8 Horror Films Ruined By Disappointing Death Scenes

We still can't believe that Freddy Krueger was killed by a pipe bomb in Nightmare on Elm Street 6.

hostel 2 paxton.jpg
Lionsgate

A well-crafted death scene is a key component of most horror films. Gruesome, gory, and grisly kills are all welcome additions to any scary movie, and some are as creative and innovative as they are downright disgusting.

The freak accidents of the Final Destination franchise, the torturous traps featured in the Saw series, and those dream-based killings perpetrated by Nightmare on Elm Street's Freddy Krueger are, for the most part, delightfully disgusting. These death scenes are generally hair-rising hits, horrifying and entertaining for their viewers in equal measures.

However, not every horror movie death can be perfect; some, in fact, can be undeservedly disappointing, dull, or unoriginal.

Whether it's Freddy's totally underwhelming fate in the sixth Nightmare on Elm Street film (the demonic serial killer is somehow destroyed by a pipe bomb), or Alex Browning's offscreen demise in Final Destination 2, these deaths left their audiences completely disappointed instead of totally terrified.

These are eight horror movies which were ruined by their disappointingly mediocre death scenes.

8. La Llorona - The Curse Of La Llorona

The Curse of La Llorona
New Line Cinema

Based on stories surrounding La Llorona, a malevolent figure from Latin American folklore, The Curse of La Llorona is the sixth installment in the otherwise successful Conjuring franchise. Although this supernatural horror film received lukewarm reviews upon release, the movie was relatively successful at the box-office, terrifying audiences with its horrifying depiction of the well-known spirit.

The film focuses on the Garcias, a young family who encounter La Llorona (aka The Weeping Woman), the spirit of a woman who, centuries earlier, had drowned her sons in a stream.

La Llorona attempts to harm members of the Garcia family, leaving burn marks on their wrists and eventually attempting to drown the children. Anna Tate-Garcia (Linda Cardellini), the familial matriarch, is ultimately able to destroy the murderous spirit before it can do her family greater harm.

However, the spirit appears surprisingly easy to destroy. Grabbing a crucifix crafted from a Fire Tree (a type of tree which grew next to the stream in which La Llorona killed her sons), Anna is able to stab the spirit, ostensibly destroying her. Throughout the film, we see La Llorona's immense (and terrifying) powers on multiple occasions; that she can be destroyed so easily is totally underwhelming.


7. Holly Nelson - Paranormal Activity 4

Paranormal Activity 4 Wyatt
Paramount

The fourth installment in this (in)famous found footage horror franchise, Paranormal Activity 4 was something of a critical flop and is widely considered one of the weakest films in the series.

Set five years after the events of Paranormal Activity 2 (Paranormal Activity 3 was, confusingly, a prequel to the first movie in the series), the film follows the Nelson family as they experience unexplained, supernatural phenomena.

The family are affected by increasingly violent and terrifying events: a chandelier nearly crushes Alex (Kathryn Newton), for example, and she is later nearly killed by a garage door.

Eventually, these unexplained occurrences turn deadly. While home alone, the family matriarch, Holly (Alexondra Lee), is suddenly attacked by an unseen force. Unexpectedly flung in the air as she stands in her living room, Holly is instantly killed when she hits the ceiling.

While this death is certainly shocking, the speed at which it occurs leaves viewers more puzzled than terrified. Ultimately, Holly's death is just another mediocre jump scare in an equally mediocre movie.


6. Laura Hunter - Saw II

The second film in this seriously sadistic torture-porn series traces the efforts of Detective Eric Matthews (Donnie Wahlberg) as he attempts to save his son from the Jigsaw Killer (Tobin Bell).

Jigsaw has trapped a group of unwilling victims in a veritable house of horrors: a run-down building filled to the brim with torturous traps, brutal booby traps, and an insidious nerve gas which is slowly poisoning those inside.

While not as inherently innovative as the first film in this now-tired franchise, Saw II remains a pretty successful sequel, and the movie includes some of the most infamous traps of the series. Amanda Young (Shawnee Smith) is forced to root around in a pit filled with used syringes, for example, and Obi Tate (Tim Burd) is cruelly burned alive in a furnace.

Despite featuring such creative and sadistic deaths, Saw II also contains one of the dullest deaths in the entire series. Laura Hunter (Beverley Mitchell) is not killed by one of Jigsaw's torturous traps, and she instead slowly succumbs to the fatal effects of the nerve gas. Dying from a seizure while in Amanda's arms, Laura's demise is certainly tragic and upsetting. However, compared to other deaths in the series, this scene is ultimately lackluster.


5. George Lanter - The Final Destination

The Final Destination George
New Line Cinema

The Final Destination is the fourth installment of this consistently outlandish series, and generally considered the weakest. While watching an exhilarating auto race with his friends, Nick O'Bannon (Bobby Campo) sees a vision: a catastrophic accident will devastate the racetrack, graphically killing drivers and spectators alike.

Panicking, Nick is able to leave the stadium alongside his group, as well as other attendees caught up in the ensuing kerfuffle. Nick's premonition ultimately becomes reality and many are killed in the ensuing disaster. As is typical of all films in the franchise, the survivors are killed of one-by-one in a series of freak accidents.

While some are delightfully gory and truly unexpected (one victim is disemboweled by a swimming pool's drain pipe), the death of George Lanter (Mykelti Williamson) is unoriginal and underwhelming.

Completely squashed by a speeding ambulance, George's death should have been shocking, completely taking audiences by surprise. However, George's death is incredibly similar to the demise of Terry Chaney (Amanda Detmer). In the original Final Destination, Terry is unexpectedly killed by a speeding bus. Unlike George's derivative demise, however, Terry's death did genuinely shock audiences.

Given the increasingly creative means by which Final Destination characters meet their grisly ends, this surprisingly unoriginal death really stands out as one the weakest in the entire franchise.


4. Pennywise - It Chapter Two

It Chapter Two Pennywise
New Line Cinema

It Chapter Two is the overlong, sprawling sequel to the wildly successful 2017 adaptation of the Stephen King novel of the same name. Set some twenty-seven years after the events of the first film, this admittedly scary follow-up sees the Losers Club return to Derry in order to take on Pennywise (aka It), the shape-shifting demonic clown who has haunted the group since childhood.

With excellent performances from its stellar cast (which includes James McAvoy, Bill Hader, and Jessica Chastain), It Chapter Two does offer some genuine scares. However, all in all, this sequel is generally considered far weaker than its predecessor, especially due to its unexpectedly disappointing ending.

As the film draws to a close, the Losers Club travel below the town's sewers in order to finally confront, and hopefully destroy, Pennywise. The group are eventually able to defeat the murderous monster... by bullying It. Yes, the gang mock, tease, and taunt the transdimensional terror until he shrinks to such a small size that Mike (Isaiah Mustafa) is able to destroy the monster's heart.

This underwhelming ending totally undermines the frightening atmosphere crafted throughout both It Chapter Two and its predecessor, leaving audiences confused and disappointed.


3. Freddy Krueger - Freddy's Dead: The Final Nightmare

The FInal Nightmare Freddy Krueger
New Line Cinema

While the tagline to the sixth installment of this slasher series promises audiences that, "They saved the best for last," this lackluster and unoriginal sequel was a critical and commercial disaster.

Generally considered the worst film in the franchise, this mediocre movie reveals that Freddy Krueger (Robert Englund), the sadistic serial killer who murders children and teenagers while they sleep, has a secret daughter, Dr. Maggie Burroughs (Lisa Zane).

Teaming up with a group of troubled teens, Maggie attempts to finally destroy Freddy, and she battles her disturbed father with a variety of weapons such as throwing knives and crossbows.

Maggie manages to trap Freddy with surprising ease, pinning him to a wall before stabbing the murderer with his own clawed glove. Maggie is then thrown a pipe bomb (bombus ex machina?) with which she is able to finally destroy Freddy.

This honestly cringe-inducing scene allows Maggie to defeat the ostensibly invincible serial killer with apparent ease. While the first five films in the franchise consistently demonstrate that Freddy is essentially impossible to injure, let alone kill, this subpar sequel goes against the established rules of the franchise. This entirely underwhelming death of one of horror's most iconic villains is a slap in the face to Freddy fans everywhere.


2. Paxton Rodriguez - Hostel 2

hostel 2 paxton.jpg
Lionsgate

This infamous torture-porn horror series centers on a wealthy, murderous group of European serial killers who lure, torture, and kill young, foreign tourists. The first film in this three-part franchise focuses on the exploits of Paxton (Jay Hernandez), Josh (Dereck Richardson), and Oli (Eyþór Guðjónsson), a group of hedonistic travelers.

Josh and Oli are graphically tortured and murdered: the former is drilled to death; the latter is decapitated. Ultimately, Paxton uses his strength and resilience to survive the events of Hostel, eventually killing one of his cruel captors.

However, many viewers were disappointed when this well-liked character swiftly kicked the bucket in the sequel's opening segment. Even though the paranoid, deeply traumatized Paxton has been living as a recluse, he is eventually tracked down and murdered in his apartment.

While we do see his decapitated corpse, Paxton's death is not depicted onscreen. This disappointing demise makes us wonder why Paxton survived the events of the first film in this horror series. If the filmmakers had always intended for the character to die, we reckon that a grisly onscreen death would have been a far more fitting send-off.


1. Alex Browning - Final Destination 2

Final Destination Alex
New Line Cinema

Alex Browning (Devon Sawa) is the central protagonist of the first Final Destination film, an innovative horror movie which focuses on the consequences of (unintentionally) cheating death. Preparing for a flight to Paris with his schoolmates, Alex has a premonition: their plane will crash a short time after take-off, and the fiery accident will kill all those onboard.

Alex is able to disembark the plane prior to take-off, and the panicked teenager is followed by a group of his friends, peers, and teachers. Standing in the airport as the plane leaves, the surviving group watch in horror as the aircraft actually does catastrophically malfunction mid-air.

Initially, the group are simultaneously relieved and devastated. However, most of the survivors later perish in a series of outlandish freak accidents. Alex, however, somehow manages to escape death once more, ultimately surviving the events of the first film.

In the sequel, however, we discover that Alex, despite living as a total recluse, was eventually killed in his house by a falling brick. This death is completely underwhelming and, given that it occurs entirely offscreen, makes us question why Alex survived Final Destination in the first place? This disappointing revelation really ruins this otherwise entertaining sequel.


Contributor

Madison Rennie hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.