8 Wild Movie Fan Theories (That Were Actually Correct)

RoboCop is Jesus? Not as dumb as it sounds.

Origami Crane Blade Runner
Scott Free

The Internet has given people the world over a voice to use how they wish, those most of us use it to spread cat memes or dumb fan theories about beloved movies.

Fan theories have risen in popularity in the last few years, and can offer fascinating readings of classic movies (Cobb’s wedding ring is his dream totem) or make silly claims based on flimsy evidence (Max is really the Feral Kid!). It's all in the good fun, though, and most people are wise enough to take them with a grain of salt.

Once in a while one of these readings will be right on the money, however, with either the creators confirming a theory is correct or a later sequel validating it. In a couple of cases the makers will like a theory so much they’ll add it to canon, which has to make whoever came up with it feel pretty damn smug.

The following is a list of popular fan theories that were later endorsed by the creators, which range from fascinating to outright silly. 

8. The Engineers Created The Aliens - Alien

Alien Engineer
20th Century Fox

The Alien series has a rich mythology for fans to dig into, and there's no mystery more intriguing than the Space Jockey body from the original. This giant figure was the pilot of the derelict ship, who died from a chest buster following a crash landing.

Various theories about its origins were explored in comics and spin-off novels, with each offering a unique take on the creature’s backstory. Ridley Scott always mentioned wanting to go back and explore the history of the character and supported the idea the Space Jockey and his kind created the alien.

Scott finally got his wish with Prometheus, which redubbed the creature the Engineer. His kind created the human race, and their tampering with different life forms led to a disaster on the planet seen in the film.

At the end, an Engineer even gives birth to a prototype alien called The Deacon, and this creature will no doubt play a role in forthcoming sequel Alien: Covenant.


7. Deckard Is A Replicant - Blade Runner

Harrison Ford Blade Runner
Scott Free

Blade Runner only grows better with age, and seems to reveal something new every time you watch it. It’s such a rich movie numerous fan theories have sprung up around it, like the theory Deckard is a replicant who was implanted with Gaff's memories, which explains the latter’s dislike of him; plus it makes his compliment “You’ve done a man’s job.” all the more meaningful.

Of course, the main question surrounding Blade Runner for years was the idea Deckard was a replicant, with fans debating the evidence amongst themselves. Key people involved with the film insisted he was while Harrison Ford denied it.

The final word came from Ridley Scott during an interview for a documentary, where he confirms the origami unicorn means Deckard is a replicant. Fans still like to argue this issue, but if the director himself says it was the intention that’s the end of the debate, really.

You can expect the forthcoming sequel to settle the question definitively.


6. Dumbledore Is Gay - Harry Potter

Albus Dumbledore
Warner Bros.

Long before JK Rowling confirmed it, fans had shipped a relationship between Dumbledore and Gellert Grindelwald thanks to the hints of their closeness in the book. Some were as adamant about it as they were that Harry was a Horcrux all along.

Saying that, Rowling actually caught a lot of readers by surprise when she announced Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts, was really gay during a press tour in 2007. His sexuality didn't seem to be consequential, after all.

Ultimately her explanation that Dumbledore had fallen in love with Gellert Grindelwald when he was young, and had his heart broken when Grindelwald became a Dark Wizard, made sense in the context of the story. She also clarified that while Gellert knew of his friend's true feelings, he never returned them and used them to manipulate Dumbledore for his own ends.

Fans reacted positively to the revelation, since it added another layer to Dumbledore’s back-story and explained why he blinded himself to the evil actions of his former friend.


5. Dr. Gordon Is Jigsaw's Secret Apprentice - Saw

Saw 7
Lionsgate

Dr Gordon wasn’t looking too hot at the end of Saw, since he was bleeding to death after cutting his foot off. His fate wasn’t revealed during the following sequels, so naturally fans speculated about what happened to the good doctor.

The filmmakers claimed it was up to the viewer to decide what happened, but evidence within the sequels pointed to Gordon helping Jigsaw, like the grainy video footage in Saw II of a limping figure operating on a victim. The chances of actor Cary Elwes returning looked slim, though, since he sued the producers of Saw over a salary dispute.

The question of Gordon’s fate still hung the series the more it dragged on, so there was rejoicing when it was confirmed Elwes would return for the final movie, Saw 3D. Unfortunately, it was a disappointing comeback; he barely appears, and the reveal that he was Jigsaw’s apprentice is half-hearted.

The producers gave fans exactly the twist they expected, and no more. It doesn’t even explain why Gordon would be willing to help Jigsaw, considering the hell he went through in the first movie.


4. Kill Bill And Django Unchained Are Movies Within Movies

Kill Bill vol. 1
The Weinstein Co.

Tarantino likes to connect his movies together, be it easter eggs like Red Apple Cigarettes or characters being related to each other, like Reservoir Dogs Mr Blonde and Pulp Fiction’s Vincent Vega being brothers. He has all this connective tissue in mind, and while it might pass over the heads of some audiences his fans have fun spotting them.

He’s even constructed separate universes for his films, with movies like Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction taking place in the “real” world, while Kill Bill and Django Unchained take place within a special “movie” universe.

This means when Jackie Brown goes to the movies, she’s watching stuff like From Dusk Till Dawn and Grindhouse. Fans quickly picked up on this separation, and Tarantino confirmed this was the case.

Some have gone even deeper with their reading, suggesting Mia Wallace is the actress playing The Bride in Kill Bill. The evidence for this is when Mia describes the plot of her failed TV pilot Fox Force Five, she basically sums up the Deadly Viper Assassination Squad.


3. The Genie Is The Peddler In Disguise - Aladdin

Aladdin Genie Stall Holder
Disney

The Peddler is the first character seen in Aladdin, who kindly offers to tell the viewer the origin of an oil lamp in his possession. Since the character was voiced by Robin Williams – who also voices the Genie – and share the same hyperactive personality, a convincing theory emerged claiming he was really the Genie’s human form.

His robes look just like the Genie’s, they shared the same blue colour scheme and both have four fingers on each hand. It remained a theory for two decades until the director’s confirmed it, and the original concept was the Peddler would reveal himself to be the Genie at the end.

It makes sense for the Genie to be the one telling the story, but this plot point was ultimately dropped from the final cut since Disney wanted to leave the character fully powered in case of a sequel.


2. RoboCop Is An Allegory For Jesus - RoboCop

Robocop Jesus
Columbia Pictures

It’s a credit to Dutch auteur Paul Verhoeven that he took RoboCop, which on the surface sounds like the dumbest thing ever, and made an enduring sci-fi classic. There are a lot of layers to the story of a cop being transformed into a robot, including commentary on corporations, consumerism and questions of identity.

Admirers quickly picked up on the RoboCop as Jesus subtext, and it's not subtle if you look for it. You have Murphy being crucified by his killers, leading to his resurrection as RoboCop, who then becomes the saviour of Detroit; he even appears to walk on water during the final showdown with Boddicker.

Of course, this was all intentional, since Verhoeven has a fascination with the story of Jesus and even published a book on the topic.

He’s since confirmed the Jesus allegory and is impressed fans have read more into the Christian imagery than he intended, like Dick Jones being a Satan figure who falls to earth at the climax.


1. Darth Vader Was Burned In Lava - Revenge Of The Sith

revenge of the sith
Lucasfilm

It’s hard to remember a time fans were excited about the Star Wars prequels, but the promise of a new trilogy telling the story of Anakin Skywalker’s rise and fall was damn near irresistible.

Whatever the legacy of the prequels may be they still gave us some great moments, with the epic duel between Anakin and Obi-Wan being a standout. For years, fans had wondered how Anakin received the nasty injuries that turned him into Vader, with many suspecting a duel with Obi-Wan led to him being burned in lava. This was just a wild theory, but it sounded plausible.

Lucas isn’t one to disappoint his fans (at least in this one, very specific instance) and Revenge Of The Sith confirmed this was the case. The Mustafar duel concludes with the grisly moment Obi-Wan slices Anakin’s legs off and leaves him to burn, though in hindsight he probably wishes he finished the job; it would have saved so much hassle later on.

Can you think of any other fan theories that were later proven correct? Share your favourites in the comments below.


In this post: 
Blade Runner
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.