oscars also backed away. It is a hammy film that was clearly devised as Oscar bait. If it weren't for '12 Years A Slave' this may well have got a lot more attention but as it is the main shock is that someone said no to Oprah.

Contributor
Contributor

I have one golden rule: There is no such thing as a guilty pleasure. Any song or film that makes you feel good doesn't need justifying.