8 Classic Movies Hated By Their Directors

Wait, Spielberg disowned an Indiana Jones movie that wasn't Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull?!

Temple Of Doom
LucasFilm

While most fans buy into the myth a film is the sole vision of the director, the truth is it’s the result of a massive team effort. From the director, producers, writers, camera people and all the way down to the guy who grabs the coffee. It’s the director’s job to wrestle with all this chaos and make something true to his vision, but there are a million different ways this can go wrong.

Maybe the studio won’t give them the time or money to do things properly, or they clash with the cast or crew and their control of the movie slips away. This can result in a filmmaker growing to hate their own work, even if everyone else considers it a classic.

It’s important to remember they can’t view their work the way an audience does, and what seems like an inspired creative decision might have been a huge compromise in their eyes. Whatever the reasons, here’s a list of directors who hate their own masterpieces.

8. Woody Allen - Manhattan

Woody Allen Manhattan
United Artists

Manhattan is a romantic comedy from Woody Allen’s golden period, and deals with – surprise surprise – Allen playing a neurotic nerd having relationship issues. The film is deemed one of Allen’s very best, with even the poster becoming iconic.

Don’t bother telling that to Woody Allen though, who despised the finished movie so much he begged the studio to destroy it, and even offered to direct a replacement movie for free. He thought the movie was a total failure, and he later explained that at that stage in his career he felt he was capable of better work.

The director would later say that The Curse Of The Jade Scorpion was probably his worst movie, and in that particular case, it’s pretty hard to disagree with him.


7. Tony Kaye - American History X

The Royal Tenenbaums Gene Hackman
Buena Vista Pictures

American History X is a powerful, disturbing drama that rightfully earned Edward Norton an Oscar nod for best actor. Norton is known for being quite hands on with his work and often gets involved with script rewrites and editing. It’s said his attitude during the making of The Incredible Hulk was a big reason Marvel didn't ask him back for The Avengers.

Norton got involved in a big way with post production on American History X because he felt director Tony Kaye’s edit – which was said to be way flashier and slick – ruined the story. He helped the studio recut and restore key scenes that had been trimmed, but Kaye was not a happy man because of this.

He felt the re-edit destroyed his movie, and put out ads in Variety decrying his treatment by Norton and New Line. He also wanted his name removed from the credits and replaced with Humpty Dumpty; his request was understandably denied.


6. John Woo - A Better Tomorrow II

A Better Tomorrow 2
Cinema City

The original A Better Tomorrow made Chow Yun-fat and John Woo household names and launched the Heroic Bloodshed genre that Woo later perfected with The Killer and Hard Boiled. A Better Tomorrow II is also considered a classic of this sub-genre, though it uses the lamest trope imaginable to bring back Chow’s deceased character from the original; a previously unmentioned twin.

The action is top notch – which is a given for Woo, really – but the story is choppy and oddly paced. This is because Woo had severe disagreements with producer Tsui Hark; Woo felt it should focus on Chow, and Hark though it should focus on his gangster mentor instead. Woo felt those scenes didn’t quite work, and when they couldn’t agree they sent it to the studio editors to cut themselves.

Woo was shocked when he saw the sloppy job they did with the narrative, with key emotional scenes being snipped. The director was so upset he disowned it completely, with the exception of the blood-drenched final gunfight, which he describes as a “mad painting.”


5. Sam Peckingpah - Pat Garrett And Billy The Kid

Pat Garrett Billy the Kid
MGM/Warner Brothers

It took awhile for Pat Garrett And Billy The Kid to find the love it deserved, but it’s easily one of director Sam Peckinpah's best. The film had a stormy production, and Peckinpah's clashes with the studio over budget and crew eventually became public. Peckinpah's alcoholism was also getting out of hand during this period; at one point he urinated on a screen showing dailies because he hated them so much.

The film finished over budget and schedule, which infuriated the studio. Peckinpah delivered a cut he was happy with to them, which they then took out of his hands and severely trimmed. This was the version released in 1973 to mostly negative reviews, and Peckinpah himself hated what they’d done.

The film faded from memory for years afterwards, until Peckinpah's original cut was found and released on video. This led to it being reassessed and is now considered a masterwork of the Western genre; it's just a shame Sam passed away before he could enjoy some of the kudos.


4. Michael Mann - The Keep

The Keep Michael Mann
Paramount

When you think of Michael Mann you picture intense thrillers like Manhunter, Heat or The Insider. It’s a fair bet you don’t think of horror movies set during World War 2 that feature a big rubbery monster, or Gabriel Byrne as the most Irish Nazi ever, but that’s what he delivered with his second film The Keep.

The film was a bomb back in 1983, but it’s since gone on to become a cult classic because of its dreamlike atmosphere and the awesome Tangerine Dream score. The production was fraught; Mann clashed with the studio over the movie's tone, and the planned ending had to be scrapped because the special effects technician died, and nobody else could figure out how to make the complicated effects work.

The film was finally taken away from Mann and re-edited, leading to noticeable jumps in the narrative. Since that heartbreak, Mann has rarely talked about it, and rumour has it the film has never been released on DVD or Blu-ray because he’s embarrassed by the end result.


3. Steven Spielberg - Indiana Jones And Temple Of Doom

Temple Of Doom Indiana Jones
LucasFilm

Temple Of Doom is by far the darkest entry in the Indiana Jones series, featuring brutal scenes of torture and gore. The tone makes sense since both Spielberg and George Lucas were going through hard times in their personal lives, with Lucas just coming off of a divorce; suddenly, the heart ripping scene makes a lot of sense.

The darkness of the story doesn’t stop Temple being a fun adventure, and some fans even prefer it to the original. One person who definitely isn’t a fan is Spielberg himself, who appreciates that people like it but he personally thinks he messed it up. He finds it “...too dark, too subterranean and much too horrific.”

He feels his personal life at the time affected the movie, and that it revels in the misery too much. He is thankful he met his future wife Kate Capshaw while making it, but it’s his least favourite of the series; that’s right, he thinks Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull is better.


2. Fritz Lang - Metropolis

metropolis lang
UFA

Metropolis is a groundbreaking silent film from 1927, featuring elaborate special effects and visuals that would inspire the likes of Blade Runner, Brazil, Star Wars and best of all, Queen’s music video for Radio Gaga.

It’s pretty much the great granddaddy of the sci-fi genre, and you’d be hard pressed to find anybody who’d give it a bad review. That’s unless you asked director Fritz Lang about it, who would have given it a low rating on the IMDb. To quote the man himself, he “detested” Metropolis after it was completed.

In the end, he thought the movie was “silly and stupid”, and that its political subtext didn’t work because it was essentially a fairytale. He also wasn’t fond of the Nazi party’s admiration for it, which led him to flee Germany when they offered him the chance to become head of a film studio making propaganda for them.


1. Orson Welles - Citizen Kane

Orson Welles Citizen Kane
Warner Bros.

Citizen Kane is often voted the best film ever made, and filmmakers regularly cite it as one of the most important films in history. It’s really good, basically. It might come as a shock to learn Welles himself kind of hated it, but not because he thought it sucked.

Kane became something of an albatross for him and despite actors and producers telling him how much they loved it, they still wouldn’t hire him for other projects. He also felt some of his other movies were much better, and people’s obsession with it slowly began to drive him mad.

Welles wasn’t much of a fan of his own work because he always felt he could have done a better job, so he couldn’t appreciate the love Citizen Kane received. Considering he made one of the best films ever, he obviously set his bar a little too high.

Can you think of any other filmmakers who hated one of their own movies, despite the film being considered a masterpiece? Share them with us in the comments below.


Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.