8 Unpopular Movie Plot Twists That Don't Get Enough Credit
A movie can live or die by its plot twist. Employed by writers and filmmakers alike as a way to make you rethink everything you've just spent two hours watching, a plot twist can enhance the quality of a movie in ways you never thought possible, or spoil the narrative entirely for the sake of a quick shock. Because most of the time, plot twists just don't work - revisiting a movie with the twist embedded in your mind will often expose gaping plot holes and logical flaws that render the story unworkable. When a plot twist does work, of course, it can bring a whole new perspective and added layers to your movie - but let's be honest, most movie twists only ever cause us to shake our heads and sigh, because it's actually incredibly difficult to write a genuinely brilliant one that holds up on a second viewing. As a result, there are tons of motion pictures out there that feel like they've had shocking twists dumped onto the end for the sake of it, just because it seemed like a better idea than ending the movie, you know, normally... In its most basic form, then, a plot twist can be regarded as "a sudden or unexpected change in a movie's direction," which is the criteria I'll be using for motion pictures I've assembled here. So whereas there are some pretty unforgivable twists inherent to a lot of movies nowadays, here are 8 that are pretty much loathed or looked upon with disapproval by the movie-going public at large, although - in retrospect - they're probably nowhere near as bad as we've made out...
8. The Book of Eli (2010)
The Twist: A badass drifter named Eli spends his time wandering a post-apocalyptic wasteland protecting an old book... a book that is eventually revealed to be the last remaining copy of the King James Bible... and guess what? He's been blind all along, don't you know? Why It's Unpopular: It's a goofy, gimmicky idea, and it makes no sense at all - how would Eli be able to fight the way he does if he lacked vision? It's not like he's Daredevil! Why It Deserves More Credit: The general public took this reveal like it was a personal insult, failing to forget that this was a B-movie, and that Eli turning out to be blind is an amusing, schlocky touch that makes sense given the context of the movie. The same thing was done with Japanese flick Zatoichi (also B-movie fun), and nobody thought it was out of place or complained then. And although it doesn't really matter, it's scientifically possible to learn to "see" with echolocation, so what's the problem? Book of Eli is ultimately bit of fun, just like this underrated twist.
7. War of the Worlds (2005)
The Twist: Earth is invaded by aliens for Mars, and Tom Cruise goes on the run with his annoying children for a couple of hours, only to find that... wait, simple bacteria has stopped the aliens dead in their tracks (as in... they're all dead), and the world goes back to normal. Why It's Unpopular: Bacteria killing the aliens is horribly anti-climatic. Couldn't Spielberg have thought of something a little bit more exciting than that? You know, like he did when he put that tank in the shark's mouth for the climax of Jaws. Why It Deserves More Credit: Because it's genius. And aside from the fact that it's genius, it was also in the original novel in H.G. Wells, who opted for a scientific and realistic approach to the human race having somehow beaten the Martians, who have heat rays and mechanical tripods. Fact is, the Martians are in possession of technologies far superior to our own, but they completely overlooked an aspect of their invasion that we, too, take for granted on an everyday basis: bacteria. We've built up an immunity to bacteria over millions of years, of course, whereas newcomers have no defense against it at all. Many said it was anti-climatic to end the movie in this way, because they wanted Tom Cruise blasting fighting an alien with his bare hands on top of a tripod, but the ending we got is logical and super clever and you can't convince me otherwise.
6. No Country For Old Men (2007)
The Twist: After finding a suitcase full of money, Llewelyn Moss enters a dangerous game of cat and mouse with a terrifying hitman, only to... end up getting killed off-screen twenty minutes before the ending of the movie? What? Are you kidding me, Coen Brothers? Why It's Unpopular: Having followed Moss for the entire length of the movie, suddenly killing him off without warning (and off-screen, no less) seemed like a certified smack in the face, and film-goers did not appreciate the casual and fanfare-less way in which this character was suddenly dispatched. Why It Deserves More Credit: Because it's a brilliant deconstruction of our expectations, and the Coens are making a great point: why do we need to see Llewelyn Moss killed on-screen, anyways? If they're showing us that he's dead (and it isn't left on an annoyingly ambiguous), what does it matter? We're given the same information that we would have if we'd have seen him shot on-screen. So although it's frustrating, it's a clever way to approach the material. It also links perfectly to the themes in the movie - that the moment Moss takes the suitcase, he's doomed, and he won't be able to outrun his destiny. This point is echoed throughout the movie via Sheriff Ed Bell, who has become disillusioned by the amount of evil in the world - evil that he finds much too overwhelming to deal with. The sudden nature of Moss' death highlights the inevitably of this evil. It may be irksome, but it makes sense given the themes of the movie.
5. The Happening (2008)
The Twist: People across the United States suddenly start killing themselves at random, and it turns out... ohmyGod, plants are releasing a strange toxin that is forcing them to do it. Because nature is angry at us. Why It's Unpopular: "Plants did it." It sounds incredibly dumb. And it doesn't help that M. Night Shyamalan tries to make this all seem scary by shooting close-ups of trees blowing in the wind accompanied by tense musical cues, which is what happens - a lot. Why It Deserves More Credit: As with so many M. Night Shyamalan ventures, the man's ideas aren't necessarily terrible - it's the way he executes them that kind of spoils everything. Take this idea, which sounds ridiculous in premise, but definitely could have worked had it not felt so slap dash. Shyamalan was onto something when he decided to make a movie about the wrath of nature, but he went about it in the wrong way: this reeks of Stephen King and the kind of concept that he might've worked wonders with on the page. So had the writer/director insisted on a specific type of plant releasing the toxin, and not just "plants on the whole" (which just sounds "blah"), it might have been a little more buyable - we could believe that one plant had evolved to the point where it could release a toxin or something, right? So although it's easy to scoff at this idea, The Happening was spot-on as a relevant take on man vs. nature, it was just clumsily laid out on the screen. And at least he had the balls to reveal the "plot twist" halfway through the movie and not at the end this time.
4. Secret Window (2004)
The Twist: A writer named Mort played by Johnny Depp has his life continually turned upside down by a guy named John Shooter... but it turns out in the end that - brace yourself - Johnny Depp was John Shooter all along. He's got split personality disorder! Why It's Unpopular: Oh, man, one of those endings- what a waste of time. There's no twist worse than the one where it turns out a character is insane or schizophrenic or something, is there? The fact that it was pretty obvious didn't help either. Why It Deserves More Credit: All right, bear with me, because I'm not going to defend Secret Window as if it's some forgotten masterpiece, because it mostly resembles a TV movie, and though it's good in places, it's still pretty average for a thriller. But the twist itself - in which one character turns out to be another - isn't as terrible as we all probably think it is. Once again, execution was the straw that broke the camel's back here - the twist simply isn't that bad because - in the context of the story, anyway - it actually makes sense. The concept worked much better in its original novella format to be totally fair, and that's because it was written by Stephen King, who can make contrived plots of this sort into believable masterpieces. But remember that he came up with the idea back in 1990 and not in 2004, so although it might've felt like old hat when the movie version came out, the idea at least came from an era where it didn't feel done to death like it does now. And at least when Mort turns out to be Shooter it doesn't compromise the story, as with so many twists of this type.
3. Iron Man 3 (2013)
The Twist: Iron Man meets his match in his most dangerous enemy yet, a terrorist calling himself the Mandarin, as played by Ben Kingsley... but towards the end of the movie we discover that the Mandarin is actually the character played by Guy Pearce, Aldrich Killian, and that Kingsley is actually playing an actor named Trevor Slattery. Why It's Unpopular: Trevor. His name is Trevor Slattery. That's why nobody like this twist: because the filmmakers made the Mandarin into a kind of joke. That aside, isn't this just a pointless compromise of an iconic character for the sake of a laugh and a plot twist that doesn't really benefit the story on the whole? Why It Deserves More Credit: Hey, at least the filmmakers tried to do something different, and I don't think anybody could say that it wasn't nice to see Ben Kingsley playing two very different characters. But the real reason that this doesn't get enough credit is because the character of the Mandarin is sorely outdated, and writer/director Shane Black managed to create a new and interesting way to deal with this guy. It didn't please everybody, but it fit well with the tone of the movie - even if some people did think it was much too jokey overall.
2. The Birds (1963)
The Twist: Having been attacked and trapped in a house by the world's avian population for no real reason at all, our surviving characters step outside to find that the birds have completely calmed without explanation. They drive off into the distance, pensive about the future... Why It's Unpopular: A cop-out ending, implemented purely because Hitchcock had no other ideas how to end his picture. With no explanation as to why the birds started acting up in the first place, it's even more annoying that they suddenly decide to chill out no reason, to. Why It Deserves More Credit: I never knew that this sudden twist of an ending was considered rather unpopular until I stumbled upon hundreds of reviews citing this part of the movie as its weakest - and going by what I've read on message boards, too, it seems like people were left feeling a little betrayed. But this is a far cleverer ending than one might realise at first, although you have to understand the core idea behind The Birds first. The Birds, ultimately, is about the unpredictability of nature, and how sometimes things happen and there's no way to explain them. As human beings, we constantly seek out answers and explanations for everything, and as a result things tend to happen according to the established "logic" of the universe. Which is fine, until you remember that it was us who came up with those rules in the first place. We don't actually know what's true. So when, in Hitchcock's movie, the birds start randomly attacking, we instantly want to know why. But what if such a thing happened one day in real life? There's no reason it couldn't - we think we understand everything, after all, but we don't. Not really. So ending the movie with the birds suddenly calming down isn't a cop-out - it's a moment that sums up the entire conceit of the film: all the "rules" of the universe are still just guesses.
1. The Village (2004)
The Twist: A creepy thriller movie set at in an isolated community at some point in the early 19th century... but wait, this is a film by M. Night Shyamalan, so of course the movie is actually in the modern day, and the village elders have been keeping it a secret from everybody else to protect them from humanity (or something). Why It's Universally Hated: It seems pretty lame, considering that it the entire movie is based around the idea that a community aren't aware that the modern era is a few miles away, but for what real purpose? It's almost as if M. Night Shyamalan wrote this movie just so he had an excuse to use this twist or something. Oh. Why It Deserves More Credit: All right, so the execution was lacking, but you can't really say that the general idea was all that bad - it's an intriguing prospect, and one that would have probably been improved had Shyamlan explored the repercussions of what happens if said village has to suddenly face up to the real world. If he'd have opted to split the movie down the middle, with the "twist" at the mid-point, and then explored the exposure of the village or something, it might've been more interesting. As it stands, it's an alright twist, but nowhere near as bad as everybody claims it is. And remember... if this had been a movie by anyone else, we probably wouldn't have guessed that a twist was coming at all. This is just where it became popular to hate on the Shya-Man, and we were all mentally prepared for a twist from the get-go. Had anybody else helmed this movie, it might've been better received - our expectations would have been different, at least. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.