8 Movies You Wrongly Thought Were Sequels
Someone's been lying to you.
If there's one thing you ought to be able to count on from a sequel above all of the rules about escalation, more character development and the exploration of some new ideas: a sequel should always be a sequel. If it's going to claim openly to be a follow-up to whatever the last movie released in a franchise, it should have the decency to actually follow through on that.
But it seems that that simple rule doesn't actually seem to matter to some movies. Despite promising a continuation of established - and usually lucrative (which is often the key point) - franchises, they stand as monuments to Hollywood's occasional insistence on packaging things in a way that best suits the bottom line, rather than the audience.
Sometimes, the transgressions are slightly more forgivable - like when marketing campaigns suggest that a prequel or a remake are a sequel - or when the film-makers are playing with the idea of anthology films, but there are some cynical examples out there that leave a slightly bad taste. And invariably, when a film is seeking to use an established brand to sell itself, you just know it wasn't good enough to survive on its own.
Basically, what you need to know is, if it walks like a sequel and quacks like a sequel, it's not always a sequel...
8. 10 Cloverfield Lane
Though it has the word Cloverfield in the title and an alien invasion sub-plot, 10 Cloverfield Lane is not the super secret sequel project it initially seemed to be when the curtain was first drawn back on it. In reality, the links between Cloverfield and its "follow-up" are quite vague - it's definitely the same world, but it's not exactly the same story.
What 10 Cloverfield Lane really is - rather than a sequel - is a brand expansion. It's an opportunity for Paramount to establish an Anthology of Cloverfield movies - which will be expanded further with God Particle in 2018 (though the title may change). They aren't linear in any way, and there's no real hint that they are even tied together the same way serial movies traditionally are.
Instead of thinking of it as a franchise, it's best to think of Cloverfield as a way to model films. They're siblings rather than sequels, and each will stride out on their own journeys confidently, with the marketing boost of belonging to an established brand but no requirement to follow on narratively. it's all terribly clever.
7. Home Alone 3
Can you say cynical cash grab? Home Alone 3 is less a straight sequel to the excellent Macaulay Culkin movies and more a completely unrelated movie with one basic similarity with the Home Alone brand name slapped on it.
The "sequel" manages to lose everything that made the original good - the McCallister clan (and Kevin chiefly) and the Wet Bandits - and replaces them with a dumb plot about a lost cloaking chip, four hitmen (without the charisma in Joe Pesci's little finger between them) and a precocious lead child who is not Macaulay Culkin. He's not even a bargain basement Culkin.
But being bad doesn't disqualify it from being a sequel: it's the complete lack of any tie to the other films other than the vague idea of home invasion and traps. And it's that kind of tenuous relationship that would suggest you could claim that the Saw movies are set in the Home Alone universe. Or the original Purge. Or Funny Games. You can't just have plot similarities and expect anyone to just accept it being a sequel without all the other qualifiers.
6. The Bourne Legacy
When Matt Damon decided to follow Paul Greengrass in pulling out of the original Bourne 4 - which would have been a straight sequel - Universal simply ploughed on undeterred, bringing in Tony Gilroy and Jeremy Renner and sticking with the title of The Bourne Legacy.
Even with a different lead character, it seemed likely we were getting a sequel, given that the title had Bourne in it and was also the same as a genuine Jason Bourne-starring sequel novel written by Eric Van Lustbader in 2004.
Sure there are links (like David Strathairn's character reappearing), but Legacy is an entirely different beast, which introduces chemical augmentation to its super soldier plot and whose only real tie to Bourne is the idea of shady government black ops programmes.
Legacy is an anthology movie, the same as 10 Cloverfield Lane was, and it arguably might have done better critically and at the box office if they hadn't lumbered it with the Bourne brand name. That way it wouldn't have been directly compared - which ultimately made it very obviously appear inferior.
5. Halloween 3: Season Of The Witch
Just as the Nightmare On Elm Street movies are defined by the central appearance of Freddy Krueger, Saw movies involve Jigsaw (or his apprentices) and Fast & Furious movies have to include Dom Toretto's gang, the Halloween franchise is inseparable from Michael Myers.
The Shatner-mask wearing oddball killer is synonymous with the brand - hell, he is the brand - and his studio found that out the hard way when they had the audacity to make a "sequel" without him with Season Of The Witch. On reflection, though there's a 3 in the title there and it was released as part of the Halloween series, it's nowhere near being a sequel to the first two movies.
The main draw character is gone and the mythology focuses on something else entirely as if the studio were trying to diversify and explore anthology movies. And while it wasn't enough to kill the franchise, all the claim that it's a sequel did was make it look inferior by proximity - like a weird concept album released after two runaway hits.
4. Indiana Jones And The Temple Of Doom
If it wasn't for the opening confirmation that the film is set in 1935 - and thus before Raiders Of The Lost Ark - you could still be forgiven for believing that Temple Of Doom is actually a straight sequel to the first Indiana Jones movie.
After all, why would they really need to make it a prequel when Raiders had only just introduced the character and there was no need for the soft reboot opportunity usually afforded by prequelisation. But it definitely is a prequel, and not the direct follow-up the marketing campaign seemed to be suggesting it was going to be.
That all makes the fact that Indy claims in Raiders not to believe in magic ("a lot of superstitious hocus-pocus") all the more confusing, considering he'd not long encountered Voodoo and possession. Maybe it's just religious "magic" he wasn't a fan of?
It feels like Temple Of Doom was designed to follow the James Bond-like anthology/serial approach to movies, whereby the character remained the constant, but each new chapter wasn't so much a linear sequel as another adventure. Which isnt' a bad shout really - it's just a shame we didn't get 25 of them.
3. Troll 2
Somewhat infamously in the video game world, the version of Super Mario Bros 2 released to the Western market was in fact a disguised Yume Kōjō: Doki Doki Panic, which was repurposed to take advantage of interest in the Mario brand when it became clear that the originally planned sequel wasn't going to be viable. They basically slapped on the name and the characters and expected nobody to really notice (or to care).
The same trick was attempted by US distributors when they were handed the movie Goblins. Clearly not confident of the film's ability to succeed as an independent under its own power, they renamed it Troll 2 after the1986 original, which had made more than $5m from a relatively small $700k budget.
Anyone who was tricked into believing it was a sequel would have noticed immediately that it wasn't one. The two films have no connection at all, and the title is a complete misnomer, given the lack of any actual trolls.
2. The Evil Dead II
There has been some debate for years over the true nature of The Evil Dead II, with a fairly loud thread of fans refusing to accept that it is anything other than a sequel. Sure, it retreads the same ground, they'll say, but it's different ENOUGH to consider it a straight sequel to the first after the first 7 minutes that are just a recap of what came before.
And that justification works if you want it to, but the reality is that The Evil Dead II is basically a redo from a clean slate, with the recap wiping out the need to watch the first film (how many sequels have such a lengthy recap opening?) and inconsistencies suggesting its events possibly didn't happen. For instance, where are the dead bodies around the cabin?
It was all down to rights issues, so it's odd that anyone involved in the second film would ever bother trying to defend the first one. Even Bruce Campbell calls it a "requel", whatever the hell that means.
1. Dirty Dancing 2: Havana Nights
The second anyone ever suggested making another Dirty Dancing movie almost 20 years after the original should have been the exact same moment the conversation should have been killed dead. It's one of those films so protected by nostalgia (and actually being good on top of that) that it ought to have been given protected status years ago.
Sadly, that wasn't the case as the studio decided to bring out a belated follow-up in 2004, starring Romola Garai and Diego Luna as the new generation of star-crossed dance lovers, who find love in Cuba rather than at Kellermans. It was set in 1958 - a full 5 years before the original, for some reason - and it essentially just steals the plot.
Even worse, Patrick Swayze actually turned up for a cameo as a dance teacher (unnamed), confusing the timeline entirely and basically ensuring that it's impossible to consider it a sequel, despite the title.
Which other non-sequel sequels belong on this list? Share your own suggestions below in the comments thread.