9 Deleted Movie Sub-Plots That Changed Everything

These background stories could've completely ruined our favourite films...

Hannibal thumb
United International Pictures

I imagine that when writing a screenplay, it's difficult to strike the right balance between 'focussing on the storyline and keeping things tight' and 'giving too little surrounding emotion or information, leaving the world feeling barren.'

You want the audience to feel that the universe you've created is real, and part of that includes acknowledging things happening outside of your primary plot-line.

Usually sub-plots help to flesh things out a bit without completely altering the main path of the film. We get to know side-characters, have an additional cause for concern and so on. A good sub-plot is a very useful tool! Done right, a secondary plot focus can change a film's tone for the better or even help drive forward the film's momentum and regulate pacing.

Not all sub-plots are good though, for a variety of reasons - and some even have the potential to derail the whole film. Whether ill-planned, poorly-executed or just weirdly unsuitable, a little ole sub-plot can become a big ole problem.

It's fun to think about what could've been had our favourite movies kept to their initial plans, and of course that includes a range of haywire subplots. For better or for worse, they would've changed absolutely everything.

9. Nightcrawler - A Sympathetic Backstory

Nightcrawler movie
Open Road Films

Nightcrawler’s protagonist Lou is a bad person. He’s not likable, he’s not relatable and - as much as we may try - we don’t really understand why he does the things he does to the extent he does them.

It would have changed the film’s entire tone then if we were to be given some deep Lou-lore. For instance if we were shown sequences from his childhood that explained why he was like this - like that he had developed an obsession with death from a young age after his whole family was murdered in a break-in gone-wrong - we could almost understand.

The initial intention was to paint Lou as a damaged person, a ‘survivor’ archetype who was just trying to get by, day to day; his morals pushed to the wayside by harsh reality. There would be a whole sub-plot revealing Lou’s traumatic past and showing how it relates to his current self, but alas this was not to be.

Director Dan Gilroy decided it would be more effective if he went the opposite way and made Lou unimaginably cold. He said it would detract from the experience if he had to set aside time to spend on Lou’s past or to give him some sympathetic scenes and so all of that was cut from the script, and new Lou was born.


8. The Uninvited (1944) - The Missing Priest

The uninvited 1944
Paramount Pictures, Inc.

There is one line that remains in the final cut of this film that betrays its earlier form, a line in which a character refers to a priest we’ve never seen or heard of. Out of the blue and without much followup, it’s a comment that is easy to ignore - but if you know, then you know.

Before the final cuts and touches, The Uninvited featured a whole subplot and additional character by way of Father Anson. In the book the film is based on Uneasy Freehold by Dorothy Macardle, where Father Anson is a local priest and advocate for Mary’s character.

He helped paint the picture, along with other locals, of Mary being a beautiful, virtuous woman and her rival Carmel being ungodly. His input rooted the film’s supernatural elements in more biblical origins, with heavier mentions of demons being the antithesis of angels, rather than run-of-the-mill monsters.

Much of his motivation in the novel is that he wants to perform an exorcism on the haunted house, something that could’ve made for some nice scary visuals if included in the film.

Father Anson was however completely removed before the film ever reached audiences, taking with him his biblical brand of supernatural horror.


7. Love Actually - A Much Sadder Story

Love Actually Cut Subplot Deleted Scenes
Universal Pictures

Depending on your feelings about rom-coms, you either adore or detest Love Actually. It’s a sickly-sweet Christmas classic, intertwining stories of various couples across the UK to deliver one united message: Love is all you need. Merry Christmas.

One of the features of Love Actually that makes it such an easy watch is that you know it has a happy ending. Everyone gets a pleasant, satisfying ending (apart from that one woman who gets sort-of cheated on by Snape), and the audience is left content and smiling. Great!

Well originally, we were going to get a whole other couple included in the story, with this plot thread focussing on the school head teacher and her terminally ill partner. Not only would this have made for one overtly gay relationship in a film that is otherwise entirely straight (you can argue that Bill Nye is gay, though it’s ambiguous), but it also comes with an undoubtedly sad ending.

We would have spent time with them in their home, the teacher caring for her partner as they come to terms with the inevitable - and then dealing with the aftermath when it happens. The story would’ve had a totally different tone than even the saddest other ones, and overall, could've shaped the movie slightly differently; less 'perfect'.


6. Hannibal - Another Serial Killer

Hannibal Ending
MGM

You may have noticed when watching the sequel to the infamous Silence of the Lambs that at one point a whole other serial killer is mentioned - a killer by the name of ‘Il Mostro.’

In real life, Il Mostro refers to the ‘Monster of Florence’ who murdered fourteen people over the 70’s and 80’s. In fiction, Il Mostro has been firmly cemented into the story of Hannibal. In the 1999 novel, an investigator is left in disgrace after arresting the wrong man accused of being Il Mostro; in the TV adaptation, Hannibal and Il Mostro are alleged to be the same person, and finally in the film they almost meet face to face.

That was until that whole bit was chopped out with Hannibal’s own surgical precision. After referencing Il Mostro, he actually makes an appearance as Hannibal murders Chief Inspector Pazzi. Working as a janitor in Florence, he encounters the titular cannibal mid-murder but manages to escape with his life, soon afterwards fleeing the city.

The sub-plot relating to Il Mostro’s similarly horrible crimes - culminating in his appearance and fleeing - clearly wasn’t top of the list of priorities. It’s a shame really, it was included in the book and TV show for a reason so you’d hope it would have more significance here.


5. Me Before You - Lou’s Tragic Past

Me Before You Sam Clafflin Emilia Clarke
Warner Bros.

This is the second Lou on this list to have had their potential tragic backstory removed. 2016’s Me Before You tells the unlikely love story of a small-town girl and a recently paralysed billionaire. Based on the novel of the same name by Jojo Moyes, it stays fairly faithful to its source material - but one big detail is missing.

In the novel the explanation for why protagonist Lou is so scared to expand her horizons is that she experienced huge trauma as a teen. At a party, Lou was raped by a group of older boys, and following this she shuts her entire life down.

She struggles to trust people and structures everything around feeling safe: right from her job down to her dress-sense. It answers the question that Will ponders on why she has no interest in branching out and seeing the world.

Author and screenwriter Moyes explained that she chose to leave it out as there was no way she could comfortably translate it to screen. In the book, she explains, the rape is covered in an almost ‘throw-away’ manner - as if Lou hasn’t processed it fully and instead keeps it tucked away in her mind.

She explained:

“We almost know before Louisa knows, how much that’s affecting her,”

After trying for six months, she decided they couldn’t get the scene right. When dedicated to film, it carries a different weight and would have to be approached totally differently. It would’ve totally changed the tone of the story and done a disservice both to the character and the important subject matter, so Moyes made the smart decision to just call it quits.


4. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 - Mary Jane Almost Appeared

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Andrew Garfield
Sony Pictures Releasing

It seems unthinkable now that they would’ve crammed another character into this film, considering how well-known Amazing Spidey 2 is now for an overabundance of characters. It wasn’t just any old character that was going to appear though, it was the ever-iconic, Mary Jane Watson.

Shaleine Woodley was cast in the role and filmed all of her scenes. The scenes weren’t huge and her part wasn’t going to be groundbreaking, but the goal was to lay some groundwork for her presence in the future.

With Gwen Stacey’s death happening at the end of the film, it would’ve felt a bit pre-emptive and calculated to start shoehorning MJ into the very same picture. A bit bad taste, maybe. I can’t speak for everyone but I certainly wouldn't feel inclined to warm up to MJ, had she swept into Peter’s life immediately following his girlfriend’s tragic death.

In the end, the decision to cut out MJ worked out for the best. Gwen’s death wasn’t sullied by a rival romance, the cast didn’t burst at its seams (close as it was) and we ended up getting our fill of MJ with the character’s next rebooted appearance.


3. World War Z - Gerry’s Wife Goes Rogue

world war z ending
Paramount

It’s a heartwarming moment at the end of WWZ when Gerry reunites with his family - embraced happily by his adoring wife and children.

A huge part of his motivation throughout is the thought of them being back together again, the drive to keep his family safe and get things back to a stage where they can all live their happily ever afters. We start and end the film with his family - they are all-encompassing.

Well there was almost a rather sour undertone to all of this, as initially there was going to be a sub-plot in which Gerry’s wife begins an affair with a paratrooper.

This sub-plot would’ve led the film to dedicate more time to Gerry’s family in his absence, and also change the family dynamic on his return, in turn influencing the whole tone of the film’s ending.

It was decided that this storyline wasn’t worth the time it would eat up, and it was deleted. In some ways I think it would have improved the film, giving it less of a text-book happy ending.

However with everything being as miserable as it is these days, having a bland happy ending isn’t the worst thing in the world.


2. Prometheus - Alien Jesus

Prometheus Gngineer
20th Century Fox

Now in a very sharp change of tone I introduce to you Alien Jesus: a genuine real idea that almost was an important sub-plot in a genuine real movie. And not just any old movie, in 2012’s already controversial Prometheus.

If in doubt, just add Alien Jesus - that’s what I always say! There’s probably a reason I’m not a screenwriter, because apparently that would never work, hence why the explicit stating of ‘Jesus was an alien sent to save you and you killed him, thus bringing about your doom’ being removed from Prometheus’ plot.

Ridley Scott, in an interview with the since closed down Movies.com, did not shy away from stating the film’s biblical links. There are a number of scenes that mirror biblical and mythical events, but after deliberation the filmmakers stopped short of actually making an official plot-point of us finding out that Jesus was an Engineer.

The biblical stuff is super hinted at, but it’s never actually explored as it was once intended. Scott even deliberated having us meet ‘God’ (another engineer, of course) in a potential sequel, but thankfully backed down.


1. Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers - Loomis’ Possession

Halloween The Curse Of Michael Myers Donald Pleasence Paul Rudd
Buena Vista

Test audiences did the heavy lifting for us on this one and managed to get one terrible Halloween subplot kicked to the curb late on in production. The test cut of the sixth Halloween film (known as the Producers’ Cut) varies quite markedly from the version we know today.

The end of the Producers’ Cut sets up a sub-plot to carry on even into the next film, meaning that had it not been removed then the impact would be felt even beyond this movie.

Originally, Dr Loomis was intended to become possessed by the Mark of the Thorn (the killy-killy thing that makes Michael do bad things) as it was passed to him by the now-dead cult leader.

The film would’ve ended with his desperate cry as he acknowledged his fate - but alas, the fate was removed. Audience members at the test screening despised the idea of Loomis becoming involved in the cult, and vocally opposed it. As a result it was decided the whole thing should be removed.

When it came time for reshoots, Loomis actor Donald Pleasance had sadly already passed away. The idea of passing on the curse was scrapped, instead Dr Loomis simply meets his demise in an off-screen death.


Watch Next


Quiz: Can You Name The Movie From Its Plot Twist?

The Girl on the Train Emily Blunt.jpg
Universal Pictures

1. Emily Faked Her Own Death

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's shortest contributor (probably). Lover of cats, baked goods and Netflix Originals.