9 Annoying Movie Characters That Only Existed To Explain The Plot
Its an inevitable fact that at some point in a film therell have to be some exposition. In fantastical movie worlds theres naturally going to be a multitude of elements that have to be set up before the actual story can begin, but even the most simplistic of concepts still require some level of set up. How ham fisted it ends up being really depends on how skilled the screenwriter is and thats exactly what Ill be looking at today. You never notice when its been done well because it comes across as natural to both the characters and the narrative, but the moment you spot it done badly thats you immediately sucked out of the action. Otherwise brilliant scripts can fall apart when the characters suddenly break out of the world and all but scream facts at the audience. But some films take it one further and create characters who exist solely to divulge or reiterate the plot to us. While this can work if an effort is made to add depth and purpose (what are Obi-Wan Kenobis lines in the original Star Wars trilogy if not a constant stream of plot points), sometimes the offenders just coming across as annoying. And it is nine of those attempts that well be looking at today. Honourable Mention: Basil Exposition - Austin Powers
In a direct parody of M, who fits the bill completely across all the Bond films (except for Skyfall), Basil Exposition appears throughout the Austin Powers trilogy and in his few brief appearances manages to send up the exact sort of characters were looking at this list, as well as providing plenty of jokes beside. Neither M nor Basil are particularly annoying so stand out as examples of exposition driven characters who actually work. Click next to explore ones that dont.
9. Mathis - Casino Royale
René Mathis may have been part of Ian Fleming's Bond novels from the very beginning, but that didn't stop him being completely reinvented as an exposition deliverer for Casino Royale. He spends a lot of time on screen during the first two of Daniel Craigs Bond, but dont let that trick you into thinking hes in the film for any other reason. Look at everything he does in Craig's first outing. He has a Montenegrin police chief arrested to protect James and then watches over Vesper during the high stakes poker game. Both of those moments are only present to stop the audience asking questions; the arrest explains why Le Chiffre wouldn't have the police eating out of his hand and having him with Vesper gives the script a convenient way to explain the rules of Texas Hold 'Em to viewers new to poker. Compared to most entries on this list Mathis is pretty well executed, but the script doesn't fully cover up what exactly hes there to do; when its revealed hes been working with Le Chiffre its more oh, OK rather oh my goodness. This is only emphasised further in Quantum Of Solace when we learn he wasn't actually implicated with the criminal, showing the whole betrayal subplot up for the fake character development it was.
8. Jennifer Dugan - Spider-Man 3
When people want to target Sam Raimis Spider-Man trilogy they tend to go for the Power Ranger Green Goblin, emo Peter or the butler who keeps his mouth shut until the plot commands him to. While the latter is an awkwardly placed example suitable for this list, theres something much riper for ridiculing in the final film. All four Spider-Man films we've got so far have been injected a sense of New York pride, with the citizens of the Big Apple as invested in Spideys antics as Peter Parker. While it was perfectly suitable in the first film given how soon after 9/11 it was released, as the series progressed it became increasingly grating; the train sequence in Spider-Man 2 was silly, but the thirds use of this ongoing trope was something else. When Spider-Man falls into the obvious trap set by Sandman and Venom its accompanied by gasps from the onlooking crowd and ongoing commentary from news reporter Jennifer Dugan, who through her terrible rapport with the news shows anchorman dully explains exactly whats happening in an attempt to make it more serious. Its the sheer bluntness of these lines, ruining any tension the scene may have had, that always bother me when I watch this. Having a Spidey beat up become a spectator event seemed to trivialise the whole thing. Didn't know that this could be the end of Spider-Man? Worried New York wouldn't care? Dont worry; rolling news is here to save the day.
7. The Commentators - Rush
Most sports movies tend to spend as little time on the actual sport as possible; if an ideas reached the point of being turned into a movie its the human relationships, rather than the physical spectacle, thats interesting. No matter how far you remove it though, the danger still remains that those who aren't fans wont know whats going on. Most films tend to litter exposition throughout, using a wide time frame so we can learn with the characters, which to some degree Ron Howard did with Rush. For the most part the film didn't seem too concerned with explaining itself and was happy to just bring non-racing fans on for the ride; the exposition was hidden within the character interactions. But in the final act that assured tact was lost and a bunch of expositional commentators were thrown in. Explaining exactly what was going on, they did enhance some moments (the worlds shock at Lauda quitting on the final race in particular) but for the most part the writing was too flat; it was overly simplistic showing none of the knowledge a real racing commentator would have. Rush was an excellent biopic and came as a great antidote to a summer of emotionally distant films, but the commentators continued explanation of what we were seeing (we get it - Hunt needs to come third to win the season) betrayed the rest of the films confidence.
6. Water Mains Controller - Batman Begins
Nolans Batman films have several characters inserted in who explain whats happening at times when it really isn't necessary - the cops during the first Batman chase always irks a lot of people - but the real kicker for me has to be the guy at the water mains centre in Batman Begins. Every time I watch this sequence in what is an otherwise perfect blockbuster I cringe a little inside. Throughout the film the microwave emitter has been overtly teased and before giving chase to Ra's Al Ghul Batman even takes some time out to fully explain to Gordon just what the evil scheme is afoot. That should be it - even the slowest audience member is up to speed and we can now get on with the final battle - but instead we have to be reminded every ten seconds just whats at stake. Its as if the film suddenly started pandering to people who arrived at the cinema two hours late. For all its brooding tone, Batman Begins feels the most like a traditional blockbuster out of The Dark Knight Trilogy and its best shown in these moments where the film overly explains relatively simple plot points.
5. Dr. Fredrichs - Paranormal Activity
Proving that suggesting something is scary to people will make them think its scary, Paranormal Activity briefly had us believing moving sheets and dropping keys were the things of nightmares. Dont feel too bad though; apparently Steven Spielberg himself was gibbering after he first saw it. Of course its easy to be cynical now, but when the first in the ongoing horror franchise hit, people were positively terrified after the promise of this low budget production being one of the scariest movies of all time. I didn't really see all the fuss, although being stuck in a screening full of teens ready to be scared from the beginning, screaming at the title card, may have dampened a lot of the effect. What really confuses me about the film's success is how it did so well with audiences despite nothing but the cycle of casual daytime/creepy night time occurring for most of the run time. Up until the last five minutes, all the plot development occurs in the opening quarter of an hour; Katie is being haunted, so she gets in a psychic who tells her its a demon. Because the plot is so slight, the psychic Dr. Fredrichs cant help but explain it all in his two brief appearances, but the fact his presence is there for no other purpose than to clarify theres a difference between ghosts and demons - he does nothing to help the tormented couple - he more than deserves to appear here.
4. Parker Selfridge - Avatar
The aliens look like the internet's favourite thing (cats) so must be good, the humans are grumpy so must be bad, the macguffin mineral is called unobtanium because it's not very obtainable (or James Cameron wasn't bothered to change its name after the first draft); yeah, not one part of Avatar is subtle. Even the characters who initially seem interesting come straight out of My First Screenplay. When we first meet Parker he proceeds to explain to Grace, someone whos been on Pandora for years, why the whole expedition is there. Like a character asking to hear something again at the start of a scene or a slow hero trying to catchup by summing up where we are in the plot, this is lazy writing that really bothers me because here its so obvious. What pushes Selfridge (geddit, it sounds like selfish because it's what he is) over to just explaining the plot is how this leader of the RDAs Pandora branch is completely dropped from events afterwards. His only other significant scene comes around the midway point where he express an opinion on trees, but it's still reaffirming the general set up rather than adding anything new. The scene is so blunt the only way it could have been more annoying is if he had a T-Shirt on saying I hate trees.
3. Ariadne - Inception
By the time Nolan got the free pass from Warner Bros. to make Inception he carried with him a lot more clout in the industry and thus wasn't as constrained as he was with Batman Begins. But while his ways of doling out exposition were more hidden this time, they were far from invisible. Inceptions labyrinthine plot, with constant misdirection and a downplayed twist, coupled with a myriad of original concepts looked a hard pill for a multiplex audience to swallow. Enter Ariadne. On an objective level her character serves absolutely no purpose to the plot. She may fill the role of the architect of the dream levels, but thats an abstract position that has little presence in the action of the films central reverse-heist. Instead, her key purpose is to periodically ask questions about the shared dreaming concept so audiences would be kept up to speed without having to suffer a massive exposition dump. What makes Ariadne annoying is that the reason for her existence becomes increasingly obvious the more you rewatch the film; she's the only character who doesn't become more interesting. Thankfully, she doesn't directly affect the film in any negative way thanks to Nolan using her only when necessary; we never feel shes asking too much. Once a point's been made it won't be repeated, which leads to much of the confusion among the less attentive audience members.
2. Caesar Flickerman - The Hunger Games
They may exist purely for expositional means, but Stanley Tucci and Toby Jones commentating duo were still such an enjoyable part of The Hunger Games. Suited in the typically garish Panem style they regularly pop up to provide some clarification of whats going on in the games. The problem is they completely betray what made the book work so well. Suzanne Collins teen novels are written from Katniss Everdeens perspective in their entirety, meaning we never leave the arena once the games begin. Ill concede some things work better on film if you actually see them (Haymitch sending Katniss help could come across more than a little contrived otherwise), but for the most part jumping to President Snow, the game controllers, or particularly the commentators negates the action, particularly when many things they explain (the cannon blast for each dead player) are pretty obvious. The only thing that I actually learnt from them was that the wasp-like creatures Katniss uses to escape the Career Tributes are actually a genetically modified version of the picnic botherers called tracker jackers. And I really dont understand why we didn't just have a character say it like in source book. Presumably Gary Ross wanted to get the most out of Tuccis salary.
1. Captain Panaka - Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace
A list on annoying characters from The Phantom Menace doesnt include Jar Jar Binks? What neglectful sorcery is this? Well for all the things wrong with the gungan hate figure, George Lucas did a good job (or bad depending on how you look at it) of making him a character that stands as memorable without the crutches of the plot. The same can not be said of the rest of the films supporting heroes. Coming at the beginning of the whole saga and lumbered with sandcrawlers full of backstory, The Phantom Menace really struggles to balance the set up of the series and its own individual story, so naturally some characters would be reduced to little more than plot spouters. Worse amongst them would have to be Captain Panaka, who as Queen Amidalas head of security takes it upon himself to make sure every possible threat is reiterated for the monarch and the audience. The ship could be destroyed, returning to Naboo is dangerous, the Gungans cant win the battle; everything out of his mouth is driven by making sure the audience understand just how serious and deadly every situation is. In fact most of the Nabooians served little purpose; even more minor character Ric Olie filled the Han Solo role of being the character's spaceship captain, but with his few lines did nothing but explain what we could easily see. Know any more characters who do nothing put explain the plot? Go down to the comments and give us the low-down.